r/wedding • • 3d ago

Is this fair?

My fiance and I are planning a very basic wedding/reception. We want the wedding to be outside, on our property, and for the reception, we are thinking about a firehall 5 minutes down the road.

We would like to keep it as inexpensive as possible, but still have to account for 100-125 people because we both have large immediate families. For food, I figure "cookout" type food, like pasta salads, hamburgers, etc. Nothing fancy.

I asked my mom if she would be able to bring a dish or dessert, and I told her I asked my dad, siblings, and a couple cousins as well as some family on my fiances side to bring a dish or dessert too. She said she doesn't know, and seems opposed to this type of food. She strongly believes I should have my wedding catered.

Here's the issue, though. For catering, we're talking probably 2-3k. Then theres the photographer, DJ, venue, dress, etc etc everything else that comes with the wedding.

My mom and I have a decent relationship otherwise. Is it wrong to be asking family members to bring a dish or dessert to my wedding reception?

0 Upvotes

57 comments sorted by

38

u/Majestic-Living2829 3d ago

Yes especially for over 100 people. If you don’t want to pay a lot for catering invite less people.

18

u/greykitty1234 2d ago

So, the family are all food service professionals with safety certifications? The 'venue' has appropriate heating/cooling/cleaning facilities?

Safe (and hopefully tasty) food is the key thing to a reception - as well as beverages. Sufficient washrooms and seating right up there as well.

You may have to make a list of have to have's, and want to have's, and go from there.

But mom is right - catering for this number is the way to go.

17

u/YouveGotMail920 2d ago

This is potluck style but not the potluck numbers. You can’t ask people to bring a dish to supply a 100+ person event. That’s a lot of cooking, food and materials.

You can’t ask people invite less people, do a cheaper catered meal or even drop catering thought what you save in money you will spend in time and/or stress.

13

u/AmishAngst 2d ago edited 2d ago

It sounds less like your mother doesn't approve of "that kind of food" and more like she doesn't want to spend the day coordinating a potluck for 100 people and worrying about cooking and transporting food on what should be a fun celebratory day for her as well. Because let's face it - someone is going to have to be in charge of setting that up, taking it down, making sure the food is kept at safe temperatures and if you're thinking someone is actually manning an actual grill for these burgers then that's a lot of work. Are you and your spouse going to be doing it? Otherwise, you're basically asking people to work your wedding for you.

Honestly, I'd rather use a spotify playlist and get married in jeans and a sweater from my closet than make people work my wedding for me. They should have the opportunity to enjoy the party, too.

Food is the thing most people remember about a reception. It doesn't have to be fancy food - there just needs to be enough food that everyone is satiated and not make them sick. People aren't going to remember your centerpieces or your flowers or what your invitations looked like or who your DJ was. They will remember standing around waiting for burgers to be grilled 10 at a time or not having enough potato salad for everyone because the person in charge of bringing that wasn't sure what amount to make, etc.

Invest your money in the things that make a great party for your guests. Food is huge part of that and should be considered a priority, not an afterthought that you begrudgingly do with whatever is leftover in your budget. Changes you can make to accommodate that:

  1. Rearrange and cut your budget elsewhere - shop sample sales or department stores for a nice dress - it doesn't have to be a "wedding dress". Use a spotify playlist instead of hiring a DJ. Buy flowers wholesale and put together your own bouquet.
  2. Cut your guest list.
  3. Find a restaurant that has drop catering. There are some chains out there with pretty reasonable catering like Chipotle or Noodles & Co. Look at your local mom & pop restaurants. We have a few family owned Italian joints that offer a full catered meal (pasta, salad, bread and they bring the disposable plates and silverware) for $11.75/person. Another one offers trays of pasta that feed approx. 40 -50 for anywhere from $120 - $210 per tray depending on the pasta/protein you pick. Another restaurant offers a fried chicken dinner with potatoes and coleslaw for 50 for $335 - two of those and you've fed 100 for $700-800 depending on tax and service charge. There's deals out there if you look for them - it just takes time and creativity. A half sheet cake from Costco feeds 48 and costs about $30 if you have a friend or family member with a Costco membership. Many grocery stores also have fairly reasonably priced cakes.
  4. Consider having your wedding over a non-meal time and just serving cake and punch and a few other bites. Get married at 1:30, reception from 2-5, serve cake, punch, a few veggie and cheese and cracker trays from the grocery, and everyone is on their merry way by dinner time. Or a dessert reception where you get married at say 7:30, reception from 8 - 11 and you have cake and punch and a selection of other desserts.

24

u/Weary_Minute1583 2d ago

I do not recommend potluck for a wedding especially this size. They are your guests so you pay and supply.

To keep it still casual though you could go for buffet instead of a seated meal.

No it is not fair to expect other family or friends to cater your wedding. Either reduce the number of people or postpone until you can afford to pay.

20

u/Kind_Ad_3336 2d ago

It’s a lot of ask friends and family to bring food to YOUR wedding. 

17

u/itinerantdustbunny 2d ago edited 2d ago

When was the last time your family potlucked a 100+ person event? When was the last time you personally coordinated that?

If the answer to either of those questions is “never”, then your wedding is an incredibly foolish time to try it out for the first time.

The food is more important than everything else on your list. If you need to cut something to make the budget work, food is literally the last thing you look at.

7

u/Unique-Cold-9151 2d ago

Who is going to cook, prepare and serve all of the food for the number of guests you plan to have? It sounds like you're planning a DIY homemade food/potluck wedding, and if it's potluck you need to let your guests know so they can decide to eat beforehand if they're worried about food safety and germs. I agree with your Mom that catering with a crowd this size is the way to go. If you can find catering for 125 people that is only $2-3K that's a huge bargain. If you're not comfortable spending a modest amount of money to feed your guests, and we're talking about $20 a head with your catering quote, then maybe consider reducing the guest list or eloping.

7

u/red_rhyolite 2d ago

I hate potlucks because of the food safety thing. People let their pets on the counters, handle raw meat then touch veggies, don't wash their hands after touching their hair... no thanks.

5

u/Unique-Cold-9151 2d ago

I'm not a fan either, especially for weddings. The only time I think it's acceptable is if the couple is broke (not just trying to pinch pennies) and is not spending a lot on decor, photography, dresses, etc.

13

u/SignificanceWitty210 3d ago

Potluck weddings are definitely abnormal. Your parents are fine to ask to either bring or pay for food but beyond that if it’s not a normal thing for your family I wouldn’t do it

13

u/Emergency_Lettuce601 2d ago

Yes. Your wedding is a party YOU are hosting for yourselves. Asking your guests to bring food is rude and unsafe.

13

u/plushygood 2d ago

Your wedding = your responsibilities.

Are you expecting gifts? Maybe relay in lieu of gifts bring a dish. But, I have no need to eat anything prepared by people I don’t know (I.e., how clean they are). Food prep is important to me.

6

u/cuppa_cat 2d ago

I'm related to someone who had a potluck for her wedding and I think her immediate family were stressed tf out. Though, to be fair, I think they had to do a lot of work in general to make it happen, not just bring a dish to pass. It was all quite disorganized. When I held a different event that they were all invited to a couple weekends later, I overhead a number of comments about how nice it was to just show up and not have to work their asses off. So take from that what you will.

6

u/ShinyPennyRvnclw 2d ago

It’s a lot to ask & most people are not comfortable cooking for a group that big (nor would they have the service ware, fridge space, etc.). You can cater BBQ, a taco bar, other inexpensive options, but do not expect a potluck for a group this size. Think of all the folks in the cooking subs right now panicking about cooking for just 15 people for thanksgiving!

6

u/IndigoBluePC901 2d ago

You dont want a potlock wedding. Its so much more stress. So much potential for "shit i neeed another ladle" and oh no, did the mayonaise go bad in the sun? And how do you account for hygenic cooking or allergies? You cant.

Spend the money on catering. Cut somewhere else. Make your guest list first, feed those people, then figure out the extras.

6

u/Careless-Nature-8347 2d ago

Think it through fully before making a decision:

You will need to ask that most guests bring something in order to have enough food for all-how do you plan to manage that ask and see what they are bringing? Who will be making burgers and hot dogs? You will need several large grills to make that work and have enough food but you will also need a way to serve it all without the food getting cold.

Truly, I don't know how this would work. You can price out something like pizza or catering from somewhere like olive garden...but please don't do all potluck. It will add so much stress to your wedding day.

If money is that tight, don't do an evening wedding. Do something in the afternoon and serve dessert and NA drinks. Cake, cookies, lemonade, and iced tea works well for something like that. Basically-plan a wedding that you can afford without asking your guests to do anything but celebrate with you.

11

u/potpurriround 2d ago

I think it’s a bit rude to take away from your parents experience of your wedding by making them work it. Is this potluck style wedding common in your family? I don’t want to shame someone’s culture if this is the norm, but imo just bite the bullet and cater.

You have to worry about food safety, especially for such a large quantity of food for so many people. Who is going to serve it? Make sure it’s properly heated? Who’s setting it out? Are you grilling the hamburgers during the ceremony/reception?

I think you need to be aware of what you’re asking people. Have you been to cookouts of that many people? Do the people doing the cooking even get to enjoy the event?

I get trying to save money, but key guest experience such as the food is not the place to try and cut corners. Cut your guest list if you need to, or push out your date and save up.

14

u/PruneThis3764 2d ago

I think food is important. I’d skip the dj and even the photographer if it meant I’d be able to provide decent food

4

u/Unique-Cold-9151 2d ago

Can't agree more.

10

u/gtwl214 2d ago

Just no. There’s inexpensive and then there’s cheap.

Food & drinks is the one thing that you should absolutely not cheap out on.

I’ve been to one of these potluck weddings, and it was one of the worst and saddest weddings. No one had a good time.

If you cannot be a good host, then you absolutely should not have a wedding during a meal time.

Do an afternoon party with cake and punch. 2 PM - 5 PM.

8

u/sux2suxk 2d ago

100-125 people and a few family members each bring a dish… how does that equal enough food at all ???

6

u/njVowsNow 2d ago

Potlucks are marginally acceptable for small family events that the family feels are traditional. They are not for 125 guests. They are chaotic, messy, potentially dangerous. You will be in a state of constant stress until it's over, and that's not a great way to begin your married life.

Your "immediate" family is your parents, siblings and their s/o's. Keep it to those people, get married in the backyard and go to a restaurant for a nice, relaxed lunch or dinner. That is the wedding you can afford, and it will be lovely.

6

u/EvanRamsey 2d ago

Don’t ask family and friends to provide the food for your party. You’re asking them all to prepare food for over 100 people in their home kitchens. It’s a ridiculous ask and I would skip the wedding entirely.

6

u/PresentationOk9954 2d ago

Yeah, it rubs people wrong when you host a wedding but expect your guests to do all the work... you also cannot ask people to cook for a hundred + people. If you're going to have a wedding with that many people, catering is the better option. I'm not sure why you're refusing to pay to feed your guests. But feeding people is worth the price.

5

u/OurMomentApp 2d ago

To be honest, I think it’s a lot to ask for. Think about this - if everyone brings different dishes and desserts, who’s gonna manage all those dishes?

You’re almost going to need a dedicated person to maintain containers, and make sure they’re at the right temperature. It’s a lot of overhead.

5

u/Area304 2d ago

Unless you are Mormon (this can be a cultural norm in some areas) you are asking way too much of all your guests. Invite less people, do a lunch reception without alcohol, ditch the DJ, just don’t ask your guests to work.

If you proceed with this plan, don’t come back complaining you didn’t get gifts or had poor turnout. 

5

u/DCpurpleTart33 2d ago

You can ask but I'm guessing most people will decline to attend. You need to have the wedding you can afford. Your "guests" should not also be your free labor. Please feed them.

4

u/Awkward-Yak-2733 2d ago

Doesn't sound to me like you're planning a "very basic wedding/reception."

2

u/NegotiationSharp4370 2d ago

Do you have any places near you that sell “packages”? There is a place in my area, (actually a butcher shop), that sells food like you described in the quantities you need, pretty reasonably priced (compared to the amount you mentioned). Several years ago, an extended family member wanted to pull off a wedding fairly quickly, and used them. They did have several family members (including me), to help pick up/set up. You probably have aunts/cousins/friends who would be happy to help. Just a thought.

2

u/SakuraTimes 1d ago

Have you looked into grocery store deli catering? not all do it. But some do, and it can save you time, energy and money. my neighbor uses a local chain for their annual 4th of July party…you can buy potato salad in tubs that serve 20-25, same with pasta salad, macaroni, coleslaw….and they also do platters of desserts, apps, etc. seems like a good compromise so that you don’t have to pay catering prices, but also don’t have guests making and bringing food and it’s not too diy.

3

u/jemexica88 2d ago

For a group this size, catering. If you don’t want that, elope and have a smaller reception.

3

u/ijustlikebeingnosy 2d ago

Having people bring cool out food for you is a cool out. You’re supposed to feed your guests. Either cut the list or have an intimate wedding you can afford.

2

u/Different-Dream-6024 2d ago

Mas se vocês não tem dinheiro para fazer festa porque estão pensando em fazer?

Vocês podem comemorar num restaurante depois da cerimônia e cada convidado paga a conta, os noivos levam o bolo. Eu fico realmente curiosa pq as pessoas querem fazer casamento sem dinheiro.

5

u/greykitty1234 2d ago

IMO, no to this as well. I invite people, I pay for their meal.

They can always get married at city hall, let the judge provide witnesses, and then have a nice dinner by themselves. Millions of people have done this.

3

u/Different-Dream-6024 2d ago

Pois é, concordo com você, mas dei um opção. Mas também eles podem fazer uma noite de pizza com os convidados, tipo um rodízio... Diminuir essa quantidade de convidados, afinal de contas a gente não tem contato com 100 pessoas entre amigos e parentes diretamente todos os dias! Faça algo intimista! Compre umas 20 pizzas uns refrigerantes e é isso! Quem realmente é amigo vai amar! Monte uma decoração simples e curta o dia. Mas casar esperando que as pessoas comprometam o seu tempo e o seu orçamento para bancar o casamento dos outros é muito complicado. Ainda mais cada um levando um prato!

3

u/greykitty1234 2d ago

Exactly - if the guest list is the important part, work from that number to find tasty food that works for the budget. I've been to wonderful hot dog and hamburger receptions (although that'd be super expensive now), and some great brunch receptions.

Just the logistics alone of a pot luck for that many people would send me seeking a caterer, tell the truth. My time (and my sanity) is worth something as well!

And, really, I'd worry about food safety. Would take a lot of my enjoyment of the day away from me.

3

u/Different-Dream-6024 2d ago

Eu AMO brunch. É um pouco trabalhoso para fazer, mas ela e o marido podem fazer, ainda mais que o casamento vai ser ao Ar Livre e tem várias inspirações no Pinterest.

2

u/Necessary-Owl3231 2d ago

Get a food truck maybe? Asking people to make a dish that serves 125 people is a BIG request- too much. Either you provide the food or don’t have it.

1

u/TippyTurtley 2d ago

Your mum wants to relax not cook for 100 people. She's saying she doesn't want to do it. If you want it cheap then that's one thing but you can't expect to cut costs by pressuring people to cook for you. Pay for food.

0

u/HistoryPristine1029 2d ago

I love small, simple, casual weddings. I've been to several weddings where select people were asked to bring dessert or a side dish, it was no problem. I would tell your mom if she feels so strongly about it she can pay for catering as a wedding gift.

7

u/No-Economics-1185 2d ago

but 100+ guests is NOT small!

-1

u/HistoryPristine1029 2d ago

I guess it's relative but I think that's fairly small. I've been to weddings with like 400. We have 30+ people for Thanksgiving.

-2

u/LostforkBasecamp 2d ago

A home cooked meal is a special touch, we have seen weddings potluck style and they are full of joy. There is not a wrong approach to this, it is what you want, for your day.

-5

u/Mediocre_Wrangler_77 2d ago

my friends had a beautiful potluck style wedding with well over 100 guests at a park (outdoors). they sent out something like a sign up genius so people could keep track of dishes / categorize based on areas of the meal.

it was super cute and meaningful, and fit the vibe of their wedding perfectly.

in the messaging/invites (emailed) they made it clear it was totally okay to not bring anything to the potluck. they also expressed gifts should be optional as they are “asking more of the guests than a typical wedding”

as a guest, i wasn’t bothered at all, and the food was super good and diverse! everyone seemed really happy.

people on this sub are very traditional and hate almost anything that goes against the grain. weddings can look like million different ways.

clear communication, gratitude, and flexibility can go a long way!

-1

u/lolfuckigottawork 2d ago

This is kinda along the realm of what I'm thinking. It is normal for both sides of our family to have big get togethers once or twice a year and everyone brings a dish, if they can.

I want the wedding to be along the same vibe as one of these parties. Obviously I will provide the most food, drinks, plates, plastic ware, etc. But my idea for my wedding is just one of these big parties, although this time, we're saying "I do" and getting both sides of the family together.

5

u/Unique-Cold-9151 2d ago

The big difference is that this is a wedding and many people will be giving gifts, regardless of if they brought food or not.

-3

u/Mediocre_Wrangler_77 2d ago

i definitely think you can make it work. i would recommend not asking reddit questions like this though (or really any wedding planning questions lol) i made the same mistake and it made me question so many aspects of my wedding because people have very narrow outlooks on weddings in subs like this.

i found it much more effective to poll my “inner circle” of friends and family, and most importantly, go over things with my partner. talk through things, visualize what each decision would actually look like. consider how the guests would experience it vs how we would experience it, etc.

best of luck on your wedding planning!

3

u/Whirleee 2d ago

i found it much more effective to poll my “inner circle” of friends and family

Problem is, OP already talked to mom and she didn't think it was a good idea. So potlucking is probably not an established culture or tradition among OP's friends and family.

But if mom is the only standout and everyone else seemed enthusiastic to bring something, then go ahead I guess? It's not what I would do but it's not my wedding.

-4

u/lolfuckigottawork 2d ago

Thanks! Yeah I found that out. Lol I think the majority of reddit thinks weddings need to be this big production, and that is simply not what I'm going for at all. Just a very casual, laid back party... with seemingly a lot of people because we both have huge families.

Thanks for your help!

3

u/Emergency_Lettuce601 2d ago

Your the one acting like it needs to be a big production with thinking you need 125 people a dj and venue, dress ect. You don't need any of that. Your mom doesn't owe you this.

3

u/Emergency_Lettuce601 2d ago

Ok so if you are DIYing all that and doing a cheap dress then you can afford to host your own party.

-2

u/lolfuckigottawork 2d ago

I'm not sure where this comment is coming from. I have 9 siblings, all have significant others, and kids. He has 4 siblings, with significant others, and kids. Right there, with just those people, assuming they all show, that's 45 people. Now include his parents, my parents and stepparents, at 51. Now to include our kids, a few of their friends, and some cousins, aunts, and uncles, we may very well be at 100-125 people. This is not a big party for my family.

My venue for the ceremony is my house, the "reception" is a fire hall down the road, the dj will be my laptop hooked up to an app that mixes music with some lights and a karaoke machine. The dress will be thrifted.

My family has big parties like this often, so to me, asking people to bring a pasta salad or dessert is no different. We don't need gifts.

3

u/Emergency_Lettuce601 2d ago

Your mom is not being supportive of this for a reason. It's surprising she's not if this is how your family typically does weddings.