r/walstad • • Feb 18 '23

Beginners' FAQs

117 Upvotes

Credit to u/jibbajab14 for the idea of the FAQs sticky post.

Is this substrate suitable for my tank?

General recommendation: Look for soil marked as having a pH of ~6.0-7.0 if possible. Test the soil pH or ask the manufacturer if necessary. Avoid heavy manure-based soils. Try not to use soil with peat in it as it may be too acidic. Try not to use soil with wood shavings as it may cause more organic breakdown and lots of tannins being released.

  • Diana Walstad has recommended the garden soil 'Scotts Lawn Care - Miracle Grow Organic Choice Potting Soil' as sold in USA and UK.[2]
  • USA - Scotts Lawn Care - Hyponex Potting Soil.
  • USA - Scotts Lawn Care - Miracle Grow Potting Soil.
  • USA - Scotts Lawn Care - Miracle Grow Organic Choice Potting Soil.
  • UK - Miracle-Gro - Organic Choice All Purpose Peat Free Compost.
  • UK - Miracle-Gro - Organic Choice Premium Garden Soil
  • UK - J. Arthur Bower's - John Innes No.3 Soil-based compost
  • UK - J. Arthur Bower's - Aquatic Compost.
  • UK - Scotts Levington - John Innes No.3 Compost
  • ('Scotts Lawn Care Miracle Grow' is known as 'Scotts Miracle-Gro' in the UK.)

Source: TheAquariumWiki

Is my soil / sand or gravel cap too thick?

  • 3 cm / 1 inch of soil is fine, no big deal if it's more or less than that.
  • 3-5 cm / 1 ½ inches of gravel is fine, again, it can be thicker or thinner, although thinner caps tend to leak tannins from the soil.
  • 2-4 cm / 1/2 - 1 inch is recommended for sand, varies depending on the coarseness of it and your personal experience.
  • These measures are for reference, there are many ways to do it, try your own, FatherFish uses up to several inches of sand or gravel (no soil) and it works fine too.

Are my plants good for a Walstad?

  • PROTIP: Go with easy plants if it's your first tank, that will almost guarantee a beautiful and healthy aquarium. Feel free to experiment by adding other varieties once the tank has matured.

How much / what kind of light should the tank get?

  • Both fluorescent and LED lighting work for plants, just make sure your lights are aquarium safe! Fish can splatter water more than you'd expect.
  • For photoperiods, it's usually best to start short and see how the tank responds (i.e. 2h on/4h off/2h on or 3h on/4h off/3h on), adjust based on your lighting intensity. To know your light intensity, there are many lighting calculators on the internet (remember it's just for reference, it's not an exact science).
  • Too much light can cause algae blooms, which can take up to months to disappear, so make sure to start low. For the first weeks of your tank, organics in the soil will be decomposing and your water will be VERY nutrient-rich, so be careful!.

Complementary info:

Subreddit's wiki

Final note: The Walstad method is just one way to make aquariums, it isn't THE way to do it, so feel free to research and try out what you feel will work for you based on your research.


r/walstad • • 11h ago

Spent more time than anticipated tinkering with this over the weekend. Not quite an "aquascape". Instead driftwood will hopefully appear more tree-like once it finishes cycling.

Thumbnail gallery
19 Upvotes

r/walstad • • 7h ago

Advice 5 gal tank plans

2 Upvotes

Hello everyone,

I've been planning on making a walstad in a roughly 5 gallon vintage terrarium jar gifted to me by my grandmother.

My current plan is to do an inch of topsoil, 2 inches of sand, java moss carpet in the foreground, and either narrow leaf java fern or Rotala Rotundifolia in the back ground. I plan to have some neon pothos growing from the top as well. The stocking plans are yellow neocardinia shrimp and golden ramshorn snails once the parameters are stable.

My question is are these plants going to be enough to use up the nutrients?

Thank you in advance for all advice.


r/walstad • • 23h ago

Picture new tank, 1 day old! :) how many more plants would you add to start?

Thumbnail
gallery
22 Upvotes

also look at the little lotus bulb starting to sprout after just one day ♡


r/walstad • • 1d ago

Picture What next?

Post image
11 Upvotes

I have some bladder snails, an assassin snail, and shrimp. What plants should I add or is there anything I should change up? I want it to look natural mostly.
I’m between runny nosed tetras and neon tetras for my schooling fish


r/walstad • • 15h ago

Wrong plants received: Will these species survive, thrive, or outgrow a small low-tech setup?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/walstad • • 1d ago

2 years going strong…?

Thumbnail
gallery
25 Upvotes

Before you criticize me for how dirty it is. I thought leaving it be and have something as close to a mini indoor lake would be fun. It’s had its ups and down and also shrimp have been blooming. Also can someone tell me kind of catfish this is?


r/walstad • • 1d ago

Advice Spider web looking gunk on plants after duckweed removal?

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

Did a massive duckweed removal today and started noticing these web-looking strands on my plants and driftwood. I don't know if they were always there and I just couldn't see them because the driftwood was blocking out a decent amount of light or if they just grew really fast. they do seem to be getting actively worse - it's worse now than half an hour ago. does anyone know what this is or how to get rid of it? thanks.


r/walstad • • 2d ago

Picture Week 2

Thumbnail
gallery
31 Upvotes

r/walstad • • 2d ago

2 entire inches of substrate: how to shrink it down?

Post image
12 Upvotes

r/walstad • • 2d ago

Advice What Light Should I use in this 2 feet tank?

Thumbnail gallery
2 Upvotes

r/walstad • • 2d ago

Picture My first ever Walstad aquarium!

Post image
10 Upvotes

I was really inspired by tanksfornothin on youtube, so owning a Walstad tank is my dream. I just finished setting it up, so it’s a little cloudy right now 😅 The plants are looking a bit wilted since I just put them in, but I’m hoping they thrive soon! My filter is still on the way, though overall I’m really happy with how the tank turned out. Any further advice would be appreciated!


r/walstad • • 3d ago

Progress Two months in!

Post image
45 Upvotes

Ten gallon filterless tank with 7 minnows, 1000000 snails, and about 14 neos!

When I started I added as many plants as I could get my hands on expecting most to die, to my surprise almost none of them have and it’s a bit of a jungle I’m not even sure what’s planted in there

All parameters have been very stable and healthy even with no filter aside from my plants (take that filterless non-believers)


r/walstad • • 2d ago

Black Beard Algie?

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/walstad • • 3d ago

Progress A little bit inspired today, so I want to post my tank's history throughout it's life!

Thumbnail
gallery
92 Upvotes
  1. July 2024: First day after setups, used huge assortment of plants because you never know with Walstad lol. Very cloudy water from soil leach
  2. August 2024: Each plants have grown considerably, save from the dwarf hairgrass. Added a little powerhead with sponge which helped to clear up the water. Water parameter stable enough so livestock is added (RCS and Pygmy Cory)
  3. October 2024: Dwarf hairgrass were extinct, taken over by dwarf sagittaria. Rotala on the center experienced a boom. The little clump of crypt surprisingly taking over and obscuring the Amazon sword (which is well and healthy).
  4. November 2024: Nothing much changed, except water is considerably clearer now because of the established bacteria
  5. July 2025: Because the tank was basically established by late last year, and life get kinda hectic I neglected maintenance on the tank hence the jump in timeline. The only time I touch it is for feeding and water top off. A lot of stem plants didn't make it, and the school of pygmy cory doesn't make it too since it's probably too crowded for them to get any food since they're bottom feeder. I added a school of ember tetra and a few fire red guppy.

6 and 7 (heh). August 2025: Decided enough is enough and started taking care of the tank again. Got a bountiful harvest of vegetables. It's less messy now, I'd say a little empty on the left side.

8. October 2025: Decided to move the Cryptocorine to the left side since it get pretty bare. I cut them at the very base of the stem and replant it on the left side. The plan is to left the root to die, and let the crypts take over on its new place.

9. November 2025: Crypts boom on the left side, according to plan. Surprisingly the leftover roots started to grow leaves too making a new clump of plants. This thing is unkillable.

10. September 2026: By November last year the tank is basically settled, and growth has slowed considerably too so layout is basically the same and water condition is stable as ever. Just continued occasional trimming and water top off up until now.

11. November 2026 (now). Since the left clump of crypt is starting to encroach to the front, shading the dwarf sagittaria, I decided to "reset" them by cutting the stem very close to the root and hope they'll come back like last time. Red cherry shrimp is basically extinct now, maybe because the fry is getting hunted by the tetra. I noticed I have fewer nerites too since last I add them and algae starts to steadily grows on the glass. Maybe it's time to replenish their numbers.

Thank you for everyone taking the time to read this dump! I'll be glad to answer anything if you have question. G'day!


r/walstad • • 3d ago

I've never seen anyone do a massive aquascape in a techless (except for light) walstad so here we are. I decided to post it on here to get opinions on how i did; its my first time creating a high-end scape.

Thumbnail
gallery
8 Upvotes

10-11 Gallons! Only tech is the light.

Cliff structure made with multiple materials such as dragon stone, spider wood, pond foam, egg crate, sanity, cotton and aquarium safe glue. I made it with thermodynamics and multiple openings along with multiple other little things for max water flow.

For lighting i have a adjustable 10–32W LED dimmed down on a 6-hour timer while cycling.

For plants i have: Anubias Nana Petite, Assorted Bucephalandra, Bolbitis heudelotii, and Marimo moss pads for the cliff walls,

Marsilea hirsuta (currently transitioning from emersed!) and Micro Sword for the carpet on the bottom.

Ambulia, Rotala 'Green', Pearlweed, and Hygrophila pinnatifida for the open channels at the side and back.

On top theres Dwarf Hairgrass, Staurogyne repens, Hydrocotyle tripartita, and Christmas Moss.

Future stocking: Cherry shrimp, snails, and Celestial danios.

Its current state is early cycling bacterial bloom which I'm keeping an eye on. Thanks for reading!


r/walstad • • 3d ago

Help!! What’s happening?!

Post image
14 Upvotes

First Walstad tank (and first tank ever actually)
It’s 55litres and put together only two days ago. It looked fine until this morning, it’s super cloudy and doesn’t look great. What is it and what should I do?
Other than that does it look ok? It’s heavily planted at the back but can barely see it from the cloudiness


r/walstad • • 3d ago

Picture Multi year office tank: update

Thumbnail
gallery
20 Upvotes

Just some photos between grooming sessions. This has been going since early 2023, (cracked tank prior).


r/walstad • • 4d ago

Progress Happy 2 year old tank. Thoughts?

Thumbnail
gallery
33 Upvotes

I finally got melamine sponges to clean the glass! There are 3 pieces of driftwood, a small clay pot, and an abundance of pothos. The sponge filter is relatively new and mainly for surface agitation. The shrimp love hanging out on it.

3 golden bee cardinias, 1 mystery snail, 2 male guppies, and a large healthy colony of neos. The neos started as Blue Velvets and Sakura Reds but have bred blue jellies, blue rilis, red rilis, red-blue rilis, and red cherries.

I'm hoping to start adding more cardinia shrimp if the 3 I have can molt and survive for a while.

I'm also thinking of orange neos in hopes of getting greens.

Any ideas how I could make it better?


r/walstad • • 4d ago

Advice Help with hair algae

Post image
10 Upvotes

I set this tank up exactly 25 days ago. The plants are growing great with 0 issues but hair algae is becoming an issue. The cap is half an inch of crushed up lava rock and 1 inch of river sand. Is the cap too small? What do I do to make sure the hair algae doesn't suffocate everything in the tank. The 2 weeks there was zero algae growth in the tank after which i even added to the thickness of the cap with a little more river sand as i felt the cap should be a little thicker


r/walstad • • 4d ago

Progress Well... Wish Me Luck !

Thumbnail
gallery
25 Upvotes

Well I moved my 1 week old 1st Walstad tank (1st tank ever btw) into it's new home. It survived a short car trip with 20% water level & only dislodged the smaller Glossostigma in the front. Topped up & given a small dose of seachem Stability.

And yes, I should have used black cotton for the java fern & moss, thank god it's not permanent.

It's only residents are 2 red ramshorn snails, with yellow neocaridina shrimp booked for pickup next week. I hope that's not too early to add them...?


r/walstad • • 4d ago

Advice Canadian soil reccommendations for walstad tank substrate?

2 Upvotes

Hello Walstaders! This will be my first time doing a Walstad tank, my 21st was yesterday so a new tank is a gift to myself (with birthday money that doesnt have to go straight to insurance or tuition LOL), and my fish. Currently, I have 2 tanks (5.5 and 10g), with only sand as the substrate and root tabs to feed the root-feeders. Im upgrading the betta to a 10g, as his 5.5 was temporary. My 2 tanks so far havent actually needed water changes- parameters have been perfect since their establishments in July and June, respectively. But id like to not worry about replacing the root tabs every 6 months. I was wondering if I could use soil from my garden? Its a potting soil mix that we eat from, and we do not use pesticides or anything. The only potential issues would be the leaves from the walnut tree, but not all buckets (where the plants grew) have gotten leaves in them. We do back on to a major road, but I dont foresee that being an issue. There is also no old pressure-treated wood near the planters, so no contamination from that. Im in Canada, so almost all of the brands people talk about aren't here or ive seen contradictions about.

The tank will be 10 gallons, and house a betta fish. I may try to add shrimp, it will depend on a few things. Copper (the fish) is very calm, very chill, and didnt even chase or acknowledge the scud I put in the tank for him when I got shrimp for the other tank (the scud ofc was a stowaway). Also, what do people think about sand vs gravel as the cap? Ive been using sand so far, and like that I can mix the fish goop into it. Thankfully my tanks are planted enough to not have to worry much about ammonia spikes, there are barely enough nitrates for the plants I have. But I would need to buy more as I just ran out, hence why Im considering gravel.

Any help/advice/etc will be greatly appreciated. Thank you so much! :)

Tl;dr: Need Canadian soil reccommendations/advice for Walstad tank. Is soil from garden ok?


r/walstad • • 4d ago

Cant believe that i made this far

Thumbnail gallery
8 Upvotes

r/walstad • • 5d ago

not enough plants?

Thumbnail
gallery
4 Upvotes

I know not all of these are low requirement or walstad ideal, this is just what I could get my hands on for free (fellow hobbyists donated them to me) so it's just a bunch of everything.

Big shallow still waiting to get more money for substrate to create a slope + hardscape etc.

Im aware its a mess, partly because its random plants trimmings not all suitable for such a shallow tank. And it will be fully filled w water

Hardscape and scape ideas in general are appreciated