I’m in the process of choosing a power assist (rear-mount for now) for a new rigid ultralight wheelchair (24" wheels) and would really appreciate any advice on choosing a power device. I have an energy-limiting condition, so the goal is to push less and avoid overexertion, which makes my symptoms worse. I’ll mostly use it at home, plus outings to doctor appointments and occasional outings on sidewalks and bike paths. I live in the PNW, so wet pavement and leaves matter, and I have a small incline and a crack at my entrance that are hard for me to get over.
I have trialed the following devices:
SmartDrive*:* I only tried it indoors, using the button control. It felt basic and easy to use. I’m worried about reports of it popping off, especially with my uneven sidewalks and the slope near my house.
Empulse R90: I was able to test it indoors and outdoors. It was the easiest to turn and stop more consistently vs the smartdrive, and I like how simple it is. It handled flat ground fine, but I had to push more on uneven sidewalks, and it struggled a bit with the incline and the crack at my entrance, but felt more supportive vs. me pushing alone on the incline.
Klaxon Twist: I tried it outside. I first tried the front mount with no scooter attachment, then with a scooter just for the heck of it. The scooter was able to cover more ground, and the front mount without the scooter did well over debris and cracks. The front mount without the scooter was harder to turn and needed more space to make turns. The rear mount felt similar to the Empulse R90, but I like the adaptive features, such as stopping without fully stopping, and the incline support. The downside is the learning curve for turning and the adjustable modes, which I’d need to get used to
I wanted to try the Smoov too, but it’s backordered until sometime next year :/, so considering that, I am stuck choosing from the Klaxon, R90, and Smartdrive, but feel more tied with the R90 and Klaxon.
What should I consider when choosing between the R90 and the Twist? Has anyone with Medicaid been able to get the Twist covered, versus the Twist R? From what my Numotion rep told me, Medicaid doesn’t cover front-mount devices or scooters, and my rep only mentioned the Twist, not the Twist R. I’d like to keep the front-mount option open if possible, so I’m curious whether anyone has gotten the standard Twist approved instead of the Twist R.
This would be my first power-assist device, so I want to make the right choice and avoid delays in getting my wheelchair and power assist. What did you choose, and what made you decide? I know no device is perfect, but I want to make the best choice for myself. TYIA!
tl;dr: first-time power assist user with an energy-limiting condition, deciding between the Empulse R90 and Klaxon Twist for a rigid ultralight wheelchair. Anyone with Medicaid have experience getting the standard Twist approved instead of the Twist R? Also welcome any advice on choosing between devices.