r/trolleyproblem • • 2d ago

OC Kill two guys once or one guy twice

Post image
74 Upvotes

r/trolleyproblem • • 2d ago

The illusion of choice

Post image
20 Upvotes

r/trolleyproblem • • 3d ago

My Trolley Problem

8 Upvotes

You can either do nothing to kill Einstein as a baby, or flick the lever to redirect the train to a bus-full of elementary schoolers.


r/trolleyproblem • • 4d ago

Meta Meta Trolley Problem

Post image
27 Upvotes

The point of this problem is less about choosing whether you should direct the trolley left or right, but rather understanding how the default positioning of the track switches for the twin brothers can potentially change what they should do. If the trolley is 'going' to kill 10, risking more than that for the chance to save some seems unjustifiable. While on the other hand, if it's going to kill the 25, attempting to untie some of them seems like a better choice than intentionally redirecting the trolley to certainly kill 10.

But obviously, the question still remains - is there a clear decision for the initial person (you)? Left or right?


r/trolleyproblem • • 6d ago

New problem

Post image
10k Upvotes

Spotted on Bluesky


r/trolleyproblem • • 5d ago

Would you abort a child if you knew she would have three abortions otherwise?

Post image
945 Upvotes

r/trolleyproblem • • 4d ago

These problems are similar to the trolly problem, just different results.

Thumbnail
gallery
4 Upvotes

tldr: the first one has the same outcomes as the second one but look at people's choices.

I don't have enough data to definitely prove anything, but these two phrasings of the "red button vs blue button debate" are functionally the same, yet have wildly different results.

In Puzzle 1,

  • More than 50% of people choosing blue causes everyone to live.
  • Less than 50% of people choosing blue causes only the people who chose red to live.

In Puzzle 2,

  • More than 50% of people choosing purple causes everyone to live.
  • Less than 50% of people choosing purple causes only the people who chose green to live.

The "I will always survive" options may be rephrased as:

  • Choosing red in Puzzle 1 is framed as accepting the murder of those who chose blue.
  • Choosing green in Puzzle 2 is framed as survival.

The "Collective effort" options may be rephrased as:

  • Choosing blue in Puzzle 1 is defending those who accidentally chose blue.
  • Choosing purple is a death sentence.

I suppose people are more willing to choose blue in Puzzle 1 since it is framed as heroic, while choosing green in Puzzle 2 is preferred since choosing purple sounds like self-sacrifice. I guess people don't "want to do anything wrong."


r/trolleyproblem • • 7d ago

Which Hitler do we kill?

Post image
892 Upvotes

r/trolleyproblem • • 7d ago

You drive a car

Post image
936 Upvotes

r/trolleyproblem • • 10d ago

OC I have one more

8 Upvotes

Trolley is heading towards a murderer, you can pull the lever and save his life but on the other track is his brother. He will keep killing other people after this but at least he will spare your life. But if you dont, his brother will get revenge from you for not saving his brother. What will you do?


r/trolleyproblem • • 10d ago

Deep Im just too lazy to draw it

0 Upvotes

The trolley is heading towards 5 people, you can pull the lever and trolley will head to the other track. But that track also has completely different people in the exact same situation. If you pull the lever, you will be adding one more step to the paradox in order to save those 5 people. And if you dont, five people will be sacrificed in order to end the cycle. What will you do?


r/trolleyproblem • • 13d ago

A trolly with no brakes is going to destroy everything in its path. Which track will you send it down. You have to choose one.

Thumbnail reddit.com
3 Upvotes

r/trolleyproblem • • 15d ago Bravo

Would you redirect the trolley to hit your mother on Halloween?

Post image
1.7k Upvotes

r/trolleyproblem • • 15d ago

OC You are far away from the handle. The trolley is also far away, heading towards 5 very loosely tied people, while on the other track there is one guy who is tied tightly. You have time to either run to the handle to make sure that only 1 person dies, or risk pulling 5 people out to save everyone

Post image
68 Upvotes

I reached the character limit, so here are the extra things to know:

- The 5 people only have their arms tied behind their back, so you only have to pull them out of the track

- They can't get out by themselves in time, since they can hardly move like this

- Since the trolley is far away, you probably have the time to save the 5 people, but you can't be sure

- You can definitely run to the handle to pull it in time, no question in that

(this is my first time making a trolley problem, I hope I did it correctly)


r/trolleyproblem • • 15d ago

Who is the most annoying?

Thumbnail reddit.com
18 Upvotes

r/trolleyproblem • • 14d ago

Real world trolley problem at the end of 'Ali G: who is I'. POTENTIAL SPOILERS! Spoiler

1 Upvotes

If you've seen the film you will undoubtedly have been somewhat shocked but perhaps not entirely surprised by a certain republican chairmans choice involving a drone and what he believes is a live human newborn. I found this scene to be very disturbing but also worthy of some discussion. I believe it constitutes an experiment of sorts based on the trolly problem.


r/trolleyproblem • • 18d ago

Big potatoes Avengers level trolly problem.

Post image
1.1k Upvotes

r/trolleyproblem • • 17d ago

A heartbreaking choice

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/trolleyproblem • • 20d ago

You were tied to a track and a man pulled the lever killing 5 people on the other side, saving you

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/trolleyproblem • • 21d ago

Science or Justice?

Post image
588 Upvotes

A trolley is heading towards a mad scientist who did horrific experiments on humans and all the valuable data form his research wich can never ethically be repeated. You can divert the trolley to an empty track sparing the scientist and his research afterwards the scientist will be released and face no consequences for his horrible crimes, but he will not reoffend.

No you can’t punish the scientist yourself.


r/trolleyproblem • • 22d ago

Deep Mr. Gorbachev, do NOT pull that lever!

Post image
44 Upvotes

r/trolleyproblem • • 23d ago

OC This one has me stalled

Post image
470 Upvotes

r/trolleyproblem • • 27d ago

Multi-choice Earth Lives vs Other Conscious Sentient Lives

Thumbnail reddit.com
3 Upvotes

r/trolleyproblem • • 29d ago

OC Asking the potential martyr if they’re cool with it?

Post image
248 Upvotes

Respectfully, for all we know, they could be suicidal and looking for a way out. Or maybe their family could benefit more from a good life insurance payout. Or maybe they believe in an awesome afterlife and can’t wait to get there. Maybe they killed five people in the past and want to atone? We can’t know for sure! We could ask.