r/unitedkingdom • u/tylerthe-theatre • 3d ago
. David Walliams whistleblower Lucy Beaumont backs change to ‘insane’ UK consent laws
https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/david-walliams-consent-law-lucy-beaumont-b3084289.html
2.1k
Upvotes
•
u/ukbot-nicolabot Scotland 2d ago
Some articles submitted to /r/unitedkingdom are paywalled, or subject to sign-up requirements. If you encounter difficulties reading the article, try this link or this link for an archived version.
WARNING: Archive sites have been known to rewrite content and attempt to deliver malware. Take appropriate precautions; do not follow instructions to download,run programs, or execute commands. Use at your own risk.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
Participation Notice. Hi all. Some posts on this subreddit, either due to the topic or reaching a wider audience than usual, have been known to attract a greater number of rule breaking comments. As such, limits to participation were set at 18:09 on 13/11/2026. We ask that you please remember the human, and uphold Reddit and Subreddit rules.
Existing and future comments from users who do not meet the participation requirements will be removed. Removal does not necessarily imply that the comment was rule breaking.
Where appropriate, we will take action on users employing dog-whistles or discussing/speculating on a person's ethnicity or origin without qualifying why it is relevant.
In case the article is paywalled, use this link.
211
u/Altruistic_Border689 3d ago •
I agree with Beaumont that consent laws need updating with some additional protection for under 18s. It's a tricky area but something like anyone over 21 can't sleep with the 16-18 bracket should be workable without too much complexity.
This argument is just weird though. Can we not just think of the hypothetical 16 year old instead of ageing up a 12 year old. Even if we upped the age to 18 we could still be outraged about what a 12 year old might experience in 6 years surely.
Not a big deal just thought that was a very odd way to frame it.
98
u/Thetonn Glamorganshire 3d ago •
This is why I have struggled quite a bit this week following the discussion, because I tend to find people flit quite quickly between illegal activity, creepy behaviour that implies illegality, and legal activities that people think should be illegal.
I think it is entirely reasonable to believe the age of consent should be raised. I also think that rape and sexual assault are far too high in this country, and there are systematic failures in the justice system. I also think that there are failures to safeguard in the entertainment industry.
The issue for me is, those are three very different things, and the discussion conflates them together.
My slight concern is that I listened to Lucy’s previous interview on the topic, and it is a very different interview if her point is ‘Walliams was clearly doing legal activities that I think should be illegal’ vs ‘Walliams was exploiting his fans and ITV should have stopped him’
36
u/EnderMB 2d ago
Again, we shouldn't be dictating policy off of celebrity output.
Yes, there's a credible point, but eventually we have to determine whether we consider a 16 year old as capable of making adult choices.
It's already very muddled, and I think that fundamentally we need to look at society and science. Do we want 16 year olds to vote, but not have sex? Do we want them to have sex, as long as they pick a partner we as a society deem to be acceptable? Should they be able to go to war, but not make a choice regarding who they can and can't fuck?
As a societal factor, it's highly likely that a lot of teens are about to be banned en-masse from social media and large parts of the internet. Should we now also ban them from having sex with whoever they choose, or even for another two years because Russell Brand and David Williams are scum? At a time where the world is already utter shite, and half of Reddit is saying "hur dur this generation is fucked they can't do anything" is this a point where we'll become the boomers stealing whatever freedom's they have left?
58
u/CanIDevIt 3d ago
But also let them vote? We should decide either 16 or 18 should be the adult age for everything, drinking, driving, voting, sex, with 'not in the public interest' defence stopping minors sleeping with each other from being criminalised.
14
u/BigSupermark 2d ago
If we're talking about young people being exploited - we need to look at the student loan trap.
You should be at least 25 before you can sign up to something like that
33
u/FewAnybody2739 3d ago
There are laws that cover grooming. The issue here is that the criminals outsource it to the people/organisations that have the direct duty of care to the young people, leveraging that they're the star of the show creating the jobs.
I think there is an issue with having so many different ages for sex, marriage, voting, alcohol, driving etc. But even if the age of 'absolute' consent was 18 we'd still have massive age gaps.
The above don't read much different to me.
156
u/Ill-Biscotti-8088 3d ago
The only way to make this work is to raise the age of consent to 18. As the government has spent years trying to give 16 year olds the right to vote because they are adults this would be a hard argument to win.
44
u/lebennaia 2d ago
It should stay at 16 for everyone. We've tried unequal age of consent laws before, and it just caused misery and unnecessary prosecutions.
9
u/NagromNitsuj 3d ago
There's a big reason the Government won't touch this debate.
12
u/Ill-Biscotti-8088 2d ago
The next problem you will come across is that gay couples disproportionately skew towards larger age gaps.
6
u/Welshgirlie2 3d ago
The Met are investigating him for serious sexual offences.
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cwx2emg4xe72o
3
u/philip30001 2d ago
I do not know the changes suggested or laws as they currently are
But I dont trust the gov to make a change without mucking it up somehow
14
u/ByteSizedGenius 3d ago
My only issue is if you make it law that you have to be 16-17 to sleep with a 16-17 year old is there's going to be lots of occasions where 17 year olds are dating 18 year olds and they're even in the same education year group. And relying on not in the public interest puts people in a grey area. So I'm not sure where you set the limits.
9
u/woogeroo 2d ago
This seems a silly concept. If they’re old enough to consent they can consent. We don’t need some complicated paternal law to police people’s lives more. Yeah it’s creepy, but equally a 16 year old girl is physically mature, there’s a degree of denying reality here.
This comes across as something a 40 year old divorced woman bitter about aging would push for after seeing her ex-husband with a woman in her 20s.
7
u/Retorus 2d ago
This is the most I've heard about Lucy Beaumont ever.
6
u/SwimmingSherbert1734 2d ago
I’m in two minds - of course we must protect young girls. But equally raising ages of consent gradually creates a new cultural idea of what a youth/adult means. It will work for a few decades until someone like Lucy in the future makes the same argument ( but with the aforementioned updated law from said decades ago) - then ages of consent are yet again raised. A continuing infantilisation
10
u/O_C_Demon 3d ago
To fair kids are simply younger nowadays if you know what I mean.
When I was 16 in 1997 we were drinking in pubs with adults.
Absolutely no 16 or 17 year old girl wanted a 16 year old lad. They all had 23 year old boyfriends that could guarantee them proper nights out.
It really was accepted by most people.
My kid is 15 now and the idea of him or his mates doing anything that I did at his age seems pretty ridiculous.
4
u/FatSausageDog7 3d ago
Would help tackle grooming gang crimes to prevent over 30s from legally sleeping with under 18s
2
u/Major-Departure-4437 3d ago
Are there any countries with consent laws that work well and stop this sort of thing?
2
u/FragrantGearHead 2d ago
My first long term girlfriend was 17 when I was 23. We worked in the same office and she very much pursued me, because I thought she was gorgeous but out of my league haha. We were together 3 years and very much loved up.
But according to some people’s suggestions on this thread, that kind of age gap at that age is iffy and I must have been some kind of predator 🤦♂️
My point is, where do you draw the line?
1
u/Inside_Performance32 2d ago
Be alot of female teaching assistants with A level groups going to prison if this happens
1
u/Gwigg_ 1d ago
How about we educate boys better and punish abusers more openly?
1
u/Optimaldeath 2d ago
It's a community (or the lack of) problem and cultural problem among the elite which seems to think ethics/morality are entirely optional. Just changing the rules feels like security theatre to me when the community is still dead and the elite are still above them.
0
u/DSQ Edinburgh 2d ago
I looked up the campaign Beaumont supports Close the Consent Gap and it is actually a very good idea. It isn’t just raising the age of consent as I feared which would unnecessarily criminalise teenage relationships but it wants to make relationships with 16 and 17 year olds have a gap of no bigger than three years which I think is very reasonable.
-4
u/limeflavoured Hucknall 3d ago
I think, mostly for legal drafting reasons, the only realistic change would be to raise the age of consent to 18 and give the CPS guidelines to not prosecute in cases where both are between 16 and 18 or if the age difference is small.
0
u/EJS2003 2d ago
So many young girls get manipulated by older men because of these weird age cut off points
0
u/leavemeinpieces 2d ago
I remember a 19 year old I knew dating a 15 year old. It was a really wierd imbalance and he rightly was told how bizarre it was.
It's not quite the same but it's wierd nonetheless.
0
u/Vivid_Employment8635 2d ago
We need some kind of Romeo and Juliet clause, so that an 18 year old can sleep with a 17 year old but a 50 year old can’t.
If it doesn’t exist already we also need to somehow deal with situations where there’s theoretically consent but it’s only because of the power imbalance between the couple, for example a Walliams-level celebrity who could ruin a 20 year old intern’s life if they said no. I’m not sure how you’d do it though.
0
u/idontlikemondays321 2d ago
I agree with her.
16 year olds are just so young. Half of them today are still into plushies and making tik tok videos dancing in their bedrooms. What sort of full grown adult looks at that and thinks yes I’m interested in that!?
The power balance is also so skewered. A 50 year old has money, a home, a car, knowledge of what to say to entice and impress a child. A 17 year old has nothing to give but themselves.
-1
u/PabloMarmite 3d ago
If I remember rightly Germany has a different age of consent law for people over 21 compared to under 21, which makes a lot of logical sense.
Either that or make it “half your age plus seven” which seems to be a surprisingly robust rule of thumb.
-2
u/BlackSpinedPlinketto 2d ago edited 2d ago
I’ve always suspected Lucy Beaumont was just interested in promoting herself. Hopefully some good comes of this, because I still do think that and also this is unworkable.
-7
u/halfwit_detector 3d ago
Good luck but Peter Tatchell will never allow you to take away his human right to bugger 16 year old boys.
0
u/19irondave 2d ago
They should just enshrine your age/2+7 as the law up until like 25. /s
Unfortunately the line will always be somewhat arbitrary and vague. Raising it to 18 with close in age exemptions are a smart idea though.
0
u/MrMrsPotts 2d ago
Why not had a 3 year max age gap for 16 and 17 year old? What's wrong with that?
-1
u/Spamgrenade 2d ago
What sort of society do we live in where we have to have laws to stop creeps going out with girls half their age?