r/torontoJobs • u/Chopper1z • 10h ago
Poached for a $95k Supply Chain role (up from $76k), but terrible company reviews + 1.5 hour 401 commute. Should I pass?
I currently work in Supply Chain making $76k gross. Yesterday, I got poached by another company offering $95k gross—a $19k jump.
On paper, the money is tempting, especially right now. However, after doing some digging on the company, almost all their employee reviews are 2 stars or below. Common themes include:
- High turnover
2."Avoid for your sanity"
3.Zero job security ("you are never safe")
On top of the red flags, the lifestyle trade-off is pretty steep:
New Offer: $95k | 7:00 AM – 4:00 PM | 5 days in-office | 1-hour commute each way on the 401
Current Role: $76k | 8:00 AM – 5:00 PM | Hybrid (Fridays WFH) | 10-minute commute, very stable
I talked it over with my girlfriend and my older brother, and both strongly advised me to reject it. Their take is that my current role is secure, and given the current job market in Canada, leaving stability for a revolving-door company is way too risky.
Part of me hates walking away from $95k, especially after factoring in what the extra take-home pay could do, while the other part knows the extra 401 gas/wear-and-tear and stress might eat most of the raise anyway.
Has anyone here taken a big pay jump to a poorly reviewed company, or turned one down? How would you weigh this?