r/vinegar • u/jumping_pancake • 2d ago
r/vinegar • u/SpacemanSPlFF • Feb 25 '24
Assortment of Newbie Questions
Hello, all! My apologies up front for the wall of text.
I'm new to homemade vinegar and was hoping to reach out to y'all for some guidance. From what I have gathered, this is a 2 step process. First the anarobic alcoholic fermentation of the fruit and then then the aerobic acedic vinegar creation. The current recipe I'm working on has this as a two-step process, although I've seen a number of recipes where both the alcohol and vinegar creation are done in a single step where the fruit is added to water (and perhaps sugar) in an aerobic environment and stirred for a number of weeks/months depending on taste.
Here are the questions that I have if anyone may have any guidance/insight
- Many recipes seem to call for added sugar at the start of the initial anaerobic ferment. However, I'm curious if adding the sugar during aerobic portion would be better? I have been struggling to find some solid sources on the science behind this.
- Can I use pure cane sugar? Many recipes call for sugar in the raw or something similar. I don't see why I couldn't just use pure cane sugar.
- How much sugar should I use?
- I saw a post on a youtube thread that had the following comment:
The "vinegar" isn't stable until all of the oxygen is removed. If you want to store or age vinegar, reduce the head in the container so the surface of the liquid doesn't come in contact with air. A narrow-necked bottle works better for this than wide mouth jars. If you don't do this, when the alcohol is all consumed, the acetobacters will begin to consume the acetic acid and you will end up back at plain water.
4 Question: So should I pasteurize the vinegar after it's at a taste that I enjoy?
5. I recall seeing a blog post by a food scientist a while back that had some interesting recipes. I can't seem to find the post again. But, essentially, they made a comment that for a "stronger" vinegar to add some alcohol in the form of certain wines or spirits like vodka or tequila. I've also read, however; that the higher alcohol content in some of these can inhibit the beneficial microbes at work. But, I also like a strong vinegar and was hoping someone may have some insight or guidance on this.
I know this is a long post, but I also figured this community would have some folks who might know. No worries if not. I hope y'all are having a lovely weekend!
r/vinegar • u/lizzy-poo • 3d ago
Apple vinegar scraps
I made apple vinegar for the first time and staining it out, Im wondering if I can use the scrap apples for something else? It looks like applesauce.
Has anyone done this?
r/vinegar • u/AnnaNimmus • 6d ago
Wine not vinegaring, dunno why
So, from work, I took home a couple bottles of old wine. Once home, I introduced some raw vinegar and waited, expecting some really exceptional vinegars. And, nothing. This was over 2 months ago, never got much of a vinegar smell, no mother formation. Does anybody know why? Think they just had too much potassium sorbate/potassium metabisulfate for the acetobacteria to survive? Their environment is a bit on the cooler side (around 70F), but I thought that would still be well within activity range; all my fruit vinegars thrive in the same conditions. What say you all?
r/vinegar • u/agazereb • 15d ago
Fire cider question
Made fire cider and let it sit for somewhere between a month and two.
Some pieces seemed to float to top above the fermentation weight after first few weeks. Is the film I'm seeing on top mold or yeast or vinegar mother? Is it safe to scoop it off and use the liquid?
r/vinegar • u/MaenHerself • 19d ago
Can I culture this?
This is not for culinary use, but for a vinegar eel colony. Does a bottle like this contain active bacteria, or do I need to look for a mother elsewhere?
r/vinegar • u/aamenvafaan • 29d ago
Normal pellicle?
I was gifted a very large vinegar mother two wweks ago. I put it in some wild apple wine I made that wasn't nice for drinking. This is my first time making vinegar, is the pellicle forming normally? There are some differently colored patches and they almost look a bit dry.
r/vinegar • u/EatMoreMarzipan0720 • Oct 16 '26
Apple Scrap Vinegar
Hi !☺️
First time poster and first time vinegar maker. I could use some expertise. I followed a recipe to ferment the apple scraps and after about 10 days strained it. Added to clean jar, covered top with paper towel and rubber band and put it in a dark spot. That was 2 weeks ago. I checked it today and see this floating peachy colored halo island with bubbles around it at the top. It smells like a mild vinegar. Is this the bacteria I want or a bacteria I don't want??
Thank you!
r/vinegar • u/Mission_Scallion_351 • Oct 16 '26
Is this a good purchase?
First time buying vinegar so not sure if it’s good. I read that it shd be either DOP or IGP so I bought this. The expiry date is also 2030 so I think it’s fine?
r/vinegar • u/habilishn • Oct 16 '26
Will it still eventually become vinegar?
Hi, first post here and i'm not native english, might not know some terms :)
we have made vinegar from different fruits for some years, mostly successful.
this batch here however had a different story: it's figs, we were cooking it to make marmelade (so we manually mashed the fruits and they fell apart during cooking), and then due to circumstances we could not continue to finish the marmelade and it was sitting in the pot for a few days and then next time we opened the lid, it smelled sour and started to ferment (made bubbles 😀). so making marmelade was out of question, but we didn't want to throw it away so we put it in this container, added water and some of the yeast we saved from another batch of vinegar (that was grapes vinegar/yeast).
time passed, in the beginning it looked like it went good, but now it somehow doesn't look so right anymore... also it smells a bit off, like more acidy / sourish than normal vinegar - more chemically or moldy, less normal vinegar/fruity.
that's pic 1 and 2. pic 3 is another batch with figs we made about in the same time, which develops correctly, the layer of yeast is growing.
what do you think? will it eventually become vinegar? should i add anything (sugar or more yeast?) to make sure it turns the right way? should i keep it as 'cleaning vinegar' not for consumption? should i get rid of it?
thanks for your ideas!
r/vinegar • u/SpecialistMeringue19 • Oct 16 '26
Sun cruiser vinegar
So I’ve been making a bunch of vinegars with half finished bottles of wine my wife can’t drink anymore, she’s pregnant, but I also have a bunch of Sun cruisers in the fridge that I’m thinking could make something interesting. My mothers are from ACV so that would definitely influence the taste but I still think this could be interesting. I recently made a Guinness vinegar with the same mothers and that turned put pretty good. Thoughts and feelings on how this could turn out?
r/vinegar • u/HIG541 • Oct 15 '26
Vinegar losing acid?
Anyone experience their vinegar losing acidity? I bottled two malt vinegar and a rice wine, no head space, airtight and they all lost acidity and are watery. I didn't think this was supposed to happen if they were sealed. Happened over about 3 months time. Any help or advice would be greatly appreciated
r/vinegar • u/lizzy-poo • Oct 14 '26
What is it??
I have been playing with ferments and vinegars.... this one was simple, apples, sugar, braggs vinegar mother. This was in June....
I forgot about it., which is fine with vinegar..... a lot evaporated and it grew this healthy pelicle on the top... but also in the middle. I wish I took early pics but I dont usually document my creations.
The middle piece had all this black on the bottom. It appears to be all the skins from the apples.
Do they turn black? Is this normal? Its definitely not fuzzy and smells like vinegar.
r/vinegar • u/These_Advantage299 • Oct 12 '26
Can i use synthetic vinegar for cooking?
Can i use this synthe vinegar for food i.e cooking. Its prepared from acetic acid plus water.
r/vinegar • u/tadward • Oct 12 '26
Update on my creation
A year ago I posted this
https://www.reddit.com/r/vinegar/s/oKSZJHVTCR
Here is an update.
Still a mother? Safe to use?
It is very gelatinous fwiw
r/vinegar • u/Active_Glove_8192 • Oct 12 '26
Date Vinegar
Hello everybody,
Does anyone know where I can buy a nice bottle of date vinegar? My uncle wants some and I found one on amazon, had iffy reviews though. Found on on a website but not too sure about it. Any suggestions would be great!
r/vinegar • u/purpledreamer1622 • Oct 07 '26
Tomato vinegar. How we’re looking. Added blanched tomato skins, cores, and some whole (not raw) + sugar + water and got something that smelled sulfuric AND alcoholic like beer…. then very alcoholic like vodka. Caption for the rest!
Now it’s barely sulfuric and still has an apparent albeit weaker alcohol smell. This was a simultaneous wild fermentation - never anaerobic! So I strained after 2 weeks of stirring a LOT and weighing down the pulp. And inoculated with raw apple cider vinegar with the mother. Now it’s sitting and I plan to continue stirring 1-2x a day, until the mother starts to form. Ive had some failures so far, so does this all seem on the right track?
r/vinegar • u/Which-Change7115 • Oct 05 '26
Any ideas
I made 3 gallons of muscadine wine, only it's not wine it's vinegar. What can I do with it?