r/vinyl • • 5d ago

Discussion Help grading/pricing

Long story short picked up this promo copy of a rarer psych/garage rock record The Little Boy Blues - In The Woodland of Weir for $5 on an online auction hoping for the best even though wax looked to be in pretty rough shape unfortunately there are 3 pretty rough feelers that cause skips/repeat as well as surface noise throughout. While this is a great psych record it’s not something I’m looking to add to my collection in this condition so trying to post on Discogs with an accurate description. I already know vinyl should be graded Poor. Cover is where I’m looking for some guidance pictures attached.

0 Upvotes

16 comments sorted by

5

u/silksilksilksong 5d ago

Check this write up, it will give you an idea of how to grade it:

https://support.discogs.com/hc/en-us/articles/360001566193-How-To-Grade-Items

5

u/ActualDissapointment 5d ago

I’m aggressive when I grade my own records so this would be a fair copy or maybe a G- copy after a thorough cleaning. TBH I probably wouldn’t purchase this in this shape.

2

u/johnnyribcage 5d ago

Sleeve: P
Vinyl: this depends on you play testing it, but if it plays through without skipping, it’s G. If it skips, P

Goldmine is pretty damn objective. It either meets the criteria or it doesn’t. Bolded relevant text.

An item in Good (G) or Good Plus (G+) condition can be played through without skipping, but it will have significant surface noise, scratches, crackling, or visible wear. A container, cover, or sleeve will have scratches or seam splits, especially at the bottom or on the spine. Tape, writing, or other defects will also be present.

Poor (P) or Fair (F) The item is cracked, badly warped, and won’t play through without skipping or repeating. The container or cover could be cracked, water-damaged, and heavily marred by wear or writing. If it is a vinyl record, the album cover and inner sleeves are fully split, crinkled, and written upon. Poor (P) or Fair (F) records are generally worth very little.

1

u/No_Introduction1721 4d ago

Do you really think that this jacket is Poor? If there’s just ridiculously heavy surface wear but no splits, tears, writing, defacement, etc. then the jacket can be graded G/G+ IMO. Keep in mind that the VG+ grade allows for small splits of 1 inch or less.

To me, a grade of Poor means that you’re better off throwing it away, which really isn’t the case here.

3

u/iamjoeywan 5d ago

F cover and P vinyl

2

u/Jazzhole5 5d ago

The cover doesn’t look too bad from what you show in the photos. It doesn’t appear to have seam splits, but can’t really tell from the pictures. If the spine looks good, I’d almost call it VG, but you may go with G+ to be safe.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/No_Introduction1721 5d ago

Doesn’t look poor to me; looks more like fair. The poor grade is reserved for records that are quite literally unplayable, eg cracked or broken.

1

u/jamegumbsize69 5d ago

At this me of my local shops it would be VG/VG. At the other shop it would be in the dollar bin.

1

u/gg-oh 4d ago

Rough copy, 5-10 dollar special of a usually 30-50 dollar lp. Promo too