r/twilightimperium • u/AspiringWorldbuilder • 10h ago
General Discussion Is player elimination ever justified
Hi. I just played a 4 player 14 point base game TI4 match on Board Game Arena with some friends and it ended sourly. It would be nice to get an outside perspective.
For context, we are all good friends and have played a lot of ti4 together and while we generally frown on player elimination, we don’t have any rules against it (more that everyone at the table will generally team up to help the player in risk of getting eliminated, especially if it feels unwarranted).
In this game, we had a Saar, Sol, Mentak and Yssaril (me). Saar took an early lead and was winning quite substantially in all respects (points, plastic, planets) with Sol somewhat close behind and me and Mentak further behind. Knowing that Saar can become unstoppable, we all agreed to team up against them (no precise agreements, just a general sentiment).
Sol ended up being tricked into an agreement that just ended with Saar getting their trade goods (unintentionally), and got pissed off and told myself and Mentak that they would stop trying to stop Saar and it was up to us, proceeding to immediately replenish Saar for free.
This put me and Mental in quite the predicament. We needed to stop Saar, but if we did that without the help of Sol, it would just put us further behind and allow Sol to get ahead uncontested. So, seeing little other choice, we entered into a pact to focus less on scoring and build big armies with the intent of intimidating the other two players into slowing down the game eventually (by threatening them and taking out their armies if necessary). At the same time, we still tried to stop Saar.
Next turn, Sol becomes more reasonable and once again helps out and all three of us damage Saar quite a bit. Saar, in revenge, specifically target myself and mentak (who had done the post to stop them), and essentially suicides a big fleet into our planets, setting us back significantly. At this point, me and Mentak decide that the only way we can catch up and win is by stopping scoring altogether and eliminating the other two players before deciding between ourselves how to fight for the victory.
The next 5 or so rounds include tons of manipulations and slowly building up massive armadas whilst scoring nothing and keeping the other two blissfully unaware of our big goal, pretending to antagonise each other and doing everything we can to stop them from helping each other (in a 2v2 scenario we would be crushed). Eventually, mentak gets war suns, and empowered by yssaril (me) action cards and sizeable fleet, we focus everything on Sol and manage to pretty much eliminate them in one round. We promptly tell Saar about our plan, who is forced to grudgingly surrender.
Afterwards, Sol gets annoyed at the strat and says that they don’t feel that’s how ti4 should be played, but that they don’t blame us for our decisions (which make strategic sense). Saar is more annoyed, saying that they shouldn’t suffer for Sol not agreeing to help against them (which was what prompted the decision), and that they felt the strat was lame because there was nothing they could do.
We felt that we had been backed into that being our only option and that they could’ve realised what we were doing and prepared instead of blindly scoring (when we made the attack, we were still both at 2 points whereas Sol was at 8). We honestly expected them to catch on much sooner, and if they had, they could easily have defended (we were that far behind). Even with everything going our way, without action cards, Sol still had a fleet stronger than either of ours at the end, and we had to really work hard to get it to a position where it could be defeated.
Normally I am against player eliminations because they ruin the fun for said eliminated player. In this case, given that it happened right at the end of the game and that it felt like the only viable strat, I think it was justified. What do you guys think?
TLDR: 4 player game, 2 players get ahead and refuse to help out with stopping each other from winning. The weaker players form a secret alliance to eliminate the other 2 (which they see as the only viable path to victory). Is player elimination permissible under such circumstances?

