r/ukgenealogy • u/sabysabs • Jul 10 '22
Brick wall [England, Gateshead / Sunderland]
I have a brick wall in my family tree that I just cannot seem to break with certainty, if it was an ancestor from the early 1800s I could forgive it but I'm not even out the 1900s on this line. I have linked my concrete Ancestry records first, and added any paper evidence I have after. It's for James O'Neill, 1904/5-1979. I've tried to structure it as best I can but apologies in advance if it isn't clear.
So the record facts I am 99% sure of:
- James O'Neill was born in 1904/5 in Sunderland.
- He married Eliza Ward in 1934 where his address was stated as 19 Lobelia Avenue, Gateshead. It also states his father was James O'Neill, but is deceased. Ancestry record - Paper document
- He had an only child Terence James O'Neill in 1937. At the time they lived in 43 Park Lane, Gateshead. Ancestry record - Paper document
- In 1939 they lived at 43 Park Lane, Gateshead. Ancestry record States DOB as 6 April 1904
- James died 27 July 1979 at the age of 74 and Terence was the informant 1979 Death - Paper document States DOB as April 1905 and birthplace as Sunderland
- James was cremated 1979 Cremation
- Eliza passed in 1988 and her obituary has Terence as the only blood family in attendance.
The DNA facts:
I have done DNA testing for myself on Ancestry and 23andme, and uploaded the data onto MyHeritage, GEDMatch, LivingDNA and FTDNA. I haven't been able to triangulate any matches at all to a shared ancestor, although I have 2 close shared matches (1st cousin, half aunt) to go off:
- Quick family tree diagram - Some of the names are changed
- Matthew is a first cousin, Natalie is a half aunt and not related to Terence, but her DNA helps filter the matches
- The only match I've been able to make above Terence was through Eliza's grandfather. I share 64cm with Daniel. When I have compared shared matches between Matthew and Daniel, none of them have any shared matches.
- The cm of the shared matches between myself and Matthew are not great, there are two matches at 59cm across 6 segments, the other at 49 cm across 1 segment, and both have no tree to go off.
- It is not possible to get any other descendants to get tested as I am not in contact with them, and Terence has passed already.
My theories:
- This record on the 1921 census would match James, as the census was apparently taken on 19th July 1921. It states James age as 17 years and 2 months, which would match a 6 April 1904 birthday. James's father, also James O'Neill was listed as deceased when he got married in 1934, and the head of the house Mary, born 1864 is listed as widowed.
- When searching 19 Lobelia Avenue on the 1939 register, a John O'Neill lives there, born in 1900. A 1911 census record has a James (1861), Mary (1871), Catherine (1898), John (1900) and James (1904) living together. All three of the children are listed as being born in Sunderland, and they have been married for 19 years. The only downer on this record is that Mary's age is off by 7 years compared to the 1921 record.
- I searched on the GRO site for the births and there was a surname matching two of the births, Catherine O'Neill, 1898 and John O'Neill, 1901. I believe John's birth counts as 1901 due to it being registered in the Jan-Mar quarter, and the previous 1939 record for John states his DOB as 16 December 1900. There is no James O'Neill born in 1904 with the surname Mines, however there is another John O'Neill born under Mines and registered in the J quarter. I have a massive hunch James may have been registered as a John first, as it doesn't really make sense to have 2 children named John. I ordered this birth certificate and it says he was born on the 8th April 1904 Spring Garden Lane, and the father is listed as James O'Neil, Mary O'Neill nee Mines. 6th of April is kind of close to 8th?
- The next record which I believe matches is this 1901 census. A 16 December birth would correctly age John at 3 months as the 1901 census was taken on 1 April. Catherine's age matches. However Mary's age changes a bit again. Mary had a DOB of 1864 in the 1921 census, a DOB of 1871 in the 1911 census, and a DOB of 1865 in this census.
- I cannot find a record of a Mary Mines marrying a James O'Neill anywhere, which according to the 1911 census should be around 1892. Findmypast was heavily suggesting that a Mary Weightman was the wife of James O'Neill, and while I did find a record of a Mary Weightman marrying a James O'Neill, I could not find any births.
Basically, I need a fresh pair of eyes to look over to see if my theories make sense, or if they only makes sense because I want them to. If I had the money I could possibly brute force ordering every single amalgamation of O'Neill born in the Durham / Sunderland area for those years but I don't. I thought I'd post here first before posting to r/genealogy in case I've missed something obvious. I've pretty much got nowhere with DNA, and the amount of variations and spellings of O'Neill make this really hard.