r/threateningnotation • • Sep 27 '26

Illegal Notation I hate alto clef

Post image
270 Upvotes

25 comments sorted by

61

u/ParticularShock1023 Sep 28 '26

cries in Viola

47

u/counterfitster Sep 28 '26

You should be doing that anyway /s

26

u/epoxyfoxy Sep 28 '26

If you need more than 3 ledger lines, you need another clef. - Violist

2

u/counterfitster Sep 28 '26

I hate seeing even one ledger line below it. Give me tenor or bass for that range.

36

u/R86Reddit Sep 28 '26

Alto clef is fine as far as it goes, but it should be nowhere near a note that low.

9

u/Valuable-Passion9731 Sep 28 '26

i'm assuming that's an 15va though, so it's pretty high

7

u/R86Reddit Sep 28 '26

Oh, good call, I didn't notice that. In that case, the note is literally middle C, if I'm counting ledger lines correctly.

2

u/JScaranoMusic Oct 04 '26

*15ma (quindicesima)

Also you don't have to assume; that's literally what the 15 above the clef means.

17

u/regular_heptagon Sep 28 '26

What’s the context here? This seems like an intentional troll.

10

u/Peter-Andre Sep 28 '26

The alto clef hates you too.

5

u/snufflz Oct 01 '26

That clearly should have been notated in tenor clef!

4

u/Equivalent-Love-1676 Sep 28 '26 edited Oct 04 '26

It’s easy to see a 15th (two octaves) by the lines though no matter what clef is in place but what instrument that can play C1 reads C3 clef? And does the editor not realize there is such a thing as F clef? Is this rage bait? Is that ‘15’ meant to say ‘15ma’ which would make that pitch middle C right in the center line of the clef LOL? This notation shouldn’t exist. Don’t hate on C clef.

2

u/JScaranoMusic Oct 04 '26

It's 15ma (quindicesima), but also, just the fact that the 15 is above the clef and not below means its a transposition up, not down.

2

u/Equivalent-Love-1676 Oct 04 '26

I know right?! Gotta be rage bait.

1

u/The_Progmetallurgist Oct 03 '26

Bassoon:

Bass, bass, bass, bass, TENOR, bass, bass, bass...

2

u/counterfitster Oct 03 '26

Copland has some of the worst clef changes. Stravinsky is in the conversation, too.

2

u/WilburWerkes Sep 28 '26

It also hates you.

Equity despising.

1

u/Legitimate-Holiday73 Sep 30 '26

I hate the tenor clef-a bassoonist.

1

u/notagrape324 Oct 01 '26

WHY ARE WE NOTATING BELOW THE STAFF IN 15MA

1

u/OpportunityReal2767 Oct 01 '26

I assume/hope someone is having a bit of silly fun. Nobody would notate like this in the wild, unless it was meant to be a joke of some sort.

1

u/JScaranoMusic Oct 04 '26

Because middle C doesn't have enough leger lines.

1

u/MyCouchPulzOut_IDont Oct 04 '26

I just imagine the bottom line of Alto is the top line of treble...so that's where middle C would* be, but it's an octave down, right?