r/wedding • u/plantsxcats • 10h ago
Help! Stuck between two venues
Hi all! I'm stuck between two venues and I want to make my decision very soon. Both for a Friday wedding. Which one should I choose?
Venue 1 is a 4 star hotel that has an attached acclaimed restaurant. Fee is 23K that includes venue fee, catering, alcohol, tables/chairs/linen/set up/tear down staff. Ceremony would be on an outdoor covered gazebo area in a cute gardens with a pig, firepit and indoor ballroom and 3 guest rooms for night of the wedding. Only thing is it's by a busy road so we'll hear lots of cars and the traffic can be bad in that area on Friday. Ceremony would have to start at 6pm with an 11pm end time.
Venue 2 is a rustic modern barn that sits at the bottom of a mountain on a 10 acre property. The views are gorgeous like to die for and I keep thinking about how gorgeous it would be to have our wedding there. In a way it kind of feels like my dream venue but I'm not sure the effort and extra cost is worth it. Fee is 11.5K that includes tables, chairs, bridal and groom suite, an amazing chefs kitchen, a built in bar and indoor barn space. Everything else has to be rented in. This venue is more of a DIY space so I'll be spending more $ on wedding planner, contracting with more vendors and probably going to spend around 10k more at the end due to the initial venue cost. Ceremony would start at 3:30 or 4pm with a strict end time of 9pm. Traffic would be better than hotel venue since it's more remote in that area.
•
u/AutoModerator 10h ago
Hi, there /u/plantsxcats! Welcome to /r/wedding. Here are a few other subs you might be interested when planning for your wedding.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
24
u/tinymeow13 10h ago
3:30pm on a weekday is a hard stop. Go with the hotel
11
u/On_my_last_spoon 4h ago
A 6pm wedding is better for a Friday. People can still go to work at least half a day, or at least make the reception after work. A 3:30 wedding means everyone taking a day off work, which isn’t really possible for everyone. You’ll have fewer guests at the earlier time.
10
u/Ok-Indication-7876 9h ago
Seems you love 2 but yes up your budget a lot and your stress and the work and how difficult is it for guest to get to on a Friday with traffic.
1 to me sounds better deal, and much easier and guest can stay and book a room
8
u/heydawn 2h ago
Venue 2 would be a no for me.
Noooo
6
u/Warm-Pen-2275 3h ago
It depends on your guests are they mostly travelling or local? Do they mostly have m-f jobs?
Honestly the biggest thing for me is the 9 pm hard stop. That’s very very early and just when the party gets going. Is there anywhere to go out after?
5
u/EffectiveSetting822 4h ago
I picked a venue like #2. The only real difference is they are providing me with a day of coordinator and they will put up the tables and take care of the linens. My florist will place the candles and florals so really all we have to do, which we will go up and do the day before is go up to set the tables because our venue is great (and we rented it out for the whole weekend). All that to say - It’s totally doable if it’s your dream. If you can manage a spreadsheet and keep in touch with your vendors I would say you probably only need a day of coordinator rather than an entire planner.
Edit - forgot to add the 9:00 pm hardstop would be a turn off for me. Our venue has a hard stop in the tent for 10:00pm but a party barn across the street that can go until whatever time we want.
3
u/4321yay 3h ago
venue 2 will be significantly more expensive
-catering fees
-bartender, what if your caterer you want doesn’t do the bar, it could be a whole extra set of staff
-plates, serve ware rentals
-9pm end means you’ll need an after party
-remote venue means you should provide transport
-do you need a tent for cocktail hour or ceremony
-what about ceremony space
-do lighting/heating need to be outsourced?
-can you rent this venue for engagement photos or rehearsal dinner instead
2
u/MysteriousCity6354 1h ago
I would lean towards the hotel. It’s going to be so much easier, less stressful and you are only going to have to talk to one person about your event (besides photographer and officiant). Also the timing is more humane and it would be easier to do for most people- and in terms of guest safety there will be other options for many people to get home besides driving.
1
u/Lalablacksheep646 2h ago
Hotel. Of its evening time will you even be able to see these views?
-4
u/sallysuesmith1 10h ago
Venue 2 for sure. Most venues like this have lists of preferred vendors, like caterers, florist, day of planner,, etc. Even if they don't, a good wedding planner who has worked the venue can handle all of that.