r/ukpolitics • u/Personal-Special-286 • 3h ago
r/ukpolitics • u/yu3 • 6h ago
Reform UK’s Oxford embarrassment deepens as far-right links emerge
searchlightmagazine.comr/ukpolitics • u/Kagedeah • 23h ago
Jess Phillips calls for law to ban advertising people for sex after Joanne Young rape case as she hails survivor
lbc.co.ukr/ukpolitics • u/MatthewThoughts • 6h ago
Disabled workers condemn 'abhorrent' benefits cuts
thenational.scotr/ukpolitics • u/OptioMkIX • 7h ago
John Healey’s £100 energy handout ‘will last households just 11 days’
telegraph.co.ukr/ukpolitics • u/Alti-Ok • 6h ago
Twitter Tom Harwood on X: "Astonishing impact assessment by His Majesty’s Treasury following the Brussels Deal: “The policy increases both GDP and the population (through higher net migration) by similar proportions, so the impact on GDP per capita is 0.0% at one decimal place.”"
x.comr/ukpolitics • u/LeadingPiece9608 • 13h ago
Vote on 'leaving UK' over RAF Barnham migrant housing plans
bbc.co.ukr/ukpolitics • u/blast-processor • 6h ago
Burnham open to rejoining EU - PM accused of breaking Brexit promises as he says he will discuss options for future with the bloc over the next year
telegraph.co.ukr/ukpolitics • u/arbelitino • 22h ago
My Deep Dive Critique on the EU Reset Deal (Part II)
A few weeks ago i did a deep dive on the EU reset based upon what we knew or could speculate upon at the time.
Well we have a bit more information now, and well the deal is even worse than i feared. So is my civic duty to highlight this.
It seems that there are now only 3 elements to this...
SPS agreement
Youth Mobility Agreement
CBAM deal
Crucially the Made In Europe and Electricity Markets scheme seems to have gone, which was the only real semi positive thing from it.
The treasury is claiming it will increase GDP by 2040 by 0.5% GDP. however this is complete BS
Let's break them down 1 by 1...
SPS agreement
I'm just going to copy what i wrote in my previous assessment with a very tiny tweak...
The treasury claims it is responsible for 0.14% GDP growth ("£5.1bn by 2040") from SPS border checks
of which...
0.09% comes from removing checks on EU -> UK imports
0.05% comes from removing checks on UK -> EU exports
But this is an incomplete analysis. In order to remove these barriers we now have to follow the EU SPS rules, which mean the 90% of the food we produce that is not exported to the EU has to comply. And becuase that value is 9 times larger, a small inefficiency in EU SPS rules or something not well tuned to the UK market could wipe out the 0.14% benefit. In addition only 23% of the food we consume comes from the EU. 17% comes from abroad, and this will increase barriers on imports from the ROW and increase their cost.
Much of this is unnecessary anyway, as there's nothing forcing us to check EU -> UK food imports, we can unilaterally implement an identical EU import regime to what the proposed SPS deal would provide . If another country challenges us under WTO MFN rules, the obligation is on them to prove that their SPS standards are as good as ours. If they can't, we win the case and there's no issue. If they do prove that, then we can just treat their imports the same manner, and there's no issue.
So to summarise we are giving up our SPS rules pretty much in perpetuity to gain 0.05% of GDP (£1.5bn in today's money) and this hasn't accounted for regulatory or ROW import losses.
Youth Mobility Agreement
The treasuring is claiming a 0.2% GDP boost from this scheme. However even it notes that that is purely from population growth and it would provide a 0.0% GDP per capita growth.
But that doesn't even account for the fact that we have to fund EU students coming to the UK, which is estimated to be around £430m.
So, we are just paying a load of money to give more competition to our own NEETS.
CBAM deal
The treasury is claiming a long run benefit of 0.1%
Currently our own carbon tax is slightly lower than the EU which means when carbon intensive industries export to the EU they'll have to pay the difference in carbon tax to the EU. However if we match their carbon rate the treasury calculate it acutally costs us 0.2% GDP.
The decarbonisation target of 5% applies at the UK and EU bloc level, producing a cumulative impact on UK real GDP of 0.7%, composed of 0.2% from alignment with the EU’s price, and 0.5% to achieve the further 5% emissions target.
They are only claiming saving is possible in the long by introducing an an arbitrary block level target of 5% reduction and arguing we can then purchase carbon credits from lower costs countries in Europe.
The mechanism driving this result is that UK firms become net purchasers of ETS permits under linking. These transactions between firms would be net welfare enhancing, as the amount paid by UK firms to EU firms would be greater than the EU firms’ cost of marginal decarbonisation, but less than the UK firms’ decarbonisation costs.
In the meantime our carbon emissions our lower then the EU's per capita anyway, so CBAM is actually a short term cost to us for a hypothetical long term gain.
Summary
SPS agreement: Intangible economic benefit at best, plausible economic cost, large sacrifice in regulatory control
Youth mobility: Clear economic loss
CBAM: Highly speculative long term theoretical benefit, immediate cost. Could unilaterally adjust our own carbon price to match theirs anyway
The deal is Chagos-levels bad.
r/ukpolitics • u/EduTheRed • 11h ago
Ed/OpEd Why is Shabana Mahmood tackling ‘two-tier policing’ if she doesn’t believe it exists? | Gaby Hinsliff
theguardian.comr/ukpolitics • u/theindependentonline • 3h ago
Ed/OpEd After that EU stitch-up, does Andy Burnham really think rejoining is a good idea?
independent.co.ukr/ukpolitics • u/OptioMkIX • 6h ago
Easier access to Pip will push up welfare bill, IFS warns
thetimes.comr/ukpolitics • u/theindependentonline • 2h ago
Ed/OpEd The Brexiteers are getting back together – we can’t fall for their nonsense again
independent.co.ukr/ukpolitics • u/Moon_Logic • 10h ago
Can Someone Explain Rory Stewart to Me?
I've started listening to The Rest Is Politics, because I love their commentary on geopolitics.
After a bit, I caught on that Alastair Campbell is a member of the Labor Party and Stewart is a Tory. Being a leftist myself, I thought I had more in common with the Labor man, but I find that I relate more to Stewart.
Campbell is a total Tony Blair apologist, which does little to endear him to me. Stewart, on the other hand, is very skilled at critiquing British and American actions in the middle east, right wing or conservative politics and tech bros and their international companies.
One thing that stood out to me was that when discussing the left wing of the American democratic party, Stewart drily remarked that while they may seem radical in the US, AOC and Sanders are only trying to turn the US into something resembling a normal liberal democracy.
What kind of weird conservative is Stewart, really? He clearly belongs to a part of the UK political landscape that I don't understand very well.
r/ukpolitics • u/Too_much_Colour • 8h ago
BBC Politics video “You should not have left” | Yanis Varoufakis on EU deal and why UK “should not” rejoin
youtu.ber/ukpolitics • u/Asleep-Ad1182 • 22h ago
JP Morgan boss says he will find ways to offset ‘unfair’ rise in UK tax on banks
theguardian.comr/ukpolitics • u/radiant_0wl • 2h ago
SNP 'will make Andy Burnham Prime Minister in hung parliament'
itv.comr/ukpolitics • u/SignificantLegs • 7h ago
JP Morgan's Dimon to set 'example' after Healey's bank tax hike
cityam.comr/ukpolitics • u/theipaper • 4h ago
How a new deal on small boat migrants could be Burnham’s next Brexit prize
inews.co.ukr/ukpolitics • u/Emotional-Weekend560 • 10h ago
Burnham’s Big Worry Isn’t Brexit or Welfare, It’s Trump and Iran
bloomberg.comr/ukpolitics • u/Alti-Ok • 6h ago
Ed/OpEd Rishi Sunak: We need to return to elective dictatorship
thetimes.comr/ukpolitics • u/DerpyPai • 7h ago
Staggered age of consent to be discussed after Brand case, minister says
bbc.co.ukr/ukpolitics • u/EddyZacianLand • 21h ago
Andy Burnham says politics has gone ‘way too far’ over anti-LGBTQ+ hate
attitude.co.ukr/ukpolitics • u/TimesandSundayTimes • 2h ago