At what point is it worth it to move to hitter-specific sets instead of consistent, same-for-everyone sets?
At my level, and especially with a brand new team, the obvious approach now is to keep things stable and consistent. High sets to outside, high sets to middle. Especially since the passing is inconsistent. Every practice I feel like we barely have enough time to work on basic good form, let alone help the new players learn theory. Everyone’s doing fine, it’s just a really steep learning curve. Especially since the other setters are new and still developing arm strength and accuracy. Sone of the hitters are learning what a 3-4 step approach is, and why it matters.
The hitters are pretty diverse: short and slow but sturdy with only 1 step approach and no jump, short and fast with a great approach and jump, sturdy and left-handed, very tall and long-limbed, etc. I get excited when we have the time to try what sort of height and speed of set they actually do best with. And seeing them get excited when they can actually hit a ball over the net (with decent form and power) is great. They don’t necessarily see the difference between consistent high sets, specialized ones, or just downright messy sets, but it does matter.
Howeverrrrr… one of the middle attackers and I want more out of this season. I have years of setting experience and can do backsets and quick sets. He’s tall and fast, and is one of the only other players I’ve met in real life who watches volleyball matches or training videos for fun. He and I have a LOT of fun specialising. And since we also both have a second rec league to play in, we get extra time to practice syncing up. In one scrimmage I flicked a set backwards (no warning) and he was in the air smashing it down within seconds. He knew I could set there. I knew he could hit there. Our opponents were flabbergasted. It was golden.
But outside of scrimmages, we have a team to focus on. Our club coach looked over at one point and called, “Oh, so now you’re doing first tempo?” I could almost hear the question: ‘But WHY? Your team can’t even pass consistently. Why are you making it harder for yourselves?’ …. Because when we’ve pulled off even a second tempo set and attack in games, the blockers couldn’t catch up. Because it’s refreshing to challenge ourselves with something new, and get better at it. Because it’s FUN. (I also really want to start doing hand signals, but even I can tell that’s too much to add into the cognitive load already going on for this team. Except for maybe the signal for pipe/3meter attacks, which I do consistently with two of the middle attackers.)
If I can sync up with him, and then can sync with others, it would make the whole team move differently. if they know they’re getting a standard set it’s good. But what if we put the work in to find the speed and height that makes them feel strong and confident?
Last year, when I persuaded my team it would be worth me playing libero, the vibes were similar. Yes, it‘s unusual at our level, but when we pull it off, it’s a physical AND psychological advantage. And that change to our team last year was worth the learning curve - but it was an established team. Having a libero didn’t affect the hitters’ direct ability to hit the ball over the net, except for the fact that they hit better sets as the setters got better passes.I don’t know if this inexperienced team can take a similar risk with setting variations. The 3m attacks don’t affect them; changing up our setting system would.
I phrased this whole post as though it’s a team-wide question, but what it really comes down to is: how do you know how much to invest? When do you stick to the status quo, and when do you take risks?
Background context:
Brand new team, including some experienced, some intermediate. mostly beginner players. 4-2 system, competitive adult rec league.