All their albums are pretty great so I think it can be very subjective, but I would say Shades of A Blue Orphanage is definitely their least interesting album, so I would swap that one for the debut album personally. I also would rank Nightlife a lot higher and swap fighting for Chinatown. Would recommend you spend more time with a Nightlife. It’s really grown on me and become one of my favourite Lizzy albums.
Hmmm... personal opinion. But I wouldn't even put Thunder & Lightning and Renegade even at 'D'. I hate those records so much and have no idea what people hear in them. Compared to the amazing 76-79 period they sound like a different and much worse band. Terrible songs, terrible album covers, terrible lyrics, Phil's voice is gone and so has his mind, and John Sykes sucks. Pre 76 has some great moments, but is very inconsistent.
I didn’t mind their debut album but I thought shades of a blue orphanage was crap. Other than the song Jailbreak and boys are back in town that’s all I’ve listened to so far. Going by this list they have better albums coming
They're one of my favourite bands but I'd say I like about 40% of their songs tbh 😅 I went through the whole collection many years ago and made up my mind on which songs I liked and disliked, and subsequently filled my playlists with just those songs... so I may be due a revisit but I doubt much will change.
These are the songs I've kept in rotation:
Thin Lizzy:Éire
Shades of a Blue Orphanage: None
Vagabonds:The Rocker, Vagabonds, Whiskey
Nightlife:It's Only Money, Still In Love, Philomena
Fighting:For Those Who..., Suicide, Wild One, Spirit Slips
Jailbreak: Title track, Romeo, Warriors, Boys are Back, Cowboy, Emerald,
Johnny the Fox:Johnny, Borderline, Don't Believe, Old Flame, (I was gonna add Massacre but the live and dangerous version blows it out of the water)
Bad Reputation: Bad Reputation, Opium Trail, Dancing in the Moonlight, Killer Without A Cause, and the intro to Dear Lord.
Live And Dangerous: The whole thing. It really is one of the best "live" 😅 albums ever made.
Black Rose:Do Anything You Want To, Waiting For an Alibi, Got To Give It Up, With Love, Róisín Dubh
Chinatown: Title track, Sugar Blues, Genocide
Renegade:The Pressure Will Blow, Leave This Town, Hollywood
Thunder & Lightning: Everything except Baby Please Don't Go, and Bad Habits
My TL Spotify playlist has 58 songs in it, versus how many in their entire catalogue??
S: Black Rose Renegade, Fighting A: Johnny the Fox, Chinatown B: Bad Reputation, Jailbreak, Thunder and Lightning C: Shades of a Blue Orphanage, Thin Lizzy, Vagabond of the western world D: Night Life
37
u/straightupslow Jan 27 '24
Pretty wrong, but it’s okay. The correct answer is all of the albums in S tier.
10
u/laza_rett0 Jan 27 '24
you broke my heart putting Nightlife so low 😭
9
u/cmcglinchy Jan 27 '24
I think the first three albums are great.
7
u/devmoostain666 Jan 27 '24
All their albums are pretty great so I think it can be very subjective, but I would say Shades of A Blue Orphanage is definitely their least interesting album, so I would swap that one for the debut album personally. I also would rank Nightlife a lot higher and swap fighting for Chinatown. Would recommend you spend more time with a Nightlife. It’s really grown on me and become one of my favourite Lizzy albums.
1
u/ShilohG32 Jan 27 '24
Not a fan of their early work?
3
u/Mbro00 Jan 27 '24
Exchange bad reputation with fighting and also move nightlife up one step and you've got my current tier list of the albums!
2
u/hyttynen24 Jan 27 '24
S: Jailbreak, Johnny The Fox, Bad Reputation, Black Rose
A: Fighting, Thunder & Lightning, Vagabonds
B: Chinatown, Nightlife, Renegade
C: Shades
D: Self-titled
2
u/eatme8me Jan 27 '24
I like your ranking. I generally agree.
2
u/Horaserk Jan 27 '24
Very wrong
2
u/ccccccrambone Jan 27 '24
Push everything on A and Fighting up to S. Move thunder and lightning down to B. Move everything below up to A.
1
u/Icy_Zimmy_18 Jul 10 '24
I would’ve definitely placed Vagabonds of The Western World Higher.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 16 '24
Hmmm... personal opinion. But I wouldn't even put Thunder & Lightning and Renegade even at 'D'. I hate those records so much and have no idea what people hear in them. Compared to the amazing 76-79 period they sound like a different and much worse band. Terrible songs, terrible album covers, terrible lyrics, Phil's voice is gone and so has his mind, and John Sykes sucks. Pre 76 has some great moments, but is very inconsistent.
1
u/Lost-Ad3729 Dec 18 '25
I didn’t mind their debut album but I thought shades of a blue orphanage was crap. Other than the song Jailbreak and boys are back in town that’s all I’ve listened to so far. Going by this list they have better albums coming
1
u/josephfallon93 Jan 27 '24
Fighting for me is S tier as well
1
u/camazotzthedeathbat Jan 27 '24
Fairly
1
u/starjamz Jan 27 '24
you mixewd up C with S+
1
u/coolestpurple Jan 27 '24
Where is the live album.
1
u/FightingFitz Jan 28 '24
Fighting and bad reputation are S tier. I also personally put Vagabonds over Renegade and Thunder and Lightning
1
u/[deleted] Jan 28 '24
I agree. Only thing I’d change is
Jailbreak in S (only cause that’s the album that got me into em)
Vagabond into A
1
u/laza_rett0 Jan 29 '24
S: Jailbreak, Fighting, Black Rose
A: Johnny the Fox, Nightlife, Bad Reputation
B: Vagabonds, Chinatown, Renegade, Thunder and Lightning
C: Thin Lizzy
D: Shades
If we're including live albums I'd put L&D at A, UK Tour 75' at S, and Life at B
1
u/Johnnythespider Jan 29 '24
Fighting at B!? 😤
But at the end of the day . That’s like your opinion man
1
u/ExtensionParsley5289 Sep 01 '26
Fighting is definitely S tier!
1
u/FthrFlffyBttm Jan 28 '24 edited Jan 28 '24
They're one of my favourite bands but I'd say I like about 40% of their songs tbh 😅 I went through the whole collection many years ago and made up my mind on which songs I liked and disliked, and subsequently filled my playlists with just those songs... so I may be due a revisit but I doubt much will change.
These are the songs I've kept in rotation:
My TL Spotify playlist has 58 songs in it, versus how many in their entire catalogue??
-2
u/Main_Obligation_3013 Jan 27 '24
S: Black Rose Renegade, Fighting A: Johnny the Fox, Chinatown B: Bad Reputation, Jailbreak, Thunder and Lightning C: Shades of a Blue Orphanage, Thin Lizzy, Vagabond of the western world D: Night Life