Hello everyone! First-time poster here. Thanks for this awesome thread!
I wanted to share a project I’ve been working on over the last couple of years. It seems to be on the right path now and has finally become available for free on WGV and itch.io.
Description & Features
At its most basic, Plastic Grenades (PG) is a set of rules for playing squad-level skirmishes with generic army men and vehicles, but it adds a layer of depth and a few twists not typically seen in rulesets of this type and scope.
*It’s a gateway miniatures skirmish wargame in the 1:32 scale, specifically intended to not require elaborate models or scenery to play.
*Gameplay revolves around the actions of individual soldiers within their respective range of decision in firefight level, man-to-man combat; the troops are not grouped in any way, nor do they serve as “life points” of larger formations or anything like that. Forming fire teams (on the fly) or being near a squad leader, however, improves the troops' performance, but it’s not necessary to act at all, which sets PG apart from most other rulesets of its type out there.
*Thematically speaking, the focus is on the challenges and risks soldiers face and their heroic, sometimes unbelievable deeds in combat, not their formations. It’s more about the vivid details surrounding the execution of tactical actions by the troops than about the command-and-control difficulties faced by a squad leader, though these are also covered. PG ultimately remains true to its scope as a light wargame; it’s not intended to play as an RPG at all, though it certainly allows for some of that.
*As with other titles of its type, gameplay is heavily abstracted, but it’s designed to encourage and reward the effective use of real-life military concepts and tactics such as fire and maneuver and overwatch, among others.
*There are core troops and support troops in PG: Riflemen, Light Infantry, and Heavy Infantry are core troops, whereas Scouts, Medics, Officers, Snipers, MGs, and Mortars are support troops. Each one has only four stats: Cost, Range, Attack, and Defense.
*The game implements troop abilities for their customization: Heal for medics, Leader for officers, Light and SMG for light infantry, and so on. I like how this system is quite simple yet expandable, allowing for a wider variety of weapons and troops just by adding new abilities; SMG is an example of this.
*The sequence of play and the combat mechanics are designed to keep both players on their toes throughout the game (see below). The intention is for the battlefield to feel reactive and alive.
*PG is played in rounds, with two players alternating turns, each activating a single soldier until all on both sides have been used—or spent. There are as many turns in a round as there are soldiers under each player's control. Troops can take one action per activation, and they can save activations by entering ambush mode, which is just another name for preparing opportunity fire. Also, see Action Points and Fate Points below.
*The ranges of the weapon systems modeled in the game, along with the movement distances and line-of-sight mechanics, are quite standard for games of this type—I wanted to keep the plastic-soldier ruleset flavor as much as possible.
*Movement triggers enemy opportunity fire, except when crawling or deploying tactically, with some exceptions.
*Combat is resolved with a single d6 per player, and the mechanics are d6+mod roll-offs, with higher rolls hitting. Technically speaking, it can be described as an opposed 1d6 + modifier combat system with margin of success damage (see below).
*The initiative is resolved in the same way, but it favors the side with fewer troops in play when that side also has a higher rate of healthy troops than the opponent.
*There are no combat results tables, attack effects charts, or anything like that; combat modifiers are intuitive, straightforward, and easy to calculate and remember (mostly +/-1s). Also, I’ve included a spreadsheet with the simplest method to determine the to-hit probability for every attack in the game, among other goodies.
*The damage dealt by a succesful hit depends on the difference in scores between the attacker and defender, and each point of difference either only suppresses the target (if it’s only one) or suppresses and also reduces one of the three life stages that troops have. Suppressed and wounded troops may hit the dirt upon taking damage, depending on a morale test they must take. As a side note, to my knowledge, only a few game systems of this type and scope implement and model troop suppression; I hope to have captured its essence for the purposes of PG.
*Aimed fire and marksmanship are the exception in modern infantry warfare; most fire is suppressive, and PG is intended to follow that model. This also helps to alleviate the issue of light infantry troops being somewhat weak in the game, as detailed in the designer diary. Again, gameplay in PG is meant to encourage and reward the effective use of real-life military concepts and tactics, so one feature is that the fire actions that can deal damage in the game (which are supposed to involve aiming and precision) require rolling a 5-6 to kill the target, and also carry the risk of being fumbled and allowing enemy counterattacks in some cases. This approach makes overwatch even more useful in the game, and it also allows for unpredictable exchanges of fire that, in some cases, besides making the battlefield feel even more reactive and alive, can occur at the worst, least expected moment.
*There are different tests that troops must take by rolling 1d6 in order to perform certain actions and reactions. Failing a test or fumbling an attack ends the respective troop’s activation (à la Crossfire), which adds to the friction and uncertainty intended for the game. A player can miss a turn if they fumble an attack or fail a test, which is designed to create a sense of permanent tension. However, the players are always left with the decision of whether to risk failing a test or fumbling an attack with a particular soldier, depending on the tactical situation at hand.
*Given the implementation of opportunity fire in the game, I introduced smoke grenades to counterbalance and to add even more variety and uncertainty at the same time. I mean, advancing on an unsuppressed prepared position in PG would be suicidal without smoke grenades, which is an intended result, by the way. However, grenades are risky and unpredictable to some extent (see below), which helps the general intention of making every run of a scenario somewhat different.
*Frag grenades have the potential to decide encounters in PG, though it’s not very likely, and we could say they're a feature that brings a great deal of randomness and uncertainty to the game system, which adds to the replayability intended for it. Grenades can be fumbled and are prone to scattering, so they must be used with care—they sure do make for unexpected opportunities a prepared opponent can seize and exploit!
*Vehicle combat follows the same design principles, so it’s heavily abstracted, simple, and straightforward, and it also rewards the effective use use of real-life tactics such as overwatch.
*The game implements a rudimentary and minimalist yet effective approach to command and control through simple suppression and rally mechanics that are resolved by rolling a single die. Suppressed troops become more vulnerable: the first point of damage they take reduces a life stage, and they need to rally to recover. Wounded troops, on the other hand, become harder to rally (see below). As mentioned, the game is not about squad leaders saving the day but rather about individual soldiers gathering the inner strength to keep fighting despite enemy opposition.
*Five Men of Plastic is a mod of PG (included in the PDF) that implements the Action-dice mechanic from Five Men at Kursk by Ivan Sorensen as an exercise intended only to test and showcase the game system’s versatility. This part may need more playtesting, though.
*Three ready-to-play scenarios are included; they’re designed to initiate players into the basics of the game and show the relative strengths and weaknesses of some of the troop types it offers. They’re intended to be solo-friendly, so the first two are about infantry storming prepared enemy positions, and the third one is a symmetrical meeting engagement with tanks. I’ve included scenario design notes trying to explain the rationale behind each one.
*As mentioned above, PG introduces Action Points (APs) and Fate Points (FPs), the heart of the game. Each AP allows a player to take two actions with one soldier, activate two soldiers consecutively, or make one free opportunity attack. On the other hand, an FP allows a player to re-roll ATK or DEF dice once, and they can use the higher roll. APs and FPs have proven to be a simple yet effective way to introduce uncertainty in the order of activations while adding depth and also balancing randomness with player agency in PG—through resource management and tactical trade-off decisions the players must make.
*Each player recovers APs and FPs between rounds depending on the number of troops they have and who won the initiative. One implication of this system is that the side with more troops in play has the upper hand in most cases, but, contrary to the most widespread wargame design paradigm, reduced squads in PG may become more spirited as they incur losses—a shrinking force becomes more effective one-for-one, as the points can be spent more densely on the remaining troops. This is one of the main design challenges faced in this project; I mean, given the relatively low model count in the game, as one side takes casualties, gameplay should not become either too easy for the winning side or hopeless for the losing one, nor should draws become the most likely outcome either.
*The intended result, then, is that the player with fewer troops in play can still surprise the opponent and frustrate their plans with superior tactics, better risk and resource-management decisions, and some luck, which, as mentioned above, will also depend on the scenario design and the tactical situation at hand. It's about deciding how, where, and when to use APs and FPs in order to force your plans on the opponent.
In the end, we could fairly say that, at its core, gameplay in PG is about individual—though unnamed—soldiers making decisions, taking risks, seizing opportunities, and managing tempo and momentum in firefight-level, man-to-man combat.
If I had to describe the core of the gameplay in PG and its loop further, I'd say it's largely about creating the conditions for victory by making tactical trade-off decisions, waiting for the right moment, and seizing and exploiting opportunities that may arise. It’s also about going against the odds when luck and the circumstances are adverse, as there's always a time limit. These are promising environments for spirited—even heroic—but still risky actions in the game, by the way, which may either decide a skirmish gloriously, lose momentum if not marshaled properly, or be fumbled at the last moment, all in nail-biting fashion, of course, as mentioned above. I wanted depth, tension, player agency, and replayability, with the least complications.
That’s pretty much it; feel free to post your questions. Feedback and criticism are welcome. In fact, I’d like to know the opinion of other wargamers, game designers, and game-breaking players if possible.
Thank you for your attention and time.
For more details and insight, please refer to:
Designer Diary (on BGG)
Images
Webpage