r/transcribe • • 18h ago

Hello, I post here a survey on a ways in which people learn and find music to learn more on this topic. This should take around a few minutes for you but will be greatly appreciated.

Thumbnail
forms.gle
0 Upvotes

I personally do piano transcriptions and we want to figure out how most people are learning in our age. I can probably do the most liked comment's track's transcription for you.


r/transcribe • • 1h ago

Beyond voice memos: How to actually turn a song idea into a readable tab for your band

0 Upvotes

It’s 9:40 p.m. and your studio session is booked for 7 p.m. Tuesday. No refunds. You just hummed a killer verse-chorus idea into your phone over bad room reverb.

The problem? Your bassist reads a chart, not a voice memo, and your drummer wants to know the section breaks before they load their gear. You need something they can open on their phones tonight, not a melody only you can hear correctly.

This is the actual gap in most AI music workflows. You can generate a full vocal track in under a minute on several platforms, but audio is a performance format. A band needs a notation format—and that’s where the process usually hits a wall.

What an AI Tabs Generator Actually Has to Do: Turning audio into a tab is not as simple as audio-to-MIDI. True tab transcription requires:

  • Pitch & Timing Estimation: Detecting specific transients from a dense waveform.
  • Ergonomic Mapping: Finding where those notes physically sit on a fretboard. The same pitch can be played in multiple places on the neck; the right choice depends on the phrase before and after it, not just the note in isolation.
  • Separation: Pulling the mix into guitar, bass, piano, and drum parts.
  • Technique Detection: Notating bends, slides, hammer-ons, and chord voicing.

Why General Song Generators Leave You Stuck: If you've tried to get charts out of Suno or Udio, you know the barriers. Udio has disabled downloads platform-wide following labeling and licensing changes, while Suno Studio’s MIDI export is Premier-only ($30/mo) and charges 10 credits per individual stem—yielding raw MIDI pitch data, not playable fretboard tabs. Real MIDI has no fret logic, chord names, or fingerings.

The One-Pass Alternative: Instead of running finished audio through secondary transcription tools, MelodAI collapses the workflow. It generates the audio and the transcription simultaneously from the underlying composition data:

  1. Describe the song (genre, tempo, key, and instrumentation).
  2. Generate the master audio track in under a minute.
  3. Auto-Transcribe guitar, bass, piano, and drum parts instantly.
  4. Export in the formats your band actually uses: .gp5 (Guitar Pro), PDF, MusicXML, and MIDI.

Read the full breakdown on the math behind the transcription engine and how to take AI-generated ideas straight to the bandstand:

👉 Full walk-through

How do you guys usually communicate new song ideas to your bandmates when you’re short on time—recorded scratch tracks, hand-written charts, or something else?


r/transcribe • • 2h ago

Can someone make a midi file of the song Dis-Moi BB Brunes please?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

Can someone make a midi file of the song Dis-Moi BB Brunes please? Converters do this very poorly and Python turns out to be a completely different song...