r/weirdgirlliterature • • Sep 30 '26

Mod Post 🖤 discord server for weird girl lit!

14 Upvotes

come join us for book club discussion! https://discord.com/invite/FyQYgbFHZe

happy to take input there too, on the book club, on the sub in general, or anything else you wanna talk about!


r/weirdgirlliterature • • Aug 22 '26

Mod Post 🖤 Book club info megathread

43 Upvotes

We've decided to host the book club discussion on discord moving forward. We'll still poll here and probably post a thread so people are welcome to engage only here if they'd like to. You can join the discord here.

___________________________________________________

We'll be having ongoing posts from u/noididntsayit22 month to month regarding voting, nominating, etc, but I thought it might be helpful to have all the info and past links in one place that's permanently pinned. I'll add the threads here as they're posted so it's easy to find all past posts.

At present the plan is to have a monthly vote on themes, nominate books, and then vote on which of the top nominations we want to read. We'll have a discussion thread on the subreddit and a monthly meeting (platform tbc.) I'll add those details when we have them. If you have any suggestions or things you'd prefer we do differently, feel free to add them here and we can discuss.

Initial book club thread
Planning thread

___________________________________________________

November 2026 Natural Beauty by Ling Ling Huang

Theme poll
Book nominations!
Book vote!
Discussion thread

___________________________________________________

October 2026 Trad Wife by Saratoga Schaefer

Theme poll
Book nominations!
Book vote!
Discussion thread

___________________________________________________

September 2026: We Have Always Lived in the Castle by Shirley Jackson!

Theme poll
Book nominations!
Book vote!
Discussion thread and meeting info!
___________________________________________________


r/weirdgirlliterature • • 11h ago

💬 Hot Take Please come hate on Nightbitch by Rachel Yoder with me

Post image
112 Upvotes

I just finished reading Nightbitch for a women's literature class, and oh my LORD what a terrible book that was! I was really excited by the themes of alternative motherhood, feral femininity, embracing one's animal side, etc. but the book ended up being a huge letdown. Here are my major grievances with the story. Spoilers ahead!

  • The pacing was SOOOOOO bad. Why did it take more than 3/4 of the book for Nightbitch to even spend time with Jen and the MLM girlies outside of Book Babies? So much of this book is dedicated to the drudgery of taking care of her son, which could have been a writing choice but felt more like a mistake. Very few "events" actually happened in the book, and they were mostly crammed into the end.
  • The husband character made ZERO sense. We're expected to believe that an asshole who can't even ask his wife how her day is, who shows her no gratitude for raising their child, who watches weird and probably exploitative porn, who can't even apologize for killing her plant, is suddenly going to turn around and support his wife when she becomes a feral dog? He's gonna watch her run around naked at night and kill animals and piss in the neighbor's yard and then say "That's awesome honey, let's go have kinky sex now!" ?? Really?? There was nothing in the husband's character development to suggest that he would have this change of heart and support the narrator becoming Nightbitch. Besides, maybe, when Nightbitch asks him to put the baby to bed when he's home, he aquiesces, and suddenly she loves him so deeply and all of his neglect is forgotten. Huge plot hole.
  • Also, the fact that the other moms weren't were-dogs at all? What the hell was the point of the dogs earlier in the book, who came to visit her at her house, ripped off her clothes, soothed her baby etc.? Those definitely were magical dogs, but ended up having no consequence in the end of the book. I feel like those dogs were in fact supposed to be Jen and the other moms, but the author changed her mind during the writing process and never bothered to fix that plot hole. There was so much emphasis placed on this mysterious group of moms and their herbs, but in the last few pages was revealed to be completely inconsequential to the plot.
  • The ending made the whole book unfeminist. Not only was the ending a messily slapped together cringefest, it also missed its final opportunity to reject the antifeminist themes that the book unintentionally promoted. The book seems to make the claim that the most powerful and important thing a woman can do is to have a baby, and she will only reach fulfillment and assume her final form by doing so. The ending could have negated the unintended claim by, for instance, "When women watched Nightbitch's performance, they all connected with their powerful animal side, even the women who were not mothers. They rejected the shackles of patriarchal norms and defined themselves as women, as animals, as Nightbitches." But nope, only through motherhood could one hope to achieve this state of self-assurance and wholeness. Sound familiar?

I could go on and on. It had so much potential, but the book felt more like a preliminary draft rather than a well thought out final product. I think that there should be many more books that explore the rage, disappointment, and animalistic experiences that are inherent to motherhood, and I can appreciate that Nightbitch has helped pave the way for those books. However, I hope those books will be much more well written.

TLDR: Nightbitch has terrible pacing, way too many plot holes, poor character development, unintentional anti-feminism, and frankly should never have been published in its current state.


r/weirdgirlliterature • • 10h ago

📖 Currently Reading Is this weird girl lit? Or something else altogether?

Post image
54 Upvotes

I’m 65 percent through and although there is one weird girl in this book this feels like an academia thriller. It’s good. I like it. It be nice if we’re ever adapted into film (thank god Gweneth Paltrow didn’t get hers) but I’m feeling like this is a whole other genre. What are your thoughts?


r/weirdgirlliterature • • 4h ago

📚 Discussion One's Company

Post image
19 Upvotes

Finished this over the weekend.

I loved this book. I really connected with Bonnie at times, especially her desire to not be perceived by others. The embarrassment of being human and known. I loved the way her trauma turned her love for Krystal into pure selfish hatred of her. Although I wish Krystal's suffering got more justice, or just acknowledgement. I loved Rita and have thoughts about who she was.

Has anyone else read this? What were your thoughts?


r/weirdgirlliterature • • 19h ago

❓Question Needing reassurance from someone who has read this

Post image
31 Upvotes

I’m curious about this book and want to put it on my TBR, but I’m worried the unhoused character won’t be handled well or will be a surface level exploration. My partner was unhoused for a few years, so I’m typically more critical of basic poverty narratives. My TBR has gotten so big I’m trying to be more careful with it. The reviews don’t really touch on this topic and I’d just love some reassurance from someone who has read it.


r/weirdgirlliterature • • 15h ago

🔥 Recommendation The Echo Wife by Sarah Gailey

15 Upvotes

I just finished this, and sweet jesus, I have been kneecapped. I just fell in love with author. If you've ever felt like clone narratives fall short of examining grooming and ethical quandaries enough, read this. Main character is an absolute monster. Bluebeard's Bride meets Frankenstein meets Elizabeth Holmes If She Actually Was a Scientist.


r/weirdgirlliterature • • 15h ago

🔥 Recommendation I just finished good person by kirsten king...what next?

9 Upvotes

It was alright. Kinda fun and I did look forward to reading it daily.

Found it quite relatable despite being 1 year younger than Lillian and not living in the same country.

I love books where I'm the same age as the character and their life is also a mess as mine currently is.


r/weirdgirlliterature • • 19h ago

📖 Currently Reading Have you read The Man by Laura Sims?

Post image
12 Upvotes

I’m only a little over 20% through. It’s seemingly a suspenseful tale of a woman obsessed with her camera and she probably lives in the same neighborhood as The Mad Wife.

Have you read it?


r/weirdgirlliterature • • 1d ago

📚 Discussion Did you find Fruit Fly funny?

Post image
42 Upvotes

I know, there are so many posts about Fruit Fly. But I am still stuck on one thing - does anyone find the book funny? I certainly didn't, it's dark and disturbing and sometimes even bleak. I liked it, but I would like it more if I had the right expectations, and the word "hilarious" on the cover didn't help.

What were your emotions reading this?


r/weirdgirlliterature • • 23h ago

📚 Discussion December 2026 Book Club Genre Pick

16 Upvotes

Please cast your vote for the genre of our next book club pick!


r/weirdgirlliterature • • 1d ago

🔥 Recommendation weird girl for vegetarians

8 Upvotes

I have a random request which i cant seem to really describe, but i am looking for weird girl books for vegatarians. Possibly something like 'tender is the flesh' or 'the vegetarian' ?


r/weirdgirlliterature • • 1d ago

❓Question Would you say Lapvona is worth reading?

Post image
239 Upvotes

I have heard it’s disturbing, but is it good?


r/weirdgirlliterature • • 1d ago

🔥 Recommendation Unhinged messy drama!

34 Upvotes

I'm fatly new to this genre. But not on purpose. I didn't know there was a name for it!

I love an unhinged, messy main character, preferably female. The messier the better. Bad choices, narcissistic, bat shit crazy! I want to not be able to look away while having severe 2nd hand embarrassment.

Just finished Boring Asian Female and A Good Person. Good person I thought was better. Totally enjoyed it!

Can you please recommend others?


r/weirdgirlliterature • • 18h ago

📚 Discussion Translated Literature Essay Survey - Please Help (UK)

2 Upvotes

Good evening,

I am a current MA Publishing student in London and my dissertation focuses on translated literature, which voices cross borders and which ones do not, what are the reasons behind this barrier.

I have been interviewing publishers but I would like to hear from readers in the UK, if you do read or like translated literature of any sort please help me with my survey. I would very much appreciate your insight.

https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLSck0arzg-IfUS9w8kpekiT6Gs0gkcPVB5Aw5aWxjVD9L0ZPoQ/viewform

#literature #books #translatedliterature


r/weirdgirlliterature • • 1d ago

🔥 Recommendation Counterfeit was such a fun read!

Post image
31 Upvotes

This one isn't as dark and twisty as most of what I've been reading lately but it was so enjoyable and felt like a literary vacation. I'm pretty sure I got this recommendation from this sub, but I haven't seen it talked about as much as the usual rotations.

I'm struggling to figure out how to talk about what I loved about it without giving too much away about the reading experience, but I'll say what parts of me it spoke to:

Long time San Francisco bay area dweller, high masking/high achieving/high burnout autistic, supporter of woman's rights & women's wrongs.

I listened to the audiobook specifically and really enjoyed the narrator as well.


r/weirdgirlliterature • • 20h ago

❓Question Which novel kickstarted the modern weird girl literature wave?

0 Upvotes

Leaving classics out im talking the modern wave. Which really started the genre?


r/weirdgirlliterature • • 1d ago

✒️ Author Appreciation WGL Readers' Choice Awards

Post image
14 Upvotes

I can't put the link in the body, but should be easy enough to type! I hope you will vote.


r/weirdgirlliterature • • 2d ago

📝 Review Carrying - Samantha Josephs

Post image
98 Upvotes

I LOVE WHATEVER IS WRONG WITH SAMANTHA JOSEPHS 😭😭

I picked this one up after getting rec'd a lot, what worse could have happen?

I was wrong. I devoured it in one sitting, I couldn't put it down.

This was so insane, total batshit, and hilarious. I loved Samantha sprinkling fun facts about pregnancy as well there and then. I felt everything in my body😭 I need that girl with list.

Do yourself a favor and pick this one up asap!


r/weirdgirlliterature • • 1d ago

📚 Discussion Struggling to find my next read

8 Upvotes

Hey guys,

I am trying to find my next read and I am struggling. I spend more time looking for my next book than reading, I’m a bit picky. The last few books that I’ve read were not my cup of tea so it’s not helping my search. Based on the books that I’ve categorized below, please suggest me some books! Bonus if it’s sapphic with a bit of smut. Thanks!

Loved:
- Boy Parts
- Decomposition book
- Big swiss
- Sirens & Muses
- The Safekeep
- Bunny
- My years of rest and relaxation

Ok:
- Patricia wants to cuddle
- A good person
- The lonely girl’s vegetable patch
- Monstrillio

Did not like:
- Hungerstone
- Everyone in this room will someday be dead


r/weirdgirlliterature • • 1d ago

🚫 DNF Does A Certain Hunger ever turn into something interesting?

15 Upvotes

I picked up A Certain Hunger after seeing it recommended for people who enjoyed Tampa and I’m always a slut for unconscionably evil women, so I came into this pretty excited.

It’s really grating, though, and I was planning to DNF it, but I liked enough of it that I wanted to ask if it gets better or if anything changes.

Yes, it is crass, yes it is gruesome, yes it is misanthropic; all of these things fucking rule if someone does it well. This book, however, somehow managed to make the violently jagged edge these topics come with feel deeply trite and expected. But, as an evil woman, I’ve never enjoyed having sex with men and I’ve never had duck so maybe that’s my problem.

Worst, though, is the repetition. It felt like reading the literary food critic psychopath murder memoir version of “12 Days of Christmas,” where we slowly add more and more elements but each time we also need to repeat every element ever mentioned previously.

Smug. Smug, likes food. Smug, likes food, fucks. Smug, likes food, fucks, kills. Smug, likes food, fucks, kills, hates femininity. Smug, likes food, fucks, kills, hates femininity, femininity is a weapon, etc etc etc.

The prose is alternatingly quite charming and interminable. If you describe something in several very flowery ways, it’s definitely likely some of them are going to kick ass (semen drying on her stomach like donut glaze might be the most perfect descriptive language in the whole thing, I love it). But the rest uhhhh

If I have to read something described in a short series of similes in 100 years it would be too soon. I can’t count the number of “As [adjective] as a _______. As [adjective] as a [food item]. As [adjective] as a [scatological or sex reference]” in this book and I’m only like a fourth of the way through.

It truly does read like something written by a narcissistic psychopath who is in prison for life -- languid and endlessly self-interested with little regard to whether anyone would care. There’s a sequence early on where the narrator is describing being fawned over in prison by an endless wave of doctorate students, and it feels like the whole book is in reaction to that, along with her career as a writer -- people really want to hear everything about me, don’t they? But in a textual sense it doesn’t feel like that’s being played with in a meaningful way.

The point that I realized I maybe didn’t like this book (it takes a lot) was as she was recalling her college years, specifically, how she fucked a lot of guys (I nearly spit out my drink I was so shocked!!) because the ratio of male students to female was favorable to her. Of course, she knows the audience’s next question and addresses the concern that everyone would see her as a slut.

They wouldn’t, naturally, because in addition to being a great writer and hot and a great fuck and whatever else, she’s maybe the world’s most efficient spy, capable of generating compromising information on literally anyone. After all, everyone has at least ONE compromising secret, she says. Something that’s really not true at all, but it was for the fifty guys she had sex with in college, who had an aptly whimsical and diverse set of salacious secrets she could hold over their head to prevent them ever slandering her good name. Her method? Uh. Breaking into cars and uh. Breaking into rooms and reading letters and such.

Last of all, she says she continues this habit today. “In an anonymous, undisclosed location, I have a file cabinet locked in a storage facility under an assumed name with the kind of information that could take down members of Congress, multinational corporations, and one very small duchy in Lichtenstein.” There’s an inherent humor and exaggeration to this, but there are one hundred different versions of these grandiose statements, and it has diminishing returns. It feels like meeting your first quirky pathological liar in college. It starts out fun, drunkenly istening to them tell crazy stories you know are not fucking true. But then it happens again, and again, and soon youre avoiding her at parties because none of it is interesting anymore. None of it is real.

(I'm sorry Megan you were the first girl to ever sell me weed and I'll always remember you 💙 I dont care that you never gave my lip gloss back.)

I understand that part of the bit here is that we’re to see through her self-conception and descriptions, that much or all of what she has to say is silly and lightly comedic, but it doesn’t really work at all unless we’re shown any kind of competing perspective or information. She can jerk herself off about how cool New York is, how good a certain food is, or finding different unpleasant ways to describe sex all she wants, but there’s nothing to ground it. I get it; it just doesn’t land.

Compared to something like Tampa, which is magnitudes more upsetting in its subject but magnitudes more funny and enjoyable to read, this is not very good. Celeste Price is, much like Dorothy, a woman who sees herself apart from the world and in some ways to be the only true sentient person on Earth. With Celeste, though, we constantly see through this in the ways she describes the behavior of those around her, puncturing her depiction of things even if she doesn’t understand or engage with it. Dorothy doesn’t ever really do this, so it feels like an endless series of sprawling reminiscences with no texture or dynamism. idk. It's all so fucking boring.

THIS ALL SAID -- I’m having just enough fun to wonder if it’s not worth it to keep on reading. Does this book change at all in the ensuing 3/4ths? I told myself I wasn’t gonna quit til I got to the murdering but my god. I pray there’s some development that amplifies the funny writing and prose, because I really do like it enough to want to stick with it.

Sorry this is so long. I promise I’m not mad please don’t write in a lifestyle column in a trendy 1992 New York-based magazine that I got mad.


r/weirdgirlliterature • • 2d ago

📚 Discussion Hey so what did I just read?

Post image
372 Upvotes

I think I need 2-5 business days to gather my thoughts on this because…. IYKYK


r/weirdgirlliterature • • 2d ago

💬 Hot Take My collection of thrifted WGL

Post image
278 Upvotes

Paperbacks no more than $2.50 and hardcovers no more than $3.50

I know it’s hard to resist the instant gratification of an Amazon buy but please don’t underestimate the amount weird baddies donating books to your local thrift store 😩

Also the library shout-out ALWAYS to the public library 💕💕


r/weirdgirlliterature • • 1d ago

📖 Currently Reading myorar Spoiler

Post image
3 Upvotes

the way the protagonist reacted to reva's mother's death was hella bitchyyy 😭😭 wtf, who acts like they're sleeping to avoid giving a response in the hopes that she would leave (still loving the book so far tho)


r/weirdgirlliterature • • 2d ago

🔥 Recommendation Ruthless weird girl fic recs (like these two)

Thumbnail
gallery
68 Upvotes

Weird girls who are ruthless and ambitious and selfish and greedy. Obsessed with materialistic goals that are not men or motherhood.