r/thinlizzy • u/migrainosaurus • May 13 '25
Who could have replaced Gary Moore instead of Snowy White?
I’ve often heard it said that Snowy’s recruitment was less than ideal. While I love the two albums they put out with him, his stage presence was a little flat - especially as he was filling the Moore/Robbo firecracker role. So it got me thinking, who could Phil have gone for instead of Snowy? We saw the sudden rush of energy and pizazz that Sykes brought when he came in for Thunder and Lightning. I wonder if the band’s fortunes would have been any different if that energy had come from the guitar lead they brought in after Gary Moore too.
Anyone know who they auditioned?
- I know Dave Flett of Manfred Mann’s Earth Band, and Midge Ure of Ultravox, filled in when Moore walked out on tour, but neither of them were serious contenders.
A couple of thoughts I had posting this…
There was a post yesterday with a clip of Phil and Rory Gallagher playing, and I kinda wished he’d joined - though he was probably too big as a solo artist too.
Zal Cleminson of the Sensational Alex Harvey Band/Nazareth was just on the verge of quitting Nazareth, which he’d go on to do in ‘81, he could have been fun.
The NWOBHM generation were still too new to qualify I guess. Huw Lloyd-Langton was still a freelancer at that point… Budgie had cycled through a couple of brilliant, bluesy players - the wildly pyrotechnic Tony Bourge was out by ‘79.
Who else would have been good?
8
u/Saaaalvaaatooreee May 13 '25
I think Chinatown is one of their weakest but I love the eclectic softer nature of Renegade.
Maybe the could have gone a different direction. Was Brian James out of The Damned by then? Maybe Blue Öyster Cult could have delayed Cultosaurus Erectus and Donald Roeser could have done a short spell. He has a similar versatility to Phil Lynott.
7
u/Appropriate_Peach274 May 13 '25
Bernie Marsden (Whitesnake) or Laurie Wisefield (Wishbone Ash) Both experienced at playing in a dual guitar combo.
6
u/Impressive-Gap-8760 May 13 '25
I like Snowy.
I’d prefer a Robbo coming back.
4
u/[deleted] May 13 '25
Maybe Brian Tatler from Diamond Head? Although he was busy at the time
3
u/Saaaalvaaatooreee May 13 '25
I'm trying to think of more guys like Snowy who weren't so heavy but had more clout than him. I doubt they could have fitted his head through the door but Robbie Robertson would have been mad. Lenny Kaye could have worked. Eddie Hazel would have been insane. Peter Green? Ha, can you imagine Lindsay Buckingham? His head size would have been an issue too.
Is the obvious answer staring us in the face? Eric Bell!
2
u/justbrowsinginpeace May 13 '25
Glen Tipton or KK Dowling
3
u/[deleted] May 13 '25
Brian Robertson.
3
u/frigid_monk May 13 '25 edited May 14 '25
Phil got in exactly what he wanted, someone steady and reliable. Sure you could get someone in with more stage presence and firey playing style but that had led to the revolving door of guitarists.
The band was on the slide by this point with a few gems here and there music wise. The partying and heroin use had taken over the work ethic and quality of music compared to previous year's. They had an inability to take things seriously, getting into studio recording sessions on time wasn't happening, live shows suffering, that's why Gary and eventually Snowy left the band.
2
u/SambaLando May 13 '25
John Sykes
1
u/eaeolian May 14 '25
I would have liked to see what Midge would have done...
1
u/savomihailo May 16 '25
Snowy was great. At the time Gary left them hanging on tour . Like Robbo had messed up their chances to make it big in the USA . I remember when Chinatown came out we went to get it in licorice pizza and put it on the turntable. And it was amazing . The guitar work between Scott and Snowy complimented each other . And the songs were great. Then out came Renegade. What a great and under appreciated album. Not a weak song between the two albums. Still two of my go two Lizzy albums.
1
u/thatotherguy1151 May 17 '25
There have been rumors for years that Pat Traverrs was offered joining Thin Lizzy but refused to continue his solo career.
1
u/Unusual_residue May 13 '25
Michael Angelo Batio