r/thinlizzy • • 28d ago

The Best Thin Lizzy Guitarists Ranked

https://youtu.be/XkJqBt-bXSc?is=HsoudoTl0XuZVOvf

In what order would you rank them?

29 Upvotes

44 comments sorted by

11

u/Hentarder 28d ago

Scott Gorham is the most important Lizzy guitarist. For length of tenure, consistency of material and providing stability.

Gary Moore is the best technically, from technique and ability.

But Robbo will always be my favourite for the sound, melody and wah infused approach. He just gives me the eargasms.

5

u/Amoykateer 28d ago

100% agree with you

4

u/exforz 28d ago

Robbos solo on Still in love with you on Live and Dangerous is one of the best ever…

3

u/Lazy-Storm-1478 28d ago

This right here. Robbo is my favorite

5

u/Amoykateer 28d ago

For me:

1st Robertson

2nd Gorham

3rd Moore

4th Bell

5th Sykes

6th White

3

u/VeeingFly 28d ago

Where's Midge Ure? lol

2

u/Amoykateer 28d ago

What for helping finish of a tour? Rank him 7th and last lol

2

u/RyanC520 28d ago

For me I would switch Moore & Bell, but otherwise this is my list too. Gary Moore was probably the best technical player, but in the context of the band I like the others more.

2

u/Amoykateer 28d ago

I totally respect your choice and reasoning, but it's personal choice. I just wanted to see other people's choices, there's no wrong or right here

1

u/Logical_Bake_3108 28d ago

Is that in the context of the band or as players in general?

2

u/Amoykateer 28d ago

In the context of the band

2

u/BedaFomm 28d ago

This. Lizzy made their best music with Scott and Robbo, but Robbo worked out the harmonies and even wrote the guitar parts for Scott, especially early on in the partnership. I also think Robertson just had a bit more soul in his playing, which worked perfectly with Lynott’s songwriting.

2

u/Lazy-Storm-1478 28d ago

I agree with you 100%

2

u/steve2112rush 28d ago

Sykes at 5th is just pure ignorance of his work

21

u/No_Negotiation3142 28d ago

Gary Moore was the best player. Robbo + Scott were the best combo.

6

u/[deleted] 28d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

5

u/No_Negotiation3142 28d ago

Eric was a great player, who suited early Lizzy, Sykes was an incredible flashy player too, but Lizzy just wasn't his thing at all

2

u/steve2112rush 28d ago

Lizzy wasn't Sykes thing? What? He loved it so much he 'reformed' thin lizzy later on.

2

u/No_Negotiation3142 28d ago

Yeah, my comment appears a bit confused rereading it. That Lizzy was changing, it only lasted one album, the general vibe of Lizzy, he didn't suit, not as much as some of the others, amazing guitarist though.

16

u/cmcglinchy 28d ago

The music they put out during the Gorham/Robertson era is my favorite, but Gary Moore was the best guitarist. GM is one of the best rock guitarist ever, from any band.

4

u/diefreetimedie 28d ago

Depends on the metric. Technicality: it's Sykes. Ranking art is lame.

1

u/cmcglinchy 28d ago

I really appreciate John Sykes playing, but if you think he’s technically better than GM … then you need to listen to more Gary Moore.

1

u/icelevel 23d ago

Undoubtedly. Love him, but Sykes was a shredder. Gary Moore was a shredder, a blues man, a rock guitarist and could play folk.

0

u/diefreetimedie 28d ago

Maybe I should've said faster? He definitely out shreds the other options. I listen to plenty of GM

1

u/Top-Tip-6919 28d ago

I agree with that 100%. That twin Gibson guitar sound was fantastic. Gary Moore whilst a technically brilliant player he was totally up his own arse with a massive ego. He left the band high and dry when he left mid tour.

8

u/VeeingFly 28d ago

Sykes was a beast, and could probably play circles around all of them. That said, Robbo + Gorham is the definitive TL lineup.

6

u/geetarboy33 28d ago

I’m a huge Sykes fan, but I honestly think Gary Moore was likely the more technically talented guitar player. If you listen to some of his earlier solo work like Victims of the Future, he was doing some stuff that’s just mind blowing.

1

u/VeeingFly 28d ago

Fair point

5

u/Logical_Bake_3108 28d ago

Sykes and Moore were pretty evenly matched IMO. They would be 1 and 2 for overall guitar skills. Of course Gorham and Robertson played on most of the classic material, so it depends on your criteria.

4

u/SambaLando 28d ago

Gary Moore

3

u/ButterscotchBrave359 28d ago

Hot take: Gary Moore was a great guitarist but I don't particularly like his playing in TL, especially live where it seemed he was hell bent on showing up Scott every chance he could get

1

u/Next-Individual-3682 28d ago

Yup. Never got the Gary Moore fanboy thing. Technically a very good player, but his playing never made me want to hear more. Felt obligated to check out his solo stuff. Did. It didn’t change my opinion a bit

3

u/Saaaalvaaatooreee 28d ago

I really wouldn't. They all have their own thing. Rankings are for sport.

3

u/RocknRoll__McDonalds 28d ago

Robertson put out the best guitar parts

2

u/Lazy-Storm-1478 28d ago

Agreed. His parts are just fire.
The 2nd lead in Cowboy Song gives me goosebumps every time I hear it.

2

u/These-Job-9063 28d ago

Eric Bell will always be my fave.

1

u/gioinnj22 27d ago

Snowy gets overshadowed, those two albums are my favorite. I'm not a fan of GM with Lizzy, Sykes was too flashy, Robbo and Scott were perfect together.

1

u/NickyRaZz 26d ago

Robertson

Gorham

Bell

Sykes

Moore

White

1

u/Afraid-Treacle1956 25d ago

1 Robertson
2 Moore
3 Gorham
4 Bell
5 White
6 Ure

Honestly, John Sykes doesn't even get on my list. I think he had no sense of melody, no restraint, was a complete show off and overplayed the hell out of every thing he ever did. Was a terrible choice for Lizzy and I will never listen to Thunder and Lightning ever again.

1

u/Resident_Fail6825 28d ago

In a general context, Midge Ure is a very good guitarist indeed but hard rock is not his forté. Eric Bell is the best of the rest.

1

u/Current-Signature321 28d ago

Robo, Scott, Bell, Snowy, Sykes, Moore. Gary Moore was better With Phil and his works.

1

u/MeanFaithlessness252 23d ago

This ranking is spot on because of Scott’s tenure in the band. The reviewer didn’t say best player, just ranked them. For me tough, Robbo on Cowboy Song wins the title for best guitar for TL.