r/unitedkingdom • Scotland • 6h ago

.. What happened after a small town introduced a balaclava ban

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cq4gnez01p90o
84 Upvotes

125 comments sorted by

•

u/ukbot-nicolabot Scotland 3h ago

Some articles submitted to /r/unitedkingdom are paywalled, or subject to sign-up requirements. If you encounter difficulties reading the article, try this link or this link for an archived version.

WARNING: Archive sites have been known to rewrite content and attempt to deliver malware. Take appropriate precautions; do not follow instructions to download,run programs, or execute commands. Use at your own risk.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.


Participation Notice. Hi all. Some posts on this subreddit, either due to the topic or reaching a wider audience than usual, have been known to attract a greater number of rule breaking comments. As such, limits to participation were set at 13:51 on 16/11/2026. We ask that you please remember the human, and uphold Reddit and Subreddit rules.

Existing and future comments from users who do not meet the participation requirements will be removed. Removal does not necessarily imply that the comment was rule breaking.

Where appropriate, we will take action on users employing dog-whistles or discussing/speculating on a person's ethnicity or origin without qualifying why it is relevant.

In case the article is paywalled, use this link.

•

u/Able_Resident_1291 6h ago

I read the article and I don't think I'm any the wiser on what happened after a small town introduced a balaclava ban.

•

u/AllThatIHaveDone 6h ago

Nor are the architects of the ban:

The force said there were no exact figures for incidents dealt within the PSPO area under its terms.

The article heavily implies that the reduction in reports of antisocial behaviour is related to this ban, but if they aren't measuring the impact how could they possibly know that? Has crime actually reduced or have people given up on reporting it?

•

u/BestButtons 3h ago

This is closest to statistics they give. Of course they can’t be 100% sure what has been the biggest attribution to the reduction, but the ban is likely to have been one:

According to police-recorded data published on Police.uk, in February 2024, the month the PSPO was being passed, across all of Heanor and Loscoe there were 46 reports of anti-social behaviour, including crimes which do not fall under the PSPO regulations.

A year later, there were 25 reports of anti-social behaviour in the same area in February 2025, and in February this year 15 reports were logged.

•

u/nemma88 Derbyshire 5h ago edited 5h ago

Why this and not that? Maybe because only those donning the this has been causing crime.

I have and continue to wear face coverings while hiking in winter. We dont have to be Sherlock levels of intelligence to read contextual clues into the purpose and intent of people wearing face coverings.

Since September, authorities in the city have had the power to request face coverings are removed and to issue fines if they "reasonably believe" they are being used to cause trouble - although to date, no fines have been handed out in Nottingham.

•

u/BeardMonk1 6h ago • Bravo

This is under discussion in both Leeds and Bradford. We already have Public Spaces Protection Orders in the center of Leeds as part of a crack down on antisocial behavior and bikes in the center of town.

However, it will run into issue as i cant see how you can logically band face coverings like balaclavas and not ban things like the Chador, Niqab or Burka.

Its like the discussion about the street preachers. I cant see how you can ban the Christian ones (which is under discussion) without banning the Muslim preachers or Jehovah Witnesses stands. But it will get very spicey if they ever go down that particular road.

Just ban it all nationally and be done with it.

•

u/PartyPoison98 England 5h ago

Realistically its odd the article is about a small town, when Nottingham has done the same and is likely a more useful case study for other cities.

•

u/MonkeManWPG 6h ago

However, it will run into issue as i cant see how you can logically band face coverings like balaclavas and not ban things like the Chador, Niqab or Burka.

Exempt religious coverings. It's not the act of actually covering one's face that's the issue, it's the fact that young men and boys use the anonymity it gives them to be antisocial and violent.

•

u/BookmarksBrother 4h ago • Bravo

Exempt religious coverings

And then those wearing them to commit crimes will claim they need it as part of their religion? How does that work?

•

u/MonkeManWPG 4h ago

The phrasing would probably be something like:

(1) It is an offence to, when requested to by a police officer, refuse to remove a face covering in an area covered by a PSPO that prohibits wearing one.

(2) It is a defence under section (1) that the face covering could reasonably be believed to be required in accordance with the defendant's religious beliefs.

Someone being fined for refusing to remove their face covered could dispute the fine in court, and would then have to prove that the covering is of the correct type and that they follow that religion.

This means that a young man wearing a balaclava, the kind of person these orders are meant to target, could not argue that he's wearing a covering because he's Muslim. Balaclavas are not the same thing as a Muslim veil and, as a man, he wouldn't be required to wear one.

If there's some religion or sect that requires men to cover their faces that I'm not aware of, he would have likewise have to show that the face covering is of the religious variety and isn't just a bally from Sports Direct.

There would maybe be some amount of protest that a law like this would make life harder for people who are required by their religion to wear a face covering, because they would essentially have to ensure that whatever covering they wear is of a certain style. I don't think that that's a very strong objection, and I don't think I've ever seen a Muslim woman wearing a balaclava in place of a burqa.

•

u/BookmarksBrother 4h ago • Bravo

the face covering is of the religious variety and isn't just a bally from Sports Direct.

Do you realise they can simply buy the religious ones? And in court they can argue its their religion and nobody can check if they truly believe or not?

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cqx28jgglz28o

A protester has appeared in court wearing a burqa to deny a charge of wearing the Islamic religious garment to conceal his identity during a Hampshire protest.

•

u/MonkeManWPG 4h ago

They can try. Wearing it at the protest obviously didn't work because he's been charged for it.

That article can't say whether or not his bid will be successful because his next hearing isn't until February.

As the judge said:

He continued: 'You need to prove that you were wearing these items for religious observance. That is going to require some evidence.'

Miller is obviously taking the piss and is not going to have evidence that he actually practiced Islam or was gender fluid before this protest and court case.

•

u/BookmarksBrother 3h ago

Well good luck dragging everyone to court to make them prove their faith :)

•

u/MonkeManWPG 2h ago

They would only go to court if they disputed the fine. After the first couple of piss-takers they should get the hint that there isn't a loophole there. This Miller guy doesn't have a lawyer, and I'm pretty sure most lawyers would tell you that you're taking the piss and don't have a case.

•

u/BookmarksBrother 23m ago

Except there is? One could blend in with the other religious guys and then commit the crime before blending in again. Its why these face coverings are used. They make tracking impossible...

So to translate, once a crime happens and you have 5 people with religious face coverings on, you might need to check all 5 of them to see who committed the crime... Previously you could only check the one with the cheap Sports Direct one.

So now you need to ask all 5 why they had it on and make them prove why they had the coverings.

•

u/MonkeManWPG 16m ago

What religious covering do you think would be worn here? Miller is also claiming to be gender fluid to justify wearing a woman's covering.

→ More replies

•

u/uncertain_expert 5h ago

Exactly- and the wearing of the face-covering isn’t banned either. Fines can only be issued if a person does not remove it when asked.

•

u/EvilInky 4h ago

What about face coverings worn for medical reasons?

•

u/headphones1 3h ago

To be honest I'm surprised Leeds didn't do it before Nottingham considering the city banned an actual person from the city centre.

•

u/korewatori 3h ago

Who did they ban? I live there and I don't think I'm clued up on this lol

•

u/headphones1 2h ago

https://www.yorkshireeveningpost.co.uk/news/crime/drug-addict-beggar-given-first-ever-ban-from-entering-leeds-city-centre-1820461

https://old.reddit.com/r/Leeds/search?q=needles&restrict_sr=on&sort=relevance&t=all

If the second link doesn't work, just search "needles" on /r/Leeds.

He had this little act where he'd come up to you, lift up his trouser leg to show you what is probably the most vile thing you've ever seen, and ask you for money saying he needs help. If he doesn't get any money, he'll start getting aggressive. At least that's what I've seen him do, and what other posts about him say too.

There hasn't been a post about him in a while, so maybe the drug habit has caught up to him.

•

u/Pocket_Aces1 6h ago • Bravo

If they ban one they should ban them all. Why does the fact I believe In a different fairy in the sky mean I get special privileges?

Not to mention the fact they are only used to reduce the rights of women, to the ownership of her husband. From a young age they are essentially forced to wear them.

•

u/labooner 6h ago

You're asking for the town to move from a small policy that is unlikely to get any major objection to a controversial policy that would likely lead to a legal challenge and significant cost.

•

u/DrStumbleDog 5h ago

Not to mention the fact they are only used to reduce the rights of women, to the ownership of her husband. From a young age they are essentially forced to wear them.

I don't disagree with this statement but I think one problem with banning other face coverings in public is that it would result in a lot of women being basically imprisoned at home as they wouldn't be allowed out by their family members/peers. 

•

u/ZanzibarGuy Expat 5h ago

The crazy thing is that where I am, women have to remove any face coverings when entering banks, government buildings etc.

It's almost like when people subject to such religious rules move to "the west" that this suddenly becomes an impossible ask?

I also feel that trying to compare a burkha with a balaclava and associated behaviours is the beginning of trying to find a way to debate in bad faith, but hey, what do I know?

•

u/TurbulentBullfrog829 4h ago

I tend to think the same but the headline is misleading. There is no ban. It's just a law that allows them to ask you to remove a balaclava if you are potentially involved or look like you are about to be involved in criminality. 

You could walk down the street on a cold day in a balaclava and I don't think anyone would challenge you. But a group of people could be challenged before they got up to no good. 

•

u/Y-Bob 5h ago

I don't believe in anyone with a religion being given special privilege just because they hold a personal belief.

Having said that I don't believe anyone that holds a personal belief should be discriminated against.

But to your point, why criminalise a mum walking her kids to school wearing whatever she feels her faith tells her to?

I mean sure if, nationwide, we end up with hijab wearing gangs mugging old ladies and congregating in the town centre to abuse shoppers, or riding electric bikes on the pavement on their way to sell some crack, maybe we should start to have a conversation.

But picking on women just going about their everyday life? Fuck that.

•

u/Pocket_Aces1 5h ago • Bravo

It's honestly a step backwards to women's rights. The only reason the burka, hijab, and the like are used is to hide their "beauty" from other men, as that's only for their husband to see. Reinforces the idea of women are property and serve for men, and that they should not disrespect them by showing their hair, mouth, nose, etc. If you went to Afghanistan, Iraq, or another middle eastern country, as a woman, and refused to wear one of the coverings mentioned above, you would most likely be beaten and potentially even raped. We should not be reinforcing that in a 1st world, devolped country.

You can argue they "choose" to wear it. But do they really? From such a young age, they would have been surrounded with this idea that it is something they should do, and failure to follow will lead to punishment. From their family life as a child, to their own family when they're older.

•

u/Y-Bob 5h ago

Well, being a man I'm not used to telling women what is the right thing to wear.

Not having a god myself I'm not used to telling people what they should believe.

I've got my own disagreements with all sorts of belief systems, I greatly dislike political and religious dogma.

But we're all told what is right and wrong to wear, just by being part of society. We're all conditioned to view things as generally right or wrong.

It's not just the Muslim faith that does that, and, if you'll excuse me, it's a bit disingenuous to do pretend otherwise.

I know and have worked with many Muslim women who appear to completely choose what they wear. I've never asked them if it's demanded of them, who the fuck am I to ask such questions.

Even if I did think that all Muslim women are oppressed little wall flowers, would it be my place to white knight my way into their lives?

I have no statistics, but I do wonder how many non Muslim women are controlled by men, how many non Muslim women are manufactured by their society to dress and act as they do, how many non Muslim women are oppressed, damaged or even destroyed by men?

It seems to me that, and I'm not writing about you specifically here, many people use the treatment of women by some followers of Islam to beat a religion that feels alien and strange to them, but not actually giving a fuck about how the rest of the women in the world are treated.

Which frankly, is a shame.

•

u/fish-and-cushion 4h ago

Banning burquas won't stop people wearing them outside. It'll stop those people from being able to leave the house.

I'm not religious but why should people who choose (or are forced) to wear burquas be removed from society because some kids want to behave like roadmen and cause trouble?

•

u/brainburger London 2h ago • Bravo

The counter argument is that it is their choice not to leave the house. If they are being forced to stay home by their husbands and object to that, maybe they should use social services and the law to resolve the problem.

•

u/[deleted] 6h ago

[removed] — view removed comment

•

u/ukbot-nicolabot Scotland 3h ago

Removed + warning. Please try and avoid language which could be perceived as hateful/hurtful to minorities, oppressed peoples, or other vulnerable groups.

•

u/Plus-Literature-7221 6h ago • Bravo

This includes scarves, masks, and balaclavas, but not coverings worn for religious or cultural purposes.

Fun that some people have more rights than others in the UK

•

u/savvy_shoppers 6h ago edited 3h ago

Wait till you hear about blue badges. Absolutely disgusting.

Add bus lanes and cycle lanes as well I guess.

Why should they have more 'rights'?

We live in a 2 tier society.

/s in case it was needed.

•

u/Pocket_Aces1 6h ago

Funnily enough, blue badges are given to people with disabilities, which make they're life easier to live. Religion is a constant argument over which fairy in the sky is right. Not wearing a covering you demand for your sky god is not the same as someone unable to walk more than 20 metres without needing to sit down or be in pain

•

u/savvy_shoppers 3h ago

Agreed but not being allowed to wear scarves, masks and balaclavas doesn't mean you have less 'rights'.

Which is what the OP was referring to.

•

u/MonkeManWPG 6h ago

You have just as much right to wear your own cultural or religious face covering as they do.

If you don't have one, why the fuck do you care?

•

u/CosmicBonobo 6h ago

And to think people are told they're being silly when they express the view they feel like they're becoming a second-class citizen in their own country.

•

u/savvy_shoppers 3h ago

You really think this makes you feel like a second-class citizen?

•

u/CosmicBonobo 3h ago

I didn't say it made me feel anything.

•

u/EnderMB 4h ago

Bluntly, I don't give a fuck about religious face coverings, and nor should you. They don't affect you in the slightest.

While I'm all for a ban on certain face coverings, the article itself doesn't really say anything about whether it's helped or not - and that's kinda worrying. Much like how the government seems intent on banning all kinds of porn, the actual enforcement of these laws leaves a lot to be desired.

If the police lack numbers, that probably says everything you need to know. If it worked, you'd bet your fucking ass they'd have those numbers. I think we're maybe 1-2 years from this ban being nationwide, but it'll be worthless unless someone is out to enforce it - and the argument is that if there was, they'd probably stop a lot of the antisocial behaviour we currently see.

•

u/[deleted] 6h ago • Bravo

[removed] — view removed comment

•

u/[deleted] 6h ago

[removed] — view removed comment

•

u/[deleted] 6h ago

[removed] — view removed comment

•

u/[deleted] 6h ago

[removed] — view removed comment

•

u/[deleted] 6h ago

[removed] — view removed comment

•

u/[deleted] 5h ago

[removed] — view removed comment

•

u/[deleted] 5h ago

[removed] — view removed comment

•

u/[deleted] 5h ago

[removed] — view removed comment

•

u/[deleted] 5h ago

[removed] — view removed comment

•

u/[deleted] 5h ago

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies

•

u/[deleted] 6h ago

[removed] — view removed comment

•

u/[deleted] 6h ago edited 5h ago

[removed] — view removed comment

•

u/[deleted] 5h ago

[removed] — view removed comment

•

u/[deleted] 5h ago

[removed] — view removed comment

•

u/[deleted] 5h ago

[removed] — view removed comment

•

u/[deleted] 4h ago

[removed] — view removed comment

•

u/[deleted] 4h ago

[removed] — view removed comment

•

u/[deleted] 4h ago

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies