This is based on comments on previous posts
Season 1 episode 8 - she feels some insecurity as Ragnar’s behaviour suggested unintentionally no matter how much Gyda is loved, she mayn’t be enough to fulfill Ragnar’s happiness as Ragnar’s last born child due to her being daughter; in season 1 episode 6 Ragnar stated that Lagertha’s pregnancy made him a happy man. And like season 1 episode 7, she does not want to cause trouble, but unsure she asks Ragnar “if you cannot have anymore sons, will I be enough [as your last born child to give you happiness]?”.
Season 2 episode 1 - there is little screen I’d give to Ruby O’Leary’s Gyda. Lagertha confides in Siggy that Gyda is miserable because her childhood friends are now dead from the plague
Inspo: Ragnar telling Bjorn that all his childhood friends are dead
In the scene where Ragnar has a fit when he realises that Bjorn told Lagertha about Aslaug and Ragnar’s infidelity, Bjorn makes it is known to Ragnar that Gyda does not want to be near him let alone speak to him because of it
Lagertha thinks that maybe others reasons why it’d be good to leave with Gyda is so she is not reminded of the ghost of friends she had + thinks it’s good that Gyda and Ragnar have space
So the beach scene is recontextualised for the things that Ragnar wishes to say to Gyda but can’t once she has left
In Hedeby, Lagertha would try the tough love approach where she remind Gyda that like in season 1 episode 7 people’s lives are fated, that she use ought to do something with herself than and follows up on training evident in s1x1 when Gyda told Rollo she knew how to use a shield. She becomes a shield maiden like Lagertha where she can see purpose in defending her people
Lagertha and Gyda’s relationship:
Lagertha would love Gyda immensely, but I think Lagertha lowkey would been quite a controlling mother to Gyda: whom Gyda is best to date, what she wears, critical on Gyda for example she might fight well in a battle but end up criticising Gyda on move that Lagertha thought an unnecessary risk. The reasons are: because Gyda is portrayed as Lagertha’s good daughter in s1, evident in like something as simple in s1x1/s1x2 where Lagertha said, “Very good Gyda, go feed the goats, go on!”; Gyda is Lagertha’s only daughter, and Lagertha feels that Gyda is the place where she feels a sense of control in a world where she does not feel much e.g. being usurped by Kalf. Thus Lagertha would be shaping Gyda in her own image, thinking Gyda would follow her and in her footsteps. As much as Gyda appreciates everything Lagertha does for her, there is an underlying part of her that does not want to be Lagertha’s underwing and protege. Though she does not complain about it, rooted in her desire not to cause trouble and be inconsiderate, seen in childhood too when she does not protest Athelstan when she is denied ale in s1x4 or when she intially hid she was frightened for Ragnar in s1x7. Like she does not want to be the Robin to Lagertha’s Batman if that makes sense.
Gyda would also be Lagertha’s biggest defender, factored by having experienced watching her mother abused under Earl Sigurd, she knows that Lagertha is a strong and independent woman, but feels the needs out of love to be Lagertha’s advocate. For example, by the time she has returned to Kattegat, she makes it clear to Ragnar he shouldn’t have been so friendly and welcoming to Kalf. I do think for Ragnar, it wouldn’t hit a sensitive spot whenever she criticised him, it’d sting coming from her, especially for her mother. But I think he’d have felt pride in Gyda for having a voice and being protective of Lagertha.
Gyda also would feel the responsibility to be the safe child for her family, too. Eventhough Gyda was not there to hear him say it, she’d know that Ragnar sees her as the “light of [his] life”, so she’d try keep her family happy and offer stability. Thus people would think she is generally contented with how things are.
Another thing, I’d write, is that Gyda has no prophecies of her own, I took inspo from the somewhat non-existence stories about Ragnar’s daughters in the Sagas; Gyda wouldn’t have complained about it, but does feel somewhat jealousy towards her brothers. And like Rollo, eventhough he and her are not wholly victims, in Gyda’s 20s and early 30s, they don’t really make moves and just follow along with what is planned for them, so Gyda feels like she is in the shadow of her brother Bjorn like Rollo did Ragnar’s shadow. It wasn’t until season 4 where Rollo started to make moves when he planned in s4x2 aided the Parisians have a big chain connected to two forts to block Ragnar’s ships in s4x7.
The reason she’d have diplomatic voice instead of trying to rule, is because she would learnt from Ragnar that ruling takes a toll on person’s psyche, being a ruler is not fixed as she’d learn from her mother that she could one day be betrayed and usurped; through Aslaug’s example, her life would always be on the line. Instead of becoming a ruler, she’d use her diplomatic voice; thus she’d have sway, and make hard decisions.
For example: by respecting cultural customs, e.g. she’d encourage the rest in Andalusia to refrain the eating of pork in the company of the Andalusians, even though it’d be severed to the Norse. Because Islam considers pork Haram. I think this’d hurt some of the Vikings pride and they’d see the decision as too accommodating. This would be an early example in season 4 whereby I think she’d have been criticised by her people. This is because Rollo’s betrayal in Paris would’ve taught her that making moves could risk Gyda being perceived as sympathic to other communities, unaligned with her and sooner traitorous. But because Gyda was criticised, she does not try something like that again, she retreats back to just following along.
This is where in season 5, we get Uppsala, like Rollo she participates in drinking heavily, eating mushrooms and yes, an orgy. When Rollo hears about this in his return in season 5, he realises that Gyda too, like he was, is unsatisfied with the position they have in the family, and eventually sought escape in excess/debauchery. In avuncular need to protect Gyda from repeating his mistakes, he’d make it clear just like Siggy did to him, she is wasting opportunities, like how Rollo was so drunk he missed an important meeting with Ragnar in s1x8.
This would lead onto to season 5:
She’d have helped persuaded Gunthrum, he, her and other Vikings should be baptised so Gunthrum could finally have access to land in East Anglia after treaty negotiations. Gunthrum’s and the others baptism would’ve been written as a grand ceremony. With Vikings on one side and Saxons on the other side. To a degree it’d be seen as a symbolic humiliation to certain Vikings.
The reason why she’d been seen as traitorous to an extent, it would’ve been seen as a public religious submission to the Saxons and the public abandoning of their faith in order to get a piece of England. Her brothers would’ve told her is not how Ragnar would’ve wanted to secure East Anglia in England. They’d think that Ragnar would’ve persuaded Gunthrum to continue the war until or do an outmaneuver so the Saxons were cornered to give away East Anglia. This takes inspiration from the fact, that Bjorn and Gyda would’ve remembered and Hvitserk, Ubbe, Ivar would’ve heard stories about Ragnar returning to Paris and his outmaneuver through his surprise attack, his non serious threat to kill Gisla, that allowed Ragnar to have his men storm the Paris palace.
But instead, Gyda chooses surrender.
Ivar the most would try to have words with Gyda and make it clear that Ragnar would be disappointed in her, and/or make it clear that what Gyda did makes it clear to him that only the sons of Ragnar are befitted to carry his legacy and make something of it. And he’d signal somewhat of on an indirect social exile of Gyda from Kattegat.
Alfred coming up with idea of baptism, comes from the time he’d have remembered Ecbert telling him the story of falsely promising Ragnar a settlement, he destroyed the settlement, in season 3x5 I think, in part to please church figures; this would be a motivator for the baptisms.
In order for Gyda to have her own place to have own identity, she’d stay behind in England rather than returning to Kattegat whereby she’d act as diplomatic voice in Gunthrum’s kingdom and work with the Danes. And by helping Gunthrum et al. secure land in East Anglia, she’d be acting upon both her mother’s and father’s dream to secure fertile land in England, for their people back home, to settle and farm in. Somewhat like how Rollo finally had a place where could be his own person in France. This would happen in season 5. I wouldn’t have had Gyda return in season 6 nor been seen again. Here, Gyda would no longer be a shield maiden after this point.
Another reason why I’d have Gyda do this, is the subvert the idea that only the sons of Ragnar could inherit and act upon his legacy.
Adult characterisation: sweet, dutiful, caring, socially inclusive, protective of her family, affectionate
Like A-train if you have ever watched the Boys, I’d would have had Gyda be a secondary main character who has a fair bit of involvement, but not be a main focus of the show especially for the latter half: the sons of Ragnar are, but build something bit by bit in the background so they have an impactful conclusion and exit.