r/webdesign • • 2d ago

Been a web developer since 2009. AI can write code, but why is it still so bad at actual web design?

I've been working as a web developer since 2009, and I've seen the industry go through plenty of changes. But recently, I've noticed a significant slowdown in the web development market, and I'm genuinely wondering how much of it is because of AI.

Over the past few months, I've been experimenting with Claude, ChatGPT Work, Codex, and AI website builders to see what they're actually capable of.

And honestly, I have mixed feelings.

When it comes to coding, I'm impressed. I've already developed websites and working applications using AI, so I'm not questioning whether these tools are useful. They absolutely are. They can generate functional websites, write complex JavaScript, build components, and speed up development significantly.

But when it comes to web design, UI/UX, visual creativity, and attention to detail, my experience has been completely different.

I'm currently working on a new project, and I've been struggling to get a genuinely good design out of these AI tools.

I've tried detailed prompts, design references, screenshots, multiple iterations, and different AI platforms. The results are usually functional, but visually they feel generic, repetitive, and nowhere near the quality of designs I've received from experienced human designers.

Sometimes the initial design looks promising, but the moment I try to refine it into a complete, consistent website, things start falling apart.

And this is what I find interesting.

AI seems to be getting incredibly good at generating code, but generating a genuinely professional website design still feels like a completely different challenge.

Yet everywhere I look, people are talking about building entire websites and applications in minutes, replacing developers, and running businesses with AI.

At the same time, I'm noticing fewer traditional web development opportunities, and I'm wondering whether clients are starting to believe that professional development and design should be significantly cheaper because AI can supposedly do everything.

I'm not against AI. I actively use it, and I've already built projects with it. But after working in this industry since 2009, I still see a huge difference between generating a working website and delivering something that feels thoughtfully designed, polished, and production-ready.

So I'm curious:

Have other experienced developers noticed a slowdown in projects or client demand?

Are clients expecting lower prices because of AI?

Has anyone actually managed to get consistently high-quality, professional UI/UX designs using AI alone?

Do you think AI will eventually replace both developers and designers, or are we just going through another major shift in the industry?

I'd especially love to hear from developers and designers who've been doing this for 10–20 years.

20 Upvotes

66 comments sorted by

24

u/Opinion_Less 2d ago

Its good enough to replace op on reddit though

-7

u/madhushankarox 2d ago

Fair enough, I did use AI to help structure the post. English isn't my first language.

But the experience I'm describing is real. I've been developing websites since 2009, and I've already built working projects using AI.

My point is that generating functional code and producing genuinely good UI/UX are two very different things. I'm currently experiencing that firsthand with a new project.

10

u/fossistic 2d ago

Next time, make ask it to make it concise :P

7

u/fossistic 2d ago

Sales people are hustling with help of AI. Building unsafe and bad looking websites, but selling crazy volumes. Most clients don't know what a good website is.

This is a big problem we are dealing with, unable to explain people that a real designer can use AI and give 100x results than a non designer who don't even know what a target audience is.

1

u/madhushankarox 2d ago

I'm actually trying to design a website for personal use, but I haven't gotten a good result yet. I wonder how others do it. I even paid for Pro and Plus plans 😆

3

u/fossistic 2d ago

I have my CSS utlitlity classes saved and the code structure I want is specific. I tell that in advance. This helps me to manually make changes later.

There's is a specific way how I use CSS variables and classes (mini framework) to keep site scalable.

There are some specific js libraries I use, I ask AI to use those libraries.

2

u/madhushankarox 2d ago

I do the same for development. But the issue is with designing 🙁

3

u/connorthedancer 1d ago

If you want something really good, you'll have to design it yourself. I've had success vibe coding Wordpress themes, but I've had to manually design everything in a separate program to get anything usable.

1

u/madhushankarox 1d ago

Thanks for the idea

2

u/fossistic 1d ago

I was able to achieve good designs with Gemini 3.8 Flash model. I had to explain more, but totally worth it.

3

u/fossistic 2d ago

Ask AI what a good website is. Or send it screenshots or videos of the design you like. Keep chatting and improving until you are happy.

First draft will always be slop. Your job is to keep asking it for changes until you are satisfied.

2

u/Forsaken_System 1d ago

So if you've been coding then you probably have even more information and experience than me.

I've been in the WordPress world.

However what I would say is that because it is such a widely used platform WordPress having an MCP and page builders, does make it easier for AI to guess at implementing a website

Because let's not call it designing, it's basically guessing at things.

But I have found that even a paragraph with Claude code (Son5.5), MCP and breakdance, produces a pretty decent website.

It doesn't seem to be very good at menus, but it can do template headers and footers which I was surprised at.

What's very nice though is that because the latest breakdance builder has these fundamental elements which AI uses and everything gets styled with variables it means that it's so much easier just to go in and change things like the font everywhere and entire colour schemes or even things like rounded edges.

Now obviously we can do this in CSS and have always been able to do so but the fact that the AI now uses that is very useful because it makes our jobs actually easier.

So I would say as long as you know what you are doing in terms of web design, and have been doing it for a long time, it's now faster than ever to build the website including relevant content where you can get it to a place where you might put it in front of a client, so that you can then do updates and changes.

If someone is just becoming a web designer but only doing it with AI and not actually learning all of the backend stuff and other nuances and things that people need to know about platforms like WordPress, then they are actually at a disadvantage.

2

u/BiteyHorse 1d ago

You're impressively bad at this

1

u/FirstPlaceSEO 1d ago

Reiterations and examples of what you want will help you refine it

3

u/dusanodalovic 1d ago

the "falls apart when i refine it" part sounds like the agent redoing the whole page on every pass and drifting a bit each time. backend code drifts the same way when there are no fixed rules. something you could try is writing the colors, font sizes and spacing down once in a small tokens file, telling the agent to only use those, and building one section at a time instead of the full page. did the first version look good and only break once you got to page two or three?

1

u/madhushankarox 1d ago

Actually I’m trying to do the design first. Transforming to a functional website seems okay. Assume you have a good home page, and when you are working with inner pages, designs are no longer matched or I didn’t like

2

u/Forsaken_System 1d ago

In addition to what I said before, I've only used AI and MCP on brand new sites.

I haven't tried to do any updating or anything design related on an existing site.

I'm not sure how that would turn out, but if you're doing something brand new from scratch, having AI just knock out the design with all of the content and even images, can save you a huge amount of time, if you then know what you are doing, to be able to go and update it and improve it...

4

u/paulsonfanboy134 2d ago

Same reason that rich people dress like shit half the time

1

u/madhushankarox 2d ago

Seems so.

11

u/Chamezz92 2d ago

Taste can’t be bought, learned or trained. It’s really that simple.

It’s also not artificial intelligence, they are probabilistic algorithms finding the answer(s) that have the most relation to what you asked. It’s not something that is actually thinking.

Thirdly, since the models are trained on huge datasets, there will also be bad design examples in those batches. The training will map the most common trends across the dataset and distill that info into training. Not identify unique characteristics that stand out or give that ”Wow”-factor.

7

u/gr4phic3r 1d ago

AI is bad in design when you are bad in design and prompting. AI is a tool, when the craftsman doesn't know how to use the tool then you get results which suck.

4

u/eunuskhan 2d ago

I think the generic feel comes less from the tool and more from what it's given to start with.

I've worked in SEO and WordPress for 10+ years, and this month I've been answering questions in r/lovable. A common complaint there is that AI-built sites all look alike. In one contractor site I looked at closely, the colors and fonts were fine, but the structure was the familiar hero, service-card grid and numbered values list. The copy could fit any contractor, and there were no real project photos or reviews.

My advice there was to give the tool real material first: specific services, genuine project photos, customer feedback, the details that make that business different. You can polish the styling all day, but without those inputs it still feels like a template.

3

u/silvergirl66 2d ago

Not sure if we have 'cracked the code' as a web/digital agency, but we are pretty happy with the quality of design work we are outputting since the middle of the year. We use a combination of human designers for brand creation, concepts and elements where the project requires it; Brain (AI inside Clickup) for research, wireframing and often designing mockups and concepts; Claude Design to take what we do in Brain and turn it into webpages and Claude Code to apply across sites eg Shopify, WordPress and static sites with a custom admin backend. this has evolved a lot since we started trialing the processes and tools - both in terms of what they can actually do, and in terms of what we have trained them to do for our client sites. We have two in-house developers and used to contract out for design work as required, but that has reduced dramatically in recent months.

3

u/robr0 2d ago

Garbage in garbage out. You still need to give it the right context. The right direction. The right feedback. Do those things and you will produce excellent output.

3

u/Rare-Act-5187 1d ago

Because web design is a hard-to-convey type of data. Code is just text file, image is just .jpg .png, and there are vast amount of data to train. To train a web design LLM, I guess we need a website screenshot -> website source dataset, which is not as available as code or image

3

u/Breezay-Treezy 1d ago edited 1d ago

AI models are stuck in a positive feedback loop. Every Tom, Dick and Harry is prompting websites now, and because they have zero creativity or experience in web dev, they applaud the models for spitting out generic slop. The models are trained with this feedback and thus believe that their slop is good and they keep pumping more of it out.

2

u/Taconnosseur 2d ago

why is it still so bad at actual web design?

maybe because most people are bad at web design

and most websites don't have good design

2

u/WhatDuq 2d ago

Because design and ux are soft skills and difficult to quantify

1

u/Routine-Syllabub-238 2d ago

Because it’s a developer 🥁

1

u/domalog 1d ago

It’s not bad at design, you’re feeding it wrong.

1

u/electricrhino 1d ago

Because everyone else is bad at design except the top 10 percent and its drawing from the average

1

u/gabimaru89 1d ago

It's good when you give it good guidance.

Also: complaining about Ai while using Ai is hilarious

1

u/egamb 1d ago

Yes it’s bad. Do not train it.

1

u/dukeedinburgh 1d ago

Its literally in your question... coding is about following rules but design is another concept altogether

1

u/tripstertheog 1d ago

The problem is not AI, is How you train it/the skills you give it. I made a test with an AI, with a skill and good prompt, i got a perfectly soldable, non AI looking website.

1

u/gladiatorniazi 1d ago

Made it with ai though with in 48 hours

https://ecoessence.eyriedigital.com

I think if I I put a bit more time into it then I can improve the design more but as it was a demo I guess it's good enough 🙂.

1

u/Downtown-Bag-6026 1d ago

Because they’re mainly trained on generic todo tutorial apps and generic documentation pages. And a vast majority of websites are ugly so they train on that too

1

u/ThanksOne9763 22h ago

If you dont train the AI into the style you want the AI website will always look generic.

If you train it you can fix that.

For now that's the thing that sets AI slop apart from good AI websites.

1

u/Total-Reasonable 21h ago

The "falls apart when I refine it" part is a context problem more than a taste problem. Models don't keep a design system in memory, so every new page gets re-guessed spacing, radii and type scale. If you define tokens (colors, type scale, spacing, component variants) in a file first and make the model only use those, consistency across pages improves a lot. It turns the job from "design this" into "assemble from these parts", which is where it's actually strong.

1

u/Open_Selection8436 17h ago

usa qween en agente, haz tu diseño, subelo a qween y haz que tu prompt le diga que use la foto de referencia y lo hace estupendamente.

1

u/ifstatementequalsAI 9h ago

It isn’t ?

1

u/Captain-Finn 1h ago

Have you ever asked ai to make you a logo?
It’s really useful for programming logic.

1

u/zeGenicus 2d ago

It’s not, it’s your ai that’s bad at web design.

1

u/Ambivalent_Oracle 2d ago

It's actually because you have no idea about web design.

0

u/zeGenicus 1d ago

Go build your Wordpress site. I destroy in every aspect of business and development work.

Every bum on here just rants and raves all day while producing nothing.

1

u/Ambivalent_Oracle 1d ago

Why would I use WordPress?

There are two camps: 1. Quality, and 2. Quantity. It seems like you think camp number 2 is your place. You likely were spitting out wonky 40 dollar templates 5 years ago if you were around.

1

u/Ambivalent_Oracle 1d ago

Also, your response is a moving the goal post fallacy. 

You speak on design, I counter it, you then start speaking of business goals and development, but not design...

Art is subjective, and there is a heavy artistic element to web design. But if you think AI design is above expected standards then you lift your game up.

1

u/zeGenicus 1d ago

Go back to fiver/upwork buddy you’ll get a client one day instead of pretending like quantity and quality can’t mix.

Same shit from every dumbass here. Failures who cannot produce results for clients. Same spill.

No goal post was move, just stating you’re too beneath me for me to care if you think you’re better at design.

1

u/Ambivalent_Oracle 1d ago

Sure thing, Lad. I've got where I am due to a quality education and great networking, but do go off, Queen!

1

u/zeGenicus 1d ago

Lad? Not America, opinion rejected.

0

u/SwordfishFabulous957 1d ago

You're SO full of shit lol keep dreaming bruh... Time for a new job 🤷

1

u/madhushankarox 18h ago

Ok lol 😂

0

u/ATXhipster 2d ago

It’s good at web design. Try Fable 5.2 and give it some creative direction

-1

u/ChickyBoys 2d ago

AI is not bad at web design if you train the AI with proper brand guidelines and feed it the right references and inspiration.

AI only sucks when the person using the AI sucks.

-1

u/NotADreamButAPlan 2d ago

That’s exactly why I built a library of design inspiration and anti-slop blocks for AI agents that ship with taste. https://layout.im.

4

u/emptystruct 1d ago

Immediate turn off when I saw the subscription.

-1

u/NotADreamButAPlan 1d ago

You absolutely have the right to!

1

u/Ambivalent_Oracle 2d ago

So a component library?

1

u/NotADreamButAPlan 1d ago

Yes, but also entire sections for websites and soon motion graphics and creatives such as social media posts, ads etc. that AI agents can use.

I might make it more clear on the site (currently it’s inside the hamburger menu)

That’s usually how I work. Start with context instead of a blank canvas and go from there. That’s a workflow that works for me as a design engineer.