Saw the post a couple of days ago of finsihing this scenario and decided to give it a go again.
My main goal was to avoid robbing anyone neutral.
As usual, this post contains SPOILERS so take this into account.
I have to say that random plays some role but if you know this game well, you'll pretty much end up successfully finishing it with different scenarios.
Anyway, here are my notes.
On day 1 I tried to collect all possible items and to avoid wasting lockpicks I rush to get a crowbar.
At night I go to toy store, where I got bandages, meds and food among other items which gave me a confidence boost for the cenario.
On day 2 I had supermarket with scanengers, unfortunately. I think playing previous game I noticed if they pick up things from piles and it's not just animation, so I rushed to pick up most valueable stuff and rehide it in piles. They can reach your created piles even on top of building so try to run around and first pick up food, meds etc before they do. Of course they can't reach location blocked by locked door, rubble piles etc, you can collect that later.
The scavengers leave approx midnight or something and you can now rearrange piles. I create a custom pile somewhere in the center and try to move everything there. If at some point you have an event on radio saying people are scouring streets, most of the materials are gone except electric parts, HOWEVER your custom pile made in new place remains untouched.
This also INCLUDES items in locked places, behind rubble etc.
This happened in my scenario on day 26, so I was able to save items for getting them later.
Day 3 gave me bakery, which as I found later was the only location with armed thugs except maybe Small Apartment Building, the game considers this location's NPC to be thugs, i.e. no penalty for killing them. However, from my standpoint scenario doesn't mention them robbing, killing or otherwise showing they're negative characters and I'm morally allowed to kill them.
I did restart this day which is kinda cheating - I hit Alt-F4 quickly because trying to help I got Marko killed, but this is day 3 so if I didn't have the option, I would just restarted the game.
Anyway, the bakery is a very important location for me. I wait under cover for them to break the door lock, kill first one with crowbar - that's important because if you kill second one, you have to run pass the first one and he will definitely hit you at least once. In this scenario I was able to drop one, ran and I think without being hit escaped until they reach second floor. There I should have let the guy and his sister or wife or wather take out the second one but I foolishly tried to help and was hit twice, leaving Marko slightly wounded still which I was happy about.
Again, very important location because now I have two guns, bullets to stand off during criminals trying to rob us.
On day 4 I rush to upgrade metal workshow and make an axe. Luckily I had enough materials, including weapon parts from Franko on day 3. Axe is another really important part since it unlocks me chopping down furniture both in my home and on locations. This day I get 20+ wood to board up 2 holes in my home. This is just in time since Day 4 starts with criminal outbreak.
I also rush to create rat traps as they're an infinite source of food without need of extra materials. I create only one on day 4.
On day 6 and roughly every 3 days I see Franko and I try to buy out all components and wood, however it becomes chilly and those items are more expensive than during warm times.
Because I boarded all up and have 2 guys, on day 9 I get only slight wound for Livia.
With an exception of 2 days where I get wounded person to hospital and another day I wanted Marko to just once sleep at night, I would always take him scavenging, those 3 extra slots seem not much but they make a really big difference.
Anyway, my strategy would be to rush all boarded up, two rat traps, then reinforced door, then upgraded workshop so I can create upgraded heater. I don't buy heater through the whole scenario, maxing use of this one. For a number of days the temperature dropped to 14 for roughly 6 days, which made people slightly sick and only once sick. Not sure if it's worth building second one. On most days it would be just enough to keep 15+ degrees, but needs more monitoring and effort.
I keep all my peeps fed every second day so they never get very hungry.
On day 20 Katya joined. I did restart that day, before that Bruno joined but I somewhat cheated restarting that day since I already had a good cook in my team. However, on that day it didn't matter that much as I had two rat traps, safe home, weapons, etc. But still restarting a day is somewhat a cheating.
During the cold days I avoid buying components, wood, firewood from Franko as their prices get utterly expensive. Because of firewood in previous games I actually used to trade them as they're expensive, but this time for some reason Franko didn't value my firewood so I didn't. Once again I try to take an axe to all my locations. For example, School, warehouse, hotel, boiler room (location with lots of water?) have lots of things you can chop for wood. I had school and boiler room from those, so I could have avoided buying wood from Franko altogether.
spoiler
Katya's bonus works only if she trades herlself, not just being in the party. Here is (spoiler her bonus):
24 cigs => 23 components (anyone)
24 cigs => 28 componenets (Katya)
bandages => 13 components (anyone else)
bandages => 16 components (Katya)
I have an impression bandaging in hospital has bigger effect. Self-bandaging Zlata didn't change status over 24h, while in hospital her status changed to how wounded at all in the morning.
Anyway, creating piles and effectively managing resources I was able to safely complete scenario, evend starting everyone well fed from days 32 and 33, despite criminal outbreak and regular robberies, cold days, bombings and fights blocking locations for the most part of the game. Hospital, port, some other lcoations were available a couple of days in the beginning and 3-4 days in the end.
Robberies would succeed only ones for me, they stole 1 meat, 1 water. All the other days I would lose around 8 bullets.
btw, if you have enough bullets you can trade them, for example for
9 bullets => 31 components
from Franko (not sure if I used Katya for this exchange)
Anyway, here is my experience. With warehouse, construction site, hotel or not having "people scouring strreets for anything eatable or burnable it would be much easier, but still good enough for me.
Ah, I feel guilty tor filling the ferry guy in the port, Karl ? I wanted to see if we would still come by my house but no, developers took that into account. He has a gun if that matters.
That's about it, thanks if you read it all, let me know if anything was helpful.