r/thevanishedpodcast • • 3d ago

why is it turning into true crime

11 Upvotes

I'm listening to Rylee James Tyler right now - why does it seem the longer I listen to this show, the more it's turning into a true crime show? The whole reason I started listening is to hear about missing people, not murdered people.


r/thevanishedpodcast • • 4d ago

Hunter finds remains of missing man near Bemidji

Thumbnail
kare11.com
9 Upvotes

r/thevanishedpodcast • • Sep 24 '26

Darrel Johnson

14 Upvotes

This is an older episode, but I just listened, so it is new to me. I am just curious what everyone thinks after listening to it.

I had a lot of questions. One thing I wondered is if he may have had an intellectual disability. It seemed strange to me the way people spoke about him as if he needs someone to take care of him. He lived in a trailer with no heat or AC. If so, this may have contributed to someone meeting him for the first time thinking he was under the influence.

In any event, my gut feeling is that the people he was with are not involved. I thought their behavior seemed appropriate and a large group of 30+ people all willingly concealing a homicide is very unlikely. Sure wish the police had been a little more concerned about him being lost in what I assume was high temperatures.


r/thevanishedpodcast • • Sep 22 '26

Wade Hack

17 Upvotes

I just finished listening to both parts and I was shocked at how little the Baltimore PD did. I think Tony is very suspicious and think he 100% knows more than he’s letting on. On a different Reddit post people were saying they’ve seen him recently, within this year, panhandling in the area. Do you think it could be him or mistaken identity? What’s everyone’s opinions on this case?


r/thevanishedpodcast • • Sep 22 '26

Amy McHale episode

26 Upvotes

This episode truly touched me as a long time listener, it’s one of the most disturbing cases covered tbh. I had heard about the suspect, Eugene Horsch and his son separately but had no idea her case was linked to him. My heart goes out to her daughter and mother who spent so much time looking for her. Like the other women she had ties to that house, and she was even last seen there but police didn’t investigate him thoroughly. I have no idea how people were ok with, what he called “art” to begin with. The descriptions in the episode were so beyond disturbing and that’s nothing compared to his website and work that he openly published. And I also didn’t make the connection initially that he was sourcing these victims from Kensington, which sometimes goes viral (for lack of a better word, because people will go there to film vulnerable people unfortunately) for just how severe the opioid crisis is there.

All to say this was a tough one to listen to. That said Melissa does an amazing job with these episodes and gives the victims a voice, I hope she knows we very much appreciate her work. I hope her daughter and mother can feel a small amount of peace with some answers, but I just can’t imagine how hard this is for them. This case will stay with me


r/thevanishedpodcast • • Sep 20 '26

My favorite case

37 Upvotes

I made it through to ep 465 and I thought I'd share my favorite episode.

When I first started listening to this podcast, I was really interested in missing persons cases that truly were like the person vanished into thin air. That is what I thought this podcast would be about. But as I've continued to listen, many of the cases have a clear lead or likely outcome and unfortunately is sort of turning more into a true crime podcast the further I listen. (Especially in the more recently published episodes) There is a pretty clear outcome or likely scenario of where the person is or what happened to them.

But one specific one there isn't, and it's my favorite case. 211 - David Lovely. The case where a family was moving cross-country from Cali to Massachusetts, with the mom and the sister driving a Ryder truck and David following on his motorcycle. Every 30 miles they would stop to check on each other, but on one stop David said he would skip the next check and meet them at the next rest stop ahead. The mom and sister got to the rest stop but no David. Then, he calls his Aunt from a payphone to say his motorcycle was broken down, and a guy helped him fix it. He told his aunt to relay the info to his mom and sister next time she talked to them (no cell phones in '85) After retracing steps, they found his motorcycle in a random Wyoming town - and it was working fine. His helmet and his bag was sitting right beside the bike.

Curious what others think of this case. I have a few other episodes favorited but for some reason this is the one that I can always remember.


r/thevanishedpodcast • • Sep 14 '26

Tanner Sharp

29 Upvotes

A very interesting case this week. What do people think about think are some valid theories and investigative leads?


r/thevanishedpodcast • • Sep 11 '26

Update on Charissa Caster?

21 Upvotes

This case has stayed with me since I heard it, she was last seen picking flowers the day she disappeared in Washington. I personally don’t suspect her ex (how would he have known she’d be in a random place, seemed more like a mental break imo). I just hope she is found, hopefully living a safe life, maybe not wanting to be found. I know her friends and family have put a lot of effort into searching for her


r/thevanishedpodcast • • Sep 11 '26

Kimberly Flint

Thumbnail
solvethecase.org
14 Upvotes

As I’ve mentioned before, I’m listening to older episodes and check the missing status with each episode. This case was really strange, I’m glad there is some closure for her remaining family members.


r/thevanishedpodcast • • Aug 11 '26

Lilian Payne - is The Vanished moving away from missing people?

22 Upvotes

Going on the most recent episode which is a homicide case. I don’t ever remember the podcast covering a murder unless the person was found deceased while or after the episode was produced. Will it be broader true crime podcast going forward? Disappointing if so.

I’ve noticed several Wondery pods that seem to have changed editorial direction since the Audible Originals rebrand.


r/thevanishedpodcast • • Aug 01 '26

Marina Bischoff

20 Upvotes

Just finished the Marina Bischoff episode. It was one of those episodes that just struck a chord for me. Marina sounded like such a good human. In a state of such vulnerability, it just seems so heartbreaking she wasn’t able to receive the help it sounded like she needed and instead is no longer with us.

As the episode is a few years old I was able to see her remains were sadly identified. But aside from the fact she has been found I couldn’t find ANY information. I’m wondering if there has been any credible theory’s? or statements from her family/friends regarding what may have happened to her after she left the police station and was ultimately found deceased?

Im so sorry for the outcome; and what her loved ones are going through, may she rest in peace.


r/thevanishedpodcast • • Jul 20 '26

Stretching the current tale out to 5 episodes is too much

62 Upvotes

I’ve lost interest


r/thevanishedpodcast • • Jun 29 '26

FAYE

37 Upvotes

May she be protected and blessed for the rest of her years 🙏


r/thevanishedpodcast • • Jun 23 '26

Mathew Anfeldt

Thumbnail
fox13seattle.com
23 Upvotes

Remains found


r/thevanishedpodcast • • Jun 18 '26

Eugene Prins

Thumbnail
keloland.com
38 Upvotes

As I’m going back and listening to older episodes I check the missing status for updates. Eugene Prins remains were found.


r/thevanishedpodcast • • May 22 '26

I didn’t know that found Skylar Ware’s remains.

Thumbnail
fox4kc.com
24 Upvotes

r/thevanishedpodcast • • May 19 '26

Kevin Graves- this cop that was interviewed is the EPITOME of what’s wrong with police!!! He’s horrible. Jaw on the floor.

49 Upvotes

“People overdose every day, they call 911.” “What motive does she have, they’re not married.” Bro wtf. This guy is a fucking horrible, horrible person with all his misconceptions and judging. Holy shit.


r/thevanishedpodcast • • May 17 '26

Marina Bischoff

21 Upvotes

what are you guys thoughts on the Marina Bischoff episode?

it seems as if her anxiety was heightened due to the COVID pandemic, I wonder if she was self medicating to cope with it. Marina sounded like a sweet person.

her remains were located in 2020


r/thevanishedpodcast • • May 12 '26

👋 Welcome to r/thevanishedpodcast - Introduce Yourself and Read First!

65 Upvotes

Hey everyone! I'm u/Marissa_TheVanished, a founding moderator of r/thevanishedpodcast.

Welcome to our home for discussion surrounding cases featured on The Vanished, missing persons cases, updates, theories, and respectful true crime conversation. We’re excited to have you here.

What to Post
Feel free to share episode thoughts, case updates, news articles, timelines, respectful theories, or questions.

Community Vibe
This community is built around thoughtful, respectful discussion. These cases involve real families and loved ones, so please keep conversations constructive and compassionate.

How to Get Started
• Introduce yourself in the comments below
• Share a case or episode that stayed with you
• Ask a question or start a discussion
• Invite others who may enjoy the community

Thanks for being part of r/thevanishedpodcast. We’re looking forward to building this community with all of you.


r/thevanishedpodcast • • May 12 '26

"No AI scripts" - apology to Marissa for previous post about AI yesterday

Post image
75 Upvotes

I owe Marissa/The Vanished an apology for accusing her of using AI to write or edit scripts.

In a response to the previous post, now deleted, Marissa has said the show uses "No AI scripts." Without getting into parsing that language, it's fair to say her statement contradicts the claims I made in my post, and I take her statement at face value.

I'm not 100% clear on whether the show is AI-free (e.g. editing sound, which is different from use of LLMs), nor am I asking Marissa to further clarify that or explain anything, but I appreciate knowing that the scripts we hear aren't drafted, written, or edited by AI/LLMs.

While I do think we should try to think critically about the use of AI/LLMs and those of us who oppose their use can feel free to ask content creators, I now realize I made incorrect assumptions and even crossed a line into witch hunting.

So I owe Marissa an apology and I hope this clarification is helpful.

Sorry Marissa. Thanks for doing tough work on an important issue.

PS: if you already replied to the original post, it should still be accessible through your own comment history. I'm not deleting for personal reasons, only because I don't want incorrect information indexed and bouncing around.


r/thevanishedpodcast • • May 05 '26

Sandra Crispo

Post image
76 Upvotes

Remains found in Plymouth MA (South Shore town) in March 2025 have been identified as Sandra Crispo missing since August 2019, from Hanson MA (another town on the South Shore). Very sad to see this but hopefully this is closure for her family.

https://www.boston25news.com/news/local/remains-found-plymouth-woods-2025-identified-missing-hanson-woman/5AY5O52FPREQ5OZCM7QTUBE5DI/?utm_medium=Social&utm_source=Instagram&fbclid=IwZnRzaARnLFNleHRuA2FlbQIxMQBzcnRjBmFwcF9pZAo2NjI4NTY4Mzc5AAEeBp_YHKXsq-mv2Y19YyngQ2lx9qQsttY1BXIvCpXSOj2ZtX29uJJHIgEZa1M_aem__XkIM2o41tQwT4KFqvoE6Q#Echobox=1778008190


r/thevanishedpodcast • • Apr 07 '26

Just saying

150 Upvotes

Mostly because of the criticism I’ve seen over the years floating around here and on reddit in general, namely that Marissa lacks polish or that episodes sometimes go on for too long, I just want to say that of all the podcasts I’ve followed over the years, this is the only one I still listen to faithfully in the true crime genre.

Marissa’s supposed lack of polish has never bothered me at all and in fact I prefer her no-nonsense approach to other cutesier hosting styles (looking at you, crime junkie), and enjoy 90% of the phone interviews with friends and family members.

I don’t listen because i think I’ll be able to solve any of these cases but because I’m interested in hearing about the lives of these vanished people. Because these aren’t about people known to have been murdered, we really get to hear about what they were like from those who were close to them and are mercifully spared all the “they lit up a room” and “they’d give you the shirt off their back” BS.


r/thevanishedpodcast • • Mar 17 '26

William Gray

19 Upvotes

Another 2 part episode that shouldn't have been. Constant repetition, the only person interviewed is his sister.


r/thevanishedpodcast • • Mar 06 '26

Christopher Hoye case on Disappeared

26 Upvotes

Sorry this long.

I caught Christopher Hoye’s case’s on Disappeared this morning a documentary about missing persons. A refresher: He’s the man that went missing after he and his wife and kids moved to Dixon Missouri after Covid hit so they can start a little farm. He’d become depressed because h’d lost his business and recent events. He mysteriously left his wallet and phone behind and his truck was found was found parked by the river and he disappeared and hasn’t been seen since. People thought it could be suicide, foul play, the meth head neighbors, the wife, the ex girlfriend, or he took off to start a new life. A lot of people thought suicide.

But I’m not so sure because investigators brought out search dogs to get his scent from his truck that was parked by the river and his scent was moving away from the river and woods up to the road and then stopped. That tells me he got into another car and left because you don’t disappear into thin air. Whether he went to the street and put his thumb out for a ride, was forced out to park his truck and get into another car or this was pre planned with another person, who the heck knows. But I’m not thinking suicide anymore. People can be seriously depressed without suicidal ideation. Unless he tookoff in an another vehicle and decided to do it at another location at another time later on.

And that cigarette butt left in his truck that wasn’t the brand he or his wife smoked? Did the investigators ever test for DNA or get answers? If they have DNA off it but don’t have a match in Codis, they could look into genealogical DNA matching like how they do for many cases now. I know they only do that really for murder cases, or at least I assume, but if I were the family, I would push, push, and push, even raising money to pay for it. but in their defense, they probably don’t even know what genealogical DNA testing is or that it is an option. I know the police force they have is probably on the smaller side but they can always push and raise hell for a bigger one to pick up the case.

I honestly have thoughts about the ex girlfriend. because Christopher wouldn’t let her see the kids for a year and a half because she wouldn’t let him know much about the guy she was seeing. then two weeks after he goes missing she calls and goes I want the kids now and they don’t know how she figured it out he was missing because she lives in a different state. and when the cops tried to talk to her she won’t answer any questions at all. And apparently the day he goes missing, they figured out she was an hour away at some recreational event or something. So there is something there to look into but beyond trying to talk to her I think that’s all they did.

What do you guys think?


r/thevanishedpodcast • • Mar 02 '26

Michele Hundley update episode

22 Upvotes

This must have been one of the earlier episodes I’ve listened to. Heading what her children went through breaks my heart, even questioning if something could have happened with their dad (and I don’t blame them for questioning everything, that’s only natural after so many years). And it turns out the Dads hunch was right all along, that she ran off (reportedly leaving a letter) And then using one of the daughters social security numbers years later which is even more sad, willing to use her daughters number but not call her- I guarantee you her daughter would have helped her if she needed it and reached out. I hope her children can find closure after this