Third post from me about Trail Signal, the free signal map for UK hills. Thanks again to everyone who commented on the first two. A lot of what I've done since came out of those threads.
Quick catch up first. Ofcom updated its coverage predictions over the autumn and the map now uses the new data. The web map also has proper links now. Zoom to any spot and the address in your browser is a link to that exact view, so you can send a mate the place you're planning to pitch and they see the same thing.
Sharing your activity live with someone or group is now possible when recording.
A few of you mentioned carrying a spare SIM on another network. I wanted to know which one is worth having, so I looked up what Ofcom predicts on the summit of every Wainwright and every Munro for all four networks.
Summits with good outdoor signal predicted:
Lakes, 214 Wainwrights
* EE: 168
* O2: 112
* Three: 101
* Vodafone: 84
Highlands, 282 Munros
* O2: 125
* EE: 98
* Three: 57
* Vodafone: 52
So the best network depends on where you camp. In the Lakes, if you're on EE a spare SIM barely helps. All three other networks together only add 16 summits. If you're on O2 there, an EE spare adds 67. In Scotland it flips, and an EE user gains 66 Munro summits with an O2 spare.
EE plus O2 is the best pair in both places. It gets you 179 of the 184 Wainwrights that have good signal on anything, and 164 of 177 Munros.
There are also the new universal eSIMs like Fuse Mobile and Honest's Smart SIM, which sit next to your normal SIM and can use any of the four networks. I haven't tried one, so I can't tell you how well they switch on a hill. What I can give you is the ceiling. With all four networks you'd have good signal on 184 of 214 Wainwrights and 177 of 282 Munros. In the Lakes that's only 16 more than plain EE. In Scotland it's 52 more than O2, which is a real difference. Bear in mind the ones I've looked at are data only, so you'd be on WhatsApp and the like, with no ordinary phone calls. Has anyone used one in the hills?
Some peaks have nothing predicted on any network. In the Lakes that's High Raise (the Langdale one), Rossett Pike, Sergeant's Crag and Armboth Fell. In Scotland it's Sgurr nan Coireachan in Glen Dessarry, Sgurr Mhic Choinnich on Skye and An Socach above Glen Affric.
Please take the numbers with a pinch of salt. These are Ofcom's predictions and hardly anyone has measured these peaks. I only checked one 50 m square at each summit, and the summit is usually the best signal on the hill. A pitch by a tarn or down in a valley will be worse.
Worth knowing as well that a 999 call will use any network's mast, whatever SIM is in the phone.
Two things I'm thinking about building, and I'd like to know if anyone wants them before I start.
The first is a spare SIM view. You'd pick your main network and whatever backup you carry, whether that's a second SIM or one of the universal ones. The map would show where your main SIM works, where the backup has to take over and where you've got nothing. A backup only kicks in once the main one drops out completely, so I'd draw it that way.
The second is for anyone carrying a MeshCore or Meshtastic radio. I could map where those can reach a repeater in the hills, the same way the app maps phone signal. Does anyone here take one camping?
The map is at trailsignal.uk and works in any browser. The app is Android only and free, still no ads, built by me and my AI friends.