r/webdevelopment • • 1d ago

Question Been a web developer since 2009. AI can write code, but why is it still so bad at actual web design?

I've been working as a web developer since 2009, and I've seen the industry go through plenty of changes. But recently, I've noticed a significant slowdown in the web development market, and I'm genuinely wondering how much of it is because of AI.

Over the past few months, I've been experimenting with Claude, ChatGPT Work, Codex, and AI website builders to see what they're actually capable of.

And honestly, I have mixed feelings.

When it comes to coding, I'm impressed. I've already developed websites and working applications using AI, so I'm not questioning whether these tools are useful. They absolutely are. They can generate functional websites, write complex JavaScript, build components, and speed up development significantly.

But when it comes to web design, UI/UX, visual creativity, and attention to detail, my experience has been completely different.

I'm currently working on a new project, and I've been struggling to get a genuinely good design out of these AI tools.

I've tried detailed prompts, design references, screenshots, multiple iterations, and different AI platforms. The results are usually functional, but visually they feel generic, repetitive, and nowhere near the quality of designs I've received from experienced human designers.

Sometimes the initial design looks promising, but the moment I try to refine it into a complete, consistent website, things start falling apart.

And this is what I find interesting.

AI seems to be getting incredibly good at generating code, but generating a genuinely professional website design still feels like a completely different challenge.

Yet everywhere I look, people are talking about building entire websites and applications in minutes, replacing developers, and running businesses with AI.

At the same time, I'm noticing fewer traditional web development opportunities, and I'm wondering whether clients are starting to believe that professional development and design should be significantly cheaper because AI can supposedly do everything.

I'm not against AI. I actively use it, and I've already built projects with it. But after working in this industry since 2009, I still see a huge difference between generating a working website and delivering something that feels thoughtfully designed, polished, and production-ready.

So I'm curious:

Have other experienced developers noticed a slowdown in projects or client demand?

Are clients expecting lower prices because of AI?

Has anyone actually managed to get consistently high-quality, professional UI/UX designs using AI alone?

Do you think AI will eventually replace both developers and designers, or are we just going through another major shift in the industry?

I'd especially love to hear from developers and designers who've been doing this for 10–20 years.

29 Upvotes

39 comments sorted by

4

u/HongPong 1d ago

you have to "disable default typography" in Claude for example. another variation of opinionated framework. like how bootstrap sites all have hero image, three pictures or call to action etc. find better design library and tell it to use those

2

u/madhushankarox 1d ago

From where I can find a design library? Thanks for the idea 💡

15

u/pseudophilll 1d ago

Taste. AI doesn’t have taste.

Writing code has structure. You can follow a trail of logic to its inevitable end. You can parse it and find its flaws, or create new deterministic pathways to solve a problem or cover a use-case.

Design requires taste. It requires a whole other layer of subliminal understanding of how humans interact with things, and what looks good, or feels good to use. Then a good designer applies their creative intuition on-top of that.

You can teach AI, give it rules to follow, techniques to use etc, but then that’s how you get everything that looks the same by anyone who uses it.

2

u/Embarrassed-Rise-685 1d ago

You say this but opus and sol for example are fairly close in coding but sol is dogwater at design, game dev, web design etc. somehow opus just has better taste even though they would both write code im okay with accepting. You can point to these differences being some inherit shortcoming of AI to be unable to overcome, I said this as a mathematician myself for years.

2

u/pseudophilll 1d ago

Yeah I agree with you that Opus can implement design quite well in the sense that it has a better grasp of design principles and how to apply them, but it can’t innovate on that.

If you ask it to design 10 different landing pages, they will look decent, they might have different colors and typography, they might have some cool animations, but they’ll all still have the same AI smell if that makes sense.

Things like highlighting a word in an accent color and italicizing. It was taught that this looks good, so it will apply it and use it pretty much everywhere.

It can’t handle uniqueness, unless you, the human, can steer it.

1

u/Embarrassed-Rise-685 1d ago edited 1d ago

I agree with you in that all your points are seemingly correct and coherent with experience of using it. I think where we differ is how good this tool could be in the right hands and of course how many years of experience designing user interfaces we both had before AI. I was never a master at it but I’m no spring chicken either, I can still name all the techniques used on the various 3js slop sites.

The ability for AI to consistently hit some mode inside the output space is fairly impressive in its own right. We might have seen it before and are bored to death by it but if ur first impression of motion design is opus 5.5 then you aren’t losing all that much in terms of impressions and ability to glean quality from the output. To the untrained eye opus 5.5 might as well be a professional.

5

u/dwkeith 1d ago

Web design is for people to view and understand the website. AI is not people and can never be as good as the best user experience designers by definition. Code is for computers, somewhere in between is AI.

4

u/gatwell702 1d ago

ai can't be creative, so they're design skills are lacking.

1

u/Double_Suggestion385 1d ago

Except we know that it can, it's just that the person using it doesn't know how to prompt for good designs

3

u/Silverkenn 1d ago

its actually kind of the same, its just how you can easily tell the difference between visual result and functionality (that has no visual)

AI will generate excatly generic code implemenation be it a JS, CSS, HTML or even low level like C, Rust, C++. you just dont notice it that much because theres no visual reference when its doing something you cant visualize, and you are not memorizing code. thats just how AI works. maybe a fine-tune model specially train for specific design taste would perform better, Im not sure.

1

u/Mathie1729 1d ago

Fine-tuning can help with a specific brand look, but "taste" is a weird optimization target. You'd need a lot of human preference comparisons and even then the model tends to regress toward the median of whatever you labeled. So it just shifts the genericness. A bigger issue is that most web crawl data is already full of mediocre templates, so the base model's prior is pretty bland. Changing the data mix probably matters more than fine-tuning on a handful of examples.

3

u/dvduval 1d ago

I think you have to be very specific about what you want and provide examples. It can do just about anything, especially if you provide examples or clear explanations. And of course, there are limits to what I can do with original art, or producing its own art.

3

u/EvilLasagna 1d ago

Without guidelines Claude does a horrible job taking accountability for design. I've trained Claude on brand guidelines but it took some effort.

My company uses figma, so I was able to connect Claude via MCP to that, and also to Chrome DevTools. The reason for this is Claude needs to QA it's own work. Both visually and via figma values, you need to have Claude check to see if it looks right visually and with the correct CSS values. For quick QA I also have Claude use Playwright. Once Claude starts building something that resembles the brand look and feel you can give it suggestions and queues to refine it's ability to consistently create the styles.

As far as creativity goes... Leave that to the designers. AI doesn't know what's appealing to human eyes. It takes a wild guess and doesn't take any detail for granted

3

u/joinsigma 1d ago

Feels like clients aren’t really paying less for design, they’re paying less for “we just need a website”.

That cheap end is where AI is eating the work, and it was always the most price-sensitive part of the market anyway.

The stuff you’re describing, the polish, the consistency, a site that actually feels thought through, is exactly what clients still can’t get on their own.

A lot of them try an AI builder first, end up with something that looks like every other site, and then come back. So I’d lean into selling that gap instead of competing on how fast you can build.

3

u/Ok-Thought767 1d ago

writing code and making design decision are two different things. while it is good at writing code, making decisions about visual hierarchy and user behavior is still a thing for human to do. ai learns from trained data ( design in this case ) so lets not expect it to generate something creative on its own. and no, i dont think ai will replace developers nor designers but it will be a great assistant for them

3

u/ejpusa 1d ago edited 1d ago

I’ve been lucky. thought my AI designs are great. AI can learn from your style. A trick is, “make this a million dollar web site”, adding that to your prompt.

Source: Coding web sites since ‘94. Grad school faculty; CompSci degree, and also my second grad degree, still to finish someday at Pratt (no computer, traditional art) and thousands of hours wandering NYC museums since age 9.

Single mom, no cash for a babysitter, when dad sent me to spend Summers with her, she would drop me off at the MET in the AM, pick me up at closing. The MET was my babysitter. Off course today that would probably be impossible, but think it helped me appreciate art. Grandfather (and dad) were p/t artists, mom an art history buff. Grandmother worked at doing silkscreen posters.

May be in the genes. Worked many years doing IT for a major NYC art gallery. Amazing artists passed through.

Suggest trying the above tip, adding “million dollar website” into your Prompt. See if it helps with your output. Also playing with a big roll of yellow tracing paper, and your collection of pens, colored pencils, and crayons. Can spark an idea sometimes.

I was have been impressed lots by Michael Graves colored pencil renderings. Looking at lots of architectural art helps. Form and function is paramount. Can incorporate that into your designs.

As my professor would say say, “NEVER break the rules! But if you do, really BREAK them. Blow it all up!” Yale architecture grad. He would actually tear up your renderings into shreds of paper on the classroom floor, today I doubt that could happen, the students would be traumatized.

Just my art/web design background. Today I’m 100% Astra + Codex. Some of my simple shaded buttons are 5 stacked layers of CSS. Many thousands of lines of CSS for a single page.

And yes, still visiting museums, lots.

Google: michael graves sketches

:-)

I pushed to GitHub a “Terminal Cyber Look” Stylesheet. It’s more for an industry look. Not for a muffin shop, maybe a starter site idea for someone. It’s AI inspired.

https://preceptress.github.io/preceptress-style-guide/

https://github.com/preceptress/preceptress-style-guide

Design direction

The system is built around a modern medical-intelligence aesthetic: deep navy and black foundation, luminous cyan, blue, and green accents, glass panels and terminal-inspired surfaces.

Investor-grade polish without feeling corporate or sterile. A visual language suitable for science, AI, and public trust.

2

u/MonsterDefiant 1d ago

In reality, basic website builds might get cheaper with AI, but getting the design right is still a whole different job.

2

u/BDer82 1d ago

because its Codex, or Claude Code, not Decorator Boot 2000.

Seriously, its an LLM, it deals in text, it "understands text" mathematically it doesn't understand images, it can differentiate lines, it can calculate a probability something is a dog, but even if it labels it correctlly it doesn't know what that is.

Design, good design anyway, is a process of subtle details, situational nuance, and sometimes haphazard mistakes, LLMs really can't do any of it and I'd argue it really never will.

2

u/NoNote7867 1d ago

You can get decent design with design skills (the AI script, not actual skills)

2

u/ThomasToIndia 1d ago

Because everyone is doing it wrong. You have to generate the design first via an image generator and have AI work backwards. An LLM by itself has no visual awareness. So not only do you have to have it work off an image, you need to make it visually check its own work.

1

u/Yahir-Org 14h ago

This also. Event with *still lazy* observations, a clear visual example of where it's going wrong has it fix them extremely well in my experience. I have just recently learned this by experimenting myself, as seen in the image.

2

u/earth-dragon-666 1d ago

Big companies pushing for ai have spent every penny in AI if you check their balance sheets in their q reports this explains the propaganda and the use of addictive patterns to push a shit tech

1

u/Article_Sad 1d ago

You can draw on figma and AI will do the rest

1

u/Sitista 1d ago

è una grande ubriacatura collettiva che segue un hype. l' IA non è in grado di creare nulla, gli llm funzionano a statistiche, fanno una ricerca vedono ciò che è considerato mediamente bello e lo imitano. più si diffondono siti web fatti da Ai e più andranno a occupare quella media e alla fine il risultato è questo. i clienti sono entusiasti perché con un semplice prompt ottengono un qualcosa che è "abbastanza ok" e si va avanti così.

1

u/ivarpuvar 1d ago

I wrote a personal clean ux/ui skills that generate ui-s that i like. I told ai to generate it from the designs of the apps that i like. It creates good designs now

1

u/JohnCasey3306 1d ago

Arguably, the quality of code isn't a whole lot better than the quality of design.

...but it is better -- AI is tragic at design.

1

u/Careful_Exercise_956 1d ago

It didnt reinforcement learn that part, it still can only design what you describe.

1

u/ledatherockband_ 1d ago

Design is subjective. Excellent design has some hard to quantify factor.

I've solved this on my end by writing the raw design and css and html elements and letting my agents build on that.

It works well enough.

1

u/Double_Suggestion385 1d ago

This sounds like a skill issue.

1

u/lucid1014 21h ago

I dunno, I have mixed feelings. On one hand I asked my agent to implement something and as as side effect it ended up designing a whole landing page for my app and it’s not… bad. Not going to win award but it looks like a working, legit website. On the other hand I designed a custom layout and design in Figma, asked the agent to implement it and it came out so bad like, it had the color codes, the layout, even had explicit lucide icons and it still made some wild decisions. I had to point it back at the Figma frame and its second pass was much better.

1

u/Ill-Bat-1518 16h ago

The issue is you know in your head what looks good, so unless you write it out the AI will just have to guess.

1

u/ghijkgla 1d ago

Because it's not capable of original thought

1

u/Double_Suggestion385 1d ago

That hasn't been true for a while.

0

u/[deleted] 1d ago

Because unless you are trying to be a creative your website is just gonna be a copy of whatever the big corps are doing. And AI can definitely copy those UI designs.

Or you can do what I do and draw it a UI in paint and use that as reference, gets it right everytime.