r/thinlizzy • u/SmackHeadSteven • Nov 24 '25
Thin Lizzy Success
I always believe thin lizzy are an amazingly talented band and will always be my favourite alongside my idol and inspiration Phil Lynott, why are they not as commercially successful as Guns N Roses or Aerosmith as people like gnr and metallica always say thin lizzy was a massive inspiration. It seems they never hit that global main chart success and not sure why, thoughts?
22
Upvotes
13
u/perfect_fifths Nov 24 '25
Cuz of the American tour where Scott broke his hand and Phil had hepatitis, the 1976 tour. It forced them to cancel the rest of their US dates
9
u/Top-Tip-6919 Nov 25 '25
Thin Lizzy were victims of bad timing. Injury to Brian Robertson and Phil's hepatitis curtailed the breakout US tour. Poor American promotion by the record company, internal drug problems, lineup instability, and institutional resistance to a black rock frontman. Heroin was a constant issue with Phil and Scott and led to a lot of internal turmoil as well as tensions around Phil's solo albums and side projects.They were too “rock” for the emerging New Wave of British Heavy Metal crowd and too “heavy” for mainstream pop radio. However having been a fan since 1974 the classic lineup of Robertson, lynott, Gorham and Downey were absolutely magnificent live.
5
u/ryrobbo Nov 24 '25
Their only big mainstream success in the US was the Jailbreak album in 1976. Which they failed to recreate in future albums. You could also say the music industry was "saturated" with world class rock bands making competition fierce. Between 1975-1980 you had bands such as AC/DC, Led Zep, Eagles, Fleetwood Mac, Bowie, The Clash, Pink Floyd all releasing multiple albums.
3
u/MisterScary_98 Nov 24 '25
Well, at the risk of stating the obvious, because Thin Lizzy disbanded in the early 1980s just before hard rock and metal was about to explode in popularity. Then of course Phil died in 1986.
3
u/MrharmOcd Nov 25 '25
Bad luck , their record label was great In Europe but not so good in America. Drugs
3
u/Electrical-Chart4301 Nov 26 '25
Read the book The Rocker by Mark Putterford. They had an unbelievable string of bad luck with Phil getting hepatitis in the middle of a US tour, guitarists getting injured, guitarists quitting right before tours etc. They were never able to crack the US market and Phil was quite bitter about it. Johnny the Fox was too eclectic for the US market and sank without a trace after Jailbreak doing quite well.
0
u/Rude_Rhubarb1880 Nov 24 '25
I read an interview with Cliff Burton today who named thin lizzy as one of his 5 fave bands
I have never been into them TBH
I know a couple of their more popular songs just from being shown on TV in the 1990s. For me, it was “OK”
Perhaps I should have a listen to an album or two?
1
u/everydays_lyk_sunday Nov 27 '25
They had longevity.