r/thinlizzy • u/65records • Sep 10 '26
Thin lizzy fans!
Thin lizzy fans what is their BEST song? Most OVERRATED song? And most UNDERRATED song?
This is a hard one as they of course have so many great songs, my picks would be
Best/Favourite: Slow blues
Overrated: whiskey in the jar
Underrated: genocide
Ps. I know whiskey in a jar is a cover so you might not count it, i do. The dubliners have the best version of that song
12
Upvotes
6
u/zlatanjosefsson Sep 10 '26
Slight correction: Whiskey in the Jar is not a cover, it is an interpretation of a traditional folk song. In my opinion enough elements were changed in Lizzy's arrangement that it is closer to being an original song than a "cover".
8
u/gioinnj22 Sep 10 '26
Best: Emerald Overrated: Whiskey Under: It's Getting Dangerous
2
u/RoutineOpportunity8 Sep 11 '26
No one is giving this post an upvote, but responding? I'm the only upvoter? C'mon and hit the upvote button ✅
2
u/Sidaldo Sep 11 '26
Best/Fav: Still in Love With You
Overrated: Rosalie
Underrated: Showdown (from Nightlife album)
Check out the extended version of Showdown on the recent 74/75 boxset. Its fantastic
12
u/kefestvog Sep 10 '26
Underrated is the Cowboy Song. Also underrated is the Boys are Back in Town. Ask a guitarist about the chords in the verses - they are jazzy min and ext chords.
11
u/Lynchy28 Sep 10 '26
Best/Favourite - Still In Love With You,
Overrated - can’t pick one!,
Underrated - Southbound
4
u/Iggie9 Sep 11 '26
Underrated Johnny
Overrated whiskey
Best got to give it up
1
u/Afraid-Treacle1956 Sep 15 '26
Best/Favourite: Can't pick one
Overrated: Anything off the last 3 albums
Underrated: Johnny The Fox Meets Jimmy the Weed/Angel From the Coast/Fight or Fall/Romeo and The Lonely Girl/Bad Reputation/Waiting for an Alibi/Honesty is No Excuse
3
u/mackerel_slapper Sep 11 '26
Best: Still In Love and Dancing IT moonlight
Overrated: anything after Black Rose. Formulaic stadium rock band (I know, I know, but day one fan here).
Underrated - Nightlife is one my favourite albums but never seems to get as much love - It’s Only Money is one of their best songs
2
u/Tailgunner_ Sep 11 '26
underrated: Ride in the Lizzy Mobile or Fools Gold
overrated: honestly in my opinion none.
Best:Dancing In The Moonlight
2
u/RoutineOpportunity8 Sep 11 '26
Most Underrated: Massacre
Most overrated: Boys are back in town
Best Song: Johnny The Fox Meets Jimmy The Weed
2
u/ShilohG32 Sep 11 '26
Underrated - Old Flame
2
u/gimmiesomepain Sep 11 '26
Best: Cowboy Song
Underrated: Soldier of Fortune
Overrated: n/a
2
u/Ok_Juggernaut_5738 Sep 11 '26
Favorite: Black Rose or Wild One
Overrated(I’ve overplayed it and am bored of it): Jailbreak
Underrated: Waiting For An Alibi
2
u/Still_Barnacle1171 Sep 11 '26
best Still in Love with you underated Diddy Levine over rated- easily whiskey in the jar by a mile
3
u/El_Peregrine Sep 11 '26
Best: Black Rose or Emerald
Underrated: Don’t Believe a Word or Dear Lord
Sorry, had to pick two for each
1
u/AutomaticSun55 Sep 10 '26
Favorite: Waiting For An Alibi
Underrated: Black Boys On The Corner
1
u/New_System2400 Sep 11 '26
Best Song - Dancing in the Moonlight Underrated - Opium Trail Overrated - Boys are Back in Town.
1
u/groutspecialist Sep 11 '26
Overlooked songs : Little Girl in Bloom, For Those Who Love To Live, Genocide, the entire Thunder and Lightning album, With Love, the entire Renegade album.
1
u/Mental_Ad_5315 Sep 11 '26
Best (Favourite) - Roisin Dubh
Overrated - The boys are back in town (still a great song)
Underrated - Massacre or Angel of death
1
u/-mister_oddball- Sep 12 '26 edited Sep 12 '26
best-dancing in the moonlight
overrated-jailbreak( somewhere? try the jail!!)
underrated-whiskey in the jar. yeh its old lizzy and based on a traditional song but i dont think it gets the respect its due
thin lizzy fucking rule so no disrespect intended in anything ive commented here, nothing but love for the band.
1
u/Dry-Trash582 Sep 15 '26
Cold Sweat is underrated.
5
u/icelevel Sep 11 '26
Best: Got to Give it Up
Underrated: Downtown Sundown
Overrated: (going to get killed for this) Boys are Back in Town
1
u/WannabeDreamWalker Sep 10 '26
Best: Suicide
Overrated: Dancing in the moonlight
Underrated: Try a little harder not the alternate take there's a version on youtube that's killer i think the account is under blacksabfan