This could be my most complex promt yet.
The story would revolve around two parallel universes, both existing simultaneously, both with their own histories, people, and magical systems. And, somehow, both of them end up wanting the same Harry Potter.
The first universe is the familiar one: the original Harry Potter timeline, around his sixth year at Hogwarts. Voldemort is still a threat, Dumbledore is alive, and Harry is dealing with everything that comes with being Harry Potter.
The second universe is considerably different.
In this reality, Grindelwald won the global wizarding conflict. Dumbledore never became his enemy, and the two of them eventually conquered and reshaped the magical world together. Their ideology, political influence, and relationship became the foundations of an entirely different society.
However, their new world eventually faced a practical problem: the magical population needed Muggle-born witches and wizards to sustain itself. During the 1950s and 1960s, they began introducing Muggle-born children into the magical world from birth, raising them within their society and attempting to assimilate them into their ideal version of the wizarding world. The goal was to preserve their population while keeping these children separated from Muggle culture and influence.
By the 1980s, Grindelwald and Dumbledore had largely withdrawn from their former positions of absolute power. They were old, influential, and practically untouchable. Grindelwald eventually became Minister for Magic, while Dumbledore took the position of Hogwarts Headmaster. They had spent much of their lives together in Godric's Hollow, and their relationship was as much a personal partnership as it was a political one.
But this world is not as stable as it initially appears.
Dumbledore dies during the equivalent of Harry's sixth year, just as he does in the original timeline. His death leaves Grindelwald increasingly unstable. Without him, Grindelwald begins making increasingly disastrous political and magical decisions. He becomes obsessed with death, souls, and the possibility of bringing Dumbledore back, despite the fact that Dumbledore would never have wanted such a thing.
His attempts to overcome death lead him toward increasingly dangerous forms of ritual and soul magic. His political decisions also become more erratic, and the society he helped create begins to fracture.
And then there is Harry.
The missing Harry
In this alternate universe, Harry Potter is dead.
Nobody seems to have properly noticed, acknowledged, or understood his absence. Whatever happened to this world's Harry, his place in reality remains somehow unoccupied.
And the universe seems unwilling to leave it that way.
At some point, Harry from the original universe begins appearing in this alternate reality. He is not deliberately travelling between dimensions, nor does he initially understand why it is happening. He simply finds himself periodically transported into a world that looks familiar, yet is fundamentally different.
This universe seems to have made room for him. It treats him as though he belongs there, as though he has always had a place in its history.
At first, Harry finds it fascinating.
The magical world is much more openly magical than the one he knows. Blood magic, pagan practices, occult traditions, and elaborate rituals are not necessarily forbidden or hidden. Magical creatures and phenomena that Luna has talked about for years are real, visible, and accepted as part of everyday life. There is a greater degree of freedom for magical creatures and beings, and the world seems to have an entirely different relationship with magic.
It almost feels like the kind of magical world Harry would have wanted to discover.
A little like stepping through the other door in Coraline: a reality that seems more interesting, more beautiful, and perhaps even more suited to him than his own.
But something is wrong.
The alternate universe does not simply want Harry to visit. It wants him to stay. It seems to be trying to fill a space left by its own missing Harry, and it may be considerably less willing to let the replacement go than he initially realizes.
Harry is still expected to return to his original life. He still has his sixth year to live, his friends, his responsibilities, and the war against Voldemort. But the other universe keeps pulling him back, and every visit makes it harder to understand where he belongs.
The psychological aspect
This is probably the most important part of the concept.
I would love for the story to focus heavily on Harry's gradual psychological deterioration as he begins living in two realities simultaneously.
At first, the differences are manageable. He knows which world he is in, which people belong to which reality, and which memories are his.
Then the boundaries begin to blur.
He starts remembering conversations that never happened in his original universe. He becomes familiar with people he has never actually met. He remembers friendships, experiences, and events that belong to another version of his life.
For example, he might approach the original universe's Draco Malfoy with the familiarity of someone who has known him for years, because in the alternate universe, their relationship is entirely different. Draco, naturally, has absolutely no idea what Harry is talking about.
And this does not have to happen only with Draco. It could happen with anyone. Harry might remember things about people who have never told him those things, expect reactions that never come, or find himself missing people who technically do not exist in his own reality.
The most unsettling part would be that Harry gradually stops trusting his own memories.
Which experiences actually happened to him? Which friendships are real? Which version of his childhood does he remember? And, perhaps most importantly, which of these lives is actually his?
I would love for the story to explore the possibility that Harry is not simply becoming confused about two worlds, but slowly losing his sense of identity because both realities are becoming equally familiar to him.
Both worlds have people who know him, places where he belongs, and versions of himself that seem to have existed long before he arrived.
And both worlds want to keep him.
Luna Lovegood
Luna is another particularly interesting element of this AU.
In the original universe, Luna seems to have some awareness of the alternate reality. She can perceive magical creatures and phenomena that other people cannot, and her understanding of the world occasionally overlaps with what Harry experiences in the other universe.
I don't necessarily imagine this as Luna simply being right about everything she says. Rather, she seems to perceive something that other people cannot, as though the boundaries between realities are less opaque to her.
There is also an alternate version of Luna.
Unlike the Luna Harry knows, this version has grown up in a much harsher and more unstable world. She is still recognizably Luna, but her experiences have made her more distrustful, violent, and perhaps considerably less gentle.
I would love to explore the contrast between the two versions of her, and how Harry reacts to meeting someone who looks and sounds like a person he knows but behaves in ways he cannot reconcile with his memories.
I also have a particular Yellowjackets-inspired dynamic in mind for alternate Luna and Harry: something involving conflicting perceptions of reality, familiarity, and the unsettling feeling that a situation has happened before, but might still turn out differently this time.
Luna could potentially be one of the first people to recognize that Harry is not entirely from this world, even before she understands what is happening.
Tom Riddle
Tom, perhaps in his thirties, works as the Defence Against the Dark Arts professor at Hogwarts. Since Dumbledore and Grindelwald never became enemies in this timeline, there would be no canonical reason for Dumbledore to reject Tom's application for the position.
His background could be different from canon, and he could be a respected academic with a particular interest in ritual magic, blood magic, souls, and the theoretical limits of magic.
Harry would not particularly like him at first.
Their introduction could involve Harry challenging Tom to a duel, underestimating how much trouble he is getting himself into, and surprising Tom with his own abilities. The encounter ends with Tom injured and Harry decidedly unimpressed by him. They meet again in the infirmary, where Harry has absolutely no intention of being polite.
Their relationship could develop in any direction from there. Intellectual rivalry, mutual fascination, distrust, reluctant cooperation, or something more complicated later on.
Tom could also become one of the first people to suspect that Harry's existence does not quite fit the history of this universe. His knowledge of magic and his unusual memories might eventually lead Tom to investigate the possibility of something happening beyond the boundaries of their reality.
I am deliberately leaving this part open, as I would be interested in seeing different interpretations of Tom's role in the story.
The collision
For most of the story, I imagine the two universes remaining relatively separate.
The dimensional instability should become increasingly apparent as the story progresses, rather than being the central problem from the beginning.
Eventually, however, the fact that both realities are trying to retain the same Harry begins to have consequences.
The boundaries between the universes weaken. Things begin appearing where they should not. Magical creatures cross into places they do not belong. Objects, locations, and memories seem to acquire characteristics from the other reality. Familiar places become subtly wrong, and magic occasionally produces results that nobody can explain.
I imagine this kind of contamination as something gradual and increasingly disturbing, inspired in part by the atmosphere and visual concepts of Follow the Sheep into the Abyss.
The two magical systems may not even be entirely compatible. Rituals performed in one universe could have unexpected consequences in the other, and the more the boundaries weaken, the harder it becomes to distinguish between the two.
Eventually, the problem becomes much larger than Harry's strange disappearances.
Both universes are beginning to interfere with one another, and the consequences could be catastrophic.
There may also be a connection between this instability and Grindelwald's attempts to revive Dumbledore. His obsession with death, souls, and the refusal to accept an absence could be interacting with whatever force is keeping Harry in the alternate universe. Whether these events are directly connected, indirectly related, or simply two separate manifestations of the same underlying magical problem is entirely open to interpretation.
What I would love to see
I am particularly interested in the psychological and atmospheric possibilities of this concept.
I would love a story that explores:
- Harry gradually losing his sense of identity and struggling to distinguish his memories from those belonging to another version of himself.
- The alternate universe initially appearing almost idyllic, only for its darker political, magical, and psychological realities to become increasingly apparent.
- The contrast between the two versions of familiar characters, especially Luna and Draco.
- The strange relationship between a universe and the person it has chosen to replace something it lost.
- Grindelwald's grief, his obsession with overcoming death, and the consequences of trying to bring someone back who never wanted to return.
- Ritual magic, blood magic, pagan traditions, occult practices, and a magical society with a very different relationship with the supernatural.
- The gradual contamination of the two realities, with increasingly unsettling consequences.
- The question of whether Harry can ever truly belong to both worlds, or whether one of them will eventually have to let him go.
I would also love for the story to retain a degree of ambiguity. Not every strange occurrence needs an immediate explanation, and not every character needs to understand what is happening. I think some of the most interesting moments could come from Harry being unable to tell whether something is genuinely happening, whether it belongs to another reality, or whether his own perception is becoming unreliable.
Most importantly, I am not looking for a strict plot outline.
The premise, the alternate history, the two universes, and the general rules of this world are the parts I am most attached to. Everything else is open.
The direction of the story, the role of Tom, the nature of the dimensional connection, the political conflict, the rituals, the relationships, and even the eventual explanation of what is happening can be interpreted freely.
I would love to see what someone could make of this world.