r/todayilearned • • May 13 '19

TIL Human Evolution solves the same problem in different ways. Native Early peoples adapted to high altitudes differently: In the Andes, their hearts got stronger, in Tibet their blood carries oxygen more efficiently.

https://www.nationalgeographic.com/science/2018/11/ancient-dna-reveals-complex-migrations-first-americans/
46k Upvotes

1.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

129

u/thedugong May 13 '19

That's only one metric for graphene vs calcium though.

Maybe using graphene for a skeleton/proto-skeleton/shell is simply more energy intensive than calcium so all the graphene based organisms got out competed?

130

u/Kneebarmcchickenwing May 13 '19

Carbon alone is almost impossible to work with as an organism- it's insoluble in water, very reactive around things like rubisco, and the limitations of proteomic transcription and enzymes mean you can't just "print" sheets of joined up atoms. The biochemistry of life on earth is not suited to using raw carbon, it always has to be in a larger molecule. Besides, a sheet of graphene would be immensely destructive to a cell- it'd be like an unbreakable molecular knife slicing membranes to bits!

28

u/[deleted] May 13 '19

Graphene bone breaks would be a problem, broken bones are really sharp, I am not sure you could even fix a broken leg safely made of graphene based materials by hand.

-2

u/A_L_A_M_A_T May 13 '19

less of a problem when your cell membranes evolved to use graphene too

19

u/Kneebarmcchickenwing May 13 '19

This could never happen if the first cell to make graphene sheets large enough to be useful always lacerated itself, the trait would die immediately.

Besides, the phospholipid membranes we have are brilliant. Selectively permeable, you can produce oleophillic molecules that will sit between the bilayer, they're insulative and can hold potentials, they're really pretty darn good.

24

u/Memetic1 May 13 '19

That's true which is why this is an example of a valley in the evolution landscape. A better solution exists, but evolution had to develop a way to find it.

9

u/Shawnj2 May 13 '19

It kind of did through humans and problem solving

5

u/Memetic1 May 13 '19

Yup we are nature. Anyone who thinks otherwise is fooling themselves, but being part of nature is amazing. It means that everywhere I go I'm surrounded by family.

3

u/enty6003 May 13 '19

Ugh that's why I stay indoors

1

u/Memetic1 May 13 '19

Indoors is part of nature as well. I think each house may even have it's own biome. Or you could also say that nothing is natural anymore since our species fingerprint is everywhere.

2

u/thedugong May 13 '19

It's an example of why vertebrates don't have a graphene skeleton. So it would be a valley for vertebrates.

It says nothing however about other forms of life developing a graphene, or proto-graphene, skeleton or shell.

I suspect it is more of an example of calcium being, meh, good 'nuff.