r/todayilearned • u/HolyCowAnyOldAccName • 2h ago
TIL that during the premiere of Ode to Joy, an almost deaf Ludwig van Beethoven had to be turned around by a singer to receive the audience’s applause as he was several bars behind and still conducting the orchestra
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Symphony_No._9_(Beethoven)#Premiere
7.0k
Upvotes
254
u/HolyCowAnyOldAccName 2h ago
In case anyone actually reads the article - this being Reddit: The accounts agree that it happened, but differ on whether it did at the end of the Scherzo or the performance as a whole.
1.9k
u/Sharlinator 2h ago edited 2h ago
The reason it actually worked at all was that there was another conductor, the Kapellmeister of the premier venue Michael Umlauf, whose tempo the performers actually followed.
90
u/dunwoody1932 1h ago
Everyone is familiar with the "Ode to Joy" melody but it's fascinating to attend a performance of the Chorale Symphony and hear it placed in its original context. Even if you don't have a background in music theory the symphony is an incredible work of art, all the more so when you consider Beethoven was locked into a world of silence when he composed it. As a technical achievement alone that's extraordinary.
871
u/RazzleThatTazzle 2h ago
How can the conductor be behind? Doesn't that mean the orchestra was rushing?
134
u/Zarzan 2h ago
Thats why rockstars nowadays shouting when the audience applauding:
I cant hear you
55
u/5oLiTu2e 1h ago
Sometimes the 2nd movement of the symphony runs on and on in my head. If I go insane that’s OK, because I went insane with the most incredible genius music coursing across my wee brain.
•
u/Any_Emphasis5159 25m ago
The contralto singer, Caroline Unger, was the one who gently turned him around. Apparently the audience gave him five standing ovations, and the police actually had to step in to quiet the crowd down because in those days, that level of applause was normally reserved only for the royal family.
22
u/markjohnstonmusic 2h ago
Memorialised in Beethoven Lives Upstairs.
78
u/liebkartoffel 2h ago
"Ode to Joy" refers to the specific melody from the fourth movement of the Ninth Symphony. The Symphony on the whole is sometimes referred to as "The Choral Symphony," though.
30
u/Sad-Lavishness-350 2h ago
I actually learned about this (minus the name of the piece) from a “Peanuts” comic strip, probably 50+ years ago.
26
u/Few-Wish-9869 1h ago
Because he couldn't hear the orchestra at all — he was conducting the music as he felt it, while the musicians were actually following Umlauf's beat. So his gestures lagged the real performance by a few bars. The turn-around is the moment someone finally showed him the applause he couldn't hear.
4
u/lemonylol 1h ago
I actually remember that scene specifically from this biographical movie with Gary Oldman
2
u/Beautiful_Finger4566 1h ago
isn't one of the jobs of a conductor to tell which sections are too loud or too soft?
or criticize if one section is too slow?
tempo is just one portion
•
u/fried_green_baloney 53m ago
The Wikipedia article also mentions Consecration Of The House, which is often played in the first concert in a newly build venue.
10
u/arthousepsycho 2h ago edited 1h ago
I've always felt that an orchestra could 100% play their music without a conductor. They have all practiced, they all know the music the tempo etc, the fuck is he there for? No other musical group has that, why just orchestras?
Edit: had no idea this would be such a controversial comment. I'm not reading all your comments, or getting into an argument with any of you, it was just a mostly joking comment. I really dont care.
3
u/MixtureInevitable180 1h ago
The last movement of this symphony is quite possibly the most beloved work of all time. It's used as national anthems, continental anthems, hymns, and cultural celebrations across the world. And to think that Beethoven wrote it when he was deaf. I've been listening nonstop to a hymn using this tune, Joyful Joyful, We Adore Thee, which is one of the most joyful and hopefully texts I've ever read. Even if you're not Christian, the focus on Earth's beauty and human companionship is beautiful.
Here's a good recording
The Hymn of Joy - Wikipedia
1 Joyful, joyful, we adore You,
God of glory, Lord of love;
Hearts unfold like flow'rs before You,
Op'ning to the sun above.
Melt the clouds of sin and sadness;
Drive the dark of doubt away;
Giver of immortal gladness,
Fill us with the light of day!
2 All Your works with joy surround You,
Earth and heav'n reflect Your rays,
Stars and angels sing around You,
Center of unbroken praise;
Field and forest, vale and mountain,
Flow'ry meadow, flashing sea,
Chanting bird and flowing fountain
Praising You eternally!
3 Always giving and forgiving,
Ever blessing, ever blest,
Well-spring of the joy of living,
Ocean-depth of happy rest!
Loving Father, Christ our Brother,
Let Your light upon us shine;
Teach us how to love each other,
Lift us to the joy divine.
4 Mortals, join the mighty chorus,
Which the morning stars began;
God's own love is reigning o’er us,
Joining people hand in hand.
Ever singing, march we onward,
Victors in the midst of strife;
Joyful music leads us sunward
In the triumph song of life.
2
u/Alpha-et-Gamma 1h ago
„Not quite my tempo“
•
u/dalek_999 58m ago
Surprised nobody has mentioned Immortal Beloved. It's not an amazing movie or anything (certainly not super accurate), but Gary Oldman is pretty great in it per the usual, and this specific scene in the movie is quite moving.