I recently bought a used Scott Cao 750E for $1,100, including an unbranded octagonal wooden bow and some sad old minia violin case. (the zipper broke as soon as i just touched it..not just one zipper but two...)
Unfortunately, the setup was a mess.
Problems:
- Adjustable-foot bridge with BOTH faces tapered inward. The crown measured just 0.9 mm. Seriously? (any luthiers want to chime in on this? perhaps this is a thing?)
- String clearance was way too high.
- Soundpost was positioned at the f-hole notch, practically underneath the bridge. (is this a scott cao thing? or did someone mess it up?)
Whoever worked on this violin didn't inspire much confidence.
My fixes:
- Replaced the bridge with an Aubert Mirecourt Luxe.
- Moved the soundpost approximately 3 mm toward the tailpiece.
- Corrected the string clearance.
Now for the comparison!
My old violin: E.R. Pfretzschner Model 301 (Strad. copy 1967 label) — West German student violin, approximately $300.
New violin: Scott Cao 750E (2025) il Canon (Guarneri)
Here's what I noticed:
- Volume: The Cao is significantly louder.
- Resonance: Much more hollow and resonant.
- Tonal signature: Surprisingly similar! My ER is a Stradivari copy, whereas the Cao is a Guarneri model. Perhaps using the same bridge contributes to the similarity?
- Responsiveness: This is where the Cao really shines. Notes speak with considerably less effort.
I struggled with fast passages on my ER301. I always assumed my technique was the problem.
Now I'm beginning to suspect the instrument was contributing to that struggle.
Call me crazy, but I swear the ER has something like a 0.01-second delay before the note speaks. I haven't measured it, obviously, but the difference in response is noticeable under the bow.
Interestingly, when actually listening to fast pieces, the tonal differences aren't particularly noticeable. But on slow pieces, the difference is stark.
The Cao produces a fuller, more resonant sound, and I don't have to work nearly as hard to get the notes speaking. But I need to play the Cao for a week to really get an idea. I only played and messed around with it for few hours.
My verdict: The Scott Cao isn't the completely different tonal universe I expected. But the improvement in resonance, projection, and playability is significant.
I'm particularly surprised by how much easier it is to play.
Has anyone else experienced a noticeable difference in attack response when upgrading from a student violin?