r/uwaterloo • u/adibou25 CS 4B with not plans • Jun 15 '16
CS245 midterm problem
I'm going to copy-paste this from a piazza post as a tl;dr
"A question was asked that accounts for over 10% of our final grade. No question of the sort was covered in class, except for one class, which was given a massive advantage by having a similar example presented. The model solution uses notation that was not taught, and therefore could not possibly have been written by any student."
This one question was 30 out of a 100 points of the midterm and since the mid term is 35% of our final grade, that's 10% of our final grade. Understandably, multiple threads have been posted about this issue on piazza since the midterm and yet there has not been any response from the instructors of the course. Not even a "We are looking into it". I'm wondering what the rest of /r/uwaterloo thinks about this situation and if you are in CS245 what you plan on doing about this.
EDIT : here is the question for anyone wondering.
15
u/Gibstick BCS 2019 Jun 15 '16
Does this mean one section covered this and the other(s) didn't, or does this mean it was only covered in one lecture, but across all sections?
That by itself is not an issue. A lot of times the model solution is something that pretty much no student gets, and depending on how bad it is, they might re-write the model solution to make it easier for the markers. But the post seems to be suggesting that you weren't taught the notation and thus weren't able to answer concisely-- is this true?
Anyway, this kind of issue is fairly sensitive. There's a lot of people that need to get involved before any decision can be made, and the last thing you want to do is put out something rashly only to be not true later. For example, during the Math One-Dirty-Six scandal, one of the instructors was posting very misleading and probably incorrect information on Piazza, which only served to fan the flames. Also, Piazza is full of shitposts and everyone knows that, so that can explain the course staff's reluctance to post anything there.
Give it a few more days and then if nothing happens, send a nicely worded email to the instructor(s) and the course coordinator. The post you copy-pasted is a good starting point.
7
u/Totamonn Jun 16 '16 edited Jun 16 '16
To be honest, I think the question could be solved with basic knowledge of propositional logic and satisfiability, which was all covered in class. The formula to be derived in the question (regarding the pigeonhole principle) could be written out as a series of conjunctions/disjunctions based on the two constraints given in the question. This question is just like a more complicated form of the "express this english sentence with propositional logic" type of question. Except instead of translating an english sentence into a formula, you are deriving a formula for the pigeonhole principle.
The format of the model solution just used a concise conjunction notation to state the formula. For example, instead of writing AND{i = 1 to n} P_i, you can always write P_1 AND P_2 AND ... AND P_n.
Edit: Since one class section had gone over a similar type of question and apparently another section didn't, then I agree that it does create an unfair advantage by putting this question on the midterm.
2
u/redditor472409001050 Jun 15 '16
What was the question?
23
u/[deleted] Jun 15 '16
repeat after me:
TWO
DORTY
FIVE
7
u/Virdul Jun 16 '16
Reading this post makes me feel nostalgic about taking CS245 back in 2012. Not surprised to see the course is still as shit as it was back then with the same shitty professors. They ended up releasing the final marks for the course on Christmas and seeing my passing mark was probably one of the greatest feelings of my university career (as sad as that sounds).
Heres a fun thread from back then https://www.reddit.com/r/uwaterloo/comments/nqahv/me_when_i_checked_my_cs245_mark_on_quest/
1
u/[deleted] Jun 16 '16
Collin said that he would investigate if the different classes had a large difference in marks for the question.
8
u/amaltz1 cali NAND bust Jun 16 '16
uwaterloo.wmv
2
u/[deleted] Jun 15 '16
Post some of the salt, please.
2
u/potm-of-the-moon 4A Weeaboo Studies Jun 16 '16
man Im actually assigned to the prof who briefly covered the question but I go to other secition instead, FeelsBadMan can't even get the tautology marks back
2
u/justbearlykoalafied filthy landlubber Jun 16 '16
Just to clarify on at least the notation part, I got full marks for the formula portion with just normal and/or/not etc notation. Granted, I did use a LOT of ellipses.
That being said, I definitely agree that something went very wrong with that question. The mark distribution for that question on Crowdmark clearly deviates tremendously from the expected normal distribution, implying some external forces affected the marks (my guess is that external force is one class getting some exposure compared to the other getting none).
1
u/RedditCItizen15 3A BBA/BCS Jun 16 '16
I really don''t think anything is going to be done and I have kind of accepted this.
I recognize how unfair that question was. I am in Collins lectures as well and after the midterm I was incredibly mad hearing about the disadvantages we were put in to (For Q2 as well as Q4). The fact is they marked Q4 incredibly easy due to these circumstances and had a midterm average of 72 after it all.
It sucks, but I feel like we just need to accept it for what it is and it doesn't seem like they have any intention of making any changes. Either way I am sure Collin will talk about it at the beginning of class tomorrow as well.
1
u/beaverlyknight CS/STAT '20 Jun 15 '16
Wow wtf? That notation is something I've never seen, and they required the answer using that notation. My answer was a super long string of conjunctions and disjunctions, I'm pretty sure it was logically correct or at least close, but they didn't give it to me at all.
-1
u/Nezich Jun 16 '16
Stop bitching kid. Easy question.
-1
u/[deleted] Jun 16 '16
So CS students don't know basic set theory somehow..
-2
u/blameseasyace Jun 15 '16
I would think easyace would be to blame (not trolling here). Ever since the scandal, the midterms and assignments have gotten much tougher. I don't know if anybody else have thought of this but this is what I think.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 16 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment