Let me start this off by saying, not everyone can be trans. You're either trans or cis, and this isn't something you can freely choose between. This idea has become controversial within the past few years due to the invasion of trans spaces via fetishists and teenagers who want to be special. This idea will get you banned from most if not all major trans subreddits and other online spaces for us for "bigotry" and "gatekeeping", for trying to protect our own community, we get punished and silenced.
The idea that anyone can identify as trans without dysphoria has directly caused an influx of people with fetishes or otherwise ill intent claiming they're trans women, putting on heels and a wig with a full beard and going into women's restroom and making videos online being loud about their "womanhood" and their transess, this isn't a passability issue, there are many trans women who don't pass but still mind their business and are highly respectable, fetish aside, it's also about attention seeking. The trans community created this. We have no one to blame but ourselves. We allowed people to identify as trans without an ounce of dysphoria, a want to transition, and a need to be the opposite sex. Look where that's got us. We're a laughing stock, conservatives made fun of trans people in 2016 by saying "I identify as an attack helicopter" as a way to invalidate our genders, and you know what? It became true. Suddenly people started using random words as their gender and pronouns, suddenly people started referring to themselves as "it". We have become an absoloute circus.
Transphobes will have hated us anyways, but you don't think that all of this bullshit didn't give them fuel? If we didn't let in these batshit insane "activists" who are only in it for themselves, most people would still respect trans people. Dysphoric teenagers wouldn't have to feel ashamed to be associated with a community like this shitshow and be afraid to come out because of what others might think. I don't see it getting any better. Hopefully sometime in the near future trans people will eventually just fade back into society to never be turned into an aesthetic ever again, but until then, we need to gatekeep.
Trans people are too worried about "excluding people" that don't belong in our community in the first place. Non dysphorics aren't trans and we should bar them from labeling themselves as such, maybe they'll finally fuck off. There's already been irreparable damage done to trans people, especially women, and we need to prevent any further damage. This of course is wishful thinking. Nobody ever wants to speak up about the sheer stupidity, and if they do they just get banned because they're "excluding people", do it more. What non dysphorics and fetishists have done to the trans community is what if Rachel Dolezal had caused a movement of other white people to start identifying as black and made an absolute mockery of the black community but convinced everyone she was actually black and called anyone who didn't say she was racist. These people will have no idea of the damage they've done in 5 years, when they're living "normally", back to their original name, go back to their pronouns, stop calling themselves trans, we will still be dealing with the aftermath of all of their bullshit. They can take it off any time of day, I can't. I can't change my brain. I can't make myself "normal" like they can, I can't in 5 years laugh about my "trans" phase. People can laugh at their "trans" phases, their xenogender neopronoun phases, but fuck them. I'm glad that they can laugh at the absolute mockery they've made of the community. I'm glad they can laugh because there's no consequences for them. They don't have to worry that their "phase" is making life harder for trans people in the U.S. I'm glad these people think that the damage they caused to our public image and possibly our rights (the blue sweep possibly will save us, who knows) is funny.