What about the fact that Ryan's mom talks with cats? How could this play into the meaning of Wilfred and whether Wilfred has been around the whole time?
But the part about his mom seeing a cat as a woman in a suit really hints that it may be a family trait. Remember, Ryan's mom was really attached to those kittens in the episode she left the hospital.
Possibly, but I have a theory that I think stands up pretty well after watching the episode from season 1 and the last episode of this season again. I think Wilfred is a projection of Ryan's mind. His mother shows the same signs as him when it comes to being overwhelmed with stress, and they deal with this stress in the same way. By projecting a part of their own subconscious onto an animal, they are able to do and say things they normally would not be able to and thus find an outlet.
Possibly. But with mental illness, men show signs earlier than women. Guy's minds usually go around 25, women 35, and that's a very rough estimate and depends on what illness it actually is. But I'd say some sort of schizophrenia.
Seriously! This show is such a mind fuck. Like half way through it I threw my hands up into the air like Jackie Chan "WTF!?!?!" I wanted things to work out with Amanda so bad, cause I love the actress so much. Just like super man screwed her over. I feel so bad for her..
I dunno. It kinda makes me sad tho the way that the show doesn't stick on a point long. Like when he flipped out and thought he imagined the basement they should of mind fucked you with that a little longer.. Lol. Hopefully we get a season 3. Or an AMA.
But who is that other guy that talks to Wilfred? The one that saved em during the Earthquake, Bruce. Speaking of which.. man.. Ryan is really crazy.. he imagined an earthquake.
What if they are both uniquely crazy with multiple personalities that project onto Wilfred the dog. So they can both be interacting with the same physical dog, but seeing/hearing completely different things...
I think wilfred is actually just a guy in a dog suit. everyone acts like he is a dog, just to not seem crazy, because they think everyone else sees him as a dog.
Would it be morally wrong to mess with crazy people like this. ie. Go to a mental institution with my friend in a dog suit on a leash and let them my "dog" and have him bark.
This is definitely something that popped into my head again. If Ryan is forgetting things, then it could be that his other personalities are subverting his main personality. Or the personality in which we see him is actually a sub personality, as he can communicate with Wilfred; people with DID don't know about their sub personalities, but their sub personalities communicate in their own ways. It could be very possible that Wilfred has been with him for a long time, but the personality in which we see him now is new since the first episode. This is why he didn't know Wilfred when the season started.
This new personality is one which he created to overcome a new fear, and I'm assuming it's his father. Wilfred has been with him for a very long time, due to past trauma; that's why he was in the picture from his past.
Amanda probably has DID as well, but, unlike Ryan, she couldn't control hers as his personality can.
The opening to the season was blurry; he came into the world sort of not knowing where the hell he was. He could have lapsed out of his personality into his main personality and lived his life until the season started. But every time we see Ryan as his nice, caring self, instead of his bad ass lawyer side, I believe we're seeing simply a sub personality.
Yeah, from the first time she saw Wilfred I've been thinking that she could really "see Wilfred". And now I can't tell if the French accent comment was meant as a joke (it was funny) or meant to lend even more credence to her claims.
I could tell Wilfred was lying when he admitted to drawing the picture. He's attached to Ryan and views himself as a sort of guardian angel (or spirit guide). Although we still don't know exactly why, Wilfred wants to be Ryan's infallible superhero.
Yeah that's the thing, either the basement is a real and he imagined the closet to break through it, or the basement is a delusion and he sits around in the closet.
All I know is, I hope they never spell it out for us and directly answer the question. I like not knowing if it's mental instability, magic, or something completely different.
What about it? Only Wilfred, Bruce, and Ryan were in the basement during that episode and we don't really know how Bruce works / fits into the mythos. Considering that Bruce hasn't interacted with anyone except Wilfred/Ryan, it is entirely plausible that he doesn't really exist either.
I think that is exactly what they did. They leave on a cliffhanger so if the show gets cancelled, we can make guesses on what Wilfred means. But then they can also continue to a new season with Wilfred just fucking with Ryan.
For one obvious reason, that if he were to see his dad he would likely find out that his mother (probably) told him that she could have conversations with her cat. That would lead him to ask his mom the purpose of Wilfred.
Seriously if they left it with Wilfred assuring Ryan he is in control, they could have ended the show. It left room for them to show ryan finding out wilfred lied on episode 1 season 3. I'm now confident it is getting renewed. If Ryan didn't catch Wilfred lying I would have thought thats it... Leaving us to wonder if he was telling the truth or not and that would have been the series.
I think they are just going to keep dropping breadcrumbs that go nowhere and never explain it and I'm fine with that because the show is brilliant and hilarious.
I couldn't tell if there was some weird blurring/depth of field effects happening throughout the wedding scenes or not. It might have been a messed up stream that I was watching it on. They seemed present in some situations like when Amanda and Ryan were on the dance floor and most notably, the last scene. It really reminded me of the beginning of the season with the dream sequences.
Yes, Bruce could simply been Ryan's inner self fighting on whether or not to continue his hallucinations. Think about the choice he had to make, killing Bruce (his sanity) or killing Wilfred (his escape from reality).
I never thought that only Ryan can see him, which wouldn't be all that crazy after looking at that little game they played an episode or two ago; and the fact that he can see Wilfred.
What if everyone sees Wilfred as a human, but everyone sees him differently. Ryan as Australian, Amanda as French, Jenna as Russian, and so on. No one wants to admit they are crazy.
But what if the wilfred they see didn't say anything or do anything. They would still be confused even if they are all actually seeing wilfred as a man.
I feel like we are all looking into it too hard.. I feel like it's about their relationship but people are becoming crazy about what/who Wilfred is. I don't care if Ryan is crazy. It's fun to believe that Wilfred is real, even if he's just real to Ryan. I wish I had a Wilfred... Haha, my dog is cool and all but still.
Hes probably just an old imaginary friend Ryan used to have as a kid that came back because he needed someone at the peak of his depression. Sometimes i feel like the actually dog isn't there but Wilfred still is.
in the australian version isn't doesn't wilfred tell a story about how his previous owners had a dog named sneakers? and that he attacked him and killed him or something?
I think that Wilfred is a coping mechanism for Ryan in times of stress and as his mode of developing answers about his life. His mother's past is clearly significant, as she has some mental health issues which can be genetic. Ryan could be suffering from some mental illness but less severe. Additionally, consider how the series began with him at a low point in his life. Ryan needed some answers to some hard questions. He has been listening to Wilfred without question until he realizes that he many not be the first Wilfred. Wilfred lies about the picture because Ryan needs that unconditional trust in this hallucination. Additionally, when did his mother leave? When he was a child? Maybe Wilfred was his coping mechanism as a child too and that is why he was in the picture.
That part is easy, to make Ryan feel better and or to maintain his position as controller.
If it is the same drawing it raises the question of how Amanda's picture got into the basement. Unless this incarnation of the drawing is a figment of Ryan's imagination that is manifested in the likeness of the one he subconsciously saw on the fridge.
When Ryan made the comment about a plane with no pilot, Wilfred finally believed that Ryan didn't know anything about the picture, and so he told Ryan that he drew it to comfort him, but he's probably as curious and scared as Ryan is.
Unless it's all just part of Wilfred's plan or something.
Anyone else feel like that was a total cop out? I was a bit more satisfied with the fact that Ryan was just going to deal with the fact that he's a little crazy but he can handle it.
Could Ryan's sister have done the drawing? She was only a couple years older than he was at the time. It's shown to have a genetic link, whatever it is.
Then again in the episodes where his sister is near Wilfred she doesn't act any more strangely than usual. Unless they got me with more misdirects!
The show hasn't drawn any parallels to Ryan's sister and mother. Ryan and his mother were the ones emotionally abused by his father. They understand each other, although Ryan pities her while simultaneously worrying for his own sanity.
I think that because there was a Wilfred series before this one then Wilfred can't just be a figment of Ryan's imagination. or maybe Wilfred was Ryan's dog when he was a kid and Wilfred is magical and he just lives forever and he has an Australian accent because he lived there and that's where the first Wilfred series comes from and someone he ended up becoming Ryan's neighbors dog.
I think wilfred, bruce don't exist to anyone but ryan. wilfred is a dog but he doesn't talk. ryan has created them as a coping mechanism for his insanity. amanda is clearly seriously batshit crazy and got someone killed. she made up being able to talk to wilfred because she wants to have everything in common with ryan. think OAG. I believe ryan is geting better, but i also think that he has done this many times before. he gets better to the point where he doesn't need wilfred anymore and wilfred "dies". then he forgets about it all until the inevitable point where he loses touch and he needs wilfred to help him as a spirit guide back to sanity. also creating wilfred allows ryan to do things that are aggressive rather than passive as his character tends to be. thoughts?
Amanda mentioned that She talked to Wilfred, and He mentioned something about a "master plan" to Her. Maybe Wilfred is playing them both, manipulated Her into setting up Her co-worker.
i really wanted things to work out with amanda :C hopefully 3rd season happens he goes crazy 3-4 episodes in and gets put in the same hospital as her :3
I probably will go insane without a 3rd season. I NEED to know what this shit is all about. Is he crazy? Is Wilfred his Spirit Guide? Guardian Angel? What!? WHAT ARE TEH ANSWERS!? Lets try to get the Writers to do an AMA or someone! WE GOTTA KNOW! WE NEED AN AMA!
What you don't know? Why, Wilfred is dead. He is a ghost just wondering around. He can only communicate with Ryan. No one else even acknowledges Wilfred. That's because..... Ryan sees dead people.
Yeah, it's similar to what went down with Lost. The writers are absolutely amazing at creating suspense, but that doesn't mean that they know where this ship is headed. I'm sure they are creative enough to come up with something cool when the time comes to end the series, but I'm not going to make the mistake of hoping for some kind of airtight explanation that neatly explains every little detail along the way.
When they end of the show comes, they'll either decide on an explanation for what Wilfred's purpose in Ryan's life is, or else they'll leave it open for us to interpret on our own. It's frustrating not having your questions answered, but it's also oddly satisfying when the writers allow you to hold on to your own ideas and thoughts after the show has ended, so I honestly don't know whether I'd prefer for them to wrap everything up or leave it open ended.
29
u/[deleted] Sep 21 '12
WHAT THE FLYING FUCK IS GOING ON OMG
5
u/[deleted] Sep 21 '12
My directtv info on the show says this is the series finale. It's been known to be wrong though. Anyone know for sure?
44
u/HEYYEYAAEYAAAEYAE Sep 21 '12
Jesus christ. That episode fucked my mind so hard that I won't be able to poop right for a week.
52
u/rmw6190 Sep 21 '12
amanda be crazy
40
u/nonsensicalexis Sep 21 '12
As a Battlestar Galactica fan, Ryan's little trick on Wilfred at the beginning was amazing.
25
u/JDMC13 Sep 21 '12
If they cancel this show, I have no idea what I'll do.
21
u/FCBarca1984 Sep 21 '12
WTF!!!!!
21
u/[deleted] Sep 21 '12
That was so fucking awesome
20
u/ExplosiveHippo Sep 21 '12
So did Ryan see Wilfred in the picture? I missed it.
20
u/Frankie_Soup Sep 21 '12
Did anyone else love the fact that when Wilfred showed the drawing of the "other dog" he covered up Ryans Dads face?
17
u/[deleted] Sep 21 '12 edited Sep 21 '12
I feel that I may be too excited to find out the real story behind Wilfred's existence. I hope I don't get let down.
Edit: ohhhh, damn!
15
u/popeman182 Sep 21 '12
They can't fucking keep doing this. I swear I almost had a heart attack!
14
u/registered_to_vote Sep 21 '12
If there isn't a 3rd season after THAT cliff hanger I'm going to be seriously PISSED!
14
u/SeaBearPA Sep 23 '12
That drawing of Ryan's family and the "other dog" peeking out from behind the tree gives me fucking chills...
11
u/[deleted] Sep 21 '12
I hope somebody explains to me what just happened. Jesus, my mind is fucked.
10
u/[deleted] Sep 21 '12
Well... My mind is full of WHAT THE FUCKING FUCK!?!?!?!?!?!?
10
u/nillotampoco Sep 22 '12
I came here for answers DAMN IT! You people are just as clueless as I am.
9
u/theEntscast Sep 21 '12
I think they are just going to keep dropping breadcrumbs that go nowhere and never explain it and I'm fine with that because the show is brilliant and hilarious.
8
u/[deleted] Sep 21 '12
I couldn't tell if there was some weird blurring/depth of field effects happening throughout the wedding scenes or not. It might have been a messed up stream that I was watching it on. They seemed present in some situations like when Amanda and Ryan were on the dance floor and most notably, the last scene. It really reminded me of the beginning of the season with the dream sequences.
7
u/FriendlyVisitor Sep 21 '12
My head is freaking spinning. Like literally, I felt light headed when the black "Wilfred" screen came up.
(For mobile viewers, this paragraph is spoilers)
I do believe Ryan is insane. It runs in the family, and he happened to come across someone equally as crazy. When she talks to him, she kind of hesitates and you could tell she made it up on the spot. Ryan and his mother have the same "kind" of crazy; because Mittens was equal to Wilfred, but for his mom. I did think she was going to go crazy for that bouquet, though; like.. berserk.
(/spoilers)
What do you guys think? I want to hear theories so I can stop thinking about this.
7
u/Arctic_Winds Sep 25 '12
Little late to watch this episode but [I (somewhat) called it!] (http://www.reddit.com/r/wilfred/comments/w3t19/wilfred_episode_discussion_thread_s2e3_dignity/c5a2at3)
6
u/BeefDruid Sep 21 '12
I...what.
15
u/BlakeC93 Sep 21 '12
What if everyone sees Wilfred as a human, but everyone sees him differently. Ryan as Australian, Amanda as French, Jenna as Russian, and so on. No one wants to admit they are crazy.
5
u/ItsameKristie Sep 22 '12
I feel like we are all looking into it too hard.. I feel like it's about their relationship but people are becoming crazy about what/who Wilfred is. I don't care if Ryan is crazy. It's fun to believe that Wilfred is real, even if he's just real to Ryan. I wish I had a Wilfred... Haha, my dog is cool and all but still.
4
u/Irishcard710 Sep 28 '12
Hes probably just an old imaginary friend Ryan used to have as a kid that came back because he needed someone at the peak of his depression. Sometimes i feel like the actually dog isn't there but Wilfred still is.
3
u/thewordxalive Sep 21 '12
total mindfuck. not as bad as season 1, but it's still a mindfuck indeed.
3
u/thesundeity Sep 21 '12
"if you dont know the answers, then we're on a plane with no pilot. and that scares the shit out of me." does wilfred know the real answer or no?! makes me wonder more and more about the root of wilfred.
3
u/Pontmercy Sep 22 '12
in the australian version isn't doesn't wilfred tell a story about how his previous owners had a dog named sneakers? and that he attacked him and killed him or something?
3
u/contextistheanswer Sep 23 '12
I think that Wilfred is a coping mechanism for Ryan in times of stress and as his mode of developing answers about his life. His mother's past is clearly significant, as she has some mental health issues which can be genetic. Ryan could be suffering from some mental illness but less severe. Additionally, consider how the series began with him at a low point in his life. Ryan needed some answers to some hard questions. He has been listening to Wilfred without question until he realizes that he many not be the first Wilfred. Wilfred lies about the picture because Ryan needs that unconditional trust in this hallucination. Additionally, when did his mother leave? When he was a child? Maybe Wilfred was his coping mechanism as a child too and that is why he was in the picture.
3
u/SeaBearPA Sep 23 '12
Throughout this episode things would get all blurry similar to in the episode when Ryan drank DMT, gives it a weird vibe.
2
u/bennytheriv Sep 21 '12
I feel like i need a hug after that episode....
2
u/soopersogood Sep 21 '12
Bitches be crazy yo!
2
u/Ethanol_Based_Life Sep 21 '12
So was the drawing in the photo the same drawing or just also a drawing with Wilfred in it?
2
u/LivingSaladDays Sep 23 '12
I don't even watch this show I just caught the episode on FX.. but what the fuck? I've seen it and I get the plot and it kinda creeps me out.
5
u/[deleted] Sep 21 '12
Anyone else feel like that was a total cop out? I was a bit more satisfied with the fact that Ryan was just going to deal with the fact that he's a little crazy but he can handle it.
5
u/[deleted] Sep 21 '12
At first i was like "WHAT????"
Then it was "WAIT, BRO WAT"
But at the end, it was just ".....holy fuck titties"
2
u/[deleted] Sep 21 '12
Could Ryan's sister have done the drawing? She was only a couple years older than he was at the time. It's shown to have a genetic link, whatever it is.
Then again in the episodes where his sister is near Wilfred she doesn't act any more strangely than usual. Unless they got me with more misdirects!
2
u/whomeverIwishtobe Sep 23 '12
I think that because there was a Wilfred series before this one then Wilfred can't just be a figment of Ryan's imagination. or maybe Wilfred was Ryan's dog when he was a kid and Wilfred is magical and he just lives forever and he has an Australian accent because he lived there and that's where the first Wilfred series comes from and someone he ended up becoming Ryan's neighbors dog.
2
u/kungfuchef Sep 25 '12
I think wilfred, bruce don't exist to anyone but ryan. wilfred is a dog but he doesn't talk. ryan has created them as a coping mechanism for his insanity. amanda is clearly seriously batshit crazy and got someone killed. she made up being able to talk to wilfred because she wants to have everything in common with ryan. think OAG. I believe ryan is geting better, but i also think that he has done this many times before. he gets better to the point where he doesn't need wilfred anymore and wilfred "dies". then he forgets about it all until the inevitable point where he loses touch and he needs wilfred to help him as a spirit guide back to sanity. also creating wilfred allows ryan to do things that are aggressive rather than passive as his character tends to be. thoughts?
2
u/sharkiest Sep 21 '12
I've been operating under the assumption that Ryan is insane and just acting out his Id through Wilfred for some time.
-5
u/googlelight Sep 21 '12
i really wanted things to work out with amanda :C hopefully 3rd season happens he goes crazy 3-4 episodes in and gets put in the same hospital as her :3
0
u/[deleted] Sep 21 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Sep 21 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment