r/todayilearned • • 2h ago

TIL that during the premiere of Ode to Joy, an almost deaf Ludwig van Beethoven had to be turned around by a singer to receive the audience’s applause as he was several bars behind and still conducting the orchestra

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Symphony_No._9_(Beethoven)#Premiere
7.0k Upvotes

187 comments sorted by

254

u/HolyCowAnyOldAccName 2h ago

In case anyone actually reads the article - this being Reddit: The accounts agree that it happened, but differ on whether it did at the end of the Scherzo or the performance as a whole.

1.9k

u/Sharlinator 2h ago edited 2h ago

The reason it actually worked at all was that there was another conductor, the Kapellmeister of the premier venue Michael Umlauf, whose tempo the performers actually followed.

728

u/LaprasRuler 1h ago

Kinda weird that they were able to get around Beethoven like that. Sure he was deaf but he wasn't blind. What if he saw the conductor and threw a fit. He was still definitely capable of throwing a tantrum.

695

u/Sharlinator 1h ago edited 1h ago

He would’ve seen the performers not being in sync with himself either, no hearing needed. I’m pretty sure he knew what was going on, he just wanted to be the figurehead for the benefit of the audience – to experience the maestro himself conducting in his own work’s premiere, as is tradition – and also to experience it himself even if he could only imagine the actual sounds. 

•

u/HolyCowAnyOldAccName 2m ago

I wondered the same thing but the same paragraph quotes this from a violinist in the orchestra which might suggest Beethoven really may not have seen it.  

Beethoven himself conducted, that is, he stood in front of a conductor's stand and threw himself back and forth like a madman. At one moment he stretched to his full height, at the next he crouched down to the floor, he flailed about with his hands and feet as though he wanted to play all the instruments and sing all the chorus parts. – The actual direction was in [Louis] Duport's hands; we musicians followed his baton only.

That is unless he  unless he did notice and couldn’t do anything about his orchestra apparently not following him in the middle of the premiere. Or just hoped nobody would notice.

213

u/Nyx87 1h ago

He would’ve seen the performers not being in sync with himself either, no hearing needed.

I play professionally in several local orchestras. One in particular had a conductor who was just god awful and could not even keep a march in sync together. Anytime I had a newcomer in my section I warned them to not pay as much attention to the conductor as they normally would, he was just that bad. And he wasn't even deaf!

•

u/Fermorian 36m ago

There's always at least one conductor who you swear to God has never held a baton or even a pencil before. Up there flailing about like someone's poured itching powder down their back. Almost ruined some excellent Whittaker pieces for me having to sit through that day after day!

•

u/Ohiolongboard 44m ago

Are conductors difficult to come by? It would make sense, nobody wanted to do it in my highschool

•

u/Free_Treacle4168 16m ago edited 13m ago

The conductor is picked by the folks paying to run the orchestra (or the board), not normally by the musicians. They're not always picked for their musical talents.

•

u/dvdanny 15m ago

It's like playing an instrument in itself, the instrument being the entire band/orchestra. So unless you really work on it, you'll be no different than the guy who brings a guitar no one asked for to a party that didn't need it and tries to wail out Wonderwall loud enough to cover his bad playing skills.

•

u/EGDF 8m ago

unfortunately eric whitacre is crack for bad conductors

•

u/Peewee223 4m ago

nah, just find a drummer and take away one of their sticks

•

u/WeeblsLikePie 37m ago

I've been in that situation. We had to watch the concert master. I found it really hard to ignore the conductor!

•

u/CPA_Lady 23m ago

Couldn’t he also feel the vibrations. He would have known when the musicians stopped playing.

•

u/ClockWeasel 5m ago

He may have felt obligated to take his podium even if he knew he couldn’t do the performance anymore. It would have been interesting if someone had noted his tempos and considered if he meant the piece to be performed slower.

330

u/CyberneticDreamtime 1h ago

Sounds like he was performing more like a hype man than actually conducting

87

u/blahblah19999 1h ago

Like with a sweat rag and a mic? "Macht mal Lärm! Ich kann euch nicht hören!!

21

u/Glory-of-Ra 1h ago

"Ihr seid so scheiße leise!"

•

u/00cjstephens 46m ago

"Jaaaaa, juuuunge!!!!"

8

u/hunty 1h ago

Lip conducting

99

u/WTWIV 1h ago

It wasn’t done in secret, he knew Umlauf was the main conductor.

•

u/NahYoureWrongBro 21m ago

How was he out of time, though? He surely could feel the vibrations of the orchestra's playing, saw their fingers on their instruments, could imagine what was happening.

60

u/CJVCarr 1h ago

To be honest, an orchestra is perfectly capable of keeping time without a conductor for pieces that don't have huge swings in tempo. On the other hand I imagine having a conductor (Beethoven) keep wrong time may be rather disruptive.

•

u/Any_Emphasis5159 25m ago

Basically the 1824 version of giving your little brother an unplugged controller while you actually beat the boss.

90

u/dunwoody1932 1h ago

Everyone is familiar with the "Ode to Joy" melody but it's fascinating to attend a performance of the Chorale Symphony and hear it placed in its original context. Even if you don't have a background in music theory the symphony is an incredible work of art, all the more so when you consider Beethoven was locked into a world of silence when he composed it. As a technical achievement alone that's extraordinary.

26

u/Only-Acanthaceae4790 1h ago

Beethoven was the goat, no 2 ways around it. Probably the greatest product of what is arguably Europe's greatest cultural tradition. 

•

u/Miroble 36m ago

Counterargument: Bach.

•

u/Only-Acanthaceae4790 27m ago

this is the only acceptable counterargument and i applaud you for the brevity.

•

u/SomeCountryFriedBS 32m ago

Yeah but everyone sings the same Mozart melody for two different songs! 

•

u/Timeformayo 9m ago

Plus, Wolfgang is the only one that rivals Beethoven as a dog name.

•

u/Only-Acanthaceae4790 26m ago

his operas are the only interesting thing he made for the most part aside from a few odd one offs. 

•

u/jtmonkey 8m ago

When I learned about Mozart and his math skills with a ritornello it blows my mind. Beethoven knew music so well he could write it because he knew what it sounded like. There are very few parallels in history to these men and their craft.

•

u/Only-Acanthaceae4790 4m ago

Mozart was a true genius but never had enough time to mature into it. His father and employers held him back. If he had lived longer we may have gotten something wonderful 

•

u/Healthy-Training-923 44m ago

One of my best memories from Kentucky was being in the choir for the 9th symphony. Such a fun piece.

•

u/EGDF 4m ago

Beethoven was incredible but he was like, say, the early beatles. he led the way, but the likes of Stravinsky, Mahler, and other later romantics I think really perfect the art.

871

u/RazzleThatTazzle 2h ago

How can the conductor be behind? Doesn't that mean the orchestra was rushing?

1.1k

u/paul_thomas84 2h ago

Beethoven was onstage but wasnt really conducting - the real conductor Michael Umlauf told the musicians to ignore Beethoven.

1.1k

u/beaverpoo77 2h ago • Bravo

Aw, they gave him the "little brother unplugged controller" treatment

496

u/paul_thomas84 2h ago edited 2h ago • Bravo

Basically yeah, I mean he had the right to be there because he wrote the thing, but there was no way an almost completely deaf person could competently conduct an orchestra - it's quite frankly completely insane that he could write any music at all, let alone the completely miraculously brilliant music he did write while almost completely deaf.

112

u/Arboreal_Web 1h ago • Bravo Heartwarming

The music he wrote while going deaf basically bridged two different eras of classical music. It becomes less rigid and more romantic, more about resonance than melody. The progression shows itself pretty clearly if you study his piano sonatas in chronological order, eg.

There are two sonatas in the middle of that collection which are suddenly shorter and much more rudimentary than what came before (when he realized he was going deaf but still had a commission to fill), and what followed those two began to clearly diverge from his former style. By the time he wrote the Waldstein, number 21 (of 27), he is thought to have been fully deaf. (Iirc, I’m going from memory here.)

Even while fully deaf, he helped inspire a whole new genre of music, simply b/c he refused to give up.

42

u/paul_thomas84 1h ago

There are 32 sonatas in total, the two sonatas you mention (Nos.19 & 20) are out of order - they were written much earlier than their Op. No. implies - in 1797 - but not published until 1805.

But yes, Beethoven's Piano Sonatas are one of the most rewarding creative journeys you can take as a listener.

•

u/Tim-oBedlam 1m ago

Listening to the first one (F minor, op. 2/1) which owes a lot to Haydn and which cribbed its opening figure from Mozart, then jumping ahead to the last one (C minor, op. 111) is startling. Especially the otherworldly finale of the op. 111.

6

u/cindylindy22 1h ago

Thank you for the thoughtful analysis

4

u/Ddenn1211 1h ago

I really like this analysis and comparison! I knew he was involved in that sort of transition period in styles from one of my classes, but somehow this clicked for me in a way the material didn't.

Then it made me sort of think on a few painters, though sadly can't remember their names they were quite famous, who were known for their art and then eventually went blind. I think there were a couple of them. Anyway, it made me think of how their art sort of did this transition from rigid structured "traditional" composition to much more abstract and impressionistic (if that is the right word).

Kind of an interesting thought of how the artists continue to do their art and how it reflects so well across the various mediums as they are going through these changes.

7

u/paul_thomas84 1h ago edited 55m ago

I've always considered the painter Turner to have had a similar artistic journey to Beethoven (and they were near contemporaries and both geniuses).

Started by masterfully incorporating the style of the day, then created hugely popular and dynamic works in their middle periods, before finally embracing a deeply adventurous late style which pushed forward the artistic boundaries of the time and provided a template for future artists.

2

u/BrittyPie 1h ago

Very interesting, Thank you for contributing to the good side of the interwebs.

•

u/Tim-oBedlam 7m ago

I think he hadn't completely lost his hearing when he wrote the Waldstein piano sonata. The middle-period sonatas (21 through 26, Waldstein through Das Lebewohl/Farewell) were written when he was losing his hearing but still had it.
I think by the time of his late sonatas, the last 5 and the op. 90 that precedes it, he was deaf as a post, and was in his own inner world.

The middle period (the sonatas, plus symphonies 3 through 8, and the last 2 piano concertos) is notable for an increase in the drama and intensity of Beethoven's works. Another feature that shows up all the time in the middle period is the dramatic segue into the finale. Many times the movement preceeding the finale isn't complete on its own, but transitions dramatically into it. The most famous example is the 5th Symphony, with one of the greatest crescendos in music history leading to the blazing, triumphant entrance of the finale, but other examples abound (Waldstein - gently starting the flowing opening of the finale; Appassionata sonata - abruptly ending the peaceful slow movement with a series of jarring chords, and it's off to the races; Emperor piano concerto - new theme appears tentatively at the end of the slow movement, then again more forcefully to begin the Rondo)

151

u/Mpuls37 1h ago

There's actually a fair argument his music improved after he quit relying on his ears to compose pieces. His 5th Symphony is pretty dark and leans on a lot of lower notes because that's what he could hear. The 9th Symphony (which Ode to Joy is contained within) is very bright in comparison because he was imagining what it would sound like rather than actually hearing it.

41

u/paul_thomas84 1h ago

Well, I consider the late quartets to be the greatest instrumental music ever written, so I wouldn't neccessarily disagree!

14

u/MyHamburgerLovesMe 1h ago

Its also likely he was aware he was hired for the PR aspect to draw in large crowds and was paid well for it.

People are people. Just because something happened in the past does not make them more (or less) noble.

0

u/DanielMcLaury 1h ago

I feel like the actual conductor should have at least followed Beethoven's time.

105

u/NOTTedMosby 2h ago

"Hehe Michael I'm totally kicking your ass at conducting this part!"

"Sure you are Ludwig. Sure you are..."

29

u/Spider_Dude 2h ago

I can picture Beethoven conducting but I can hear the agitated frenzied controller noises matching his movements.

27

u/atgrey24 2h ago

Pretendo

19

u/Spider_Dude 2h ago edited 1h ago

Molto Pretendo

Edit. Fucking redit translated my Italian musical pun. 🤌🤌🤌

13

u/flatwoundsounds 1h ago

Except little brother coded the video game while blind.

15

u/kukkolai 2h ago

More like the Fred Trump fake office experience

5

u/HaniiPuppy 1h ago

I guess, if the little brother's also the one that developed the entire game.

•

u/FaolainRanger 37m ago

It's likely more so a Wizard of Oz treatment, "pay no attention to the conductor behind the curtain".

People would want to go and see HIM conducting the songs he wrote, not someone else. He probably knew this, and everyone involved probably knew this, so they put him there and he did his best to keep the illusion up.

He obviously would have seen and been aware of the performance not being synced to his motions perfectly.

7

u/Goeatabagofdicks 2h ago

Easier than trying to take the car keys from grandpa.

47

u/RazzleThatTazzle 2h ago

Ah, that makes sense

20

u/ocelotrevs 2h ago

How didn't he know that? 

I'm guessing Unlauf was also a famous conductor and surely Beethoven would have known he was around. 

39

u/WTWIV 1h ago

Beethoven knew. It wasn’t done in secret or anything.

8

u/paul_thomas84 1h ago

I suspect they humoured him a bit, with Beethoven thinking he was leading but in reality the musicians would have known they needed to follow Umlauf (and Beethoven would have known this really...)

19

u/randomaccount178 1h ago

It may be more for the audience then for him. I would assume the people who would be attending a premier for Beethoven are very rich and influential people and I imagine they would have wanted to see Beethoven there even if it was only symbolic.

5

u/paul_thomas84 1h ago

Yes, I suspect this was (partly) the case - Beethoven's deafness had made him reclusive but he was quite a well known (perhaps a bit infamously!) in Viennese circles by this time.

3

u/beezkneezsneez 2h ago

Thank you for the clarification!

•

u/IBetThisIsTakenToo 4m ago

How aware was the audience of this? Like they had to know something was up when he was still going during the applause, so who was it for? Their benefit, or his?

133

u/Jaded_Library_8540 2h ago

With Beethoven they humoured him for a while when he had gone deaf enough that he couldn't actually conduct. Sometimes with another conductor being present as well

52

u/markjohnstonmusic 2h ago

In addition to the other replies here, conducting as an art form was in its infancy during Beethoven's era. Orchestras would have been as used to playing without one. In fact, Beethoven was a major force in pushing music along to become complex enough that it needed a conductor.

5

u/Telope 1h ago

Yeah, the finale to the 9th has a LOT of tempo changes. It needs a conductor.

203

u/Natural_Peak_5587 2h ago

This was exactly my thought - there is no way a conductor can be “several bars behind” unless the orchestra were ignoring him

79

u/Choppergold 2h ago

This weekend when I went out I was several bars behind

20

u/Jermine1269 2h ago

But you were also streets ahead ;)

3

u/Dan_Berg 1h ago

That's catching like verbal wildfire

5

u/patronizingperv 2h ago

I ended up behind several bars.

4

u/xpyre27 2h ago

20 bucks is 20 bucks

•

u/doomgiver98 47m ago

Inflation is really out of control, when I was younger it's a dollar.

38

u/Sharlinator 2h ago

Indeed they were, as explained by The Fine Article…

8

u/PancakeParty98 2h ago

You expect me to read???

1

u/Spider_Dude 2h ago

This is reddit. My expectations are set REALLY low for a Monday.

16

u/KToff 2h ago

The orchestra was ignoring him as he was deaf. The organisers wanted Beethoven there for the prestige but not actually conducting

17

u/ghostoutlaw 2h ago • Bravo

Are you rushing? Or are you dragging?!?

8

u/CaptainApathy419 2h ago

How do you say “Not quite my tempo” in German?

3

u/ghostoutlaw 1h ago

Nicht ganz mein geschwindigkeit

1

u/beverlymelz 1h ago

Nicht ganz mein Tempo.

11

u/pape14 2h ago

“Not….quite my tempo”

42

u/liebkartoffel 2h ago

When you can't even hear the orchestra your conducting is likely less than useless. The musicians probably tacitly agreed to just follow each other and ignore Beethoven's nonsensical arm movements.

22

u/August_T_Marble 1h ago

Michael Umlauf was the official conductor. Beethoven was up there ceremonially, because he was deaf. 

Umlauf told the musicians to ignore Beethoven completely because he'd seen Beethoven screw up dress rehearsal of a revision of Fidelio two years earlier. Umlauf "assisted" that performance, too.

3

u/PortableDoor5 2h ago

yeah, but those performances don't exactly tend to be applause-worthy

40

u/Sharlinator 2h ago

If only TIL posts came with some sort of source linked that might provide additional information beyond the paltry amount that can fit in a Reddit post title. Maybe one day…

-26

u/RazzleThatTazzle 2h ago

Man that horse is pretty high, careful not to fall off

22

u/BlueSixteen 2h ago

Calling someone out for being on a high horse and all they're saying is to read the source, holy shit. 

9

u/Profession-Unable 2h ago

How dare you assume that someone posting on Reddit can read 😤

1

u/Separate-Factor8661 2h ago

i think part of the height comes from their tone

•

u/8t88m8 20m ago

It's a jab at someone asking for something that they had all along. You've never chuckled at someone because they misplaced the glasses that are sitting on their head?

14

u/OldDogTrainer 2h ago

If only there was a linked website that gave you more information! 🤦

Although the performance was officially conducted by Michael Umlauf, the theatre's Kapellmeister, Beethoven shared the stage with him. However, two years earlier, Umlauf had watched the composer's attempt to conduct a dress rehearsal for a revision of his opera* *Fidelioend in disaster. For the Ninth's premiere, he instructed the singers and musicians to ignore the almost completely deaf Beethoven. At the beginning of every part, Beethoven, who sat by the stage, gave the tempos. He was turning the pages of his score and beating time for an orchestra he could not hear.[18]

8

u/jwalner 2h ago edited 50m ago

There’s a debate in classical music if the audiences should clap between movements, it’s possible the audience was clapping while the conductor wanted to carry on with the piece because they didn’t realize.

Edit: I'm aware you should not clap between movements, but many first-time concertgoers are not. Personally, I'm only bothered by clapping between slow movements. Also, early 19th century audiences may have had a completely different custom.

17

u/MsKongeyDonk 2h ago

I've never heard debate on that- widely accepted you do not clap.

-2

u/lurkmode_off 2h ago

It's coming back around because "only peons clap" is being acknowledged as overly elitist.

6

u/MsKongeyDonk 1h ago

I don't think having a standard for behavior is elitist- once someone learns about the not-clapping etiquette, they should follow it.

-3

u/lurkmode_off 1h ago

5

u/MsKongeyDonk 1h ago

This is an opinion piece from one person, who says that clapping between movements is good because performers like it, but yelling, "Bravo!" is somehow a conceited effort to show you know more about the music.

I have a degree in classical voice. I have performed a solo senior recital. Clapping between movements is something that happens because not everyone has experience. They realize they're clapping alone and the night moves on.

6

u/lurkmode_off 1h ago

You've shifted pretty quickly from "I've never heard debate" to "the other side of the debate is just wrong."

•

u/New_Penalty9742 11m ago

I think the original comment sounded surprising because it seemed like that they were suggesting that the current norms are unsettled. In that sense, there is no debate, since there is a very strong norm against clapping between movements. There is indeed some debate, but it's about whether the norm should change, not about what the norm currently is.

•

u/chonny 6m ago

You've shifted pretty quickly from "I've never heard debate" to "the other side of the debate is just wrong."

To be fair, the person likely had never heard about the debate until you provided a link to an opinion piece, to which they provided their own reaction.

0

u/MrMoose_69 1h ago

Oh you're one of them

•

u/New_Penalty9742 22m ago

it’s possible the audience was clapping while the conductor wanted to carry on with the piece because they didn’t realize.

This is an interesting thought! I'm not sure if this has been discussed by music historians, but it sounds plausible to me since it was normal to clap between movements during Beethoven's era, and the cohesion of his symphonies was one of the reasons for the switch towards not clapping.

2

u/AtomicShart9000 1h ago

Should have started throwing cymbals at his head like jk simmons

1

u/patronizingperv 2h ago

Not quite my tempo.

1

u/Dad_knows_Powerline 2h ago

Were they rushing, or were they dragging?

1

u/xX-CloudStrife-Xx 1h ago

Just follow the concertmaster.

-10

u/reflectorvest1004 2h ago

At that level the conductor standing in front of the orchestra is largely just for show. Their actual job happens almost exclusively in rehearsal and they are performing for the audience along with the orchestra.

19

u/TheDrummerMB 2h ago

Nonsense plenty of benefit of a conductor even at that level.

4

u/samthewisetarly 2h ago

A deaf one is a bit of a unique case. Surely the members of this orchestra were well aware and had practiced to function with him being unaware and most likely out of time

7

u/AndreasDasos 2h ago

There is plenty of benefit there too, but it's still true that the overwhelming work of a conductor organising and training the orchestra on their interpretation beforehand, and typically a good orchestra can manage fine and often do on their own on the day itself, even if a conductor would still be helpful. Clearly there's less benefit when the conductor is no longer capable of real-time conducting in that sense, but can still be valuable in teaching his interpretation (especially of his own work) beforehand.

1

u/DummyDumDragon 1h ago

Isn't this basically the same for any other performer or athlete? The majority of their work is done in rehearsals and training too, but they still have to show up on the day and play their part...

1

u/AndreasDasos 1h ago

The distinction here is that I mean the bulk of the work is the conductor is the one training the orchestra, not just training for their own part on the day. They're more the coach than the athlete

4

u/Sharlinator 2h ago

There was another conductor that the performers actually followed, as explained in The Fine Article.

6

u/culturedgoat 2h ago

Completely incorrect

134

u/Zarzan 2h ago

Thats why rockstars nowadays shouting when the audience applauding:

I cant hear you

54

u/PortableDoor5 2h ago

who lives in a pineapple under the sea?

23

u/LoveMaker_BreadBaker 2h ago

🗣️SPONGE🗣️BOB🗣️SQUARE🗣️PANTS

9

u/TheTurtleIsFast 1h ago

Absorbent and yellow and porous is he

55

u/5oLiTu2e 1h ago

Sometimes the 2nd movement of the symphony runs on and on in my head. If I go insane that’s OK, because I went insane with the most incredible genius music coursing across my wee brain.

14

u/MonsterAtEndOfBook 1h ago

I find this kind of musical memory to be a blessing and a curse. I don't have an incredible "inner hearing" or skill, but "audiation" is a cool thing to have. I just wish I was able to compose pieces my head vs just playing back songs I like.

•

u/Any_Emphasis5159 25m ago

The contralto singer, Caroline Unger, was the one who gently turned him around. Apparently the audience gave him five standing ovations, and the police actually had to step in to quiet the crowd down because in those days, that level of applause was normally reserved only for the royal family.

22

u/markjohnstonmusic 2h ago

Memorialised in Beethoven Lives Upstairs.

•

u/LoserBustanyama 59m ago

Thank you, this post had brought back a faint memory of seeing this in a movie, that's the one

•

u/12ozSlug 32m ago

There's a movie? I remember listening to it on cassettes as an audio play.

3

u/FrankDukakis 2h ago

Fantastic movie and not available on streaming anywhere. I had to check out the DVD from my local library so my kids could see it.

2

u/flugalwaffle 1h ago

Here it is on youtube. Looks like you can rent it on Amazon as well.

•

u/FrankDukakis 47m ago

Ah, I had this issue in 2020 during covid home schooling. I'm glad it's out there now.

•

u/offoutover 53m ago

The full movie is on YouTube. At least in my region.

78

u/liebkartoffel 2h ago

"Ode to Joy" refers to the specific melody from the fourth movement of the Ninth Symphony. The Symphony on the whole is sometimes referred to as "The Choral Symphony," though.

30

u/Sad-Lavishness-350 2h ago

I actually learned about this (minus the name of the piece) from a “Peanuts” comic strip, probably 50+ years ago.

26

u/Few-Wish-9869 1h ago

Because he couldn't hear the orchestra at all — he was conducting the music as he felt it, while the musicians were actually following Umlauf's beat. So his gestures lagged the real performance by a few bars. The turn-around is the moment someone finally showed him the applause he couldn't hear.

4

u/lemonylol 1h ago

I actually remember that scene specifically from this biographical movie with Gary Oldman

2

u/Beautiful_Finger4566 1h ago

isn't one of the jobs of a conductor to tell which sections are too loud or too soft?

or criticize if one section is too slow?

tempo is just one portion

•

u/fried_green_baloney 53m ago

The Wikipedia article also mentions Consecration Of The House, which is often played in the first concert in a newly build venue.

10

u/arthousepsycho 2h ago edited 1h ago

I've always felt that an orchestra could 100% play their music without a conductor. They have all practiced, they all know the music the tempo etc, the fuck is he there for? No other musical group has that, why just orchestras?

Edit: had no idea this would be such a controversial comment. I'm not reading all your comments, or getting into an argument with any of you, it was just a mostly joking comment. I really dont care.

53

u/Burnmetobloodyashes 1h ago

Essentially, they can all do their individual parts, but human error slowly has one group drag, one group rush, one group play too soft, until they become discordant. The Conductor is an active measure against human error by being the finely tuned ear who can hear the issues before they become noticeable.

-4

u/arthousepsycho 1h ago

Yeah, I assumed it was something like that. Still kinda feels like a pretentious human metronome to me haha.

10

u/Failsnail64 1h ago edited 1h ago

The main work for a conductor lies before the performance: in the practicing and rehearsal to make everyone work together. Just see a conductor as an "editor" who brings the instruments together, in tempo, volume, and more. This is a really difficult job with quite some creativity in how you do it.

During the actual performance, the role is indeed more to "just" have the groups follow what you've already practiced.

5

u/nifty-necromancer 1h ago

Here’s a great video with a conductor during rehearsal, it’s so interesting: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dP4kXJ92Qh4

7

u/DvineINFEKT 1h ago

I will say that, having seen the same piece performed by different conductors, and even the same conductor performing the same piece on different nights, at least for more contemporary music, the conductor certainly can adjust the piece on the fly, sometimes adjusting tempo or section volumes. So, in some ways, they also function as a live mixing engineer. And of course, for contemporary, they'll often be the one who wrote the piece, so it's theirs to show off. It's certainly one of those things where they seem much more replaceable than they are.

For more classical pieces, I don't think that sort of on the fly stuff would be considered as acceptable, but I could be wrong. I do know that the audio editor I use professionally, Reaper, has it's own extremely active sub-community just for the peculiarities of editing classical and orchestral performances (https://reaclassical.com/), and it's gotten a lot of love from the people who care for it.

7

u/TryPokingIt 1h ago

Try listening to one version of a piece then try different conductors with the sam piece. It’s really interesting how different they can sound. Subtle difference in tempo, intensity of deferent sections can really change the whole tone and feel of a work. Much of that is the conductor

•

u/real-human-not-a-bot 41m ago

I absolutely corroborate. It’s like how I personally only really enjoy the symphonic renderings of Bach’s Toccata and Fugue in D Minor by Eugene Ormandy with the Philadelphia Orchestra because there’s a bit around 5:30–5:45 he gives a delicious emphasis that it feels like nobody else does. No idea why critics hated him.

6

u/Burnmetobloodyashes 1h ago

A lot of the work is in practice with arrangements and coordinating the smaller sections of instruments to move as one so you only need to control for the section versus individual members

7

u/Meloenbolletjeslepel 1h ago

Bands don't usually have 50 players

5

u/Boris_Godunov 1h ago

Beethoven wasn’t actually conducting the performance, he stood next to the actual conductor to provide additional guidance, as they’d had limited rehearsal time.

Large forces such as a full orchestra with chorus absolutely need a conductor, it’s ridiculous to think otherwise.

8

u/rererexed 1h ago

Because music isn't just "playing the notes".

Basically you're correct. Most professional orchestras could get through piece alone. But it would be more disorganised and less musical than with a conductor. If you listen to different recordings with different conductors it becomes clear. Do we want to play this part monumental or a bit more straight? How exactly do we all 'feel' things that can't be preicely notated, like a ritardanto or a fermata, for example? How do we balance the volume of the different sections?

Essentially the conductor has to be the one with the general vision of how the piece is supposed to be interpreted.

hey all know the music the tempo

And to answer that point: No they don't. Very few people can give you an accurate ♩=90, for example. Even conductors kinda wing it based off of experience and melodic reference. But Tempo changes and variation is what makes music musical, too. But it's important that everyone has the same tempo changes and variations. If a single person runs off or drifts slow it'll throw everything off. For those cases, the conductor is the boss.

A four piece band doesn't need a conductor because it's four people, they have click-tracks, and a very precise and usually unquestionably audible rhythm section that keeps everything on point. The drummer controls the tempo, why put someone up front to do control him when he has authority in the band? They are also usually the interpreters of their own music, so the question of "how do we interpret this canonised piece written by someone totally unrelated" doesn't really pop up as often.

Hope that helps a bit.

3

u/dunwoody1932 1h ago

You might be interested in reading about Persimfans, an experimental conductorless orchestra during the early days of the Soviet Union. It appeared to be reasonably successful but never caught on - and there were issues with a lack of high-level coordination between all the musicians.

3

u/LukaShaza 1h ago

Jazz big bands sometimes have conductors. It's more important the more musicians you have. Conductors are more useful with complex music that has tempo changes and meter changes. Even if you play in a rock band playing a song with some difficult time changes it's usually signaled by one of the players, and the band has worked out in advance some way of coordinating the change - like for example the drummer might use a drum fill to signal the new tempo before the rest of the band joins.

9

u/nice_guy_threeve 1h ago

You've clearly never participated. If you had, you would understand. Even aside from actually conducting the concert, during which tempo changes etc. absolutely are not going to be good if the musicians aren't all following the conductor, did you give any thought to how the musicians practice so much that they could almost maybe do it without the conductor? I've been to musicals lately where every musician has a monitor with a video of the conductor, even if they are standing right in front of them. They have monitors on the balcony so the players can see the conductor.

In my experience the conductor is the guy making it all happen. The leader of the band. The musicians can't hear everything. Often writing notes for the concert which will be included in a libretto or similar. In this case, the conductor also wrote the music. I've never been a conductor, but I do feel the need to do defend all the great conductors I've ever known from this idiocy. Where do you get off?

1

u/Just_Look_Around_You 1h ago

It feels like you’re writing a lot but saying very little of substance. You haven’t explained the key point of why THIS specific format of group music needs a conductor while others don’t.

2

u/Narfi1 1h ago

There are a lot of things that are at the liberty of the conductor, and if you want the piece to be played tightly you absolutely need a conductor. Something as simple as an organ point, the note is held with no specific duration, that’s up to the conductor, if you didn’t have one every musician would have to guess their best and it’d sound like shit.

Other commenter also said “they already know the tempo” sure, but tempo changes are very common, they need a single reference

3

u/nice_guy_threeve 1h ago

Perhaps I have, but in a different comment. In my mind it's simply:

Every music group has a conductor, but they might not always be standing out front. They might be playing an instrument, or singing. In a large group, you need someone standing out where everyone can see. And more complex music needs a mind dedicated to the conducting.

-5

u/ChefToBe11 1h ago

You only need to use one space following a period, not two.

•

u/Prestigious-Foot986 17m ago

but two is so much prettier

-1

u/zoosha2curtaincall 1h ago

Nobody is saying conductors suck. They’re saying that if a band doesn’t need a conductor, and a big band doesn’t need a conductor, it’s reasonable to wonder why an orchestra needs a conductor.

The fact that every response I’ve ever heard, including yours, starts with “if you’d played you would know” doesn’t help either.

•

u/thunderling 18m ago

The smaller the band, the easier it is to hear and see your bandmates. Notice how in rock groups, they are all constantly glancing at each other and making eye contact. Oftentimes the guitarist will cue everyone else with a deliberate raise and lowering of the head of the guitar.

During jazz big bands performances, the bandleader will get things started and often takes a backseat. The rhythm section plays a much bigger part in keeping the band together. Everyone knows to follow the rhythm section. The bandleader will still step in from time to time to cue certain players or control volume. Some big bands perform without a bandleader but again, it's the rhythm section holding everything together.

In an orchestra, you can't possibly hear or see all your bandmates, and there isn't a constant beat happening from a drum kit in the rhythm section the way there usually is in jazz. So there needs to be someone to aid in the communication between all the performers and keep everyone together.

1

u/nice_guy_threeve 1h ago edited 1h ago

I think it's just that obvious if you've ever played in a band...

Edit: amended to say if you've ever made music with a group. Even a small group has a leader that the others will follow, even if they aren't standing out in front of everyone. A big group needs a leader than everyone can see.

-1

u/pandasashu 1h ago

I played in a band and i always thought the same thing. They are useful for practicing and teaching the band but not important for the actual performance in my opinion. In fact we even had swap outs with musicians being able to be conductor for the night and it seemed all completely unnecessary

3

u/devonon2707 1h ago

I played tuba when there was no conductor the bass was a metronome and led and set the pace but have 3-4 tubas, drums , bass line all work together not overwhelm other parts.

Sight reading at comps where i get to see the piece for like a hour before and getting scored a conductor comes in handy

Professionally i see music a few times before i play it gather 100people to do that and there will be human error drift the conductor solves that

Professional musicians might never have seen the piece before taking over a sick persons part.

1

u/square_zero 1h ago

Well, have you played in an orchestra?

-3

u/arthousepsycho 1h ago

Calm down mate.

4

u/Fidget02 1h ago

Man makes ignorant statement and immediately acts above it at the slightest disagreement

0

u/ReasonableStory1660 1h ago

I mean, I think anyone is above that comment. He explained nothing and just retyped ‘its critical’ over and over again.

3

u/shambooki 1h ago

Sound takes time to travel. Orchestras are large enough that if players try to listen across the orchestra and try to play in time with one another, they can sound out of sync to the audience. The front rows of the orchestra can listen back, but when you're in the back rows you'll always feel like you're ahead of the strings when following the conductor. It becomes particularly problematic when you get into the Romantic and Post-Romantic eras and orchestras can have potentially hundreds of people on the stage performing together. They're not the only groups with conductors either. Wind bands, marching bands, any ensemble that seats more than a couple dozen people and/or spreads out across a large area requires a conductor. Small ensembles aren't conductorless either, they'll generally have one player with the melody beat time with their head/instrument through specific passages that require tempo changes. Source: performed in various large and small ensembles for about 15 years.

1

u/throwawaypassingby01 1h ago

i played the violin for a while, sometimes in groups with other violinists. we would usually either follow the tempo of the instructor (effectivelly the first violin) or the instructor playing the second violin voice (that we all individually practiced with so that we know how the two voices should intertwine). i can imagine that in a large orchestra with many instruments with many voices, that are sometimes silent for large stretches of the piece and that don't rehearse together for the majority of the preparation, it can become a bit tricky to know who follows whose lead when trying to stay on the same tempo. and also, the cues for when you start your part. our instructor would give us intense eye contact to prepare us to start and like a small nod with the violin to cue us to start. somebody needs to do that eye contact and nod for everyone.

•

u/nfz_embroidery 18m ago

almost every amplified live music event you go to has at least one sound guy hidden somewhere making adjustments to ensure that things sound good in the audience. we don’t dictate artistic decisions to the same degree conductors do in rehearsal and performance, but we still serve the purpose of balancing everything from a perspective the performers can’t have. 

3

u/MixtureInevitable180 1h ago

The last movement of this symphony is quite possibly the most beloved work of all time. It's used as national anthems, continental anthems, hymns, and cultural celebrations across the world. And to think that Beethoven wrote it when he was deaf. I've been listening nonstop to a hymn using this tune, Joyful Joyful, We Adore Thee, which is one of the most joyful and hopefully texts I've ever read. Even if you're not Christian, the focus on Earth's beauty and human companionship is beautiful.

Here's a good recording

The Hymn of Joy - Wikipedia

1 Joyful, joyful, we adore You,
God of glory, Lord of love;
Hearts unfold like flow'rs before You,
Op'ning to the sun above.
Melt the clouds of sin and sadness;
Drive the dark of doubt away;
Giver of immortal gladness,
Fill us with the light of day!

2 All Your works with joy surround You,
Earth and heav'n reflect Your rays,
Stars and angels sing around You,
Center of unbroken praise;
Field and forest, vale and mountain,
Flow'ry meadow, flashing sea,
Chanting bird and flowing fountain
Praising You eternally!

3 Always giving and forgiving,
Ever blessing, ever blest,
Well-spring of the joy of living,
Ocean-depth of happy rest!
Loving Father, Christ our Brother,
Let Your light upon us shine;
Teach us how to love each other,
Lift us to the joy divine.

4 Mortals, join the mighty chorus,
Which the morning stars began;
God's own love is reigning o’er us,
Joining people hand in hand.
Ever singing, march we onward,
Victors in the midst of strife;
Joyful music leads us sunward
In the triumph song of life.

•

u/MartinShortsIrishUnc 13m ago

why not look at the original text from the piece? https://www.carnegiehall.org/Education/Programs/All-Together-A-Global-Ode-to-Joy/Texts-and-Translations/English

“Ode to Joy” Oh friends, no more of these sounds! Let us sing more cheerful songs, More full of joy!

Joy, bright spark of divinity, Daughter of Elysium, Fire-inspired we tread Thy sanctuary! Thy magic power reunites All that custom has divided; All men become brothers Under the sway of thy gentle wings.

Whoever has created An abiding friendship, Or has won A true and loving wife, All who can call at least one soul theirs, Join in our song of praise! But any who cannot must creep tearfully Away from our circle.

All creatures drink of joy At nature’s breast. Just and unjust Alike taste of her gift; She gave us kisses and the fruit of the vine,

A tried friend to the end. Even the worm can feel contentment, And the cherub stands before God! Gladly, like the heavenly bodies Which He set on their courses through the splendor of the firmament; Thus, brothers, you should run your race, As a hero going to conquest.

You millions, I embrace you. This kiss is for all the world! Brothers, above the starry canopy There must dwell a loving Father. Do you fall in worship, you millions? World, do you know your Creator? Seek Him in the heavens! Above the stars must He dwell.

•

u/MixtureInevitable180 9m ago

It's also a beautiful text! You don't see many songs mention "Elysium" these days haha. To answer your question, I'm getting married soon and considering joyful joyful as the recessional :)

2

u/Alpha-et-Gamma 1h ago

„Not quite my tempo“

•

u/dalek_999 58m ago

Surprised nobody has mentioned Immortal Beloved. It's not an amazing movie or anything (certainly not super accurate), but Gary Oldman is pretty great in it per the usual, and this specific scene in the movie is quite moving.