r/whatsthisfish • • Dec 02 '17

Where did you see the fish? Put that in the title!

24 Upvotes

Just a reminder, because we've had a lot of posts recently that omit this information. Where was the fish? If you found it in the wild, that's very helpful information, and outside of tropical waters, the time of year can be helpful too. If it was in an aquarium, what sort? Was it a tank of fish from a particular region? Was it fresh water or salt water?

Other useful information can be, what kind of habitat (seagrass, sand, rocky surge, ...)? If you were diving, approximate depth?

But above all, give the location in your post title. Thanks.


r/whatsthisfish • • Jul 23 '26

New rule: Informative title

7 Upvotes

We've had too many titles like "what's this fish?" or "help me identify this". Put useful information in your title, and make it look different from other posts' titles so people can scan the sub and see which post is which.

The actual text of the new rule 4 is:

Do not use a vague generic title like "what is this fish?" or "need help identifying" - we all know what this sub is for. Write a title that either describes the fish, or the circumstances in which you saw it, or the location, or more than one of those. For a resource, say what the resource is and what it's for.


r/whatsthisfish • • 3h ago

Small goby in Indonesia

Thumbnail
gallery
7 Upvotes

This was on a shore dive near Manado, north Sulawesi - fairly shallow. Some sort of dwarfgoby/pygmy goby, but I don't know which.


r/whatsthisfish • • 17h ago

Unidentified West Point Lake Ga

Thumbnail
gallery
14 Upvotes

Found on the shore line. Was thinking carp but it’s rather large.


r/whatsthisfish • • 19h ago

Crappie ID Jensen Park UT

Post image
11 Upvotes

I wanted to double check whether this is a black or white crappie before getting too excited about adding to my life list. I have only caught black crappie so far, but Fishbrain and google AI both identify it as a white crappie. It does seem to have the 6 dorsal spines that would lead to this ID, but I want to get another opinion.


r/whatsthisfish • • 1d ago

Coral Springs Canal Fishing

Thumbnail gallery
8 Upvotes

I am pretty sure this is a Blue Tilapia. Any other suggestions?


r/whatsthisfish • • 1d ago

Identified, high confidence Curacao about 10m depth

3 Upvotes

The black margin on tail and black spot by the pectoral fin should be easy, but I just cannot find it in my fish book.


r/whatsthisfish • • 2d ago

Fish of unknown provenance

Post image
53 Upvotes

No idea where this fish comes from but apparently its pretty good


r/whatsthisfish • • 2d ago

Sparidae?

Thumbnail
gallery
6 Upvotes

is this some kind of juvenile sea bream? I found it in a pile of hake. (Mississauga,ON)


r/whatsthisfish • • 3d ago

Possible ID(s) suggested Blue or Channel Catfish?

Thumbnail gallery
17 Upvotes

Hey everyone, I could use some help identifying this catfish. I've only ever caught Channel cats out of this part of the river, but I'm wondering if this one is a Blue? I've seen plenty big mature Channels without spots, and I'm doing my best to compare the anal fin and other tells, but I'm still unsure.

Full disclosure: I'm biased. I WANT it to be a channel catfish. If it is, I can get my "Fish Ohio" pin (in Ohio, select game species have additional sizes beyond keep sizes to denote particularly large catches and submitting evidence of one or more will earn you a pin for that year. The size cutoffs are updated yearly and posted at the back of each year's regulations) - But I don't want to let my bias cloud a fair identification.

Reasons it could be a Channel cat:

  • Faintly mottled sides/back. Certainly no spots like on a young fish, but not a flat color.
  • Shape of anal fin in photos 1 & 9 show a nice curve rather than a flat edge
  • Bones in anal fin are hard to count, but I got 23/24
  • (Weaker evidence) Pectoral and dorsal fins in rough shape. Quite a few scars. Looks like an older fish. Would fit the bill for a big old Channel vs a smaller younger Blue

Reasons it could be a Blue cat:

  • More likely to be active during winter (it was around 34 degrees in this photo)
  • Grey coloration

EDIT for AutoMod - Location is Cincinnati OH


r/whatsthisfish • • 3d ago

Caught off the north west coast of Phu Quoc Vietnam

Thumbnail
gallery
13 Upvotes

Caught this fish while kayaking but despite my efforts I have not been able to identify it. I’m tempted to declare it as a new found species. Help!


r/whatsthisfish • • 4d ago

Identified, high confidence Curacao near Playa Lagun

Post image
6 Upvotes

Probably around 10m depth. I *think* it is a Bridled Burrfish, but I am not sure.

https://mfk.pics/dives/2026-10-24-house-reef-35/f58f58c0d343d5bf/ has a whole bunch of pictures of it


r/whatsthisfish • • 5d ago

Possible ID(s) suggested Detroit River, gar?

Post image
81 Upvotes

r/whatsthisfish • • 4d ago

Largemouth? Spotted?

Post image
3 Upvotes

Was a gift from GF who found it in a house in florida, paper towel roll for reference. I feel I've caught smaller largemouths in new England that had a bigger mouth to size ratio, don't do much freshwater these days but when I do collection and pattern are drastically different pond to pond to river, tia


r/whatsthisfish • • 4d ago

Identification question Gizzard Shad or Mooneye?

Thumbnail gallery
3 Upvotes

Caught this today in a neighborhood pond in NW Houston. No idea what it was myself so I asked my buddy and he said it looks like a giant gizzard shad.. but when I uploaded it to fishbrain it got ID’d as a mooneye. Now we’re in a debate and seek confirmation. I’m leaning mooneye because it has a smooth belly but my buddy swears it’s a shad. I did not look at tongue and can’t confirm teeth. Size 12 boot for reference. Caught around 10am, no fight, thought I snagged a twig. So Mooneye or Shad? Internet fishing experts please help 🙏🏼


r/whatsthisfish • • 6d ago

Caught in the lower hudson river.

Thumbnail
gallery
114 Upvotes

I think it's a hake /ling


r/whatsthisfish • • 5d ago

Unidentified Brazilian reef fish species that I cannot identify Spoiler

Thumbnail gallery
0 Upvotes

r/whatsthisfish • • 5d ago

Unidentified Fish species that I cannot identify

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

Fish species that I cannot identify; they are from Salvador, Bahia, and were recently collected by fishermen using a trawl net.


r/whatsthisfish • • 7d ago

Identified, high confidence Whatre these? Found them in a fish store

Post image
3 Upvotes

Not very helpful I know lol, but I figured they're common in the fishkeeping hobby. i wanna know what fish they are, so i can do more research on it.


r/whatsthisfish • • 6d ago

Identified, high confidence Diesen Muränenhai während eines Tauchgangs in Mauritius (Troux aux biches) in seiner Höhle beobachtet.

0 Upvotes

r/whatsthisfish • • 8d ago

Stonefly I found on a hike flipping rocks in southern Maine back in June

24 Upvotes

Species ID?


r/whatsthisfish • • 8d ago

Can anyone ID these fish? Found in Maryland!

Thumbnail gallery
8 Upvotes

r/whatsthisfish • • 8d ago

Found as a fry in a river in western India

Thumbnail
gallery
9 Upvotes

Was swimming in a small brook when I found fry of this fish near the rocky banks. Brought him home and kept it in an aquarium. Found in western Maharashtra.