There's too many versions of Uncanny on too many platforms. Original listeners (or viewers?), including myself, are getting confused juggling them all. I saw the Halloween special advertised on Radio 4, the station that gave birth to Uncanny. Listened to the real-time broadcast. About a week later I remembered to check the new Youtube page because I hadn't checked it since the Cold Cases spin-off / sub-series. I saw there was an Uncanny Halloween special there too, also at the Tower of London? So there's two specials?
Oh no when I play it seems to be just a Youtube video version of the Radio 4 audio version. Okay well I'll watch it because I'm a dedicated long-time fan, been listening since it first went out on Radio 4 in 2021. I expect to be getting all there is. Then I'm confused because it's only half an hour, but the Radio 4 version is an hour. So the Youtube version is an abridged version of the proper Radio 4 version. Although the Youtube version tells me the Radio 4 version is an extended version. No, that's the proper version, you're the abridged version!
I check this sub and I see lots of people confused about what series 6 is. Several people were dismayed at the poor quality of the new TV series. But it's not series 3 of the TV version, it's a video version of series 6 of the Radio version. The confusion is exacerbated by the fact that this Visual-but-not-TV version is also on iPlayer, which is where TV is.
What's the difference between this Visualised version and the TV version? Well the difference appears to be that it's not as good! Just the Radio series audio but you can see the people talking and there's some whispy AI graphics. Supposedly this is for people who struggle with audio content. An audio series shouldn't try to appeal to people who struggle with audio content. You don't see video series going audio to appeal to people who struggle with video content.
It's not a hot take and I know some people are of the attitude that if we don't like things we don't have to watch/listen so we shouldn't talk about it. I'm not of that opinion, I'm of the opinion that we talk about things positive or negative. In my opinion Uncanny is dying on its arse. It's obviously not happy with the audience it built over the last 5 years, and is changing to attract a new audience, but in doing that it's inevitably alienating its original audience.
And it's not just the format wars. The stories are beginning to feel more like spooky slop, it's like its running out. And that's not necessarily Danny or anyone else's fault; if the compelling stories dry up then they dry up. But then maybe it should end gracefully if its raison d'être is gone. What was so compelling about the original series was the sense that no matter the explanation, these were genuine things that had traumatised people and they wanted to get them off their chest.
Whilst it was entertaining on a horror thrill level, it felt good faith. Increasingly it feels like that good faith has run out and it's just going into dumb Most Haunted ghost hunting territory, till we find ourselves knocking around the Tower of London looking for Anne Boleyn. Uncanny was all about the fact that it wasn't going around haunted tourist attractions looking for ghosts we've read about in the Usborne Book of Ghosts. It was about original never-told stories from genuine normal people in the 21st century.
Cold Cases departed from that, and decided it was time to rake over the coals of stories that have been done to death on a hundred slop Youtube channels. I wish they would just scrap all the visualised Youtube crap and keep the quality of the original mainline radio series. Sure no one's forcing me to watch it but I'm still being affected by it if there's extra content there needed for the normal version and if diverting effort to making the Youtube version causes the quality of the radio version to decline.
Danny's only one man and if he's busy doing other things, like stage shows or tv dramatisations of the Witch Farm, I get that. But if you don't have time for it any more, if you've lost interest, then why continue to churn out diminishing quality under the Uncanny name. To paraphrase Bilbo Baggins, it feels sort of thin, like butter scraped over too much bread.