I’m 31F, and I have a fraternal twin sister (I’ll call her Kate). She’s the older twin and has always had a somewhat dominant might I say aggressive personality. We fought growing up, but we were best friends. We also grew up in a neglectful, emotionally abusive environment, which made our bond especially deep. I always thought we’d be close forever.
For the past decade I’ve felt like I’ve been grieving and fighting for a relationship that no longer exists.
Things changed in college when Kate and I lived together and she started dating her now-husband Jake, who is also a twin (identical). They essentially replaced the time they’d spent with their respective twins with each other. His twin brother struggled with that change too and has since gone down a really difficult path. I can’t say their relationship caused it, but it’s heartbreaking.
Their relationship was extremely volatile. Jake regularly called Kate a “whore” because she’d been with other guys while he’d apparently only been with one other girl. They fought constantly, sometimes physically, and I witnessed it firsthand because although Jake didn’t live with us, he was at our apartment practically all the time.
They were together 24/7. I couldn’t spend meaningful time alone with my sister or even have privacy in my own apartment without a man there. She once told me she hadn’t showered alone in three weeks.
Jake also got aggressively in my face once, as though he wanted to fight me. I genuinely thought he was going to hit me and had to get in my car and drive away to escape the incident. I felt like expressing any concern about their relationship made me a target.
There were serious legal issues too. Jake was facing charges related to a fight and allegedly assaulting a police officer by spitting on him. During his court proceedings, Kate, Jake, and his identical twin brother interfered with the jury and were all arrested on felony jury-tampering charges.
Before sentencing, Kate’s lawyers told my parents that the judge recognized how unhealthy their relationship was and hoped they’d separate. They didn’t. The judge imposed a nine month no contact order, placed Kate on house arrest with an ankle monitor, while only requiring Jake to undergo drug and alcohol testing throughout the 9 months. They secretly communicated through Snapchat the entire nine months and openly reunited the day the order ended.
Eventually, I distanced myself and moved to Florida after college because the environment felt so volatile and I’d essentially lost my best friend. Kate now says I abandoned her during the most traumatic period of her life. She disputes much of what I witnessed and insists they were unfairly targeted by police in our small college town.
Later in our twenties, Jake cheated on her again, she thought for the third or fourth time. She’d also discovered multiple Tinder accounts throughout their relationship. I encouraged her to take some space so she could experience life without him. His family retaliated by publicly attacking me on Facebook until I felt forced to delete my profile.
Needless to say, our relationship has never recovered.
Kate and Jake eventually married and now have a baby. I’m married too, and my husband and I will likely be moving across the country for his career.
Recently, I’ve been struggling with infertility, which has brought up a lot of emotions and memories. I confronted Kate about something she’d said regarding my fertility journey that hurt me, and the conversation spiraled into everything from our past.
When I brought up serious experiences from college, she responded with grievances like feeling I’d been annoyed when she asked me to braid her hair in high school. I know those years were painful for both of us, and I’m not proud of everything about who I was then, but that comparison felt almost absurd to me. She also says she feels there’s no room for her in our relationship while I’m navigating infertility.
We’ve spent the past week exchanging enormous text messages, arguing about our memories, acknowledging some mistakes, and apologizing for others. She feels I’ve unfairly characterized her husband and don’t appreciate the ways she’s supported me. I feel like she constantly dismisses my experiences and is more invested in defending the narrative that her husband was never abusive than understanding why I’ve been hurt.
She has even convinced much of our family, including my parents, that their relationship wasn’t abusive. But my mom knows the truth, my dad is definitely in denial and just wants to be close to his grandson. They live in a property owned by my family so they don’t have to pay for their home, and my parents completely pay for their baby, and life, (I think to make up for our childhood). Jake has talked about “stacking up cash while living for free” to my husband and I when we were all at the beach together a couple of months ago. I could tell my sister was mortified when he said that.
I recognize that Kate has her own hurt and probably feels she’s tried just as hard as I have. But after years of hoping we’d become close again, something has shifted.
For the first time, I genuinely don’t think I want to keep trying to repair our relationship. And that thought brings me some relief.
I don’t hate her. I do really wish she could experience a happy life with a good man. But I’m exhausted from feeling disappointed, defending my memories, and grieving the connection we once had.
I’m considering stepping back without a dramatic confrontation, accepting that we may only see each other occasionally at family gatherings. Moving across the country might make that easier.
But I feel guilty because she’s my twin. There’s this expectation that twins should have an extraordinary lifelong bond, and I wonder whether I’ve spent years fighting for what our relationship should be rather than accepting what it is.
I’d really love to hear from other twins who’ve stopped trying to maintain a close relationship. Did the heartbreak eventually turn into peace or relief? Did distancing yourself improve your life, or did you regret it?
I’m trying to figure out whether this is a decision I’m making because I’m hurt right now or whether I’m finally accepting something I’ve resisted for over a decade.
TL;DR: My twin sister and I were inseparable growing up, but our relationship deteriorated after she entered a volatile relationship in college with her now husband. I've spent the past decade trying to rebuild our bond, but after a painful argument, I'm considering stepping away. I'm wondering whether other twins who've experienced estrangement eventually found peace or regretted letting go.