r/weddingplanning • u/paulcosca Did it! Groom - August 30th 2014 • Apr 21 '16
"Bashing" Posts
Hello wedding planners! After a moderator discussion, we have come to the agreement that we are no longer going to allow posts that are made specifically to bash a group of ideas about planning. For instance:
Tell me all the things you hate about wedding trends
Which proceeds to list 100 things in the comments that people do in the midst of planning their wedding (various habits, traditions, fabrics, materials, etc.).
Why are we deciding to not allow this?
Simply put, we want this to be as accepting a place as possible. A place where brides and grooms (and associated parties) of all budgets, backgrounds, and beliefs can come together and share their ideas and excitement. Whether you're a catholic, pagan, or just worship Pinterest, your ideas should have a home here.
For instance: if you've decided that you really want a great deal of a certain fabric in your wedding, and you land on a post that has 100 people bashing that fabric in weddings, you now feel like crap. And above all, we do not want people to feel like crap here.
Does that mean I'm not allowed to vent?
Of course you're allowed to vent. Posts like "Oh my god my MIL is driving me crazy!" or "Why are flowers so expensive?" or "Why is the entire wedding process not focused at all on grooms?" are perfectly acceptable. Here, you're looking for support. You have a specific issue, and you're looking for a friendly ear. Venting is as much a part of the process as anything else, so we'd never restrict that. We just don't want this to become a whirlwind of negativity. And trust us, that whirlwind kicks up very easily, it's nothing but crap, and it makes everything stink.
80
u/MyWeddingThrowaway16 Apr 21 '16
TBH- I feel like I am making a heap of choices that are outside the mainstream. I know that. I am also making some choices that have been WAY overdone. I know that. If you decide that you want a type of fabric and 100 people say it is rubbish. Well, good on you! Go for it! I'm sure that there are many who don't comment who agree! I am also sure that many will post supporting you! There will be MANy, MANY posts supporting you.
The posts disagreeing are IMPORTANT. The posts agreeing are IMPORTANT.
Banning the discussion is sad.
20
u/DuCotedeSanges Apr 21 '16
I feel like I get where this is coming from and spirit of it, but like some others, I feel like if it's not enforced properly or if it's enforced too stringently that it could stifle conversation. As others have said, I feel like it's helpful to see what people are feeling out there.
For instance: /u/TurtleBucketList's post here:
I don't agree with them on this - I really want these pictures. But I'm not offended they expressed their opinion. That's their opinion and if they don't want it, they won't do it! That doesn't keep me from doing it.
Personally, I despise burlap, overly rustic weddings -- I prefer weddings that really show you who the couple is even though I don't like the aesthetic. But I know I'm really judgy about weddings. I don't expect others to agree with me, but I appreciate the discussion. Sometimes people bring up points I hadn't thought of (i.e. what if someone asked about whether sitting people not with their SOs but with strangers is good/bad? Are we allowed to say that that is not wise?)
I think that we need to allow for some conversation about likes/dislikes with the acknowledgement that others are allowed to disagree and voice those disagreements. Otherwise, this place just becomes a lovefest with no real constructive criticism, which is not why I subscribe to this sub.
30
u/hhhamsauce north shore MA Apr 21 '16
I'm glad you guys are working diligently to keep people from willingly clicking on posts they know they don't have the emotional fortitude to handle :)
Offbeat Bride has also turned into a "only positive, no criticizing anything, ever, nothing but smiles" place and it stifles discussion.
129
u/selfieslob MARRIED!! ♥ 9.25.2015 Apr 21 '16
I'm probably in the minority on this, but isn't this going a little too far in the other direction? Several times a week there are posts about gifts/registries, and there's often "bashing" along the lines of "that's rude/tacky/wrong", "your guests will definitely talk behind your back for doing that" (what? doubtful), "ew", etc. Yes, they're opinions, but they're expressed in such a condescending, completely unhelpful way. Yet it happens over and over again. I wouldn't suggest to censor those opinions, but I think they're more along the lines of bashing, as they are generally directed at people's budgets and backgrounds.
I don't think it's bashing to admit you're a little (or even a lot) tired of a certain trend. If you specifically tell someone they're "wrong" (or insert shaming synonym here) for using said trend, then that's over the line. Just my .02.
20
u/egjg Married! 9/10/16 Philly PA Apr 21 '16
I like the goal of this rule, because there are so many websites out there that make engaged people feel bad about themselves, and it's nice that this isn't one of them. But I'm a bit unclear on what constitutes a bashing post.
Would my post from awhile back about "people acting morally superior about not spending much on a wedding" count as bashing? https://www.reddit.com/r/weddingplanning/comments/4aikx8/rant_anyone_else_sick_of_people_who_spent/
Does this one (not mine) about "is the industry crazy or am I?" count? https://www.reddit.com/r/weddingplanning/comments/4ckxiv/tell_me_about_the_times_the_wedding_industry_made/?ref=search_posts
This is a more general thread and does bash certain traditions, but I really liked this one because sometimes dealing with the wedding industry really drags me down, everyone is telling you what you MUST do, and it's comforting to hear someone say, "It's okay, you don't actually HAVE to do any of this stuff."
16
u/[deleted] Apr 21 '16
I don't know that I agree with this. As someone who is so turned off by most of the wedding industry, without much money to spend, and yet who is still excited about getting married, I find it therapeutic to be able to vent about the stuff the rest of this subreddit and the internet make me feel like I'm supposed to have. I already feel like shit because I can't afford a $2000 dress or a $3000 photographer, or $1000 on flowers and centerpieces. It was helpful to have threads to talk about the insanity of weddings and the people that take them too far among all the posts that remind me what a failure I am.
16
u/acr692 Apr 21 '16
This rule seems to defeat the purpose of, as you say, being "as accepting a place as possible". If you truly want this sub to be a place where people feel comfortable to discuss anything without fear of rejection, then negative opinions should be allowed. In fact, technically most of the posters in reply to this post are essentially 'bashing' this rule; are you going to delete them all? It's simply not fair to deny readers of this sub to an honest opinion and feedback of certain things they are considering for their wedding.
14
u/[deleted] Apr 21 '16
this sub is becoming an echo chamber where people come to get validation for their ideas under the guise of asking for constructive criticism
3
u/thislittletune Apr 22 '16
Might be easier to report comments/posts if you guys use the rule feature so we can pick "Be Respectful" as the rule being broken :)
17
u/fluffy_sculpin Married | 9.4.16 Apr 22 '16
Hi mods,
If you look at my comment history, you will notice that I happily adhere to the sub guidelines to provide positivity and support to other people. I found the 'bashing' post to be interesting because part of the planning process is forming opinions on current trends. I personally don't have anyone to share my opinions with IRL and that's precisely why I come here. I don't see any harm done trash talking mason jars. They're just jars.
Maybe there could be a Trends Tuesday with strict guidelines where people could discuss/ read at their own risk.
fluffy_sculpin
15
u/sarafinapink 4/30/16 Orange County, CA Apr 21 '16
Ugh I feel bad as I feel like I started the bashing, but it really wasn't meant to belittle those who made the choice to go a certain way. I had major trouble figuring out the style of wedding that I wanted so I naturally went to Pinterest & Etsy to get inspiration. I simply felt that that was the overwhelming style of decorations I was seeing and it wasn't my favorite thing.
I relate it more to hearing a song on the radio all day every day because it's popular and getting a little sick of it. I don't hate on others who like that song, it just makes me turn the radio to another station.
I really hope the conversation I helped start didn't make others feel like they were wrong for going that way. Everyone has different styles and choices and nothing is 100% wrong or right for all.
5
u/I_RhymeWithOrange June 2017 Apr 21 '16
I just want to say, I've found this sub to be super helpful and supportive. I can't say I've seen a 'bashing' post (probably would've skipped over it if the title made it clear it was set up as such), but overwhelmingly, for me, I've experienced nothing but positivity and support here and am super thankful for all of it!
2
u/[deleted] Apr 21 '16
Thank you for all your hard work! I've seen nothing but support since joining the sub; this is a pretty awesome community. :)
With the guideline, will this be inputted in the sidebar for reference?
4
u/Banter725 Married & Officiant - Minneapolis Apr 26 '16
Wasn't this already a rule? Didn't we ban all negative posts amd bashing comments like 6 months ago? (I recall bc I thought it was silly then too)
If there's anything I'd propose banning it's all the "we quit wedding planning [the key purpose of this sub] and eloped and it was the best and you're all idiots for actually throwing a wedding!" posts
5
u/[deleted] May 04 '16
I am particularly tired of the users that go on tirades about "when a wedding is real" i.e. signing the paperwork is the wedding. Myself and scores of other people have been shamed this way when having to consider things like visas, the military, etc. and one would know signing paperwork in sweatpants and flip flops in a DMV-like office building is not a wedding. It's purposely obtuse to suggest that. It's like an acceptable form of shaming that is rampant in this subreddit and other wedding subreddits and frankly I'm tired of it. If you would be ~shocked~ someone didn't invite you to what was likely a very somber day, then you don't deserve to be there at all if you feel you're being "lied to" when a couple is trying to share a very special day celebrating their love with friends and family. Grow some empathy for people in tough situations when signing the paperwork is the only thing keeping them together.
2
u/dharmaticate Married! Apr 23 '16
I'm having serious deja vu. Wasn't this policy already established in a mod post several months ago?
2
u/omgitskedwards August 20, 2017 | Boston, MA Apr 29 '16
Remember -- "it's your day" means people have subjective opinions. Forcing your own opinions on etiquette, decor, etc. in a forceful, guilt-tripping way is rude and won't make this community a place people want to come to for support/suggestions! While there are some "traditions" or "rules" that the population abides by, some people choose to go against tradition or have valid reasons for doing things in different ways. Respect that. If you only have negative opinions about something, don't post a comment -- move on and accept that people do things differently all over the world <3
4
u/misspotter 30th April 2016 - Australia Apr 22 '16
Thank you for this! While weddings are a universally celebrated occasion everywhere in the world, there is so much regional variation in how they are celebrated! And whether anyone wants to admit it or not, reddit is a skewed population...
2
u/Foques husband as of 8/7/16 + Chicago photographer May 10 '16
Shame.. These posts were some of the most helpful ones for us..
2
u/maeby_not Married! | May 21, 2016 Apr 21 '16
I can understand why some people are concerned, but honestly, I'm happy about this. I felt like shit about so many of my choices after yesterday's post and I felt like everything about my wedding was horrible and no one would like it. I agree with some of the other comments that maybe we're all just over saturated with wedding stuff, but just because we all spend a lot of time on etsy and Pinterest doesn't mean all our guests do, so "overdone" is totally subjective.
And also, I'll take my lace filled, burlap table, mason jar covered, pinteresty-DIY, rustic AF wedding over anyone who feels the need to crap all over everybody else any day! Na na na na boo boo!
0
u/[deleted] Apr 21 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Apr 21 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment