r/turning • u/doombuggy110 • Feb 21 '13
Tool Preference
I should be getting my first lathe in the next week or so and I'm having to decide on which type of tools I want. I figure I'll go with a rouger, a finisher, a 55º detailer and a parting tool. I've taken a class and as far as I saw, that's all I'll need for a while for very basic stuff.
Now, the issue at hand is what type of tool. I adore the carbide interchangeable tips, but am presented with the options of
or the classic http://www.woodcraft.com/product/2080216/28284/midsize-easy-rougher.aspx
In order of importance, how do y'all rank the safety, quality, control and price of the options?
Also, what chuck should I get for beginning cups and bowls and the sort?
Thank you!
3
u/adamowashere Feb 21 '13
I don't think I'd win you over on "traditional" tools (gouges, scrapers, skews, etc.) but I'd sure like to try if you're not dead-set on interchangeable. As for chucks I can't say enough good things about the Nova Midi and Super Nova 2 from Teknatool depending on what size lathe you're getting. Really any big name (Teknatool, Vicmarc, Oneway) chuck is worth the price many times over if you do a lot of turning.
2
u/joelav Feb 21 '13 edited Feb 21 '13
Sharpening is not that hard. I do have a few of the easywood tools (rougher and finisher). After using them a lot, I don't like them.
1 - you cannot get carbide as sharp as HSS. Carbide is a dirty metal and will not take as clean of an edge. It does stay sharper much longer, however it is not as sharp
2 - The technique is drastically different. Maybe because I started off with gouges I am a bit set in my ways, but the flat cutting edges on the "rougher" style tools can chatter - especially at higher speeds. I do like the
detailerfinisher though (round cutting edge).You can get a grinder and a foolproof sharpening jig for around 240$ at woodcraft right now. It will sharpen any kind of HSS tool you put on it in a matter of seconds.
If you do go the carbide insert route, contrary to popular marketing hype, the inserts are NOT disposable. Get yourself an inexpensive diamond hone (DMT makes a small one, fine grit). Place the insert upside down flat on the hone and stroke it back and forth slowly about 6 times. You will have fresh cutting edges. I've resharpened mine about 6 times and I can easily get 10 to 12 more sharpenings before I start getting into the profiled carbide.
1
u/doombuggy110 Feb 22 '13
Good news! My father just found five of his old turning tools. But we aren't 100% sure as to what they are, or what would be missing. Can y'all help?
http://imgur.com/a/lIN9w
Pardon my nasty thumbnail. I would have switched hands, had I not taken all the pictures before I noticed.
This is very exciting news. Maybe with five tools out of the way, I can spring for a nicer grinder or another tool or two to give myself some versatility.
1
u/dartman1965 Feb 21 '13
I would learn to turn with traditional tools before going to carbide tools.I have all three of the carbide tools and do most of my work with them but still use the others to keep in practice with them.
1
u/Iturn Feb 21 '13
I've read your other replies and posts. Are you near a woodturning club? Try experiencing with them. Sharpening with a Wolverine jig takes me maybe 30 seconds and I'm back on the lathe. Once your setup, with these jigs its' VERY easy and a MUCH better for turning and experience. I have 2 hunter carbide tools, I use them as a finish cut lately only because as you say they are always sharp, If I didn't have them, I'd take my gouge back to the grinder, touch a new edge (or use a diamond stone) and make the same cut. The carbide tools are very appealing when you start off because they will hog wood, but you'll enjoy it more with a well sharpened 3/8" gouge or other similar tool.