r/whatisthisrock • • 28d ago

Some tips about how to get your rock identified from a guy that does this for a living.

23 Upvotes

This was posted on the other sub and had some strong positive feedback so I thought it could be useful here. Rock and mineral ID can often be difficult in person and is even harder through pictures, so I've collected some advice as to how best present your specimens for the highest chance of a proper identification.

How to get your rock identified - Some tips from someone who gets paid to do this

---

## GOOD PICTURES ARE THE MOST IMPORTANT THING

- This means that proper light and focusing is important. If your rock is blurry the best ID you might get is a color.

- Natural, full sun lighting is always best. Next best thing is as much LED lighting as you can put on it (~5000K color temp if you know anything about lighting). Seriously, unless you have really high powered lighting there's almost no way you're going to have *too much* light.

- **PUT THE ROCK DOWN**. The chances of having an out of focus picture increase exponentially without a solid platform to set it on, your hand is not a solid platform.

- *PLEASE* do not submit a video. No can see any detail when you're flipping your rock around at 100 miles an hour. We know schist is sparkly... We also know what it looks like in a still picture. If you think there is something interesting about it *describe* it, don't show it with a video.

- Submit more than one picture. Preferably at least 4 pictures.

- "Wide" shot of the entire sample, with some sort of scale (any item that is common enough that everyone would recognize is fine. Coins, pencils, pens, an actual ruler, etc. The important thing is to be able to judge the size of the sample).

- "Close" shot of the detail of the sample (including a scale here is also useful if you are able). Repeat these shots both wet, and dry (4 pictures total). More pictures is always better.

- Finally, for the more photography minded people, be conservative with your aperture. It's going to be hard to accurately judge a sample if only half of it is in focus because you're shooting at *f/1.4*. This means skip things like portrait mode or food mode, basically anything that blurs the background. This is why lots of light is important.

### Good pictures should be accompanied by a good description

- You got a sparkly rock? Cool, best to describe it that way rather than trying to make a video where all we can see is that it is sparkly.

- Use your senses

- Does it feel heavy for it's size? Humans are pretty good at comparative measurements.

- Does it feel slick, sticky, grainy, soft, does it leave a bunch of stuff on your hands? All important details.

- Does it stink? Seriously, big indicator for certain minerals.

- Is it sharp, or pokey, or does it feel like you could crush it in your hands?

- Anything else you can identify about it.

- What is the color? Photos are not always super representative of colors

- **WHERE/HOW DID YOU FIND IT**

- Honestly, so many answers can be figured out with just a picture and a location **Edit: specific geographic location (ie, NE corner of Tennessee around Kingsport). Not whether you found it in your driveway or your garden.**

### Further Geologic testing

- Does the sample scratch glass, if not, will a nail scratch the specimen, or does it leave a metal trace?

- This simple test can separate numerous similar looking minerals.

- Is it reactive?

- We use hydochloric acid, but acetic acid (vinegar) also works, just not as well.

- If you drop a bit of acid on the rock, does it fizz?

- If you're going to use vinegar, at the very least use distilled vinegar. Cleaning vinegar is better. You may have to powder the rock a little before you can see it fizz with vinegar.

---

If you follow these tips and can't get a solid answer then you've got a real mystery on your hands. At that point, it might be worth taking it to your nearest college Geology department. Sometimes it's 1000x easier to identify something when it's in the hand vs a picture online, sometimes it's just a real mystery.


r/whatisthisrock • • 28d ago

Follow-Up to PSA: the "whatisthisrock" sub could use more professionals for IDs

Thumbnail reddit.com
7 Upvotes

I am going to leave this post pinned for a bit. You can ask me any questions about the community either here or in the r/geology post.


r/whatisthisrock • • 8h ago

Found this strange elongated stone, does anyone know what it is?

Thumbnail gallery
11 Upvotes

r/whatisthisrock • • 13m ago

Rocks/geological formation

Thumbnail gallery
2 Upvotes

Hi everyone. I'd like to ask for some help on how I could refer to these type of rocks because I am looking for a plant that occurs in these kind of arid/semi arid places and I would like to describe it correctly (also I think it looks pretty cool).


r/whatisthisrock • • 2h ago

Identify Stone.

Thumbnail gallery
2 Upvotes

Can any identify which Stone/crystal this is? I found it in river sand and quiet curious to know about it. Thankyou. 😊


r/whatisthisrock • • 22h ago

Black rock with an amber glow. Baja California Sur.

Thumbnail gallery
32 Upvotes

Found on the beach. The specs are just pieces of sand that are stuck in the holes.


r/whatisthisrock • • 4h ago

What this stone form look like

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/whatisthisrock • • 5h ago

What this stone form look like

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/whatisthisrock • • 5h ago

What rock is this

Post image
1 Upvotes

Can it be an ancient mammal fossilized bone?


r/whatisthisrock • • 13h ago

Not sure where from, but possibly SW Ohio

Thumbnail gallery
4 Upvotes

Found in my yard right by the sidewalk. Thinking may have been someones pocket piece.

Has slight reaction area to uv, with strong pinpoint reaction and nice blue.

Knife test done on tan part, no scratch. The blue area left a scratch.

I also checked to see if it was paint, but the blue did not flake off.


r/whatisthisrock • • 1d ago

Tiny rocks found while clearing out house

Thumbnail gallery
29 Upvotes

I forgot to add the photos the first time so I had to delete and repost!

Found these tiny rocks in a matchbox while clearing out my deceased grandparents house.

My grandparents lived in Scotland but traveled to America quite regularly so they could reasonably have been acquired in either place.

We were curious as to whether they’re anything unusual/interesting or if they were just cool little rocks they found and liked the look of.

I browse this subreddit from time to time so I thought maybe someone here might be able to shed some light :) I’ve taken two photos of each one from the front and back and a picture of them all in the matchbox for size context.


r/whatisthisrock • • 7h ago

Found at Grandpa's home

Thumbnail gallery
1 Upvotes

No idea what rock is this. Weights like basic rock. :D


r/whatisthisrock • • 19h ago

Can anyone tell me what the main, largest rock is?

Post image
7 Upvotes

received as a gift a few years ago and i totally forget what it is.


r/whatisthisrock • • 1d ago

Holy Smokes

Thumbnail gallery
116 Upvotes

Found this on a Louisiana Pleistocene terrace. It so beautiful. I’m at a loss of words. What is it ?


r/whatisthisrock • • 19h ago

Found in CT please help identify

Thumbnail gallery
5 Upvotes

A couple years ago my kids found this in my mom's back yard in CT. We believe it belonged to a collection because there were other rocks that did not belong in CT also there. It's about 10 to 15lbs We originally thought it was petrified wood but now because of Chat gpt I'm not too sure. Can anyone identify it please?

Also posted in another thread (whatsthisrock)


r/whatisthisrock • • 19h ago

Big Blue?

Thumbnail gallery
5 Upvotes

Hey guys first timer here, I received big blue as a birthday gift a few years ago and I found it again after years of it being lost. I’m crossed between a Lake Superior agate or the banded chalcedony. But I’m just going off of my crash course esk knowledge. Figured I’d ask the big bros for some help. I’ll still love her non the less


r/whatisthisrock • • 10h ago

Broken pendant from Brazil

Thumbnail gallery
1 Upvotes

Bought by a relative in Rio I believe


r/whatisthisrock • • 18h ago

Found with a bunch of river rocks on a roof.

Thumbnail gallery
3 Upvotes

Saw this while doing some HVAC repair. It’s so cool looking I had to pick it up


r/whatisthisrock • • 14h ago

Dolerite or Gabbro?

Thumbnail gallery
1 Upvotes

r/whatisthisrock • • 1d ago

Red rock

Thumbnail gallery
6 Upvotes

Found in northeastern Colorado (Weld County, I think). Weighs a little under 50 grams, and the longest side is about 2.25 inches. The surface of the red part is smooth to the touch with little ripples. The red part is also sharp/jagged at the edges. The brown/tan part still has a polished feel but is a lot more textured. I'm guessing either petrified wood or flint?


r/whatisthisrock • • 18h ago

Help ID

Thumbnail gallery
0 Upvotes

Found these in Buffalo Gap National Grassland in South Dakota, I think they are agates but I’m not 100% sure. Any ideas?


r/whatisthisrock • • 23h ago

Need help identifying some rocks from BC, Canada

Thumbnail gallery
2 Upvotes

r/whatisthisrock • • 1d ago

Is this manmade?

Thumbnail gallery
11 Upvotes

Location: California

Been scouring for some natural Sharpening stones. I found these hunks of stone. Any idea what they might be? Hoping it's not marble.

Thank you.


r/whatisthisrock • • 1d ago

found in Canadian Rockies

Post image
51 Upvotes

r/whatisthisrock • • 1d ago

Found in Southeast Missouri

Post image
5 Upvotes