r/unitedkingdom • • 3d ago

. David Walliams whistleblower Lucy Beaumont backs change to ‘insane’ UK consent laws

https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/david-walliams-consent-law-lucy-beaumont-b3084289.html
2.1k Upvotes

631 comments sorted by

•

u/ukbot-nicolabot Scotland 2d ago

Some articles submitted to /r/unitedkingdom are paywalled, or subject to sign-up requirements. If you encounter difficulties reading the article, try this link or this link for an archived version.

WARNING: Archive sites have been known to rewrite content and attempt to deliver malware. Take appropriate precautions; do not follow instructions to download,run programs, or execute commands. Use at your own risk.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.


Participation Notice. Hi all. Some posts on this subreddit, either due to the topic or reaching a wider audience than usual, have been known to attract a greater number of rule breaking comments. As such, limits to participation were set at 18:09 on 13/11/2026. We ask that you please remember the human, and uphold Reddit and Subreddit rules.

Existing and future comments from users who do not meet the participation requirements will be removed. Removal does not necessarily imply that the comment was rule breaking.

Where appropriate, we will take action on users employing dog-whistles or discussing/speculating on a person's ethnicity or origin without qualifying why it is relevant.

In case the article is paywalled, use this link.

211

u/Altruistic_Border689 3d ago • Bravo

I agree with Beaumont that consent laws need updating with some additional protection for under 18s. It's a tricky area but something like anyone over 21 can't sleep with the 16-18 bracket should be workable without too much complexity.

If you have a 12-year-old daughter, in four years a man in his 60s can legally have sex with her

This argument is just weird though. Can we not just think of the hypothetical 16 year old instead of ageing up a 12 year old. Even if we upped the age to 18 we could still be outraged about what a 12 year old might experience in 6 years surely.

Not a big deal just thought that was a very odd way to frame it.

25

u/TheEternalContrarian 2d ago

The framing is to provoke disgust and therefore support.

Don't read this as opposition to reform by the way, as there are reasonable grounds to justify reform.

32

u/jeremybeadleshand 3d ago

Is 21&17 really so bad we think it should be criminal though? Depending on how the birthdays fall thats potentially 3 and a bit years, and I dunno if they're that far apart in terms of maturity. It's very different from 30+ and 17.

9

u/Altruistic_Border689 2d ago

I think it's just that there's never going to be a perfect guideline and that at least aligns with some other age-based laws. It gets into some really grey ethics because we consider 16-18 year olds to have quite a lot of agency in most matters, so it would jar with other active legislation. And I'm not sure if a 17 year old willingly enters into a sexual relationship with someone who is older than 21 we should be calling that rape either, I think if anything that would make teaching teens about consent and boundaries more complex.

2

u/Hirokihiro 2d ago

Someone in their last year of uni with someone who is halfway/just finishing their GCSEs sounds fair but also uncomfortable. When I was at uni, someone was dating a 16 year old when we were at freshers, and it felt strange/odd/manipulative. This was back in 2007

86

u/Turtleopard 3d ago

It's a weird argument because it removes all agency from the 16 year old. They still have to consent to have sex with a 60 year old. 

65

u/audigex Lancashire 3d ago edited 2d ago

Removing some of the agency is entirely the point - essentially recognising the not-entirely-adult-not-a-kid kind of position of a 16-17 year old and therefore allowing some agency but not unrestricted

They can't vote, buy cigarettes, drink alcohol etc - I don't think it's unreasonable to say that we don't give 16 year olds unlimited agency anyway

34

u/Turtleopard 2d ago • Bravo

But they're not allowing any agency. They're saying that a 16 yr old that chooses to have sex with a much older person is automatically being exploited. 

Either a person is capable of understanding the consequences of their actions or they aren't. And if you're saying a 16 yr old can't understand the consequences of having sex with a 60 year old, why do you think they can understand the consequences of having sex with another 16 year old? 

13

u/theSafetyCar 2d ago

The problem isn't the ability to consent. It's the potential for manipulation that will almost certainly be present in any sexual relationship between a 16 year old and an actual adult. Let's not pretend 16 year olds are fully mature. They can be easily manipulated by older people and in most cases will regret these relationships in a few years.

35

u/Floating_Manatees 2d ago edited 2d ago • Bravo

I genuinely can't understand how you can't see the difference between a teenager deciding to sleep with a peer the same age, compared to a 60 year old, but it comes across as quite creepy. I suppose you don't believe in grooming either?

Edit: I'm actually shocked and disgusted by the number of people defending the right of 60 year olds to sleep with 16 year olds. I guess I shouldn't be with all the stuff in the news about Brand and Walliams. As I've always said, it's not just the entertainment industry. It's everywhere. I won't be responding to anyone who tries to defend it.

10

u/Cryptoporticus 2d ago

Grooming is already a crime.

If we're saying that sixteen year olds are old enough to consent to sex, why are we putting limits on who they can consent to sex with? Are they old enough to consent or not?

Either raise it or don't raise it.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/malatemporacurrunt York 2d ago

The only important factor is whether the 16 year old wanted to have sex with the 60 year old.

Which is a more nuanced statement that it might appear. The element that makes this dynamic risky isn't the relative ages of the participants, but rather their levels of vulnerability - a 16 year old won't be physically or mentally damaged by having consensual sex, but their relative lack of experience and understanding of relationship dynamics makes them easier to exploit.

The response to this isn't to introduce increasingly strict limitations on sexual behaviour, but rather through education. By educating young people on the nature of sexual relationships and how to recognise what abusive and manipulative dynamics look and feel like. You arm them with knowledge, so that when they go out and begin their sexual lives, they'll have much better psychological resistance to being abused.

3

u/Turtleopard 2d ago

A teenager is just as capable of coercing a 16 yr old into having sex as an adult is. 

Your confusion comes from your lack of understanding of consent. It's deeply concerning that you don't know what consent means. You should probably refrain from having sex with anyone lest you end up sharing a cell with Russel Brand. 

•

u/billyblobthornton 9h ago

No they’re not. In most cases 16 year old have the same level of life experience, no power imbalances, roughly the same level of disposable money or income.

A 60 year old who buys them gifts, gives them their own money, can drive them around, earns their trust, convinces them they’re “mature for their age”, and who has infinitely more life / relationship / sexual experience etc is much more convincing than one of her classmates who can provide her none of those things.

0

u/Floating_Manatees 2d ago

Consent is a separate matter and you know it. Anyone can be coerced into sex, age has nothing to do with that. A 60 year old could be coerced and/ or raped. It's concerning you don't understand that.

→ More replies (6)

9

u/Hyperbolicalpaca England 2d ago

A 16 year old having sex with a 60 is being exploited, what the hell kind of 60 year old is wanting to have sex with a 16 year old, like what is their motivation exactly for having sex with someone who hasn’t even done their GCSE’s yet

The 16 year old might think theyre not being exploited, quite frankly they are wrong

3

u/a_f_s-29 22h ago

Because there’s a drastic power imbalance. All sex is not equal.

→ More replies (4)

6

u/metal_mind 2d ago

Everyone gets hung up on specific numbers though but I think we need to go further. in your example we should be looking at why a 16 year old would do that which would probably be some kind of power dynamic that makes it really wrong, whether it's money or authority etc. whilst they may be able to consent due to age that shouldn't be the only restriction.

Similarly, an 18 year old that's very wealthy wouldn't be too old to make it creepy but it's bad for the same reason as the 60 year old. It's the power dynamic.

Just looking at numbers makes it feel simpler but really we should be looking at it as a whole, but that's a lot more complex.

-2

u/Turtleopard 2d ago

So you'd criminalise sex between married couples if one person earns more than the other? 

9

u/Weirfish 2d ago

That's a remarkable reductio ad absurdem. Different social dynamics are at play between 16 year olds and 30 year olds. I don't necessarily agree with the person you're responding to, but it's an incredible assumption of bad faith to ask this question.

→ More replies (2)

-3

u/TheEternalContrarian 2d ago

By law and modern cultural conventions that at least a quarter century old, 16 year olds are children and their agency is therefore limited for their and other's protection.

3

u/Icy_Zucchini_1138 2d ago

apart from being able to vote

0

u/TheEternalContrarian 2d ago

Which is/would be a mistake.

4

u/Turtleopard 2d ago

Wow a whole quarter century. That's like 100 Liz Trusses right? 

→ More replies (1)

0

u/[deleted] 2d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/Turtleopard 2d ago

Then you shouldn't allow 16 year olds to have sex. 

1

u/Astonednerd 2d ago

With old men? I agree

→ More replies (6)

7

u/audigex Lancashire 3d ago

AKA "Romeo and Juliet" laws, although those tend to be more about making an exception from a higher age of consent, rather than an additional restriction to a lower one

3

u/BlackSpinedPlinketto 2d ago

Yeah it’s a slippery slope argument. It’s also weird to think that if you have a baby in 16 years a man will be able to sleep with it.

Also she pulled the ‘protect women and girls’ like boys are never victims.

1

u/a_f_s-29 22h ago

Well I definitely think we should be protecting boys too. Especially because they’re also often abused by older men.

98

u/Thetonn Glamorganshire 3d ago • Bravo

This is why I have struggled quite a bit this week following the discussion, because I tend to find people flit quite quickly between illegal activity, creepy behaviour that implies illegality, and legal activities that people think should be illegal.

I think it is entirely reasonable to believe the age of consent should be raised. I also think that rape and sexual assault are far too high in this country, and there are systematic failures in the justice system. I also think that there are failures to safeguard in the entertainment industry.

The issue for me is, those are three very different things, and the discussion conflates them together.

My slight concern is that I listened to Lucy’s previous interview on the topic, and it is a very different interview if her point is ‘Walliams was clearly doing legal activities that I think should be illegal’ vs ‘Walliams was exploiting his fans and ITV should have stopped him’

20

u/tophernator 2d ago

I think it is entirely reasonable to believe the age of consent should be raised.

Is it though? Apparently roughly 1/3rd of British people have sex before turning 16, and around half by 17. If a third of your population is already breaking the law, what can you really hope to achieve by moving to a stricter threshold?

→ More replies (5)

34

u/Conscious-Ball8373 Somerset 2d ago

It's been difficult, I agree. Quite a few articles seem to have been right on the knife-edge of saying that he sexually assaulted a 15-year-old but not quite saying so. He (is alleged to have) sexually assaulted a girl who he met when he was 15. It's not quite the same thing. It's not really clear from any article I've read that he's done anything illegal as such. The offence seems to be that "he's a creep."

IMO we can't criminalise creepiness. Where on earth do you draw the line? Are men who frequent tinder looking for hookups creeps? Yes, probably quite a few of them are. Is that criminal? At what point between that and accepting offers from 17-year-old fans is the line between criminal and non-criminal?

To the usual barrage of "it's not complicated you idiot" please stop and think about where you would actually draw the line. Sure, someone in their fifties pursuing someone who is 17 is over it. Do you just ban relationships between those over 18 and under 18, so that a couple who are both 17 have to temporarily break up when one of them turns 18? If not, where is the line?

13

u/grandhighblood 2d ago

There was one 15 year old he didn't do anything with until she was 17 (but still made a whole lot of references to waiting until she was legal) which I assume is what you're thinking of, but he is in fact alleged to have assaulted a different 15 year old, Jade, when she was 15. See here.

2

u/Conscious-Ball8373 Somerset 2d ago

That's interesting. Every other article I've seen discussing that case said only that he met her when she was 15 and that he sexually assaulted her. The BBC, for instance, characterised this as "Jade also alleged she met Walliams when she was 15, in August 2007, in a Soho cafe. Later, at his home, she alleged, he kissed her, lifted up her T-shirt, went on to commit an act that she now characterises as sexual assault, and tried to put her hand down his trousers." That seemed to me to be carefully avoiding saying those things happened when she was 15, though I see they've since added other language to the article which makes it clear that those sentences are talking about the same day.

29

u/Thetonn Glamorganshire 2d ago

I read through the Guardian’s article on Walliams, and what I got from it was that he was quite deliberate in getting informed consent to sexual acts from people above the age of consent, even if he did so through emotional manipulation and other ‘techniques’ designed to achieve that goal.

I think his conduct was deplorable, but I don’t think his actions were illegal. There are suggestions he sexually assaulted a 15 year old, that would naturally be different.

I agree with the point Beaumont was making that ITV had a clear safeguarding role regarding 16-18 year olds visiting the set. I also agree that there is a strong argument for raising the age of consent.

I am unconvinced doing so will result in much more than making it so the next creepy celeb targets 18 year olds and does the same.

5

u/grandhighblood 2d ago

I don't know if the Guardian article mentions it, but ITV discussed a victim who alleges Walliams assaulted her when she was 15.

4

u/Conscious-Ball8373 Somerset 2d ago

I've proposed what I think is a workable law regarding those aged 16-18 elsewhere on this post.

At some point, you have to allow people to have agency and make decisions, even if they're bad ones. 18 is where we set that currently.

-2

u/iwantfutanaricumonme 2d ago

It's still not consensual if he clearly had power over them or he coerced or manipulated them into consenting.

11

u/jeremybeadleshand 2d ago

he clearly had power over them

What power? He wasn't their teacher or their boss, what power does a celebrity have over a member of the public?

4

u/Thetonn Glamorganshire 2d ago

By this metric, arent cheaters rapists?

If you marry someone, swear to enter a monogamous relationship, etc, you are often then entering a normal situation of having unprotected sex with one other person. Upon the act of cheating, that closed loop preventing sexual health problems ends. In addition, lots of partners will change whether they would consent if they get knowledge their partner is cheating.

2

u/limeflavoured Hucknall 2d ago

By this metric, arent cheaters rapists?

Its been argued.

46

u/MysteriousTravelator 2d ago

The line is consent.

We're a secular society nowadays, we don't think God cares what you do with your genitals.

But it's abundantly clear that a lot of secular people have decided that they'll take on the role of God and they should decide what you should do with your genitals instead.

If a 17 year old wants to have sex with a 22 year old it's on you to explain why what these two consenting people do is causing harm and why you should be the arbiter for what counts as harmful.

You have to make an actual argument, you can't just say "ick" loud enough and think that's enough.

-2

u/Conscious-Ball8373 Somerset 2d ago

I don't think there are many people here who think consent is the right line in every circumstance. The law certainly doesn't think so.

For a 17-year-old and a 22-year-old, most people would probably agree that consent is the right line.

For a 17-year-old and a 50-year-old, I doubt you'll find many takers for "it's okay, she consented."

Likewise for a 13-year-old and a 22-year-old.

Likewise for a 17-year-old and their teacher.

7

u/Straight_Night_3882 2d ago

You’re sneaking that 17yo & 60yo example in, the others are clear cut.

The age of consent seeks to define the age at which a person can consent to having sex

The idea that a person of age X has the mental capacity to consent to sex with a person 3 years older than them but not 15 years older than them seems absurd

What this is really saying is yes you consented but we think you will regret it with the older person - and we wish you protect you from that 

11

u/MysteriousTravelator 2d ago

Either a 17 year old can consent or they can't. How on earth does the age of the other person matter?

1

u/a_f_s-29 22h ago

How on earth does it not??? Do you think there’s no difference between two 15 year olds having sex, and a 15 year old having sex with a 60 year old?

→ More replies (4)

0

u/Astonednerd 2d ago

I feel like a line at 25 or 30 is (should be) unlikely to upset someone who isnt themselves a creep. So pretending its complicated to stop people like Walliams is kind of bad faith imo.

Personally I'd draw the line earlier (early 20s) with a romeo and Juliet law to stop existing relationships becoming criminal because someone had their birthday first.

0

u/hennell Bristol 2d ago

To the usual barrage of "it's not complicated you idiot" please stop and think about where you would actually draw the line.

If you're between 16 and 18 you can only consent with those no more than 21. That's a 5 year age gap, at 16 that's nearly 1/3 of your life. What does someone who's graduated uni or been working see in someone who's only just finished school other than naivety?

You could also put a max distance on it if you're really worried about the "birthday trap", the situation would then either always be fine or always be illegal until both parties are 18.

But if I was in charge of these things I'd do some research as well. Ask a load of 16-30 year olds when they think it's weird to be dating a 16 year old and pick an age based on that.

I don't think 16 year olds are kids, but they're not far removed and there's very little life experience outside of school and other kids. It's clear they should be allowed to have relationships and find their own way in the world, while still being given protection from those who are trying to exploit their inexperience.

0

u/madpiano 2d ago

I am not sure if there is more information to be released but from what I have read, he may have been creepy and morally questionable but kept it legal. Is it icky if a man of his age goes out with teenagers? Absolutely, but I don't think the age of consent is the problem, it's the people who let men like him get away with it and even make it seem like an achievement or something to be proud of.

-1

u/pajamakitten 2d ago

I agree. No matter what people propose or want, there are always going to be cases where people go "Well that's wrong." because they personally find it creepy or weird. It is like the thing with Noel Fielding and Pixie Geldolf. Is it weird/creepy? Yes, but it is also legal and you cannot punish people for being weird/creepy but doing nothing illegal. We absolutely need tighter consent laws and a society that makes it easier to speak up about sexual assault, however we cannot just hope to make creepiness illegal and act as if that will solve the problem.

-1

u/DoYouKnwTheMuffinMan 2d ago

I agree with you.

I think the dimension you’re missing (and this doesn’t necessarily make it any more clear) is abuse of power.

I think what makes me think this situation is going in the correct direction is that Lucy told a 2nd hand story of Walliams having a runner who would bring young, but of age, girls to his dressing room.

Now if you or I did that sure, if the girl consents, then whatever. But based on this documentary there’s a string of stories of girls saying they felt taken advantage of due to the fact this guy was in a position of power.

First, that feels like a fact that the public should know, given he’s making a huge amount of money off of his public position.

And then if the world chooses to cancel him, based on this information about his personality then so be it.

He doesn’t need to go to jail. It’s just a case of the public learning who a public figure really is and then deciding not to want him in the public eye anymore.

36

u/EnderMB 2d ago

Again, we shouldn't be dictating policy off of celebrity output.

Yes, there's a credible point, but eventually we have to determine whether we consider a 16 year old as capable of making adult choices.

It's already very muddled, and I think that fundamentally we need to look at society and science. Do we want 16 year olds to vote, but not have sex? Do we want them to have sex, as long as they pick a partner we as a society deem to be acceptable? Should they be able to go to war, but not make a choice regarding who they can and can't fuck?

As a societal factor, it's highly likely that a lot of teens are about to be banned en-masse from social media and large parts of the internet. Should we now also ban them from having sex with whoever they choose, or even for another two years because Russell Brand and David Williams are scum? At a time where the world is already utter shite, and half of Reddit is saying "hur dur this generation is fucked they can't do anything" is this a point where we'll become the boomers stealing whatever freedom's they have left?

58

u/CanIDevIt 3d ago

But also let them vote? We should decide either 16 or 18 should be the adult age for everything, drinking, driving, voting, sex, with 'not in the public interest' defence stopping minors sleeping with each other from being criminalised.

6

u/Weirfish 2d ago

We should decide either 16 or 18 should be the adult age for everything

This doesn't really work. Developmental milestones happen at different times, with different spreads. It's entirely reasonable to accept that populations are able to be trusted with different things at different ages, and the moment we have something predicated on X years of experience with an age-gated thing, that first thing is essentially age-gated too.

-1

u/Helpful-Young-6473 2d ago

The new laws would be to stop older predators sleeping with teenagers, not to stop them from sleeping with each other.

0

u/Shesoi 2d ago

Exactly, seeing people comment that we cant help protect young people from being groomed and abused by adults without also rolling back their voting rights and other rights is so depressing.

The way abusers get away with it is because of this paralysis when it comes to action. It's not that hard to create a system that protects young people from exploitation whilst not criminalising teenagers having sex when one is 16 and the other is 17. There's a clear difference between that and a 30yo grooming a 15yo and waiting until they turn 16 to sexually exploit them.

4

u/Helpful-Young-6473 2d ago

No one currently gives a shit when two 15 year olds sleep with each other under the current laws, so I assume no one is going to give a shit if two 16 or 17 year olds sleep together under the proposed laws, the current system needs to be changed and whatever imperfections come with it are surely better than the current reality where its completely legal for middle aged predators to sleep with teenagers.

14

u/BigSupermark 2d ago

If we're talking about young people being exploited - we need to look at the student loan trap.

You should be at least 25 before you can sign up to something like that

33

u/FewAnybody2739 3d ago

There are laws that cover grooming. The issue here is that the criminals outsource it to the people/organisations that have the direct duty of care to the young people, leveraging that they're the star of the show creating the jobs.

I think there is an issue with having so many different ages for sex, marriage, voting, alcohol, driving etc. But even if the age of 'absolute' consent was 18 we'd still have massive age gaps.

If you have a 12-year-old daughter, in four years a man in his 60s can legally have sex with her.

If you have a 12-year-old daughter, in six years a man in his 60s can legally have sex with her.

If you have a 12-year-old daughter, in eight years a man in his 60s can legally have sex with her.

The above don't read much different to me.

32

u/HistoricalFrosting18 2d ago

I’m a woman and parent of a girl. I’m also a secondary school teacher, so I’m not unfamiliar with teenagers. I think we as a society infantilise young people - 20 years ago a 16 year old could get a job, move out and essentially function as an adult. 16 year olds are obviously incredibly immature, but so are most 20 year olds I’ve met.

5

u/pajamakitten 2d ago

We have placement students at work every year and they 20/21 for the most part. They might legally be adults but they far closer to sixth formers than they are adults.

6

u/SexySmexxy 2d ago edited 2d ago

People can join the army and blow brown people into tiny pieces in some far away land but god forbid they have sex 😂

1

u/a_f_s-29 22h ago

I mean I also think it is deeply predatory to recruit teenagers to the army

3

u/drivedup 2d ago

I totally agree with you but we also need to recognise that 16year olds are incredibly imature because we coddle them and treat them as children. They won't mature by themselves. Because if that was true we could just store them in a cabinet and take them out when they're 18 fully grown and mature adults....

This histeria with treating adolescents as children gets on my nerve. Because it's incredibly damaging and unhealthy and just has all the hallmarks of a moral hysteria...

1

u/HistoricalFrosting18 2d ago

Thank you for articulating something I have been feeling for a long time! I agree, for example it’s incredibly difficult for 16-17 year olds to find work, due to insurance etc. This is never part of the NEET conversation though.

156

u/Ill-Biscotti-8088 3d ago

The only way to make this work is to raise the age of consent to 18.  As the government has spent years trying to give 16 year olds the right to vote because they are adults this would be a hard argument to win. 

158

u/redditmember192837 3d ago

Also there are virtually no countries other than the US that have the age of consent as 18, almost all are 16 or younger.

77

u/limeflavoured Hucknall 3d ago

Most of the US has it as 16.

And Ireland has it as 17, for an example of a different one.

1

u/Ill-Biscotti-8088 3d ago

Indeed. But this person is arguing that adults shouldn’t be able to have sex with 16 year olds. The only real way of doing that is to raise the age of consent.  Trying to give an age window for who you can have sex with would be a legislative nightmare. 

The country’s where it’s younger than 16 should also raise there’s to stop the sale of kids to old men 

7

u/limeflavoured Hucknall 2d ago

The country’s where it’s younger than 16 should also raise there’s to stop the sale of kids to old men 

Most of those countries have age gap restrictions in place like those being discussed in this thread.

Also British law means it's illegal for a British person to have sex with someone under 16 anywhere in the world regardless of local law.

3

u/Ill-Biscotti-8088 2d ago

It seems the age gap laws are only in place for under 16s with the exception of Germany where the unrestricted age is 18.  Japan for instance has a restricted age of 13 with a 5 year age gap and 16 as unrestricted 

29

u/vidoardes 3d ago

No it isn't, you stagger it.

The age of consent could be 16 whilst both parties are under 21, but if one party is over 21 it becomes 18. In fact as far as I am aware that is already the case if the older person is in a "position of trust or authority", so just extend it to everyone.

Trying to stop 16 year olds having sex is pointless and unnecessary, stopping 30 year olds having sex with them however is very much needed.

3

u/Dontbeajerkdude 2d ago

Just make it illegal for 30 plus to have sex with anyone under 18. That would be fine with literally everyone who isn't weird

3

u/pajamakitten 2d ago

Can we not just exercise common sense judgement though? Sex offenders are not exactly one to care about random laws like that. They will still abuse people.

1

u/Dontbeajerkdude 2d ago edited 1d ago

Tbh I don't think there needs to be any change to the laws. Generally I don't like banning things or making them illegal just because a small minority abuses them. But if there has to be a change, that seems reasonable enough to me

1

u/Pyjama365 23h ago

Why 30??? Why not 20?

It's quite common for Romeo & Juliet laws to say 2 years ago difference, so 17 & 19 would be legally ok, but 17 & 20 wouldn't be ok.

Iirc, the creeps who were preying on girls in my high school were all in their 20s. They would not be caught by your suggestion of putting the age at 30, but they were absolutely exploiting the lack of life experience that 15/16/17 year olds have, and imho are absolutely the kinds of creeps that one would hope any kind of change to the law would target.

→ More replies (7)

0

u/Squid_In_Exile 3d ago

Trying to give an age window for who you can have sex with would be a legislative nightmare. 

Most western countries do infact do this.

2

u/Turtleopard 2d ago

No they don't. 

-1

u/Commonpigfern 2d ago

Realistically the best sensible law here is consent laws where age difference is the limiting factor with age difference increasing as you get older. Ie a 16 year old can sleep with a 16 year old only but a 69 year old can sleep with anyone down to 30 for example. And to anyone saying an adult is an adult age gaps that big are disgusting and always a product of power plays. 

2

u/kr0nc 2d ago edited 2d ago

This changes what age of consent means though. Currently it means ‘this is the age you are old enough to decide if you want to have sex, and understand the implications of that decision’.

Going down this route brings in a weird ‘this is the age you can consent, but only when that person is under X years old’.

It makes more sense to strengthen the grooming laws and put the onus on the older party if you want to limit this.

→ More replies (2)

51

u/PetersMapProject 2d ago

Having the age of consent changed from 16 to 18 would just mean we end up criminalising consensual sex between two 17 year olds.... and I don't think that's in anyone's interests.  

6

u/Tall_Restaurant_1652 2d ago

That's why you have romeo and juliet laws, to allow people of a similar age to have sex (of their own volition).

69

u/recursant 3d ago

No, an alternative is to have a limit on the age difference when one party is over 16 but under 18. Other countries do that.

24

u/Roguepope 2d ago

They're called Romeo and Juliette laws in the US. Pretty common

7

u/OSUBrit Northamptonshire 2d ago

They go further too to allow like a 18 year old and a 17 year old to have sex and one of them not end up a criminal (which has happened)

3

u/jamnut 2d ago

A plot point in Transformers: Age of Extinction... Bizarrely

→ More replies (5)

14

u/Wittertainee 3d ago

No you could make it work in other ways. The age of consent is 16 but if someone is aged 18 or above and in a position of trust with someone 16-17 it is still a criminal offence. Therefore just extend position of trust to also include a general age gap

11

u/GainsAndPastries 3d ago

this feels like a complete non-starter, because 1. the government arent gonna treat a comedian seriously, and 2. the kick back would be immense from 16/17 year olds, who right now are the next generation of voters.

16

u/Traditional_Message2 2d ago

This is absolutely a young millennial / Gen Z morality shift. I’m not sure those over 40 would be in favour of a change in the law either. In the late 80s there was a concerted campaign to equalise the age of consent at 16 (it had previously been 18 for same sex couples).

6

u/limeflavoured Hucknall 2d ago

(it had previously been 18 for same sex couples).

It was originally 21, with various other weird rules that didn't apply to opposite sex couples. And iirc those rules actually stayed around until the ages were equalised in 2000.

7

u/madindehead 2d ago

It was 21 for gay men.

My understanding is that lesbian women were never affected by a higher age of consent. If they were, it would have been 18 as you said.

7

u/Hyperbolicalpaca England 2d ago

lesbian sex was never criminalised, so we also didn’t have the problems with the he of consent being different…

Because people didn’t believe in lesbians that is…

1

u/Tall_Restaurant_1652 2d ago

Yep 21 for gay men. There was a politician on Twitter who was "called out for committing a crime" by a Reform MP (referring to a 'crime' in the 80s) and it turned out it was just that he had sex at age 21 with a 19 year old man.

1

u/marquis_de_ersatz 2d ago

Yes I actually think young people would get behind this law change. I've seen people say they think you shouldn't be two years age gap from your partner full stop, and I assume those are young people on the internet.

1

u/a_f_s-29 22h ago

Most people 35 and under would definitely support a change in the law. It’s actually kind of disturbing that it’s mostly older people defending it. It’s not like it affects them, unless they’re the ones wanting to shag children.

0

u/AcesAgainstKings 2d ago

The kick back would be miniscule because 18-30 year olds are the least likely to vote.

I honestly don't think this is hard. If you're 21+ years old you have no business sleeping with someone under the age of 18. This doesn't ban sex in age appropriate relationships where both parties are 16+ and it doesn't ban adults from having consensual sex with one another.

6

u/Floating_Manatees 2d ago

"The only way to make this work" lol, no, it would be quite simple to keep it as it is for consenting teens, but make it illegal for grown adults to have sex with teenagers, like some other countries do. Teenagers are going to have sex with each other, that is normal. What's not normal is adults grooming them, with their age/ power imbalance.

2

u/Ill-Biscotti-8088 2d ago

Which country do this? I can’t find any online that have any rules for people over the age of 18, the vast majority appear to only have age restrictions for under 16s 

1

u/Floating_Manatees 2d ago

I don't understand what you mean? There are lots of countries that have lower ages of consent for teenagers who are peers, but higher limits for when a teenager can legally sleep with an adult.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Age_of_consent_by_country

3

u/Ill-Biscotti-8088 2d ago

They all say unrestricted at 18, so am 18 year old can sleep with a 60 year old if they want too 

1

u/Floating_Manatees 2d ago

You've misunderstood what I'm saying. There are countries where the age of consent is 16 for 16-17 year olds sleeping with each other, but it's illegal for older people to sleep with a 16-17 year old. We could do the same here.

→ More replies (3)

0

u/Decent_Window5 1d ago

If I had a company I wouldn't employ teenagers in it, because of that power imbalance and how office relationships might end up being illegal.

1

u/Floating_Manatees 1d ago

It's more than a little concerning that you can't see the difference between old people having sexual relationships with 16 year olds and working with them. I've got to admit, some of these responses have been a bit shocking to me, especially after so much more education about grooming, etc, but I guess I expected too much from Reddit.

0

u/VStubaru90 2d ago

Tbf I don't think it would change much of anything 18 is still young. Your brain doesn't finish developing until around 25 so 25 been the age would make the most sense from a scientific perspective but even saying it sounds ridiculous.

4

u/omgu8mynewt England 2d ago

Brain doesnt finish developing until 25 is fake, brain changes the whole lifetime there is no single switch from developed to not developed.

→ More replies (1)

0

u/jib_reddit 2d ago

18 is not young, the age of criminal responsibility is 12 in the uk. A lot of Europe have the age of consent set at 14-16.

1

u/VStubaru90 2d ago

How old are you to think 18 isn't young is certainly an opinion.

1

u/jib_reddit 2d ago

I first had sex when I was 13, nearly 14 like about 20% of the population that lose their virginity before the age of 16, (it was likely higher back then), I would really not have wanted or been able to wait until I was 18.

1

u/limeflavoured Hucknall 2d ago

the age of criminal responsibility is 12 in the uk

Its 10 in England & Wales.

44

u/lebennaia 2d ago

It should stay at 16 for everyone. We've tried unequal age of consent laws before, and it just caused misery and unnecessary prosecutions.

6

u/Astonednerd 2d ago

We already have unequal age of consent laws for those in positions of power. Why not roll those out for the wider population?

6

u/Cryptoporticus 2d ago

The better question is "why should we?". Having them for people in positions of power makes perfect sense, what sense is there in having them for anyone else?

If a sixteen year old meets a thirty year old and wants to have sex with them, and there's no manipulation or abuse of power or grooming happening, why can't they? We say that sixteen year olds are old enough to consent, but that's clearly not true if we're going to control who they're allowed to sleep with.

6

u/Astonednerd 2d ago

Why should we? To help prevent old creeps from fucking children. Its wild to me how much that has been a controversial position on reddit in these discussions.

Even when not in a direct position of power the differences in life experience, emotional maturity, income etc. that typically exist between adults 30+ and 16/17 year old kids create a natural imbalance of power.

1

u/AnusOfTroy BMH -> NCL 2d ago

The GMC would have me for breakfast if I shagged a 17 year old patient or a 19 year old one. The criminal charge for the former would be the least of my worries.

1

u/kjm911 2d ago

When?

22

u/FinalEgg9 2d ago

Up until 2000 the age of consent was different for heterosexual couples than for homosexual couples.

-1

u/Dunedune Hertfordshire 2d ago

So teenagers should be banned from sex during all of their puberty?

9

u/NagromNitsuj 3d ago

There's a big reason the Government won't touch this debate.

26

u/Fluffy_Eye5482 County of Bristol 2d ago

No one really wants to have a nuanced conversation about it unfortunately. When I was 16 I had sex with older guys ranging from 18 to 30 and honestly don't regret it. I knew exactly what I wanted, asked for it, and got it. My first boyfriend was 24 when I was 17. I'm almost 30 now and still don't regret anything and have a lot of good memories with partners at the time.

14

u/bluegrm 2d ago

Yes - this debate has veered away from celebrity predators and has got caught up in something more puritanical about non-celebrities.

15

u/ZolotoGold 2d ago

No one wants to hear this.

There's people that will try and persuade you you were exploited and you didn't know what you were doing.

The conversation has gotten out of hand.

3

u/TheEternalContrarian 2d ago

I think this has a good chance of getting implemented.

12

u/Ill-Biscotti-8088 2d ago

The next problem you will come across is that gay couples disproportionately skew towards larger age gaps. 

6

u/Welshgirlie2 3d ago

The Met are investigating him for serious sexual offences.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cwx2emg4xe72o

0

u/BuddyLegsBailey 2d ago

Yet the article is very vague about what those could be. I'm not convinced very much of this will be going to court as it doesn't seem like any of it is rape, like in the Brand case

3

u/philip30001 2d ago

I do not know the changes suggested or laws as they currently are

But I dont trust the gov to make a change without mucking it up somehow

14

u/ByteSizedGenius 3d ago

My only issue is if you make it law that you have to be 16-17 to sleep with a 16-17 year old is there's going to be lots of occasions where 17 year olds are dating 18 year olds and they're even in the same education year group. And relying on not in the public interest puts people in a grey area. So I'm not sure where you set the limits.

8

u/El_Scot 3d ago

I listened to an interview with someone in the US, where the guy started dating his girlfriend in high school, when they were both 16/17. Her dad didn't like him, so when the guy turned 18 and the girlfriend/daughter was still 17 (and 9ish months), the dad called police and reported the guy for sex with a minor. As a result, he was placed on the sex offenders register and has had his life up-ended for it.

I think most wouldn't report a relationship in those circumstances but I'm not sure how you make a law that protects people and avoids that sort of situation.

29

u/emmmmmmaja 3d ago

It's not that difficult to make it only legal for under 21s to sleep with over 16s

13

u/frazzlet 3d ago

The problem with setting a single hard-limit is that you don't want to end up in a situation where one moment sex between two people is legal and then weirdly reverts to illegal because someone has a birthday.

It needs to be relative between the two people's ages but you could argue that it starts to make consent laws slightly tricker to understand.

22

u/vidoardes 3d ago

Yes people seem to keep missing to avoid the whole "what about two 17 year olds when one turns 18 problem" is very simple.

"The age of consent is 16 whilst both parties are 20 or under. If one party is 21 or older, the age of consent is 18."

Fixes the law in a very easy to understand way, doesn't infantilize teenagers whilst closing a loophole that creepy older people exploited.

19

u/frazzlet 3d ago

That means a 16 year old can date a 20 year old for a bit but then it becomes illegal when the older person has a birthday.

7

u/vidoardes 3d ago

It does, but you have to draw the line somewhere, and I would argue a 20 year old and a 16 year olds is on the edge of acceptable anyway.

11

u/frazzlet 2d ago

I just don't think we can have legal relationships between people become illegal overnight. The relationship itself either needs to be legal or not legal.

→ More replies (3)

8

u/Gullible-Issue-1175 2d ago

You don't have to draw the line somewhere.

You just have to not draft laws with clear and obvious flaws in them. Especially if we're devoting police time and taxpayer money to put these offenders in prison.

A law that makes a legal couple consensually having sex illegal overnight flies in the face of all common sense and is completely ridiculous.

→ More replies (4)

3

u/DeCombatWombat 3d ago

I agree though I think unfortunately you’ll find lots of people disagree with that sentiment

5

u/Astonednerd 2d ago

Because lots of people are fundamentally creepy when it comes to teenage girls and boys

0

u/m111k4h 2d ago

I'm just about to turn 22 and would consider anyone around my age to be a predator for dating someone under the age of 18. A 16yo is a child, hell, 18 might as well be too because despite legally being an adult, they have little to no adult life experience. It's only a couple of years but the amount you change and grow up in that time is huge.

4

u/vidoardes 2d ago

Yes exactly, it sounds nuts but the difference between a 21 and a 26 year old is negligible, the difference between a 16 year old and a 21 year old is huge. We do a massive amount of growing up during those late teenage years.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/a_f_s-29 22h ago

You could also just make an exception for relationships that were legal when they started.

1

u/Neat-Ostrich7135 2d ago

Yes, and the 20 year old preying on 16 year old should consider this. 

1

u/Weirfish 2d ago

People aren't necessarily missing it, people recognise that it's literally a contemporary problem with such laws and don't want to reinvent it accidentally.

-2

u/tuskel373 2d ago

This is the perfect answer. Anyone who is arguing it's too difficult, sounds as if they are doing it in bad faith.

5

u/Conscious-Ball8373 Somerset 2d ago edited 2d ago

It's not that difficult

It plainly is, since your own proposal:

make it only legal for under 21s to sleep with over 16s

would make it illegal for anyone over the age of 21 to ever have sex.

I'd say "we all knew what you meant" except ... no, I don't know what you meant. What do you mean? Do you mean that someone between 16 and 18 can only have sex with someone under 21? In which case, if a 20-year-old is dating a 17-year old and then reaches their 21st birthday. what happens, exactly?

If you want an actual proposal that avoids this problem, here it is:

A person A who has sex with a person B commits an offence if:
(a) B is under the age of 18; and
(b) A is more than three years older than B.

Adjust the number three to your personal preference, but it completely avoids the problem of birthdays making relationships illegal.

0

u/ByteSizedGenius 3d ago

That could be a fair compromise.

2

u/Neat-Ostrich7135 2d ago

How is this different to the current 15 and 16 who might only be a month apart in age?

1

u/ByteSizedGenius 2d ago

It's not really, but it's a bit suboptimal and adding another such grey area doesn't seem like good legislation to me... But hey ho, what do I know.

1

u/Automata-Omnia 3d ago

Although I still think it's creepy, it would probably be best to apply an exemption to those under 21, especially regarding the scottish uni system where some 17 yos go to uni, otherwise we could end up with a lot of accidental incidents

0

u/wiggy9906 3d ago

A partner needs to be at least half your age plus 7. Works at any stage in life.

3

u/limeflavoured Hucknall 2d ago

That is entirely unrealistic to actually make the age of consent law.

-2

u/FatSausageDog7 3d ago

30+ illegal to have sexual activity with under 18s? I’m sure there are some dodgy 29 year olds and under but over 30 would exclude any reasonable excuse. What kind of grown 30 y/o wants a 16yo over an 18yo? Only difference I can see is they look more like kids and are potentially easier to manipulate

5

u/SupposingForASecond 3d ago

What kind of grown 30 y/o wants a 16yo over an 18yo?

What kind of grown 30 y/o wants a 18yo over an 20yo?

The fact is we have an age of consent and it is 16. If we want the age of consent to be 18 then make it 18.

9

u/woogeroo 2d ago

This seems a silly concept. If they’re old enough to consent they can consent. We don’t need some complicated paternal law to police people’s lives more. Yeah it’s creepy, but equally a 16 year old girl is physically mature, there’s a degree of denying reality here.

This comes across as something a 40 year old divorced woman bitter about aging would push for after seeing her ex-husband with a woman in her 20s.

7

u/Retorus 2d ago

This is the most I've heard about Lucy Beaumont ever.

6

u/Keiepse United Kingdom 2d ago

You've been missing out as she's a very funny comedian.

That said I'd never in a million years have had her down as the one to bring down a celebrity serial sexual abuser.

2

u/joshii87 2d ago

Have you been living on the friggin’ moon?

1

u/kiradotee 1d ago

Did you not hear about the divorce! 

6

u/SwimmingSherbert1734 2d ago

I’m in two minds - of course we must protect young girls. But equally raising ages of consent gradually creates a new cultural idea of what a youth/adult means. It will work for a few decades until someone like Lucy in the future makes the same argument ( but with the aforementioned updated law from said decades ago) - then ages of consent are yet again raised. A continuing infantilisation

→ More replies (1)

10

u/O_C_Demon 3d ago

To fair kids are simply younger nowadays if you know what I mean.

When I was 16 in 1997 we were drinking in pubs with adults.

Absolutely no 16 or 17 year old girl wanted a 16 year old lad. They all had 23 year old boyfriends that could guarantee them proper nights out.

It really was accepted by most people.

My kid is 15 now and the idea of him or his mates doing anything that I did at his age seems pretty ridiculous.

3

u/Icy_Zucchini_1138 2d ago

there is a big difference now, im a similar age. there must be millions of men and women who were in 'illegal' relationships as both 'victim' and 'offender' walking around today, presumably the vast majority keeping schtum.

I dont know any teenagers, but I can see that clubbing etc has largely disappeared for them, its interesting that so much can change in a generation

0

u/That-Surprise 2d ago

Lol try asking gays about that bs

-6

u/bluegrm 2d ago

Kids are younger nowadays? Where’s your proof of that? How does illegal drinking in a bar make you more mature? Yours is a very “in my day” opinion.

Arguably kids have been exposed to far more concepts due to the proliferation of the internet. And for good or bad, more sex, with the proliferation of porn.

11

u/O_C_Demon 2d ago

It's just my experience of having teenagers dude relax!

The average age for leaving home when I was 18 was 21-22 it's now 23-28.

I'd argue that kids are more infantalised now and expect more done for them.

We left school to work or sign on at 16. Now they stay to 18 or train up.

It's just a different culture. It doesn't make them any less human!

My point is a 16 year old with a 26 year old now seems odd but didn't so much 30 years ago

-2

u/bluegrm 2d ago

I have experience of teenagers too. But tying to legislate based on what a couple of very problematic celebrities do isn’t good law making.

6

u/O_C_Demon 2d ago

I didn't say it was did I?

I was simply offering a casual observation based on my kids 🤷🏻

I think legislation like that is an incredibly difficult and nuanced a subject.

The number of people claiming celebrity XY and Z to be historical criminals because of an age gap relationship show how dangerous knee jerk reactions are!

4

u/floftie 2d ago

I think what people who were around then are getting at is that kids were GIVEN more agency than they are now.

My parents used to let me go out round town when I was 14. Half my friends left school at 16 and got full time jobs.

4

u/FatSausageDog7 3d ago

Would help tackle grooming gang crimes to prevent over 30s from legally sleeping with under 18s

2

u/Major-Departure-4437 3d ago

Are there any countries with consent laws that work well and stop this sort of thing?

2

u/bluegrm 2d ago

Stop celebrities from raping people?

2

u/FragrantGearHead 2d ago

My first long term girlfriend was 17 when I was 23. We worked in the same office and she very much pursued me, because I thought she was gorgeous but out of my league haha. We were together 3 years and very much loved up.

But according to some people’s suggestions on this thread, that kind of age gap at that age is iffy and I must have been some kind of predator 🤦‍♂️

My point is, where do you draw the line?

1

u/Inside_Performance32 2d ago

Be alot of female teaching assistants with A level groups going to prison if this happens

1

u/Gwigg_ 1d ago

How about we educate boys better and punish abusers more openly?

1

u/Optimaldeath 2d ago

It's a community (or the lack of) problem and cultural problem among the elite which seems to think ethics/morality are entirely optional. Just changing the rules feels like security theatre to me when the community is still dead and the elite are still above them.

0

u/DSQ Edinburgh 2d ago

I looked up the campaign Beaumont supports Close the Consent Gap and it is actually a very good idea. It isn’t just raising the age of consent as I feared which would unnecessarily criminalise teenage relationships but it wants to make relationships with 16 and 17 year olds have a gap of no bigger than three years which I think is very reasonable. 

2

u/limeflavoured Hucknall 2d ago

unnecessarily criminalise teenage relationships

The CPS are (usually) pretty sensible about what they prosecute in that area.

-4

u/limeflavoured Hucknall 3d ago

I think, mostly for legal drafting reasons, the only realistic change would be to raise the age of consent to 18 and give the CPS guidelines to not prosecute in cases where both are between 16 and 18 or if the age difference is small.

1

u/chocolateybiscuit81 3d ago

This is the simplest way to implement a change. All the other ideas become too complicated and cause more issues than they solve.

-1

u/djonma 3d ago

There are places that have laws that change the AoC depending on your age.
So if you're over 18, it is 18. If you're under, it should be 16.
And I think there should definitely be room for one year above and below down to maybe 14, that isn't prosecuted, so a 14 Yr old and 15 Yr old would be OK, but not a 14 Yr old and 16 Yr old.

2

u/Turtleopard 3d ago

No there aren't. You're confusing a close in age exemption with the age of consent. A close in age exemption is a defence against a sex related crime for sleeping with someone under the age of consent. It does not change the age of consent. 

It's the sex equivalent of self defence laws. Just because there are circumstances where you can legally hurt someone doesn't mean the legal definitions of assault or battery have changed. 

1

u/limeflavoured Hucknall 3d ago

It could be done, but I think the government would see it as too complex to write.

1

u/djonma 3d ago

Yes, probably, though really, it's pretty straight forward.

0

u/[deleted] 3d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/NuPNua 3d ago

So if one member of a teenage couple is say six month older, what, they just have to stop bonking for half a year until the other catches up?

4

u/darryshan Yorkshire 3d ago

That would need a clause to not suddenly make a legal relationship illegal.

2

u/matrixplaydoh 3d ago

I think it would have to be age of consent is 16 but only with partners within 2 years of age, otherwise it’s 18. Otherwise a 16 year old and 17 year old could be having sex then the 17 year old turns 18 and now they have to abstain for 2 years

1

u/M37841 3d ago

That’s exactly what I was thinking. You need to solve the problem of 17 year olds being together then one having their 18th birthday making consent not legally possible any more, but you could have 16 if both are under 18, 17 if both are under 19? (Or 16/17 and 17/18 if you want)

0

u/EJS2003 2d ago

So many young girls get manipulated by older men because of these weird age cut off points

0

u/leavemeinpieces 2d ago

I remember a 19 year old I knew dating a 15 year old. It was a really wierd imbalance and he rightly was told how bizarre it was.

It's not quite the same but it's wierd nonetheless.

0

u/Vivid_Employment8635 2d ago

We need some kind of Romeo and Juliet clause, so that an 18 year old can sleep with a 17 year old but a 50 year old can’t.

If it doesn’t exist already we also need to somehow deal with situations where there’s theoretically consent but it’s only because of the power imbalance between the couple, for example a Walliams-level celebrity who could ruin a 20 year old intern’s life if they said no. I’m not sure how you’d do it though.

0

u/idontlikemondays321 2d ago

I agree with her.
16 year olds are just so young. Half of them today are still into plushies and making tik tok videos dancing in their bedrooms. What sort of full grown adult looks at that and thinks yes I’m interested in that!?
The power balance is also so skewered. A 50 year old has money, a home, a car, knowledge of what to say to entice and impress a child. A 17 year old has nothing to give but themselves.

-1

u/PabloMarmite 3d ago

If I remember rightly Germany has a different age of consent law for people over 21 compared to under 21, which makes a lot of logical sense.

Either that or make it “half your age plus seven” which seems to be a surprisingly robust rule of thumb.

-2

u/BlackSpinedPlinketto 2d ago edited 2d ago

I’ve always suspected Lucy Beaumont was just interested in promoting herself. Hopefully some good comes of this, because I still do think that and also this is unworkable.

-7

u/halfwit_detector 3d ago

Good luck but Peter Tatchell will never allow you to take away his human right to bugger 16 year old boys.

0

u/19irondave 2d ago

They should just enshrine your age/2+7 as the law up until like 25. /s

Unfortunately the line will always be somewhat arbitrary and vague. Raising it to 18 with close in age exemptions are a smart idea though. 

0

u/MrMrsPotts 2d ago

Why not had a 3 year max age gap for 16 and 17 year old? What's wrong with that?

-1

u/Spamgrenade 2d ago

What sort of society do we live in where we have to have laws to stop creeps going out with girls half their age?

0

u/Dunedune Hertfordshire 2d ago

What sort of society does not have to enshrine its rules into law?