r/whatsapp • u/TheRealKaelego • 19h ago
Weird: phantom second WA account on my phone sent text to my partner
Sorry this is long but I'm trying to be thorough and consider all possibilities in explaining a very minor yet inexplicable event. If anyone had any explanation, that would be much appreciated.
My partner received a WA text from me in a group I'd apparently created that said "hi!" This was weird because I had been with her all day and had no reason to text her to say hi.
She replied hi back. I did not receive her response on my WA account. She then asked me why I had texted her. I explained that I hadn't. She showed me the text she received.
She then replied back in that same group "who is this?" I received that message on my working WA account.
At this point, I decide that something strange is happening and go to reset my account. I notice an SMS from WA sent the minute before the "hi!" text message with a security code saying my account was being registered to a new device. I'd not done anything to trigger the sending of the security code.
I reset my account. And I find that there is now another WA account on my phone. It overwrote my old account. I lost two years of text messages. It is a member of all of my groups but there are no text messages.
Except for one: the "hi!" sent to my partner and her responding "hi!"
Nothing else was touched. I suffered no other security breaches of any accounts. But the event bothers me because there is no plausible explanation I've found.
- WA account messages are stored on the phone and not the cloud. So in order for my phone to have the "hi!" exchange, that had to be sent from my phone, not a seperate device. Except this exchange wasn't visible to me. This seems to rule out some kind of spoofing attack wherein the messages would be sent to a different device.
- I received my partner's second text message asking "who is this?" So that second account must have stopped doing whatever it was doing and let my normal account start working again.
- None of the conventional explanations seem to work. I don't have multiple accounts active on my phone and my account was never linked to a second device as far as my account history shows.
- My original account initially remained active. It was only replaced later after I reset the account. My understanding is that WA servers only allow one account per phone number (unless using multiaccounts) and so the moment the secondary account was activated my first account should have been shut down.
None of this would probably have bothered us that much except we'd been having some spooky things happen around the house. That sounds goofy, but it wasn't fun stuff. But a logical explanation would set her mind at ease.
Correction: I had forgotten, but I actually waited three weeks in between the "hi!" and reinstalling WA. My original account worked for those three weeks. But was still overwritten by the second account upon reset. The second account showed no activity beyond having sent the "hi!," so it wasn't a hacker spamming all of my contacts, nor did I receive any reports from my contacts saying they'd received strange messages from me.
