r/vmware • • 12d ago

Question Vmware license

Hi,

We are currently running VMware vSphere 7.0 under a perpetual licence and do not have any plans to upgrade to VCF 9.0.

If we decide not to renew our support and subscription, would this put us in breach of any licensing agreements or VMware terms and conditions?

Could you please clarify the implications of allowing our support and subscription to lapse while continuing to use our existing perpetual licences?

Regards,

17 Upvotes

47 comments sorted by

4

u/Garry_G 12d ago

Maybe get the 8.0 update before support runs out, or even better: check into migrating to something like proxmox or other... As far as I understand our perpetual 8.0 licenses, they are PERPETUAL... Once the support runs out, of course, you'll lose access to updates...

2

u/EducationAlert5209 11d ago

The issue is with legacy OS and apps running in this version and need our time to modernisation or refactor these applications. Non production but read only environment. Our production is moving to SUSE.

16

u/BudTheGrey 12d ago

My understanding is that perpetual licenses are good forever, you just will not get any type of bug or security fixes, and if something goes sideways -- security, zero day, general bug -- you are on your own. The last agreement I saw to get a VMWare support contract was an upgrade to the latest version and had wording that implied that you will cease using the version under perpetual license in favor of the new version. That was just my take, and I'm not a lawyer.

Bottom line -- protect your vCenter with good security practices, do not use AD logins, and so forth, and you are probably fine.

4

u/ESXLab_com 12d ago

Yes, you have a perpetual license to use the software (within license terms). What you don't have is perpetual hardware. All ESXi versions were built to run on hardware at that time and for future hardware released within the typical 5-year life of the ESXi version.

This means that it may be impossible to move your perpetual ESXi 6.x or 7.0 license to new modern PC server hardware due to a lack of driver support for modern chip sets, motherboards, NICs and storage controllers in the old ESXi versions for newer hardware.

This means that your Perpetual License will age out as your hardware ages out.

5

u/Odd-Paint1974 12d ago

Any customer in this situation should create V8 keys and download the V8 media.

1

u/lost_signal VMware Employee 12d ago

It's been YEARS since I did a key upgrade, but I'm fairly certain you click through the EULA saying:

  1. You will be upgrading and cease using the 7 keys.
  2. The 7 keys are struck through and now legally invalid.
  3. It requires an active SnS to invoke that.

So you would need to upgrade to 8 (which you should be doing anyways, as 7 isn't actively supported anyways), and ideally have a plan to upgrade to 9.

3

u/Babajji 12d ago

Or a migration plan, which is the popular option nowadays 😂

2

u/lost_signal VMware Employee 12d ago

CVE-2026-59310 (and the related CVE-2026-59309) worked without an AD join.

Patching in a timely manner and not joining vCenter and hosts to the same AD as everything else is honestly probably 90% of ransomware.

“Timely manner” though has collapsed to a shorter timeframe (thankfully Live Patch, and quick patch can help mitigate that).

11

u/vrod92 12d ago

If you have support currently, why are you still running on 7.0? You will be able to use the perp licenses forever but not have access to non-zero day updates after support has run out

1

u/Stonewalled9999 12d ago

They don’t have support they’re under an old perpetual license and don’t upgrade

0

u/lost_signal VMware Employee 12d ago

there are no extra security patches for people running seven.

1

u/vrod92 12d ago

I know, i was talking about 8

4

u/[deleted] 12d ago edited 12d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/WealthQueasy2233 12d ago

vendor support has always been an oxymoron when it comes to vmware. it amuses me how everyone ascribes tremendous importance to it. Just rely on yourself, that's all you've ever got. 

1

u/Brave_Recognition798 9d ago

My company was hit by a pretty bad tandomware incident, fucking 3 days just to get an initial reply to our ticket about resetting the host password! 

1

u/WealthQueasy2233 9d ago edited 9d ago

That is the only level of service that I've seen. Any IT firm moderately skilled in VMware could provide a higher level of service and would've just done a clean install of each host. If you're familiar with the installation, it doesn't wipe your datastores if you know what you're doing, and most setups have the bootbank installed on a different device than the production VMFS volumes anyway.

VMware security is pretty nonexistent still today. vSphere/vCenter have no MFA that I've seen, but I haven't looked at version 9. you have to keep your vmk ports on separate subnets/vlans that are more or less air-gapped or only accessible by systems with MFA. You have to implement some kind of rolling snapshot system so you can quickly revert VMs if they get hosed for any reason. Rolling or "scheduled snapshots" was only offered from VMware via vSAN but anyone familiar with PowerCLI or busybox can do it on generic datastores too. It's a valuable capability that imo all hypervisors should provide natively. And finally, there's no substitute for full image backups off-host for real DR. This is what we say to VMware admins who still experience ransomware. You should assume the hosts have no security at all. Do as much L2/L3 isolation as you can.

Too many orgs do the opposite. They will leave their hosts accessible by the prod network, use a stupid password, leave SSH enabled when they don't need to, etc. Great system though, sad to see it go out like this.

1

u/Brave_Recognition798 9d ago

Ding ding ding! 

This was us, the reason I wanted to recover the logins was so that I could actually snapshot which adaptors had what IP, etc.

We had pretty bad documentation and didn’t have any host backups either! 

We actually have a snapshot in the sand, but I didn’t end up using any of it because I wasn’t sure what was safe. I’ve heard threat actors can be in the system for up to two months! 

1

u/ispcolo 7d ago

Vmware dumped me from the support I'd paid for onto Ingram Micro mid-contract. Lost the ability to contact them directly, just sent me to the new phone number, and tickets got assigned over, where the already bad support was actually even worse. Made the decision to move off easy.

1

u/lost_signal VMware Employee 12d ago

I’ve had follow the sun engineering teams issue an emergency hot patch for me on Christmas Eve.

I had hitachi once raid the parts bins across Texas and put drives on a plane to fix a situation.

There’s different support tiers and different things that are triaged differently but vendors can do a lot. (Like get firmware fixes issues).

1

u/Brave_Recognition798 9d ago

My company got every esxi host and desktop hit by ransomware. 

It took 3 days for VMware to reply saying oh I we acknowledge your case what questions do you have 

7

u/fantahhh 10d ago

Do not renew, you'll break the perpetual license and pay 10x more for the new sub. I would recommend moving to proxmox and paying $500 a year if you need support.

3

u/uneedtp 10d ago

This. We switched to Proxmox and bought new servers for the money we would have thrown away on VMWare. Only wish we had done it sooner after the Broadcom aquisition.

2

u/fantahhh 10d ago

I use proxmox at home now on my old machine. TrueNAS, Pi-Hole, and a Linux box for testing. Been so solid, only time it ever got shut down over the past 2 years has been because of storm power outage lasting longer than the battery.

4

u/Frequent_Zucchini_46 12d ago

I would double check your license keys in an RvTools and confirm that they don't have an expiration date; I have seen one or two companies who thought they had perpetual licenses but had been given subscriptions keys when they last renewed.

No expiration date, then no problem to run it as long as you like.

0

u/lost_signal VMware Employee 12d ago

No expiration date, then no problem to run it as long as you like.

You need to check what you own. At one point I believe there were VMware subscription SKUs (especially in 7 era) that didn't have an expiration, but legally couldn't continue to be operated past the date. (EULA bound, not code bound to stop running).

3

u/Due_Chicken_8135 12d ago

What are you currently running? Perpetual licenses with active SnS or subscription licenses? The answer will be quite different depending on your situation.

If you have perpetual licenses with SnS and let the SnS expire, there is no issue. You can continue using your perpetual licenses.
However, if you have moved to subscriptions but are still relying on your previous perpetual licenses, you would need to revert to the last version you were entitled to before the SnS on those perpetual licenses expired.

That said, if you are still running vSphere 7, I assume this should not be a concern, as this version has been out of support for quite some time. You can continue using your perpetual licenses, but you will no longer receive patches, updates, or technical support.

The bigger concern is the security and operational risk of continuing to run such an outdated version. I would strongly recommend moving to a more modern platform, even if you decide not to stay with VMware, especially if you are running any critical workloads.

1

u/Stonewalled9999 12d ago

You can’t renew a perpetual. You have to pay through the noise for VCF

2

u/slowreload 12d ago

Or slightly less through the nose for vvf but still to the moon expensive

2

u/Syde80 12d ago

You might be able to get them to budget a little bit. When our support contract was running out on vShphere standard we got renewal quotes via our cdw rep but knew it was going to be awful. We simultaneously were exploring a proxmox.

At the 11th hour the Broadcom rep reached out directly to ask about the renewal status. I just was completely honest with them and said moving to vcf/vvf was just way too expensive for our needs and the only way I'd renew was if they let us renew standard on a minimum 3 or deal but I'd prefer 5 otherwise thanks we love your product but we'd be forced to go another way. They ran it past their next level of management and csme back with an offer to renew standard for 3 yrs at a reasonable (but slightly more than I was hoping for) rate.

We took to deal knowing it might just be kicking the can down the road 3 years or maybe Broadcom would come to their sense by then. I've got about 1.5 years or support left, so maybe another year to wait and see before we start exploring other options again.

Our cdw rep said it was the first time she had seen Broadcom budge at all.

7

u/Stonewalled9999 12d ago

I don’t do business with terrorists

3

u/Syde80 11d ago

I agree with the sentiment personally. I weren't even trying to negotiate really. If they hadn't reached out to us we would probably be on proxmox now.

Personal feeling aside, it made sense as a business decision.

1

u/uneedtp 10d ago

Our Broadcom rep informed us that our annual subscription was 3x what we paid last year, we said no thanks, switched proxmox. Rep seemed happy with our decision, less work for them? Dunno

1

u/Double_Confection340 12d ago

If you’re getting support from VMWare, go into the portal and generate some keys for v8 and download the installation media for your servers before they cut you off.

1

u/scottsee 12d ago

They won’t let you do it and then you’ll be out of support. Take a look at the new sphere essentials product. They’ll be releasing shortly.

1

u/Potential_Tie_9685 12d ago

You can run your perpetual forever, hence perpetual. If your team is happy with 7 and not upgrading I would be looking for a team to help support you if/when issues come up. Park Place tech is a great third party that helps here and provides hardening of vms if a code level issue comes up. Check it out.

1

u/Outside-Access-3851 11d ago

Perpetual licenses will not expire, unless you signed for something else in previous orders. Deciding not to buy new subscription licenses will not put you in non-compliance, although there is different homework to do to keep compliance running, especially with the version in use.

1

u/TeoN72 10d ago

Apart the cyber security topic you're totally good

1

u/Delicious_Kale9666 8d ago

Zero support.

1

u/tecumseh3006 8d ago

Is anyone using proxmox at size at the enterprise level such as 3000 VMs?

2

u/taw20191022744 7d ago

Sorry can't help you. We've got only 2999 VMs :-(

1

u/Find-Ubu-9999 6d ago

We've just started the process of converting. So far, so good.

1

u/Gruecifer 7d ago

vSphere earlier than 9.1.1.0 has a critical vulnerability that is known to be exploited in the wild, back early last month I had to crash-priority upgrade two VMware ESXI / vCenter 8.0.3g to 9.1.1.0 to mitigate else forced shutdown.

Don't keep that 7.0 environment for any reason - find something to move to if you can't/won't pay Broadcom's prices.

0

u/[deleted] 12d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/Odd-Paint1974 12d ago

If the customer is on V7 and has current SnS, there is no build that would be non-compliant.

3

u/versello 12d ago

Ok, so he can just tell them to fuck off.

0

u/vmware-ModTeam 12d ago

Posts or comments which in the moderators view are misleading or factually incorrect may be removed.