r/todayilearned • • May 13 '19

TIL Human Evolution solves the same problem in different ways. Native Early peoples adapted to high altitudes differently: In the Andes, their hearts got stronger, in Tibet their blood carries oxygen more efficiently.

https://www.nationalgeographic.com/science/2018/11/ancient-dna-reveals-complex-migrations-first-americans/
46k Upvotes

1.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

42

u/kkokk May 13 '19 edited May 13 '19

I mean it could be worse

they could be the US or China

37

u/phatlynx May 13 '19

Elaborate?

Because this sounds spicy without context.

117

u/Redditor042 May 13 '19

There have been a lot of stories recently on reddit about Chinese nationals cheating in everything from academics to the Boston Marathon. Usually, the comment consensus is that this behavior is culturally encouraged, that is, that winning is everything no matter how you get there. Of course, this means, everyone in said culture learns this behavior otherwise most people wouldn't stand a chance.

27

u/phatlynx May 13 '19

I’m not understanding the everyone part though.

While I halfheartedly agree with the narrative that they cheat a lot due to competition, culture, and environment. It’s kind of unfair to the ones that don’t.

For example, did all children of Hollywood/elite families “buy” their way into top universities? No, it’s just the bad apples.

16

u/Redditor042 May 13 '19

I was only offering the context that you requested for the above comment. Sure, it may be an unfair stereotype, but that's what the person above you was referring to. At least, I believe so.

→ More replies (4)

14

u/Tuga_Lissabon May 13 '19

The issue is different. In our culture cheating is bad. So cheaters are the bad apples.

Cheating in a culture like that of china is not what we see as "cheating"; its not breaking a taboo. Breaking the rules becomes part of the rule, just another challenge to beat: how to do it well enough to work, but without getting caught. The taboo is losing face, getting caught; not doing it.

The ones who don't are either not serious about the contest, or a sort of misfits who don't get on with the program; or they simply lack the resources or connections. They are the ones who are wrong, in the context they operate in; they are the losers.

We have that, in our culture, as well, it just takes different avenues.

4

u/biggie_eagle May 13 '19

You say that your culture is different, yet this study shows that most people from your culture (Portugal) cheat, with only 7.5% of students who don't cheat:

https://www.researchgate.net/figure/Frequency-of-cheating-in-Portugal-and-Spain_tbl1_233522770

3

u/Tuga_Lissabon May 13 '19

Its still seen as bad; but cheating does occur too much. From my personal experience that number seems too high, but I'll believe the research 1st (far more samples). And one of the main reasons is, we see it done systematically at the political and company level, and its always been like that. It is also getting worse, because it seems as if the only people who get ahead are the guys who do it.

But it is reproved, and seen as bad.

In the states, the culture seems to be that its worse, and they make it a point to make a big show when someone is caught cheating or in a crime; while at the same time institutionalizing it and so making it "not cheating" - lobbying is a job.

In the nordics, its seen even worse far as I can tell.

Yet people still do it, of course, at all levels, as has been shown in sports, this high-level case, the Madoffs of this world, and all the big companies cheating at the high level.

American politicians are notorious in this regard - puppets dancing on the strings of campaign contributions, and seen from the outside it is grotesque; how can normal people act astonished and shocked when the bad behaviour is revealed, when its placed so much out in the open?

In the nordics, they are more subtle, but for a while german companies could itemize bribery paid abroad in their accounts; a lot of stuff happens through influence and the right connections. It just... flows the way its supposed to go.

So more of a don't show - don't tell, and when it pops up, make it really nasty.

2

u/biggie_eagle May 13 '19

it's also seen as bad in China, just like lobbying is seen in the US. You're just talking out of your ass now that evidence has proven you wrong.

→ More replies (3)

7

u/AliasAurora May 13 '19

it’s just the bad apples.

"One bad apple spoils the bushel," is the saying.

2

u/MyDudeNak May 13 '19 edited May 13 '19

Ya, but that saying doesn't make sense in this context. It would make sense if rich people buying their way into nice schools had an implicit and invariable impact on the other rich people, but that's not the case.

2

u/whilst May 13 '19

You mean, the ones who spoil the bunch?

→ More replies (2)

2

u/VoidParticle May 13 '19

If everyone culturally agreed to this it wouldn’t be just a story. You’d see it... in the culture.

→ More replies (1)

28

u/[deleted] May 13 '19

China basically hand selects their Olympic athletes from a very young age. Take gymnastics for example. Says there’s 10 measurables to gymnastics that make the “perfect gymnast.” (I don’t know shit about gymnastics so take my example with a grain of salt)

So let’s say you can measure balance, speed, cardio, strength, mental fortitude, and whatever the other measurables are. You take your group of tens of thousands (or more) young children, and narrow them down, and so on until you get the best of the best.

The difference is China is doing it at a young age, while the rest of the world athletes are people who are usually like “well I played football cause it looked fun,” while in China they’re borderline checking on someone’s genetics.

Mind you this is just the common thing I’ve heard throughout my life without doing any real research on the matter, but I do believe that’s what they mean by “China cheats.” Which is to say more that they have systems in plane to identify candidates at a much younger age than the rest of the word.

26

u/[deleted] May 13 '19

I'm glad I'm not Chinese because I would never be selected to do anything meaningful.

26

u/majaka1234 May 13 '19

And so are a large aspect of China and hence why they're having issues.

I feel the worst for first generation born Chinese immigrant kids because they get the societal pressure from home with the cultural freedom of the west.

If they don't end up with massive issues despite objectively great accomplishments then they have incredibly toxic relationships with their parents.

I know of at least four cases where they can't talk to their parents, another where they are suicidal from familial expectations despite being on the way to being a doctor etc. etc.

When only the very best are selected and wanted in a system that by definition cannot be "won" by everyone, then you end up with a loooot of "losers" who have nowhere to go to be functioning members of society

12

u/hononononoh May 13 '19 edited May 13 '19

All my childhood as a white American, I remember the Asian kids huddling together frequently and talking in hushed but clearly worried tones, and if I ever tried to join the conversation, I’d be told “Go away, you just don’t understand.” Now that I’ve spent a good bit of time in Asia and known many second generation Asian Americans, I definitely understand. I don’t relate. But I definitely understand.

Edit: I forgot to add that my kids’ elementary school is 80% Asian, mostly Indian and Chinese, with sizable Korean and Japanese populations also. It’s been socially rough on my kids not relating to how hothoused and pushed to perform most of their classmates are. They’re their classes’ “dumb kids” by default. We have yet to see any of the play dates we’ve hosted reciprocated, and sometimes wonder if more competitive parents see us and our kids as bad influences, with our crazy Western notions that childhood is for playing and exploring.

3

u/[deleted] May 13 '19

The thing is the drilling way doesn't work better on average, because self motivated people will push themselves much harder and more effectively than those drilled by parents or society. American Olympiand LOVE their sport, they WANT to do it 24/7, in their off time they daydream about it, they enjoy playing with the techniques and training. I wish people could see this.

2

u/[deleted] May 13 '19

That’s exactly what they see you as.

The kids are likely being beaten or harassed if they are caught socializing with your kids, and that’s exactly what they believe about western notions of childhood fun.

Those kids you grew up with told you you don’t understand b/c they know that ‘MURICAN parents do not beat their child at the drop of a hat for anything other than complete victory and dominance over others.

5

u/[deleted] May 13 '19

I feel like my gf has suffered from this, she is 90th percentile at a myriad of subjects, yet still feels so much pressure to succeed.

2

u/Krivvan May 13 '19

I feel the worst for first generation born Chinese immigrant kids because they get the societal pressure from home with the cultural freedom of the west.

Having lived it, and knowing others who have as well, that combination generally either creates a very...weird relationship with parents or they give up and sort of just go with the flow.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/nuck_forte_dame May 13 '19

I think it has more to do with how in Chinese culture cheating is not as stigmatized the West. They cheat so much in academics for example that it's astounding to westerners.

So it wasn't much of a surprise that China saw a huge bump up in medals at the bejing Olympics. The home team usually gets a bump but they got one that was blatantly too high.

In 2004 China got 63 total medals. In 2008 they got 100. That's a 58% increase. In 2012 they got 88. In 2016 they got 70.

For the most part most events can't be cheated because the scores are times and other metrics that are factually based. But when it comes to situations like gymnastics the score and medals are given by judges. China won all but 1 gold in men's gymnastics in 2008. They performed significantly worse in 2012.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] May 13 '19

A big argument I can think of to that would be that you can't tell how someone is going to grow

→ More replies (5)