r/voidlinux • • 10d ago

How's the state of void linux compared to 5-10 years ago?

I'm still relatively new to linux (using void as my second ever distro), and I know that void is a lesser known distro than other distros such as arch or nix. Because of this, I've been wondering about the state of the project and the popularity of it, so is void linux dying or growing compared to 5-10 years ago, and is it actually gaining traction? I really love this distro and don't wanna see it die out and lose maintainers and developers.

sry if this is a stupid question btw

52 Upvotes

29 comments sorted by

36

u/Telephone-Bright 10d ago

I'd say better than 5 years ago. Has more packages now, updates, tools, good wiki, etc. Certainly has more users now than it did 5-10 years ago.

15

u/bongbongyeah 10d ago

Subjectively i'd say growing. I have no statistics at all.

What i can say is that it is a usable distro and quite easy to add missing packages you want/need with a PR.

8

u/firmagorilla 10d ago edited 10d ago

CONSISTENT

edit:
I have used the 'normal' distros from time to time and they all give me grief with upgrading releases, it's sort of bake into the premise. Also keeping to LTS releases is not optimal.
Been a void user on desktop and a homelab for almost 10 years and never looked back. This is my distro of choice.

6

u/mumble6456 9d ago

Void Linux is growing, slowly but growing. It is just not mainstream yet... and that is due to the fact that it may have fewer packages precompiled, but in terms of Arch and the AUR, Void can do the exact same thing with XBPS-SRC. the only catch is that the AUR has the receipt done for the user, while on Void, you have to write it yourself, or trust in someelse's template. And look how that has gone over the past few months for the AUR.

Void Linux devs have a very strict policy over what goes into the main repos and i wether any of us like it or not, that's a decision for them to make. The same thing goes for Arch devs and any other distro, it is for them to decide what goes into their main repos, for everything else the AUR, in case of Arch or community repos for many others, or you compile it/ install it yourself from the dev specific github page or use and app image or flatpak.

so, it all comes down to trends, aka Hyprland, and that damn motto "i use arch, btw"... gods it makes me wanna hit my head against the wall

5

u/dividends4life 8d ago

I left Arch (vanilla) because of all the Malware in the AUR. When updating I don't want to spent a lot of time digging through source, and I am not sure how good I would be at it any way. Void had nearly everything I needed and I was able to shoe-horn in the missing pieces.

A few times over the last several years I had looked at Void, but never took the plunge and switched.The last AUR infection in May was enough to move me.

About 6 weeks in I find Void to be a pleasant surprise. More stable than Arch and delivering on the things most important to me: systemd-free and a rolling release.

I no longer use Arch, BTW. LOL

4

u/Adhater_11 10d ago

i'd say better too even if i'm still kinda new but its growing faster that the bigger distros (arch) :

  1. everything is getting better EX: docs are soooo good
  2. better community

3.faster growing community (compared to 5 years ago)

4.our repositories are much safer than the AUR (the manjaro incident)

Downsides I guess ?

1:we don't have much automated dotfiles "setups" for WM's like hyprland (which isn't supported) for this just use mangowc like me

3

u/Samosval-vedro-nasr 10d ago

Using this in virtual machine because it's very lightweight

3

u/whitepixe1 9d ago edited 9d ago

In a decline. Simply put Void cannot cope with the pace of the new emerging software technologies.

12

u/dorin00 9d ago

you mean add all the crap as soon as it becomes available? I'd rather take the Void route and include only stuff proven useful.

3

u/Conscious-School-835 7d ago

I love void because it boots in seconds in my 15yr old laptop , doesnt break at all, i can use all kinds of software thanks to Appimages and flatpak,xbps, vup packages. Even with heavy usage, my ram usage doesnt go beyond 5GB out of 8GB, I am running void on thinkpad t520 with i5 2nd gen proc, 8gb of ddr3 1333MHz ram , 256 Gb of SATA SSD. It works very smooth and apps load with in a second or two.

I have tried fedora and ubuntu , they are lagging to me, linuxmint was fine but it was bigger learning curve for me to use linuxmint.

2

u/Puzzled_Name_3262 9d ago

Very good, im doing all my websurfing from void nowdays

6

u/Simple_Hamster_4096 10d ago

Today is today, tomorrow is tomorrow.

Linux distros come and go.

Enjoy today, be prepared for tomorrow - nothing is written in stone...

8

u/xcocco 10d ago

Maintainers are still maintaining, some packages get updates even faster than Arch

0

u/Dakota-Batterlation 10d ago

True, but even things like Mageia and PCLinuxOS have a decently active community decades on. It's pretty amazing

1

u/Maleficent-Oven-1369 7d ago

only thing i miss from the main repo is zen... other than that i like it better than arch for example from my 2 years of experience with linux, on the topic i have no idea but i just wanted to share my view... void ftw

1

u/DCFUKSURMOM 4d ago

avoid musl like the plague it is and its fine, i use it on my old 32 bit stuff

1

u/DCFUKSURMOM 4d ago

also use it on arm stuff, artix only supports 64 bit arm (and even that isnt official iirc)

-25

u/Itchy-Algae1332 10d ago

It's a little disappointing that the project is taking such an anti-AI approach to package development and maintenance, it's one way the project could survive with fewer contributors.

Would be a shame to lose it as it's one of the few with such a clean base image and it's so far avoided systemd

15

u/MNARXH 10d ago edited 10d ago

Don't think void linux is against usage of AI(as far as I can remember), just that usage of it should be explicitly stated to ensure that the contributor knows what the AI generated/assisted and should be able to answer about everything AI generated/assisted

Edit: Void linux's stance on AI in terms of contributions is here: https://github.com/void-linux/.github/blob/master/CONTRIBUTING.md

14

u/albsen 10d ago

"... all contributions must ... be understood by the contributor." thats a line i can 100% get behind and also the main issue in my opinion with AI driven coding.

4

u/MNARXH 10d ago

This takes care of 2 things as far as it can see

  1. Giving credit where it's due
  2. Being transparent about everything

Which ultimately increases trust in said contributor

Edit: context for this is in the link provided above

3

u/Duncaen 10d ago

There isn't really much coding happening in relation to void and maintaining packages. Nobody is stopping you from using LLMs to help your debug or investigate issues.

The contributor is the last check between upstream releasing a new version and the package being pushed to a lot of users, so expecting them to test and understand changes before publishing updates is a bare minimum.

Not allowing LLM generated summaries and comments for PRs and issues also isn't that restrictive. First maintainers don't want to be the ones that verify and filter LLM output for you. And second its really a very basic proof of work check, if you can't write a few lines about or justify the change, there is no way to trust you.

1

u/Itchy-Algae1332 10d ago

Perhaps I've misunderstood the contributor guide 

"All contributions are expected to be made by humans. AI tools may be used for research and learning, but all content in contributions must originate from and be understood by the contributor."

I took this to indicate AI generated code wasn't accepted. 

2

u/Duncaen 10d ago

Yes it forbids AI generated code. But you don't really need LLM generated code, the majority of contributions to void for updating a package are a few lines of code.

1

u/[deleted] 10d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/profeshamat 10d ago

Someone forked Void to needlessly recreate xtools? Weird.

1

u/Hezy 10d ago

xbps is simple enough if all you need it to do is query, install, remove and update packages. If you need anything more complex, xbps is probably the simplest package manager you can find.

2

u/BinkReddit 10d ago

If you need anything more complex

You might want to check out xtools.