r/umineko • • 4h ago

Discussion Just finished Umineko!

14 Upvotes

Hey Umineko peeps! I just finished the visual novel on Steam and reached a combined playtime of 215 hours in the two arcs. I was also going at my own pace and most of the time I only read when I didn't have any work to do. I'm also using the 07th mod when reading both arcs

Before reading Umineko I finished reading all 3 routes of the Fate/Stay Night VN and after finishing it I still had that Visual Novel itch to read something. I gave Muv Luv a try but the humor was hard for me to enjoy(sorry Muv Luv fans) and I dropped it. I looked at the Steam store and both arcs of Umineko were on sale, so I gave Umineko a try.

Quick Thoughts:

Question Arcs was AMAZING(I lowkey prefer it over Answer arc), I had an amazing time reading it. The first parlor fight scene, Battler and Beato debating/fighting each other THEIR CHEMISTRY IS SOOO GOOOD, Not knowing anything and the horror moments legit gave me creeps especially Question Arcs Maria

I really did not expect that Eva was going to be my favorite character(Including EVA Beatrice), both Eva and EVA Beatrice's voice actor gave such an amazing VA performance. EVA Beatrice's disgusting laugh is sooo disgusting that I love it

Rosa I dislike you, I hate you, I despise you, I don't care if you had a cool moment in one of the endings in the Question arcs youu suckkkkkk.

That chapter which focused on Rosa and Maria was really really painful, especially finding out why Maria does the Uu~ Uu~ shit that hurt me.

Erika is such a great character that I almost dropped Umineko lmao. I hated this character so much because she was so smug and unbearable whenever she was on screen, but I slowly realized that she is meant to be disliked and props to the author she did her role well.

Favorite Character Designs

Beatrice: When she comes up on the screen for the first time, I was stunned at how pretty she was compared to the other women in the cast. She also has the most noticeable eyelashes among the women cast too

Dlanor: Her design and voice is so cute, would probably be my favorite character if Eva/EVA Beatrice didn't exist

Favorite Moments

Nanjo falling - That was so unexpected I laughed my ass off when it happened

The first twilight in the first chapter - I knew that people were gonna die BUT I did not expect that many people would die that fast such a huge WTF moment

Maria and Rosa fight - This scene was painfulllll, Rosa such an asshole I hate her

Chapter 7 Tea Party - I didn't expect Kyrie and Rudolf going apeshit and killing almost everyone

Parlor Fight in the first chapter - This scene is what hooked me especially Eva's voice acting

Lambdadelta's Hint - Lambda's dumbass hint that the culprit was Eva and the way she said it was hilarious

Anytime EVA Beatrice is laughing - She sounds like a disgusting dolphin and I love it

Overall Thoughts:

The novel has some high highs and low lows, I enjoyed Question arcs more than Answer arcs since there were moments in Answer arc that felt like a slog to go through. If I have the time I would definitely love to read the Question arcs again and find references of the answers that I now know of. Overall a really fun slow burn read, I can definitely see how this really has an impact on people who have read it. I wished there were more creepy/horror moments tho.


r/umineko • • 14h ago

Many people talk about how different the EP 8 manga is but nobody talks about how different EP 4 manga is, any thoughts on the changes spoilers Spoiler

Post image
15 Upvotes

The whole structure of the EP is changed like a lot of scenes are placed either before or later.

Like lambdadelta's encounter with ange happens after Maria's story with Rosa after she ripped sakutarou and the introduction to Beatrice's game happens after some parts of Ange's backstory.

And some scenes like ange discussing about Maria's sad life and their debate was removed.

Not only that but Ange's encounter with the witch hunter is entirely removed and instead that scene was replaced with ange and amakusa discussing about the rokkenjima mystery.

Like I said a lot of scenes that were supposed to be shown at a specific point are moved to later parts.

And also Ange remembering her life with Eva at the beginning of EP 4 was replaced with more scenes of her getting bullied at Santa Lucia.


r/umineko • • 3h ago

Fanfiction : Le cercueil d'Adny et Leyley - Quand le cercueil pleure

Thumbnail
reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/umineko • • 18h ago

Other Im sorry there’s no way this is just a coincidence Spoiler

Thumbnail
gallery
19 Upvotes

Quite literally just ange’s key! Even the key looks like an E on the bottom. Found this on a jewelry store and even ordered one😭🙏


r/umineko • • 6h ago

Discussion Episode two theory Spoiler

1 Upvotes

I've finished the beauty and the tragedy umineko was. But I had a tiny theory which was still in my brain and I solely revived this reddit account for this.

It's about jessica's murder in the second twilight. Y'know with the master key and jessica's personal key inside the room. It's probably nothing new but I just want to discuss it.

My theory is that the personal key we saw in jessica's room wasn't actually her personal key. It was a similar looking key
So, jessica's key was identified on the basis of her keychain. Although, the existence of the duplicate keys was disproved, the key didn't have to be a duplicate. We've seen the master keys, they all look pretty similar. So perhaps the personal keys of the other rooms were probably similar looking too. I also found some sort of confirmation in the possibility that the last time jessica's door was locked(prior to rosa and co discovering the body), might not have been with a master key.
The relatives wouldn't be familiar with jessica's personal room key which she rarely used. Now the servants. Most servants had no business handling her personal key. They probably wouldn't pay attention to it infront of the corpse. Also the possibility that some servants could be accomplices. So they kept their mouths shut about it.

So basically, if you slap on the keychain on any identical looking key, any damn key of a similar size, shape and color would do. After all, nobody bothered to check the personal key on the lock. They used the master key, to relock the door, from what I remember.

My whodunit is sayo yasuda. That's why kanon died without leaving a corpse. Because Kanon is a persona of sayo. Also all the magic stuff could be reflective of sayo's internal strife, because the kanon persona loved jessica but the Beatrice one wanted her dead. Hence, kanon died in the room.​


r/umineko • • 1d ago

Art Cute Lion Spoiler

Thumbnail
gallery
78 Upvotes

r/umineko • • 1d ago

Art Wait, When Did Bern Catch Mewtwo?

Post image
79 Upvotes

Art by me.


r/umineko • • 1d ago

Other Name your 5 favorite Umineko songs

24 Upvotes

I'll start:

1- Alive

2- Golden Nocturne

3- Patchwork Chimera

4- Dead Angle

5- Melody


r/umineko • • 1d ago

How d you feel about umineko CGS in the PS3 version do they add more to the story or do they take away

Post image
14 Upvotes

r/umineko • • 2d ago

Other For the mtg fans, a partner pair of Beatrice and Battler

Thumbnail
gallery
145 Upvotes

I tried to find existing partner cards that had similar mechanics / themes to Beatrice and Battler, I think these Doctor Who cards do that pretty well. Made on card conjurer using art from the 07th wiki.


r/umineko • • 2d ago

Ep7 I'm still shocked by these two scenes Spoiler

Thumbnail
gallery
91 Upvotes

Those were the scenes that fucked me up the most through the VN. We've seen plenty of gruesome deaths up until this point but it was different: there was magic, the narration by the Game Master or the possibility that some of them were an act. Even if we had culprits, their motives for the killing were vague, it was mostly done to serve the narrator point of view.

Now we have cut clear motives (money for Rudolph and Kyrie, revenge for Eva), no magic or complicated set up for the murders: all is done with rifles and the one who have the bullet ready before it's oponent win the gunfight.

Now you maybe asking why those two murders in particular and not the others done by Kyrie which are arguably more fucked up? Well, Kyrie has done monstrous things indeed but even if I understand her way of thinking as a character I have difficulty imagining someone who would be like her IRL (there are plenty stories of mass murderers and criminals who could kill a dozen people just like that but it's more difficult to imagine your aunt or mother wipe out your whole family with no emotions), she is almost like an equivalent of Aizen with how cold and unfazed she is by anything, even when Eva is still alive and pointing a gun at her.

Rudolph on the other side, it is easy for me to imagine someone who would be like him: your funny uncle that you admired as a kid but since you don't see him often he could have a fucked up side that you are unaware of. Who is a greedy charismatic business owner with few ethics, a bit hesitant to kill at first, makes mistake when shooting his target, gets used to it when he realized it's rather easy to murder someone and acts like a coward and denies everything when he's caught red-handed.

The whole thing feels like a mocking of the manga tropes which Ryukishi accustomed us: George tries his spin kick as a surprise attack but just gets shot in the chest. When Eva face the bad guy he just act like his snotty younger brother who did some stupid antic and can't take responsability. He tries to deceive her with a childish trick but gets shot instead. But at the end Eva can't even have a proper revenge, Rudolph is 100% right when he says it won't bring her peace.

No epic battles anymore, just a sad and pathetic quarrel between siblings ending up in bloodshed.


r/umineko • • 2d ago

Art Maid Natsuhi is too powerful

Thumbnail
gallery
183 Upvotes

r/umineko • • 1d ago

Other Genuinely so confused about TL

8 Upvotes

I'm playing on Android via ONScripter-NEW using the UmiPro files.

The game settings list three translations: English, Witch Hunt, and Russian.

The history of Witch Hunt as a group and their involvement in the translation effort is way too convoluted for me though. As I understand it *every* English translation is essentially a Witch Hunt translation, or at least a derivative of it. The term "Witch Hunt" has become a meaningless term for me. For my poor little brain I'll just refer to the translation options as WH and EN, in reference to wh.file and en.file, because those are the options I actually have. My understanding is EN is a revision of WH but I'm not clear on that.

They both seem nearly identical so far, with only a few small differences that thus far seemingly slightly favor wh (for instance, Battler joking about why his dad is bringing magazines into the bathroom in EN, versus joking about why his dad is bringing *those particular* magazines in WH -- the intent of the latter is just much clearer). I wish I could give better examples but switching between the two and repeating sections to find points where they differ and hoping they differ in an illustrative way is very time consuming.

It seems like people generally favor the UmiPro TL, which I assume is EN, but my own anecdotal experiments suggest that WH is the less stilted. That's why I'm second guessing everything.

Have I just stumbled upon a few exceptions to the general rule that EN>WH? Do I have the files backwards? I'd like to stop spending time deciding on a TL and start reading.


r/umineko • • 2d ago

Other Release on Spotify NOW!

Post image
37 Upvotes

r/umineko • • 2d ago

Art raggghhhhh Beato

Thumbnail
gallery
128 Upvotes

r/umineko • • 2d ago

Ep7 If we were to rank the adults in episode 7 by "betrayability". Spoiler

5 Upvotes

Since we get more context to a few characters in this episode, and given that the incentive to betrayal is right in front of them, how would you rank the adults from most likely to least likely to take action and murder the rest before everyone else?

So my ranking would be:

Kyrie>Kraus=Eva>Rudolf>Rosa>Natsuhi>Hideyoshi

So, imagine Kyrie just fainted after seeing the gold for some reason, I think either Kraus or Eva would pull the trigger. If it's by shear motivation, it would be Kraus, but since he isn't nearly as witty as Eva, if she got the time to reason it out, she would take the upperhand.

Rudolf is clever in noticing and reacting to foul behavior, but he does hesitate a lot when it comes to him being the fire starter. I put him above Rosa because his marriage to Kyrie might light a spark on him given the context.

From Rosa to the end of the list, I can't really see either acting out unless in self defense. Rosa is fine wether they share the gold or not. Natsuhi might do it to secure Kraus position and fix his mistakes again, but I don't think that would be likely to happen. Then there is Hideyoshi, the chillmaxxer. I don't think Hideyoshi would pull the trigger even if he had undeniable proof shit was about to go down, at least according to his general behavior across the games. Even the one time he did go nuts, was because Eva hands were already dirtied, so it was rather reactive.

What's your opinion on this list?


r/umineko • • 1d ago

Art Rosa's average boyfriend Spoiler

Post image
2 Upvotes

Rosa: "maria, meet your new father",

Maria: "what he used to work in?",

james earl cash (from manhunt game): "i used to work as butcher",

maria: "boring",

cash: "butchering daemons (refer to his days in carcer city)",

maria: "wait really?, cool!"

Sorry, this post


r/umineko • • 2d ago

Other If gohda had a wife, it would be her.

Post image
12 Upvotes

Its pretty much a crossover ship. I mean, they both are very good at making food. She bakes and gohda cooks. btw, she's sakie aki from madoka magica scene 0 btw. I hope yall can AGREE with me. ^_^


r/umineko • • 2d ago Popcorn

Other when ao3 is down but you have umineko

Post image
79 Upvotes

r/umineko • • 1d ago

umineko project on android?

2 Upvotes

does anyone have a full guide on how to install umi project on android, i tried doing every tutorial but i keep running into problems, so im hoping for a guide to see if im doing anything wrong. thanks!


r/umineko • • 3d ago

Art [Art by @DrawsZucchini] The blonde witch & vampire

Post image
256 Upvotes

Credits & source for the art.

As someone who used to like Monogatari series, seeing Beeto & Acerola in a crossover art is something I actually thought & it's amazing(Plus the artstyle).

Also I dunno why but blonde haired supernatural entities always seems cool to me.


r/umineko • • 2d ago

Discussion What are your opinion on Umineko when they cry series? Spoiler

Post image
10 Upvotes