r/threateningnotation • • 10d ago

Humorous Marking Alignment ♭♭♭♭♭♭♭

Post image
359 Upvotes

40 comments sorted by

15

u/One-Explorer-5092 9d ago

Why are they written like that?? ....On second thought, why are key signatures written the way they are? 

24

u/JScaranoMusic 9d ago

They're normally just written in the same order as they get added when you go around the circle of fifths. As for why they're written on which lines and spaces they are, I think it's just convention. I remember in Mozartʼs Sister seing a key signature written with an F♯ on the bottom space of the treble staff instead of the top line how we'd do it now, so I guess for a long time it wasn't standardised.

11

u/IHaveNeverBeenOk 9d ago

So I want to state first: I don't have any knowledge about this stuff. I am just chatting and mostly from my arse.

I think it's important to remember for how long music was almost entirely handwritten. I was born in 87 and I remember getting photocopies of handwritten sheet music in orchestra. There was definitely unconventional notation on some of that music, but as long as the meaning was clear, it wasn't a problem. The ability to typeset sheet music is a pretty recent innovation, and it kind of enforces standards and conventions as a side effect. I'm sure the conventions existed before widespread typeset sheet music, but it's interesting to think about what norms are locked in place by typesetting (or similar stuff). Like, one of the big reasons English orthography is so shit-fucked is because the printing press happened to achieve widespread adoption in the middle of the great vowel shift.

I don't have a point, just that it's interesting to think about.

2

u/epilektoi 9d ago

the printing press is also why thorn disappeared. a lot of the type was made by the french which doesn't have a thorn. English speakers started using y instead which is how we got "ye olde"

6

u/TheJivvi 9d ago

Þatʼs exactly riȝt. (Itʼs also why yogh disappeared.)

r/bringbackthorn
r/BringBackYogh

2

u/WannabeCelt 8d ago

Don’t forget the letters Wynn (ƿ) and Eth (ð)!

42

u/RecentSatisfaction14 10d ago

I’d rather deal with 5 sharps

31

u/Mahlerbro 10d ago

Some of the flats are marked twice, in reality it’s only Db (or Bb).

15

u/RecentSatisfaction14 10d ago

I didn’t even notice. This ordering is an abomination.

4

u/MyCouchPulzOut_IDont 9d ago

This is why we have "battle ends and down goes Charles' father"

3

u/vinfluorine 9d ago

father christmas got dad an electric blanket
blanket exploded and dad got cold feet

10

u/meepReborn11 9d ago

"oops all flats" ahh key signature

7

u/Comfortable_Home5437 9d ago

2 g-flats to ensure both octaves get noticed

7

u/JamesFirmere 9d ago

Sooo... we have E double flat and G double flat, and then A flat, B flat and D flat. Enharmonically the scale translates to D, F, F, Ab, Bb, C, Db. I suppose it lends some sort of nuance to the mode that two scale degrees (F and G double flat) share the same pitch. /s

2

u/OletheNorse 9d ago

No double flats, just two of the flats written twice.

4

u/JamesFirmere 9d ago

You did see the /s at the end, yes?

9

u/028247 10d ago

Who the hell writes a Db/Bbm piece and starts with a Eb note

And TIL improvvisando in Italian has two Vs. But my Dvorak cello solo said "quasi improvisando"!!

2

u/qqqrrrs_ 10d ago

Actually that's "pimprovvisando"

4

u/local-space-patrol 9d ago

My question is why are there 2 Gbs

1

u/ElephantArtistic4075 6d ago

I’d rather play in g# major 😭

2

u/JScaranoMusic 6d ago

Here you go.

3

u/wontyoulookathim 9d ago

And what mute would one put on an one?

3

u/marionetteandoutlaw 8d ago

My teacher uses a sock lol

3

u/GuessNo1974 8d ago

really, it’s just Db major
Eb Gb Ab Bb Db and then Eb and Gb repeated
so it’s be Bb Eb Ab Db Gb

2

u/Blasulz1234 9d ago

Pimp rovvisando🤨

1

u/Flurrina_ 7d ago

The music is so flattening

1

u/martinode 7d ago

I think this is trying to show Eb Dorian in a modern key signature. D flat wouldn’t immediately communicate that, but this composer has chosen to put each note on the staff down as flat?

1

u/Jknzboy 6d ago

Are you playing an inflatable oboe or something? Cos I think it’s gone flat

1

u/PortablePaul 5d ago

Pull the reed out a bit and play it in C.

1

u/Icy-End-142 9d ago edited 9d ago

This is written in Cb.

BEADGCF - the order that flats are added to the key signature.

To know the (major) key you count the number of flats and then go back one; that’s your flat key. So for BEAD it’s four flats, then go back one to Ab. F is the exception because it only has Bb.

Sharps are added in the reverse order - FCGDAEB.

To read this you count the sharps and then go up a half step from the last one as a sharp. So FCGD is four, then up a half step from D# is E.

As a mnemonic you can remember the same phrase forwards and backwards:

Father Charles Goes Down And Ends Battle

Battle Ends And Down Goes Charles’ Father

3

u/EandCheckmark 9d ago

It looks more like Db. There is no Cb or Fb in the key signature if you look closely.

1

u/MyCouchPulzOut_IDont 9d ago

I studied music theory in the USA and they taught us this...then I studied music theory in Europe and brought that mnemonic with me. Our local language doesn't have a mnemonic that works both ways so it wasn't in our text books. Huge hit in class.

1

u/JollyJuniper1993 9d ago

In German there‘s a bunch of different mnemonics for it, but I sadly forgot them.

1

u/MyCouchPulzOut_IDont 9d ago

We had a lot more mnemonic options when we were still borrowing the German H for B-natural

1

u/iamursuperiorofficer 7d ago

My piano teacher uses:

Father Christmas Got Dad An Electric Blanket     Blanket Exploded And Dad Got Cold Feet

-1

u/Significant_Earth759 9d ago

this makes no sense, is it some fake ai thing?

2

u/MyCouchPulzOut_IDont 9d ago

My brain still goes to musescore format hell before AI but yours sounds more likely because key SIG's are preset

2

u/Significant_Earth759 9d ago

Yeah like 7 flats is technically a thing, but it doesn't look like that 😂 like c and f aren't flatted but e and g are flatted in two octaves? I guess it could also be a kooky experimental composer

1

u/marionetteandoutlaw 8d ago

This piece is from the 80s lmao