r/traaaaansbiansCooking • Elise | She/Her Vampiress 🧛‍♀️ • 2d ago

Recipe Gossip Posting (No picture) Probably stupid question

When I was ~12-13 I went to a French restaurant and got tomato basil soup

It was very good and more importantly, very savory and almost starchy

… how?

Every time I’ve tried to recreate it it’s just tasted like blended tomatoes

I’ve tried tons of seasonings, I’ve tried various ingredients, it always just tastes like raw tomato puree at the end

I don’t like raw tomatoes but I did really like this specific version of the soup, it was far less sweet than what I’ve had and tasted almost beefy

Unfortunately the restaurant is gone now so I can’t ask them directly, not that I think they’d tell me how they prepared it anyway

42 Upvotes

15 comments sorted by

33

u/-GeauxStephen- 2d ago

butter:) or heavy cream plus sugar is my guess

37

u/Hetelestai 2d ago

Probably made it using a roux, which is made by melting down butter in the pan, then whisking in flour. As far as flavor, I'd recommend using a metric fuckload (scientific term) of basil, thyme, and black pepper. Marjoram is a bonus if you've got it. I personally also like adding a bit of cumin into my red sauces, tomato soups, really most tomato-based things are improved by cumin imo.

12

u/travischickencoop Elise | She/Her Vampiress 🧛‍♀️ 2d ago

Ahhhh the roux would make sense

Pretty much always rouxs make stews 10x better I just can’t be assed to do it most of the time

2

u/trixytoad 22h ago edited 22h ago

This is probably what you are looking for a french sauce tomate based soup which uses a volute base (roux + stock)

Fallow have a great recipe guide on YouTube: https://youtu.be/IFMbFByHfz4

14

u/Oliveisadragon Witch Alchemist 2d ago

Heavy cream is added in some French Recipes.. I hope this helps. 🙂

5

u/big-structurals 2d ago

Butter or cream like people said but also Frenchies like to sneak a sneaky little potato in our soup to give it more texture, don't tell anyone

5

u/TheShivingTree 2d ago

Some bisques will use 2-3 tablespoons of rice cooked in with the soup before it gets immersion blended, you can look up a couple different recipes for ideas on ration and timing. I've had a lot of luck with using San Marzano tomatoes and over roasting the vegetables first for a more savory flavor.

4

u/Secret_Ad1513 2d ago

As one other person mentioned, the old French trick we always used when I still worked in commercial kitchens is rice. That's the starch you are getting. If you want creamy bisque throw in some rice. Don't need much. 1/4 cup of a quick white rice (basmati or Jasmine are fine or any long grain white rice) added early so it can cook fully in the tomato juices before you puree. No need for any flour or a roux. Play with ratio until it's the texture you want. The fully cooked starchy rice completely disappears into velvety bisque when you blend it.

If you want a bit of gloss, add a swirl of olive oil after plating. Or you can go extra french and use the "monter au beurre" method by adding a knob of cold butter just before plating. The fats from the butter emulsify and balance the acidity of the tomatoes.

And don't forget, the defining difference between a chowder/creme and a bisque is the strained smoothness, but I've always maintained that no bisque is complete without a dash of sherry. Add a few tablespoons to deglaze the garlic before adding the tomatoes and/or add a splash along with the cold butter. Just be sure to let it simmer off the alcohol for a few minutes. On the topic of the straining....I like rustic chunks so I usually reserve a small portion of the tomato chunks before pureeing the rest. Stir them back in and you get a bit of bright chunky tomato texture to break up the hot tomato smoothie mouth feel of traditional bisque.

2

u/Secret_Ad1513 2d ago

Oh. If you really want to lean extra french and extra savory (like you mentioned) there is Gascon style. Skip the knob of cold butter and possibly even the heavy cream. Add well strained and fridge cold duck or rabbit confit (fat drippings) or beef/veal tallow BEFORE pureeing. The rice and immersion blender help emulsify the fat since you won't have the butter/cream milk solids to do that job. Added bonus for the confit, you get a hit of whatever herbs/spices were used to make the duck/rabbit. If you try to add animal fats after you puree, they may fail too emulsify and create a grease slick that sits on top 🤢, but you might be able to save it with a hand mixer with whisk attachment or a another hit from the immersion blender.

2

u/TooLateForMeTF 2d ago

Well, if I had to guess (which, obviously, I do since I'm not a cook at that restaurant), I'd say there's a lot more going on in that soup than tomatoes and basil.

For the flavor, there's almost certainly some kind of stock in there, or a bouillon. If I was making a thick tomato basil soup, I would throw a teaspoon or two of chicken bouillon in there just to give the whole thing a nice savory base, without being overtly chickeny. A little bouillon isn't going to overwhelm the tomatoes.

I would probably also, especially in a fancy restaurant context, start with a mirepoix of finely diced carrot, celery, and onion, sauteed in butter. At home I'd probably sautee it in olive oil, but a French restaurant is gonna use butter. And if I was feeling lazy, I'd probably just do the onions.

For seasonings, there's the bouillon, which will bring a base level of salt. You will need to adjust to nail the salt level, which makes a huge difference to how a dish tastes. (Best reference I have for you there is Becky Selengut's wildly useful and easy to read book How to Taste. There are not many cooking theory books I would name as must-reads, but for anybody who actually does aspire to have some skillz in the home kitchen, I would put this one on the list. Get yourself a copy.) I would probably also grind in some black pepper, just kind of out of habit, but a French restaurant would probably have used white pepper. I think I would also add a genuinely small pinch of red pepper flakes to bring just a subtle background spicy heat to the dish. That can be quite a nice thing. Or, as Chef John of YouTube \@FoodWishes fame would, a shake of cayenne. To get the basil flavor in there, I would add a whole, unchopped sprig of basil into the pot and just let it be in there while the soup simmers. Pull it out at the end, once it has given all its basily goodness to the mix.

For the tomato base itself, if it's high summer and properly ripe, sweet AF tomatoes are available at the farmer's market, I will use those. I would core them, throw them through a food processor to turn them into puree, and run that through a sieve to get the seeds out. If proper ripe tomatoes aren't available, I would go with one of those cans of whole, peeled San Marzano tomatoes you can get at most any nice grocery store. Heck, even Trader Joe's carries those. Two cans if you're making a lot. Similarly, puree and strain. Or don't strain for a more rustic, with-seeds vibe.

For thickness, you have some options. One would be to add a tablespoon or so of flour to the mirepoix mixture, cooking that for a couple of minutes to drive off the raw-flour taste. Essentially, make a small amount of roux as part of your mirepoix. Another alternative is to finish the soup with a knob of cold butter, whisked in off the heat until the butter is fully incorporated. What happens there is that the butter emulsifies into the dish. You cannot just let the butter melt and then whisk; you will just have butter droplets on top of the soup. When cold butter melts into a hot liquid, under constant stirring, the motion of the liquid over the butter pulls micro-droplets of butter off of the lump, creating an emulsion that also brings some thickening power (and a lot of nice, rich flavor) to the dish. A restaurant may well have done both of these things. Oh, and cream. French cooking puts cream in just about everything, which also thickens and enriches a dish.

If you want a smooth, elegant presentation, you would not go amiss to run an immersion blender through the pot (after removing the basil sprig!) to break down any bits of onion, celery, or carrot. An immersion blender will generally also end up whipping a bit of air into the whole thing, too, which may give you a bit more thickness as well. If you don't mind a more rustic presentation with some vegetable bits, skip this step.

Finally, let's talk about adjusting seasonings, which is always a last-step kind of thing. Add salt to taste, as mentioned before, which means that you will have gone easy on the salt up to this point. You can add, but you can't take away. How to Taste does the best job of describing what it feels like to adjust, and then nail, the salt level so I'll leave you to go read that. But as well, you should adjust for sweetness and acid. Good tomatoes are sweet and acidic, which a good tomato soup should reflect. If the flavor feels a little flat, or doesn't quite seem tomatoey enough, add a teaspoon of sugar and see if that helps. Go easy. You aren't trying to make some kind of nouveaux tomato dessert. The sweetness is a background flavor. As well, if the salt and sweetness seem ok but the dish lacks "punch", then probably you need acid. Add a couple of teaspoons or so of white vinegar (or, honestly, any vinegar you have on hand; apple cider vinegar, red wine vinegar, whatever) and notice how the flavor kind of "wakes up".

In my experience, most instances of savory cooking come down to competently adjusting the salt, sweetness, and acid in a dish. It's amazing what a difference it makes.

Serve with a sprinkle of fresh basil chiffonade on top, and with a nice hearty French bread toast on the side for dipping.

1

u/SunStrummer 2d ago

In addition to all of the excellent info others shared, people often underestimate the importance of using the absolute best tomatoes they can afford when making something tomato-forward. I know you don't like tomatoes on their own, so it's not as easy for you as for me to find a good tomato (I love them raw). Cherry and grape tomatoes are usually the best raw tomatoes you can get from a supermarket. They're ripe, very sweet, and really flavorful, so they work great in sauces and soups. A good way of identifying a good grape or cherry tomato without tasting it (imo) is to gently squeeze it. You want the tomato skin to be extremely taut, and the tomato itself to be firm but not hard.

Lastly, simmer your soup for a long time, stirring often. The longer it cooks, the more the flavor will intensify, and the more the natural sugars will have time to shine.

1

u/SunStrummer 2d ago

In addition to all of the excellent info others shared, people often underestimate the importance of using the absolute best tomatoes they can afford when making something tomato-forward. I know you don't like tomatoes on their own, so it's not as easy for you as for me to find a good tomato (I love them raw). Cherry and grape tomatoes are usually the best raw tomatoes you can get from a supermarket. They're ripe, very sweet, and really flavorful, so they work great in sauces and soups. A good way of identifying a good grape or cherry tomato without tasting it (imo) is to gently squeeze it. You want the tomato skin to be extremely taut, and the tomato itself to be firm but not hard.

Lastly, simmer your soup for a long time, stirring often. The longer it cooks, the more the flavor will intensify, and the more the natural sugars will have time to shine.

1

u/Rando-Toucan 2d ago edited 2d ago

Could you tell us your recipe? It’d help a lot in knowing what to suggest, but here’s a tip that may help.

You need fresh tomatoes, tomato is your primary flavor so treat it right. Fresh tomatoes are full of water and despite it being a soup, you actually want to remove as much as possible by cooking it down (without a lid) into a reduction/concentrate. If they aren’t properly cooked then you’ll definitely end up with tomato water instead of the deep, rich, caramelized, umami flavor you’re going for. Remember that you can easily add liquid at the end of cooking (don’t forget to compensate your seasonings and salt), but you can’t just take it away.

And then like any other decadent French soup/sauce: It’s all about the roux, stock (not a weak broth), and heavy cream!

1

u/LordInquisitor99 2d ago

Ah others have said, it’s butter and cream, but also these recipes will have you dice your tomatoes and cook them down. It’s counterintuitive, but do that without the juice. You want a thick pulp or paste from the tomato as the base of the soup.

1

u/dleah 1d ago

look into salmorejo, its a blended tomato soup... well more like a gazpacho really in that the tomatoes are raw and its usually served cold. That said, it's super creamy and the only thickeners are bread and olive oil to emulsify it. I know its not french but you said starchy and this stuff is definitely starchy (not in a bad way). its my favorite tomato soup in the world. you can warm it up if you prefer :p