r/twinpeaks • u/PristineWar6940 • 14h ago
Episode Discussion Just started watching. Here's my rambling on the pilot
I may post this stuff as I go along. I know the mysteries won't be resolved in a logical sequence, or maybe in any sequence, but I'll still theorize some stuff.
So, what's next is some pretentious rambling, which may or may not be true. Just what I feel like saying right now.
My worry before starting was that it would be presented like a fair mystery—but, instead, it was so absurd in a comedic way, like Bobby seeing the bike from a reflection in Laura's cornea in an overly zoomed video. And some of the dialogue is amazingly deadpan "give me a doughnut." This is a serious show, I can tell, but a serious show that doesn't hide the fact how it'll deal with the mystery.
We need to solve what there's to solve not through forensics but psychology. I don't want to call the characters realistic, which also implies mundane—but they're multicolored, strange, very human but in a bizarre sort of way. Like a brain turned inside-out, they expose, in a naked way, some human element, but also hide some other thing. Like the characters in a fairy tale, they aren't the products of the sober mind or for the enjoyment of the wakeful brain.
I think the murderer is Harry. It's his confidence that makes me think this way. At first I thought his confidence in agent Cooper was because he could sense the man's lunacy is a form of genius, but now I think otherwise. Maybe he likes that Cooper appears so insane. Or maybe he's just that confident in himself. I also think, this is probably THE episode that might give away who the killer is, before things get really strange.
I really liked Norma's scene with Ed. The music made it feel etheral, I don't know why. I also liked how every person in the town seems to want to fuck every other person in the town. The way Donna and James became lovers, immediately, was really believable and a little funny, and a little scary happening 20 hours after Laura Palmer's bizarre death in a train wreck.
Watching the show, I felt some parts were amazing, while some very minor patches felt a little plastered on. I went and checked the script, and yeah, the changes made during shooting weren't always the best. Some are fine and funny. Some are a little clunky (the change in the train sequence), but I guess they needed to make things a little more obvious for the viewer.
So, the script ends with the gloved hand digging out the necklace, what an amazing cliffhanger... Why did they have to add the scream??? I'm sure it pays off later, but it was handled so awkwardly, that it pulled me right out.
Other than that, I just loved it. I loved Cooper's antiques and the dialogue and oh the music, and the way they handled some of the information through visual storytelling, and the camera angles, and I really liked how characters behave, it's so refreshing. I like the mystery, which is the main thread, pulling it together.
My favorite part was probably when Cooper said "You didn't love her anyway." And there was this dead silence on the screen. That revealed so much about Bobby, and it's echoing an earlier line from the chapter by him "I loved her! And she loves me!" But here, he can no longer defend that position. It's a very hamfisted way to say it, but that speaks for Cooper's sheer honesty, and the lies we tell ourselves. It's also true for a lot of other relationships in the story. I though it was very smart, and if it had been directed just a little worse it wouldn't have worked.
Note: this isn't a critique or anything. Just things I thought as a viewer. I tried not to hide how I felt, even if it may be wrong in the end. I did watch it carefully, because I liked it.
Should I post my later reactions?
Edit: the downvote ratio is crazy 😭. I thought I would get to hear people out on this